Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

Posts

DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

#1

DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

Craig D

>My "Bauhaus" infill smoothing plane, 9" long (same size as a #4). The joinery is exposed so I can easily dissemble the plane (the rear infill is fastened by screws into the sole). The plane is based on a stainless steel kit made by Andy Lincoln. The dovetails have been silver brazed (rather than peined).

Craig





Slide show

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

#2

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs*

ThomD

>Great look, nice piece of work!!

If I were making the handle I would concentrate less on a hand filling design, than minimizing hand torqueby squaring up the aft surface and aligning it better with the lifeline. A slightly uncomfortable looking power surface is actually more effective.

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

#3

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs*

Craig D

>TomD writes:

>Great look, nice piece of work!!

Thanks!

>If I were making the handle I would concentrate less on a hand filling design, than minimizing hand torque, by squaring up the aft surface and aligning it better with the life line. A slightly uncomfortable looking power surface is actually more effective.

I think I'm missing something here; yes the handle is wide (big?) at 1 1/4" but I find that much more comfortable than the ~7/8" found on Stanley's and many saws (and I have smallish hands). I designed the grip like that of a saw; in a typical planeing position, the wrist and forearm are straight and the index finger points though the center of the plane. Thus the full power of the arm pushes the plane down and forward through the center of the palm. That's the theory anyway. It's not perfect and I might stand the next one a little more upright.

Craig

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

#4

Beautiful!

Hank Knight

>

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

#5

Super cool !

steve mackay

>

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

#6

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs*

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn,MI

>Craig,

That certainly looks very nice alot different than when I sent it out.Great work.Now if I send another one like mine with a return address will it come back looking like yours?

Andy


img

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

#7

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs*

Craig D

>Andy wrote:

>That certainly looks very nice alot different than when I sent it out.Great work.

Thanks Andy! That water jet is an amazing tool, very good and accurate cuts. But I can't seem to leave things alone.

>Now if I send another one like mine with a return address will it come back looking like yours?

No problem. However, the return postage might seem a little high!

Craig

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

#8

Fabulous, Stunning!!

Marv

>

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

#9

Andy, what is the reason...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>for choosing Stainless Steel instead of more conventional (traditional) materials?

Stephen

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

#10

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs*

Dominic Greco in Bucks County Pa------WebKitFormBo

>Wow!!!! That looks stunning!!

Well done!! Well done indeed!

Dominic

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

#11

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Craig,

Beautiful work! Is that your go-to smoother now?

I am curious about the silver brazing--could you describe how that is done?

Thank you, Wiley

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

#12

Re: Andy, what is the reason...

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn,MI

>Stephen,

The main reason is access.We waterjet alot of stainless steel and it is"easy" to slip a couple parts into waste areas of sheets while the machine is doing its thing.Brass is expensive,and I couldn't keep the scrap/leftover from the sheet lying around at work,it would most certainly disappear.I do know of a certain webmiester that did get an infill kit made with brass sides and a stainless steel soleplate,but I don't think it has been assembled yet : )...that is how I know that sheet brass disappears....

I could use mild steel as we cut a fair amount of that as well it is just rare that we have it in 1/8" and/or 3/16" material usually everything is 1/4" or thicker.

And answer your question with a question what materials would be considered traditional?Trying not to ask this in a smart a@@ way ,but thinking I could be overlooking common materials we may use from time to time.

Thanks,

Andy

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

#13

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs*

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn,MI

>C'mon Craig I know the post office has raised the rates lately but a finished plane can easily fit into a priority box for a flat rate of around $12.I'd be willing to send a check for this amount with teh kit to cover the return postage.

Andy

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

#14

Re: Andy, what is the reason...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Early clad planes were wrought iron sheet joined in a similar manner. I am not sure when it was replaced with steel for such applications, but true wrought iron is difficult to find and can be very expensive.

Stephen

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

#15

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs*

Craig D

>Wiley wrote:

>Beautiful work! Is that your go-to smoother now?

Thanks and I don't know yet. I have an embarrassment of smoothers, 45, 47, 50, 55 & 60 degrees (Stanley, three user made and Gordon). I suspect it will get stuck in the rotation. There are enough differences in use that I can use whichever I think will work best (or is the sharpest).

>I am curious about the silver brazing--could you describe how that is done?

Sure, it is basically high temp soldering. The joint to be brazed (the dovetails in this case) should have a gap of around 0.003" - 0.005" for best strength (not that it matters in this case) and to allow for capillary action to help the silver to flow. I use a paste flux to clean the metal and keep oxygen away from the hot metal, the stuff is pretty nasty so I use a good respirator (mask). I heat the joint with a oxy/acetylene torch (000 or 00 tip) to 1200F, add 56% silver filler and move the torch around to flow the filler (it follows the heat). It is very important not to over heat as that will burn the flux and then you're hosed. Jigging and brazing sequence is also pretty important as metal expands and contracts a lot during brazing (I usually screw that part up). Preheating helps.

I suspect brazing vs peining is toss up, durability wise, for planes. I have lots of experience with brazing and welding (from building bicycles) so that is my bias. I've made a couple of TIG welded planes and they turned out well. Lots of ways to skin this cat. One of the reasons I choose silver for this plane was the subtle contrast with the stainless steel would make the joinery visible for that touch of "class" (ie pat myself on the back).

Craig

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

#16

Ellis Walentine

Question on wrought iron

Ellis Walentine

>I just unearthed a wrought iron buckboard axle when I was doing some excavating behind my barn. I gave it to a buddy of mine who makes tools and steam engines and flintlock rifles and such. Would this type of iron be of interest to toolmakers? How rare is it really?

Ellis

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

#17

Ellis Walentine

That is beautiful

Ellis Walentine

>You've just raised the bar another notch, Craig. Thanks a lot. :-)

Ellis

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

#18

Purdy! Like your saw handles too!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>I'd would have over-stuffed myself. Very nice job on it none the same!

Why the blade set screws... Never quite got them myself?

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

#19

Re: Purdy! Like your saw handles too!

Craig D

>Scott wrote:

>I'd would have over-stuffed myself. Very nice job on it none the same!

Thanks! Couldn't overstuff, the rear infill moves (the mouth is adjustable). Not that I would have anyway, I like the bevels on the metal sides.

>Why the blade set screws... Never quite got them myself?

If you look at the pics, you'll notice I don't have the set screws installed. The iron is as wide as the mouth so they wouldn't do anything. As to why they are there, the holes were drilled in the sides when I got them and I figured "what the heck" and didn't fill them (like I did the rear infill holes, check out Andy's pic). I would sure like them on my Stanley's as the irons are pretty "floppy" (big mouth, small iron).

Glad you like the saw handles, you probably noticed the family resemblance.

Craig

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

#20

Re: Question on wrought iron

Tony - Memphis

>I took a couple of classes a the National Ornamental Metal Museum here in Memphis over the winter. I recall one of the instructors stating that some form of iron had not been produced in the US for many years (it was loud and I was overhearing a conversation in the shop). Was that wrought iron maybe? They use different materials for their projects than what we assume.

We did casting in aluminum and silicon-bronze. Did some forming in copper. Neat stuff.

Tony

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

#21

My dad had a hammer, in my youth,

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>with the same kind of finger scallops. I was surprised to find how well it fit my preteen hand, and his great big adult hand too.

I didn't find it when we cleared out the garage in selling the house a few years ago. I don't know if the hammer migrated somewhere or the handle broke, but it was sure an interesting handle.

Way not as pretty as your work, by a factor of about 10,000.

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

#22

Re: Question on wrought iron *LINK*

Craig D

>Tony writes:

>I recall one of the instructors stating that some form of iron had not been produced in the US for many years (it was loud and I was overhearing a conversation in the shop). Was that wrought iron maybe?

I think that is correct, from the wikipedia:

Wrought iron is no longer commercially produced. The last wrought iron facility shut down in 1969.

Other interesting factoids: "wrought" means "worked" and wrought iron is pure iron, with no intentionally added ingredients. Some forms are quite resistant to corrosion. Konrad Sauer used iron for the sole of one his planes.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wrought_iron

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

#23

Re: Question on wrought iron

Alan DuBoff

>Ellis,

It would be useful if the smith was going to laminate it with high carbon steel for the edge. By doing that, the softer wrought iron acts as a dampener for the higher carbon steel on the edge. The higher carbon steel is brittle when tempered, hence the softer wrought iron steel to laminate with it, otherwise the blade would be very brittle, and chip easily. The wrought iron is less fragile/brittle, and much more durable than the high carbon steel.

Some folks complain about Japanese chisels being brittle as they are, and they do laminate them in a similar fashion. In fact, the Japanese often use wrought iron from old anchor chain.

Other folks claim them to be some of the best chisels available in our day...go figure...

There are places that sell wrought iron, and yes, they do get a premium for it, so it is useful to have. But it is only useful to those that can really use it to it's fullest, like a bladesmith.

Cheers,

Alan

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

#24

Interesting commentary by Dave Burnard

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Ellis and all,

Here is some interesting commentary by physicist/blacksmith Dave Burnard. This quote is from Harrelson Stanley's forum on Japanese tools, and was made a few years ago--I hope Dave will forgive me for taking the liberty. The information is remarkable on a number of counts (IMO), but I'll let you decide:

"The changeover from wrought iron to modern mild steel making didn't happen overnight. The key technological advance was the Bessemer process which replaced the Puddling process for mass producing steel of all types. The Wikipedia articles for these processes are good introductory reading. The conversion was probably mostly complete by the late 1800's but there were still a few puddling furnaces in the US up until the 1950's or so.

The point of interest for us is that puddled wrought iron is stirred in a semi liquid state that contains a lot of slag like inclusions which result in it's unique fibrous nature. Wrought iron can be refined to various degrees which remove more and more of the slag. As this refinement occurs the material gets harder and loses the rust resistance imparted by the impurities.

In the Bessemer process, the raw iron is brought to a very high temp molten state and oxygen is blasted through it to clean out the impurities. So it's very clean and very solid - whereas wrought iron could be something like 10-30% slag by volume.

The relatively coarse wrought iron - like what you see etched in planes and chisels can be significantly softer to work with at the forge - and it is also significantly easier to abrade away when sharpening since it full of slag and is free from the build up of alloy contaminants found in modern grades of mild steel (based on recycled materials)

Japan produced very little wrought iron of it's own - so all of those anchor chains and bridge plates that plane blades are made from came originally from Europe or America. Japan went from Tatara, to importing finished product, then converted over to modern Bessemer methods.

Watetsu is old Japanese iron - made in a tatara. Kamaji refers to the imported wrought iron in it's many forms (although literally it refers to boiler plate).

Hope that helps.

dburnard

____________

Note the key role played by the impurities (slag)--the aficionados always look for black inclusions in their iron backing. Also, note that most of that anchor chain and boiler plate outside Japanese smiths' shops was originally imported from the west.

Wiley

Re: DIY Infill: Finished! *big PICs* *LINK*

#25

Thanks for the info *LINK*

Tony - Memphis

>And if anybody is interested, the classes at the museum are very good. I took sand casting and the weathervane class. They have blacksmithing and I think a pewter class this year too. I may take blacksmithing 101 next time. I would like to take sand casting again and attempt to make some sort of woodworking tool. You can also work with the folks there and use the facilities without taking a class after you complete a class. Obviously, there are limitations on that. We went to watch a cast iron pour one night. That was pretty cool, especially at night. Here is a link to a page I did on my casting class...

Great place to visit too. They always have some neat projects going on. They are also very friendly and willing to explain. I felt like I was a hamster on display when the visitors came through and watched us!

Tony


Sand Casting Class