Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Things that hand tools do easily

Posts

Things that hand tools do easily

#1

Things that hand tools do easily

Roy Anderson

>At the WIA conference, I went to a seminar by Jim Tolpin and he was talking about things that hand tools do easily but machine tools can't do at all or only with great effort. One thing was chamfering. A router can chamfer an edge easily, but it is a straight chamfer. A variable, s-curve chamfer is beyond its ability, but is easily done with a draw knife, finishing off with a spoke shave. He showed an example of an s-curved chamfer on a part of a replica Gypsy wagon that he had made.

He also mentioned putting on a scalloped irregular surface with a plane using a curved blade.

Variable pitch and spaced dovetails is another that I thought of.

What other functions can hand tools do easily that machine tools can't do or only with difficulty?

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

#2

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

Dan Donaldson

>Take one or two thousandths off something to sneak up on a fit.

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

#3

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>1. Make and inlay stringing.

2. Make and inlay small ornaments.

3. Make a 'therm' foot (spade foot)

4. Add cockbeading to a drawer (though a bandsaw is nice for cutting the bead stock)..

5. Cleaning up any surface that has ebony in it (like sanding ebony?)

6. Many sorts of simple ornaments (cloud lifts as in Greene & Greene for example, or raised plugs to cover screw--the machine guys go nuts trying to do these setups, judging from the G&G forum).

Wiley.... who would note that machines are great rippers and crosscutters and thicknessers.

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

#4

Making tenons.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

#5

Operate Quietly!

Charles Yawn

>

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

#6

Adjusting Rabbets

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Good post here. I agree that hand tools are needed for many tasks. I'm a woodworker who uses both hand tools and electron burners. But in my practice there are a whole host of tasks that machines are inept at. Aside from limitations that power tools have at times, they can also be the slower choice for many tasks. In the time that it takes me to set up a tool or a jig to do one small task I can do the same task, often in seconds, with a hand tool. They pay for themselves that way!

Tom

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

#7

Yeung Chan's "Classic Joints with Power Tools"

amelon

>Here is an excellent book which shows what's possible with power tools. But even after cutting the joints with power tools, you'll still have to refine them using hand tools. To me, there are things done more easily with power tools and others more easily with hand tools. Then there are things which are only possible with hand tools, and vice versa. In my case, I try to leverage the strengths of both and also to focus on on the journey. B)

- Bob

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

#8

Surface wide boards...

Dean J in MN

>I'd probably have more if I worked with machines, without the benefit of being limited by machines in my shop I can only come up with these off the top of my head:

. Surface boards wider than your jointer.

. Thickness stick wider than your planer. Can you pass an entire case side through your planer after a glue up?

. Free you from thinking you need to 4-square all stock. This is a big benefit to working without machines.

. (assume a few hollows and rounds) -- make any molding profile you can dream up.

. Quick, quiet and dust-free smoothing.

. Lambs tongues

. carve

. gooseneck moldings

. stike block plane for fitting mitres

There are plenty more, it will be fun to see what others come up with...

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

#9

Same Here

Frank D. in Montreal

>That book is still one of my favourites. I also mix hand and power tools as I see fit. SOmetimes one is more practical, sometimes I just feel like using one instead of the other...

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

#10

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

Roy Anderson

>Thanks for the nice starting list. I can't help but feel there are more. Help me out here. Go ahead and list those things you think hand tools do better than machine tools.

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

#11

redcoat

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

redcoat

>Appropriately sized and themed (and oft brass inlaid) paperweights.

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

#13

Carpentry example

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>When we redid our front porch, I had to trim back one of the half-columns at the wall to give clearance for the ever-so-slightly higher flooring. The half column was 3/4" inch above the framing, about 3" thick by 6" wide, and needed 1/4" or so off. I can't easily imagine how a power saw could have done that precise a job without two hours of jigging (if then). Five minutes with a sharp handsaw.

A lot of these examples have brought out that hand tools are great for irregular removal of wood; machines tend to require regularity to work well (though there are some exceptions, such as sander/grinders, but those then call for a lot of skill to avoid overdoing it).

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

#14

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

ThomD

>Splitting is one thing that power tools don't do, unless one is talking about firewood, or the micro stuff that happens in any cut. But if you need to divide some stock, splitting is always the fastest way.

Maybe it was mentioned but carving is something that power tools just have zero handle on, and while less present in modern furniture is a very important world of it's own.

Not to be argumentative, but I think tenons are easily made on power tools, and it is also easy to take off a thou, but any time the angles get complex, it really is no more difficult to do the hand version while the difficulty of doing power stuff escalates enormously.

A lot of the time the limit on machinery is that there isn't any call for the tool in question. A lot more could be done with machines if there was demand. Super surfacers are an example of the kind of machine that exists elsewhere but we don't see here. The Makita Rep told me that M. had 800 machines they don't bring in over here.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZbZOfOu8lgg

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

#15

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>tenons easily done on power tools

For that matter, nothing much done on table saws and other power tools is hard, exactly, even if tedious and requiring a lot of time to set up jigs. I still think tenons are more easily and quickly done with hand tools.

Pam

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

#16

That all depends on how many you're doing

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I just finished a set of mission-style bedside tables for my daughter, with a grand total of 100 mortises, 100 tenons. The tenons were cut on the table saw, and I can't even imagine doing that many by hand. I'd still be at it.

OTOH, the mortises were started by machine, but squared off by hand, a tedious process at best.

For just a few, I agree it's easier to cut by hand.

Bruce

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

#17

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

Dan Donaldson

>It may be easy to take off a thou with a power tool, but, at least for me, it would be a lot easier to take off 1/16" when trying for a thou ;-) I can do a lot with power tools, but the setup can be nasty for a lot of things. I have a Leigh jig. It makes dovetails very well, but if I am only doing a couple of drawers or one case, it is quicker to cut them by hand than to set up the jig and the router. This is also ignoring the fact that I can make DT's by hand that would be impossible with the jig.

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

#18

Re: That all depends on how many you're doing

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Well, Norm makes me tired everytime he cuts tenons on a table saw, even a lot of them. :)

Pam

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

#19

they make me tired, too,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>but when there is a deadline...

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

#20

Be the topic during the HAND TOOL CHAT tonight

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

#21

Methods driving design, or vise versa?

wilbur

>I always thought that one of the reasons that Mission-style furniture came along when it did was because woodworking machinery made it easier to knock off hundreds of identical joints. As was pointed out, to do that task by hand would be pretty tedious work.

There are two counterpoints to this:

1. Making a shoji screen involves making a large number of identical mortise and tenon joints as well, and that didn't stop them from developing before machinery came along.

2. Likewise, machinery seems to be best at making multiples of identical, relatively simple joints. Start throwing in angles and more complicated joinery, or non linear design elements such as carving, and you quickly get to a point where the set up for a machine kills whatever time advantage you gain in the actual cutting.

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

#23

Re: Methods driving design, or vise versa?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I think making shoji is more analogous to making windows with muntins than to Arts & Crafts furniture. Not sure how I'd apply this to your argument, except to note that with the advent of power tools and factory manufacture of windows we don't get real muntins anymore. Now we get sheets of glass sandwiched between phone muntin slices.

Pam

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

#24

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

ThomD

>Tenons can be produced on a wide range of power tools, bandsaws, routers, jointers, in addition to table saws. Not to mention specialty tools. A good example is when I made my trestle dining table. It had tenons about 7 inches wide, and they were only 3/16" smaler on each face than the stock. Ran the board on several passes over the jointer short of the shoulder, no jigs so far. I cut the shoulder on a radial arm, possibly, and I removed the intervening piece with a large slick. So is it always faster to do tenons on a jointer, no. Is it always faster to clean up the corners with a slick, no. But on a given day it was the fastest process, few absolutes many individual situations. I've been at this stuff for a long time, but it still isn't trivial for me to saw off veneer thickness pieces of 7"x7" from four cheeks.

Re: Things that hand tools do easily

#25

Re: Things that hand... easily - or so you think

ThomD

>"It may be easy to take off a thou with a power tool, but, at least for me, it would be a lot easier to take off 1/16" when trying for a thou ;-)"

Well they make those nice hand tools that take off the thous on power tools that take off thous or tens.

There are three ways of looking at this(just for starters): Taking off thous, taking off thous within a thou, and taking off several thos with a thous accuracy:

- Planes set to take a thou shaving, are very good at taking off a thou shaving, where that thou is relative to anything else is another mater. And for that mater whether that thou is fat or thin and consistent is another mater.

- Which takes us to making things not only a thou smaller, but an actual precise dimension everywhere, admitedly not even required in a lot of cases, though if one made guitars, or anything else where the parts had to interchange, one might care a lot.

- The third case taking off several thous with a thou or better accuracy, is a piece of take, shim stock or incra jig kind of deal and is very quick with little set-up.

To some degree, if you don't have tedious set-up, you just aren't working very accurately. And enjoy it for as long as you can! I do enjoy the fitting of parts to other parts because it is so easy, compared to making precise parts. Compare making to completely separate dovetail parts that never see their mate till assembly, with the usual process.

" I can do a lot with power tools, but the setup can be nasty for a lot of things. I have a Leigh jig. It makes dovetails very well, but if I am only doing a couple of drawers or one case, it is quicker to cut them by hand than to set up the jig and the router. This is also ignoring the fact that I can make DT's by hand that would be impossible with the jig."

I think there is a nomenclature issue here, a Jig isn't a power tool, it is some part pattern, fixture etc... Its usefulness is its repeatability in form, so to criticize it because it is repeatable, but not absolutely variable is not really fair. Most of our tools have some component of a jig, and pattern to them, be they chisels or planes, or saw, or router bits. But when they are so limited they fall into the jig catagory, we tend to lable them as such. The Leigh jig is pretty quick to set-up, but I rarely use mine for some of the reasons you set out. When the idea is just to get some dovetails in there for a structural joint, I have some ways of doing that that are faster. When it is a mater of doing really interesting dovetails, the Leigh ones aren't interesting enough.