Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Saw question

Posts

Re: Saw question

#26

Re: Saws born, not made

Marv

>A true craftsman can take a tool with no life and life will be created with it. For me that life comes from the craftsman himself.

What is your definition of A TRUE craftsman (craftsperson) as apposed to just a craftsperson? Once one is deamed a craftsperson, that's pretty much it. Are there different levels of craftspersonship? And if so, how would you establish the different levels?

I'm trying to figure out how a tool can come to life. Whatever is produced with the tool will not be a living thing. It will be as lifeless as the tool that made it.

I think what we might be touching on here is Symbolism. Any tool and anything that is made with the tool is symbolic of all that the tool represents. It is symbolic of it's maker and is symbolic of it's origin. The origin is symbolic of it's maker as well. Nothing is only as it appears. When we view and marvel over a Sam Maloof creation, such as a rocking chair, for example, the chair isn't only something we sit in, it is symbolic of the person who built it, plus everything the person used to make it with, including the skills required. When we realize the symbolism in things, it is only then that we can truely appreciate the item for what it really is.

Marv

Re: Saw question

#27

Re: Saws born, not made - The real asnwer

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thom,

I think you are probably very close to what Mark said. One proof of the truth of what you said is that there is no way Mark is going to come back and tease his statement apart and explain it further to us (<:).

I think there is also a physical interpretation of Mark's statement. If someone says that a saw is lifeless, the truth of that seems plain on its face--it's commonsense. And so all discussion of a saw being 'born' is a metaphor, it's a step away from what is real.

But I would argue that a saw--particularly a handmade saw like Mark is talking about--has memory. In an article co-authored by Mark and Jay Van Arsdale ("Woodwork", April 2001 Issue), Mark described how the great Japanese sawmaker Yataiki would hammer a saw for 4 to 6 hours to flatten and tension it, after it had been forged, scraped to the appropriate taper or double taper, and burnished. Now a saw that has been hand-scraped to final taper, and hammer-tensioned that way by a master maker does not look, feel, or behave like a machine-made saw. It carries its history with it.

[This is not to be derogatory to the machine-made saw, which is the bread and butter of even great craftsmen, who would not think of carrying their best saws to a job site.]

Returning to the notion that saws have memory....After Yataiki hammered for 4-6 hours on that saw body, the steel has been received thousands of little dislocations in its crystal structure, which makes it stiffer and very strong in the sense that it resists bending and springs back to hold its shape. No metal was removed by the hammering, but the steel was changed at the crystal level. It is in a state of internal tension.

The minute Yataiki performs these steps on this piece of steel, the steel has been changed from now on, and will retain the properties it has been given. You pick it up 20 years later, and it still has the pebbled surface and the strength attributes in the grain structure imparted by the original hammer.

If I pick up that saw, I can tell a few things about it, from general familiarity. But if Mark picks up that saw and examines it, he will 'read' the saw and know much of its history. Because he has made such saws. So when Mark says,

"By being born, I mean if I respect the life in the steel, etc., while I'm working with it, then the saw should still have life in it when it's finished."

I tend to read that at a physical, down-to-earth level. He can read the saw, suss out its history; he knows how the strength, hardness, and flexibility of the saw were put there; and he is determined that all of his actions will preserve and/or restore the saw to its original potential. In his own simpler and better words, "...the saw should still have life in it when it's finished." He delivers on that, too.

Wiley

Re: Saw question

#28

Re: Saws born, not made

Alan DuBoff

>Marv wrote:

"What is your definition of A TRUE craftsman (craftsperson) as apposed to just a craftsperson?"

My definition is a figure of speech! :-)

Any craftsman that can use their tools which are available, and at hand, and create with them. Lots of people fit this description.

All I really meant was that, it's in the craftsman, not the tools. I don't believe the life is in the tool.

Cheers,

Alan