Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

nice tools for carpentry?

Posts

nice tools for carpentry?

#1

nice tools for carpentry?

Joe Shelton

>Rhetorical question, I guess. Dinged my chisel plane yesterday, struggling to fit a new appliance into a hole it should have fit just fine.

Do you use your good stuff, especially planes, for carpentry?

I just had a hard time with the idea of firing up a router to take 3/32" off each jamb. (The boss would have been incensed if I'd taken it all off one side.)

What say ye?

Joe

Re: nice tools for carpentry?

#2

Re: nice tools for carpentry?

ThomD

>I don't all together use the good stuff. I remember too well tearing all the crosscut teeth off a Ryobi while triming a solid core door. there were some staples hiding in there.

Another bad experience was to come home from work and find some workmen had used a very expesnive art grade Japanese chisel as a cold chisel in removing an oil tank. Not quite what you were asking...

Over the years LV has put a good sellection of japanese replaceable blade saws on for ridiculous prices like 10 bucks. I bought heavily so that I wouldn't have to worry.

Today I was doing a neat piece of carpentry, building a daggerboard for my trimaran, and I used my dad's Rali plane. It was probably more effective that an Hotley would have been, since those planes have the most easily calibrated blade depth I have every used.

My approach is governed by:

- I have a ton of tools, mostly good, so I can use just about anything I like without endagering my only good tools.

- I try to keep some proportion in mind, certain tools are probably only going to need a sharpening if the worst happens. Other, like saws, that can be destroyed will not be put at risk.

- I can do good work with cheap tools. Ultimately it is the user not the tools, to some considerable degree. So, if I have to dip into the cheap stuff, like the discount blades, they are pretty good, and I can make them do what I need.

Re: nice tools for carpentry?

#3

Some, yes

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>As a rust hunter, I find a lot of the basic tools cheap, so I've settled on Stanley yellow-plastic-handled chisels for carpentry (the older ones are actually remarkably good tools - very tough steel, so they can handle the rigors of carpentry); but every once in a while, I'll need my 2" wide paring chisel or some other good chisel, so I pull it out and use it with care.

I don't hesitate to use the good planes, because I wouldn't use a plane where it could be endangered by nails.

So it varies.

Re: nice tools for carpentry?

#4

Re: nice tools for carpentry?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Joe,

I have separate tools for carpentry and odd jobs, and don't take ones from the bench. For sure, Borg chisels. I even have 'good' Borg chisels, and expendable ones that can be abused and reground. And decent saws, but not the real good ones. However, to take a risk with a saw, like risking a nail, it's gonna be a Sawzall, not a handtool. Workaday drills, not the good brad-point ones, where if you hit something you don't want to have the lip torn off the brad point one.

Like Thom, I've hit a staple fragment inside wood with a nice saw and torn 5 or 10 teeth off. Or dropped a saw and broke it. You drill and saw through a wall, and you don't know for sure what's on the other side--you can make a good guess, and you know what should be there, but you don't know where all the nails are. Or you end up in some kind of an odd situation like you described, and maybe you're trying to finish up today and not come back tomorrow, so you force the tool a little bit.

For me, nothing that belongs to the bench leaves the bench area.

Sorry that happened to your chisel plane. I know what you mean.

Wiley

Re: nice tools for carpentry?

#5

Re: nice tools for carpentry?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Depends on whether I'm building new or renovating. Building new I can control things like mails and wood, but would never use a good tool on plywood (LV has a Japanese plywood saw I bought for this). Renovating, it would be unusual to use a good tool, just too risky. I even display only the crummy tools, hide the good ones, so Jack won't accidentally use an expensive chisel for paint can opening and they don't rust sitting in their wooden houses.

Pam

Re: nice tools for carpentry?

#6

Re: nice tools for carpentry?

steve mackay

>I'll admit it ! I've got "shop / work " tools and " house " tools. They rarely cross over. Anything in the house thats "from scratch" is OK but NO remodeling with the work tools. The house tools hang in the garage and are fare game for LOML. Not so the "work" tools.

Re: nice tools for carpentry?

#7

Re: Plywood

ThomD

>What with boatbuilding and a looking longingly through the window at aircraft building... I have quite a fondness for plywood, and don't really consider it a lesser wood, or hard on tools, though I use cheaper, or power saws on it, and any kind of plane that works on it.

Re: nice tools for carpentry?

#8

Re: Plywood

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I don't consider it lessor, just different; and I think the hard glues are harder on fine tools than hard wood, makes me cringe to think of even trying them on plywood.

Pam