Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Saw question

Posts

Saw question

#1

Saw question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Esteemed neanders,

Could someone please explain what a slightly convex toothline (breasting) does for a saw. it really seems to make the saw more aggressive, but is that so in your experience? And if so, how does it do it?

Thanks,

Wiley...... gloating over a new saw.

Re: Saw question

#3

"gloating over a new saw"

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Don't be coy...picture, please!

Re: Saw question

#4

Re: Saw question

Marv

>Hi Wiley,

The curvature of the tooth edge causes the teeth to remain engaged with the wood throughout the forward stoke. As we perform the forward motion of the saw, the natural movement of our arm is in an oval motion. Some saws would have as much as 3/8" convexity. Usually, it's about 1/8" or so on a 26" saw blade.

Marv

Re: Saw question

#5

Re: Saw question

MikeW

>Hi Wiley,

Like Marv said, it is more the geometry of sawing at play than making a saw more or less aggressive. Aggressiveness has to do with the filing chosen. Breasting accounts in part for the motion of sawing and the relaxation of the rake at the end of the stroke.

But like Bill writes...give us more info on the gloat! Can I say you suck without a picture or more information? I guess I just did...!

Take care, Mike

Re: Saw question

#6

Re: Saw question

Marv

>Wiley,

Is it a new-new saw or an old-new saw?

If you have a saw that is breasted and another exact saw that is not breasted, both with the same tooth profile, the breasted one will be a little more aggressive for about 2/3 of the length from the toe end. The last 1/3 will be a little less aggressive.

Marv

Re: Saw question

#7

Re: Saw question

Marv

>Hi Mike,

Your two items are in the mail and headed north.

Marv

Re: Saw question

#8

How we saw; how should we saw?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thank you gentlemen,

I read Mike's 'sick monkey' blog that Craig pointed to. And have been absorbing Mike and Marv's explanations. Will get to the 'gloat' in a moment. Warning: this is a japanese saw, which could be a letdown for push-sawers. More to that in a minute.

Both Mike and Marv speak to the breasted saw being more aggressive at the outset, and less at the finish, than a straight-bladed saw. Mike relates this (I think) to the effect of breasting on tooth rake. Both Mike and Marv also speak to the 'oval' sawing motion, and that breasting is complementary with the arc that the arm and the saw make in the cutting stroke.

I tried to draw a picture of rake as affected by breasting or by the arc of the stroke, but immediate ran into trouble visualizing how multiple teeth are engaging the work. When you read old Disston texts (Lumberman's Handbook), he illustrates the cutting of a single tooth--that single tooth is either planing (rip saw) or slicing (crosscut) the fibers.

But when we saw, there are multiple teeth in the cut. Are they all cutting at the same time? This depends on whether the toothline is matching the kerf bed (is that a term?). I can see how an oval sawing motion, combined with a convex toothline, can create a complementary curved kerf bed, with several teeth engaged where the toothline meets the kerf bed. On paper, at least.

But do we want lots of teeth engaged? As I saw I am alternating between flattening the attack angle so as to guide the saw straight, and then steepening the attack angle to attack a thinner section, so that fewer teeth are making a deeper bite. I change the angle of the saw to find the thinnest section of the board to attack, rather than let the kerf bed get longer and longer as the cut deepens. Because as the kerf bed gets longer, no tooth is getting a deep bite--they're beginning to ride on the kerf bed, with each stroke is taking a thinner bite out of a longer cut line. So I change my luck by attacking a thinner section, such that fewer teeth are attacking, but they're attacking where they can get a deeper bite.

But maybe that's not right. So let me stop here and put this back to you all--what is the most efficient sawing strategy, for both accuracy and speed? Should we be varying the attack angle, or should we be going for repetition of the exact same arm motion, again and again?

The gloat.....I love this saw. Crosscut. Made by Heiji. It's 300mm which is on the biggish side for a Japanese saw; moderate breasting; constant 12 ppi; rake looks to be ~1 degree negative (aggressive); double tapered; kerf width is 37 thou and does not vary by more than + or - 1 thou along the toothline; extremely fast and smooth in hardwood. Somehow let the teeth touch the back of my knuckle inspecting it, and it made two tiny little points of blood where the teeth landed for a moment.

Wiley

Re: Saw question

#9

Re: How we saw; how should we saw?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>You want to be able to guide the saw without changing the angle. The ideal is to have a constant angle that is the most efficient angle. That said, sometimes if the stuff is thick and the teeth are a little small and clogging, it is helpful to change the angle occasionally so as to be effectively cutting a smaller thickness. I think some people, when sawing thick stuff, intentionally (or subconsciously) rock the saw during the cut to engage less teeth at a time when they want to achieve this same effect.

I'm not sure I buy the oval motion argument. An experienced worker can adjust his motion to the saw whether the saw be concave or convex or flat.

Re: Saw question

#10

Re: How we saw; how should we saw?

Marv

>Hi Wiley,

I'm more versed on western style saws that are used with only one hand a good deal of the time, except for two handed rip sawing.

As I understand, correct me if I'm wrong, when using a japanese pull saw, the work piece will usually be clamped in place while the saw is pulled with both hands. When visualizing this motion, I don't see an oval movement of the arms.

However, if a japanese saw is breasted, the aggressiveness of the sawing will be increased the same or similar to a western push saw.

For general purposes, I prefer a straight edge push saw, both when filing them and when using them. If I want the saw to cut more aggressively, I will decrease the rake angle.

With any saw, if you saw straight across at the thickness of the wood, it will of course cut faster, but probably not as smooth. And the more angle of the saw, the slower it will cut. It's the same as cutting a thicker piece of wood. This goes for ripping and crosscutting.

Marv

Re: Saw question

#11

Re: How we saw; how should we saw?

MikeW

>Japanese saw gloat a let down? I don't think so!

X-number of teeth cutting at the same time. Yes, but at any given time, with any given technique and saw, there would more or less teeth engaged in the kerf floor at the same moment. Meaning if one is ripping with a 5 ppi rip-filed saw that is held at precidely a 60 degree angle to the face of the cut in an 8/4 board, that the saw could go in a true straight line on both the forward and back strke, there would be about 3 teeth engaged.

The reality is we all do a circular motion even if one tries not to with a hand saw. The smaller the saw, and the more upright the workpiece is held (think DTs held against the face of a bench) one can muster a pretty level cut to the baseline, at least for the finishing strokes. Even with good technique, a Japanese saw doesn't have every tooth engaged with equal effect because of some slight saw tilt.

Sawing Technique. I think the right and proper way to saw is however one can obtain the desired results. Cutting geometry on a given saw may require a different angle altogether in one species to the next or to a saw filed differently (much less one with greater or lesser ppi).

In general, one can lower the sawing angle to correct a cut strying from the line. This has long been "the proper techinique" to bring a cut back on-line. This engages fewer teeth allowing the kerf to be restablished before raising the saw back to a more efficient cutting angle. With sufficient set (think too great of set in my opinion) one can lightly steer a cut. But with less set, it is the lowering of the saw which brings about the desired result quicker.

When sawing on-line where there isn't need to correct the cut, each saw in a given board and or species will have a more efficient cutting angle. Rake, fleam, ppi all play a part as goes the saw as to what that angle is. So while I think I try to replicate with consistancy "that angle" I find cutting more efficiently, it is darn hard for me to hold that angle down a board. Cross cutting 20" and narrower stuff holding an efficient angle is pretty easy for me. But long rips I tend to "forget" to move and so the angle more or less changes as the saw advances towards my side.

PPI and engaged teeth. I tend towards the "I like sawing, but I wanna get done" philosophy. So I gravitate towards coarser saws than some and deisre as few teeth engaged as possible. For the desired quality of the keeper-side of the cut that is. Some cuts simply mean I use a finer toothed saw than I might otherwise use because I am cutting close to finish size for any number of reasons.

Don't know if this helps at all. But it has been rattling around in my mind all morning.

Take care, Mike

Re: Saw question

#12

I don't know

Adam Cherubini

>Wiley,

This issue has me stumped. You have to remember that there's no way to move the saw in a straight line because it's cutting the wood and moving backwards at the same time. So it's almost impossible to think about it statically.

My experience is that I prefer a breasted saw. I've made saws both ways and prefer saws with the beliied blade shape.

Guessing, I think it's possible that the breasted shape allows your hand to travel straighter than it would otherwise. The "belly" accounts for some of the progress of the saw. This may also explain why coarser saws that move more wood have more belly.

But I'm guessing

adam

Re: Saw question

#13

Follow-up saw question--English vs. American

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Just as a matter of curiosity, I searched through Astragal Press's book "The Handsaw Catalog Collection". Astragal reprints the following catalogs of 4 different makers:

-E. C. Atkins..........1919 catalog

-Henry Disston......1918 catalog

-Simonds Mfg........1910 catalog

-Spear & Jackson....1915 catalog

Every single one of Spear & Jackson's first-line hand saws are advertised as 'breasted at the tooth line'. All of the American makers are silent on this point. Question: What was the American practice in regard to breasting?

Wiley

Re: Saw question

#14

Re: Follow-up saw question--English vs. American

Marv

>Wiley,

From what I've read, Disston and other American saw makers made their more expensive saws with breasted tooth edge but didn't do it on the higher production models. Many of them would make a saw to special order upon request.

In 1928, Disston and what few saw makers were still in business made some drastic cost reduction design changes to most all their saw models. IMO, most saws made after that date took a nose dive in overall quality. I have not run across any breasted saws made after that time made by the saw makers you listed. Simonds went out of the handsaw making business in 1926. I guess they saw the writing on the wall and chose not to take the nose dive in order to complete with the other junky saws.

Marv

Re: Saw question

#15

Re: Saw question

mark grable

>Last month a friend gave me a Simonds Precision Cross-cut Saw Tool No. 342, in a little green cardbord box marked 3.50 in pencil. I'll have to figure out how to post pictures, but briefly it's a cast steel frame with hardened steel stampings and screws. One of the screws holds a 1/16" x 1/2" file to the frame while forcing it to bow, like a Ships Plane. Does a nice jointed edge on big whip saws - about a week later someone brought me whip saw to sharpen, for a summer camp.

Its hard to imagine just what is going on down there in a saw kerf. If you start with the handle high, and lower it as you pull, you could saw a saddle or convex kerf, if the board is wide enough, and it would be the same as a bellied or breasted saw as far as the individual teeth are concerned. The likely-hood of ending up with a flat surface at right angles to your board tho is nil. Sawing all four sides of a stick to marked lines is a good exercise, cross cut or ripping, and when the kerf meets exactly on the same plane, you are getting good. I like to study the two pieces of wood as soon as they're apart. For many years I always marked at least one line to try to cut to, whatever even rough cut-off's. Ripping with a table-saw leaves some interesting lessons too. Lotsa belly in these blades.

Alot depends on how precise you need to be, or how fast you need to be.

Saws are so individual - I feel they are born, not made. Mostly they have more potential than seems at first glance.

Re: Saw question

#16

Saws born, not made

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I agree, assuming I'm interpreting your line correctly. To me it's the sawyer who makes the saw and/or the tool user who makes the tool. Now I'm assuming that there's a basic tool/saw there, but it takes more than a $20,000 Yataiki saw of tamahagane to make a great cut. And the better skilled the tool user, the more inferior the tool can be and still allow him/her to produce good work.

Pam

Re: Saw question

#17

Re: Saws born, not made

mark grable

>That is so true, skill/experience/practice is fundamental to performance - I'm even getting better at typing. (however) This computer is not fustrating - like the last one - and that helps. Also i fixed the power steering on the back hoe - and it's much safer on hills. I have to catch the leaking fluid in a tray when i get to where I'm going, and put it back in when I'm ready to move, but I'm working on the forge site now anyway. (sometimes, I admit, I blather)

By being born, I mean if I respect the life in the steel, etc., while I'm working with it, then the saw should still have life in it when it's finished.

Re: Saw question

#18

Re: Saws born, not made

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Nothing much worse than an recalcitrant computer.

Power steering on a back hoe? Now that's something I hadn't considered. Guess there's no vacuum/pressure involved.

Born not made? OK, makes sense, but that sort of assumes there's a saw in that steel just waiting to get out. I suppose, given Michelangelo's similar line about marble sculpture; but probably malleable steel can take on more forms than marble, so there could also be some hammers, chisels, etc. sitting there waiting for the smith. Perhaps you mean it more generally, that you work to allow the steel's personality to display in the saw?

Pam

Re: Saw question

#19

Re: Saws born, not made - The real asnwer

ThomD

>I think the actual concept of born not made is a Buddhist one where the idea is that everything is in everything. This way of thinking rejects dicotomies of subject/object, or in this case user/tool. There is no sharpness without a mover to apply the object to the saw or the saw to the object. There is no hardness in steel without the softness of wood (rocks are harder to cut and the saw would no longer seem hard in trying to cut them). In this sense the respect for materials is even a little artificial since they are relative and not absolute. Relative to the materials involved, the skills involved, and so on. Born in the sense that they are what they are as is vs. somthing we coral off in a little place and say we made. Nature vs nurture.

Of course in this philosophy there isn't any "real answer", "actual concept", or philosphy.

Re: Saw question

#20

Re: Saws born, not made - The real asnwer

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Of course in this philosophy there isn't any "real answer", "actual concept", or philosphy.

:)

Pam

Re: Saw question

#21

Re: Saws born, not made - The real asnwer

Raney

>And yet there is still Truth and falsehood.

It's the telling them apart that is the big freedom (Moksha)

Re: Saw question

#22

Thanks. I'm glad y'all clarified that.

Hank Knight

>

Re: Saw question

#23

Re: Saws born, not made - The real asnwer *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Truth and falsehood? I spent a day or two late last week reading Errol Morris' NYTimes column on just this topic. I don't think we want to go there here.

Pam


Morris' "Seven Lies about Lying"

Re: Saw question

#24

Re: Saws born, not made

Alan DuBoff

>That is certainly so in the Shinto world, where spirits/Gods are within most everything, but speaking for myself I don't feel any spirit in my tools, other than the life which I provide.

It's just a different perspective, where I see tools with no life, and if the craftsman can provide life they create marvelous work. If they can't provide life, nothing is created.

Witness the amount of craftsmen with great tools that don't create very much with them.

A true craftsman can take a tool with no life and life will be created with it. For me that life comes from the craftsman himself.

Out of curiosity, how long does it take to forge/scrape a Japanese saw? It is something I wouldn't mind trying someday...I've never fully understood the entire process.

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Saw question

#25

Re: Saws born, not made

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>A true craftsman can take a tool with no life and life will be created with it. For me that life comes from the craftsman himself.

Do you think the craftsperson can do woodworking without tools? If not, which I highly doubt, then your above statement can't possibly be true. Together a craftsperson and a tool can work magic, a synchrony. Either alone can't do much. I will say that the tool doesn't intend anything.

Pam