How we saw; how should we saw?
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Thank you gentlemen,
I read Mike's 'sick monkey' blog that Craig pointed to. And have been absorbing Mike and Marv's explanations. Will get to the 'gloat' in a moment. Warning: this is a japanese saw, which could be a letdown for push-sawers. More to that in a minute.
Both Mike and Marv speak to the breasted saw being more aggressive at the outset, and less at the finish, than a straight-bladed saw. Mike relates this (I think) to the effect of breasting on tooth rake. Both Mike and Marv also speak to the 'oval' sawing motion, and that breasting is complementary with the arc that the arm and the saw make in the cutting stroke.
I tried to draw a picture of rake as affected by breasting or by the arc of the stroke, but immediate ran into trouble visualizing how multiple teeth are engaging the work. When you read old Disston texts (Lumberman's Handbook), he illustrates the cutting of a single tooth--that single tooth is either planing (rip saw) or slicing (crosscut) the fibers.
But when we saw, there are multiple teeth in the cut. Are they all cutting at the same time? This depends on whether the toothline is matching the kerf bed (is that a term?). I can see how an oval sawing motion, combined with a convex toothline, can create a complementary curved kerf bed, with several teeth engaged where the toothline meets the kerf bed. On paper, at least.
But do we want lots of teeth engaged? As I saw I am alternating between flattening the attack angle so as to guide the saw straight, and then steepening the attack angle to attack a thinner section, so that fewer teeth are making a deeper bite. I change the angle of the saw to find the thinnest section of the board to attack, rather than let the kerf bed get longer and longer as the cut deepens. Because as the kerf bed gets longer, no tooth is getting a deep bite--they're beginning to ride on the kerf bed, with each stroke is taking a thinner bite out of a longer cut line. So I change my luck by attacking a thinner section, such that fewer teeth are attacking, but they're attacking where they can get a deeper bite.
But maybe that's not right. So let me stop here and put this back to you all--what is the most efficient sawing strategy, for both accuracy and speed? Should we be varying the attack angle, or should we be going for repetition of the exact same arm motion, again and again?
The gloat.....I love this saw. Crosscut. Made by Heiji. It's 300mm which is on the biggish side for a Japanese saw; moderate breasting; constant 12 ppi; rake looks to be ~1 degree negative (aggressive); double tapered; kerf width is 37 thou and does not vary by more than + or - 1 thou along the toothline; extremely fast and smooth in hardwood. Somehow let the teeth touch the back of my knuckle inspecting it, and it made two tiny little points of blood where the teeth landed for a moment.
Wiley