Interesting commentary by Dave Burnard
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Hi Ellis and all,
Here is some interesting commentary by physicist/blacksmith Dave Burnard. This quote is from Harrelson Stanley's forum on Japanese tools, and was made a few years ago--I hope Dave will forgive me for taking the liberty. The information is remarkable on a number of counts (IMO), but I'll let you decide:
"The changeover from wrought iron to modern mild steel making didn't happen overnight. The key technological advance was the Bessemer process which replaced the Puddling process for mass producing steel of all types. The Wikipedia articles for these processes are good introductory reading. The conversion was probably mostly complete by the late 1800's but there were still a few puddling furnaces in the US up until the 1950's or so.
The point of interest for us is that puddled wrought iron is stirred in a semi liquid state that contains a lot of slag like inclusions which result in it's unique fibrous nature. Wrought iron can be refined to various degrees which remove more and more of the slag. As this refinement occurs the material gets harder and loses the rust resistance imparted by the impurities.
In the Bessemer process, the raw iron is brought to a very high temp molten state and oxygen is blasted through it to clean out the impurities. So it's very clean and very solid - whereas wrought iron could be something like 10-30% slag by volume.
The relatively coarse wrought iron - like what you see etched in planes and chisels can be significantly softer to work with at the forge - and it is also significantly easier to abrade away when sharpening since it full of slag and is free from the build up of alloy contaminants found in modern grades of mild steel (based on recycled materials)
Japan produced very little wrought iron of it's own - so all of those anchor chains and bridge plates that plane blades are made from came originally from Europe or America. Japan went from Tatara, to importing finished product, then converted over to modern Bessemer methods.
Watetsu is old Japanese iron - made in a tatara. Kamaji refers to the imported wrought iron in it's many forms (although literally it refers to boiler plate).
Hope that helps.
dburnard
____________
Note the key role played by the impurities (slag)--the aficionados always look for black inclusions in their iron backing. Also, note that most of that anchor chain and boiler plate outside Japanese smiths' shops was originally imported from the west.
Wiley