Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Japanese chisel bevel angle

Posts

Re: Japanese chisel bevel angle

#26

Me too.

Hank Knight

>

Re: Japanese chisel bevel angle

#27

Re: Hollow grinding?

ThomD

>"I assume that the arguments against hollow grinding are three fold: firstly, it is not traditional (or is it?)"

Obviously not, in the really trad world they are very specific about micro differences in sharpening let alone this kind of disrespect

"; secondly, the heat from a power grinder may upset the temper of the thin tool steel layer."

This certainly can happen and it would be pretty sad with a great chisel, but it is largely a mater of skill I assume they are always ground at the factory, so it really just comes down to skill.

" A third reason may be that the hollow will remove needed support for the bevel."

I think that is less the issue that changing the geometry generally, which maters to those to whom it maters.

"With regard speed/effort for honing, it should not be necessary to hollow grind as the soft steel layer wears quickly. The advantage of hollow grinding is the same as for Western chisels - creating a small secondary bevel or microbevel requires less work, and balancing the bevel on a hollow is easier and more reliable than balancing on a flat surface (maintaining the flat is more difficult)."

In general though, who is one asking, people who know what they are doing, or hope to get there one day, or people who don't. Nothing is difficult to professionals. Do you want your doctor to tell you (though it is certainly true when they are learning) about how difficult that tonsilectomy is, or should they possibly be competant?

The one thing I don't like about hollows on japanese chisels from the cheating perspective is it seems to make the acquisition of the bevel no easier since the tiny contact points are of uneven hardness, which doesn't help. Of course it is like anything else, one can spend the time to learn to do it wrong and overcome the many associated difficulties, and then the wrong becomes eventually easy, just like the right.

Also one of my prefered guides is when the water squirts out just as the bevel is flat, which is harder to acquire whith a hollow, but again, mastery will see one through if one chooses this path.

I have hollow ground some Japanese chisels, it doesn't appeal to me, but it can be done and is done, and at some comodity level if I had to use only hollow ground chisels I would probably chose Japanese ones. Just as if I could have anything for a table cloth I might choose a Van Gough Canvas.

One thing that does occur is why use a hollow ground when machine sharpening, one can machine sharpen flat or even convex surfaces. Why choose hollow ones?

I think this is all fair stuff to talk about, rushing a little at the moment, as far as tone...