Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

Posts

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#26

My guess...

James Watriss

>I think that most of the folks who carry pocket knives consider them to be a tool, and don't want to justify having to carry one with the "Hey, what if I need to kill someone," defense.

Bad enough that kids can't even bring butter knives into school anymore without being suspended. Truth is, yes, if it's going to be classified as a weapon, we should be guaranteed to the right to carry one. But I'd rather sit on the philosophical high horse and say that it's a very useful tool. Edged weapons allowed us to shape our world, it's important to learn how to use one properly, etc. Boy Scouts have the image of being the pinnacle of public servants... and also are supposed to be very handy with a knife.

Alas, the truth is that we have to rely on the 2nd amendment to protect our tools, despite the fact that a few ten penny nails in a louisville slugger would make a much more efective and menacing weapon, and the idea that even a shoelace can be used to kill someone quietly.

"I'm sorry Billy, I can't teach you how to tie your shoes anymore... laces are illegal, and certainly not permitted in school."

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#27

Wouldn't the ADA have some say?

Paul M.

>It seems like the disabled community would protest the banning of pocket knives that could be operated by one hand. Not everyone has two you know.

There's lots of woodworkers nicknamed "stubby" in this world (usually production shaper operators) that would testify to a need for a pocket knife that can be operated by one hand. ;-)

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#28

Re: A well regulated Militia ....

Alex Grigoriev

>Being very terse, the amendments are open to different interpretations. "Well regulated militia", what it means? Does it mean that armed people should be subject of regulations, and how far should these regulations go? Do you interpret the whole sentence, as "*Since* well regulated militia *is* necessary, etc"? It's a can of worms. What "cruel and unusual punishment" means? When a punishment becomes cruel? Is life term for a stolen videotape "cruel and unusual? (conservative members of SCOTUS decided "no, it's not").

And in any case, right to bear arms, doesn't mean that you have the right to import arms without regulations. You have rights to consume stuff, you just can't bring any stuff you want from abroad.

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#29

This reminds me of my return flight from

Victor Parisian

>British Columbia a few years back. We were on vacation in Alaska with a cruise down the coast ending in Vancouver. When they scanned our bags at the airport, they couldn't identify the object in the bottom of the bag, my wife and I insisted it must be her curling irons. However when they pulled the unidentified object out of the bag, I remembered that while in Alaska I picked up a spike from the Alaskan Railroad...

Anyway they looked in their big book of forbidden items and decided that the railroad spike must be less dangerous than the nail clippers that I had to abandon in Houston on the way out of town. Go figure.

I still have the spike in a drawer somewhere.

Victor in Houston

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#30

Re: This reminds me of my return flight from

Hank Knight

>Several years ago I flew from London to Edinburgh. When I arrived in Edinburgh, I was shunted into a small room where my checked bag lay on a table in front of me. My Royal Guard escort instructed me to open my bag and display its contents. As I complied, he picked up an item from my bag that was wrapped in brown paper and carefully unwrapped it. As it appeared from the paper, the officer got a huge grin on his face and said in his heavy Scottish brogue "Ey, we don't get many of these," and he held up the Norris A5 my daughter had purchased and given to me in London. He instructed me to repack my bag and sent me on my way. I have chuckled about that incident often since.

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#31

Re: A well regulated Militia ....

Guest

>At the time, "regulated" had nothing to do with regulations. It meant equipped or functional and ready to go.

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#32

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Are you saying, Ray, that you will abide by ridiculous laws? If one has to abide by ridiculous laws to be considered honest, I will pass.

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#33

Re: A well regulated Militia ....

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Noah Webster was 30 years old when the constitution was adopted. He worked on his dictionary from 1801 to 1828. Here is his entry:

Regulated, pp. Adjusted by rule, method or forms; put in good order; subjected to rules or restrictions.

What is your source?

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#34

You're lucky it was a Norris

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Had it been a Spiers, he might have felt it necessary to claim it as a Scottish national treasure.

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#35

Hmm ...

Hank Knight

>Hmm... Hadn't thought of that. Maybe I was luckier than I thought I was.

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#36

Re: A well regulated Militia .... *LINK*

Guest

>here is one. There are many more that can be found with a bit of searching.


Well regulated

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#37

Re: A well regulated Militia ....

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Sad to say guest, your link does not say anything about "equipped" or "functional and ready to go". If you had said that well regulated meant well disciplined or well trained (both of which are mentioned in your link), I would not have questioned you in the first place.

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#38

Re: A well regulated Militia ....

Brian Anderson

>A bit long but a number of things to say.

The first point to consider is what a Militia is.

A reprint of the Encyclopedia Britannica " .... militia denotes the trained bands of a town or country, who arm themselves upon a short warning, for their own defence".

(Another source i cannot remember "a group of persons gathered together for their common defense.")

But in the context of the revolutionary war, the militia is a fighting force with some training, not as much as a full time army. It had the reputation at the time of not being well drilled. This was one of the problems that the continental army had that the foreign officers attempted to fix.

So a well regulated militia would be one that contains persons who are trained but not to the degree of a regular army. A structure would exist to facilitate the usage of the militia.

What is left to the imagination of the reader of the 2nd ammedment is who controls the militia. So far the only context we have is for the militia to be used in a combat setting..... But the militia of that period would also be called upon to support/backup the local constabulary in a way not dissimilar to a posse backing up the local sheriff/marshall. At the start of the revolutionary war the localities in Massachusettes all had their own "minutemen", Clearly a form of militia.... Also clearly under LOCAL control.

The reality is that the militia is made up of civilians turned soldier for the moment of need. Thus the right to keep and bear arms is really to have persons who could be members of a militia when needed. While the 2nd ammedment makes it clear that a militia is important, it does NOT state that to keep and bear arms that one must be a member of the militia.

On the original subject of this thread; The right to keep and bear arms applies to all forms of arms, weapons that, in my opinion, an ordinary person might have. At that time a sword, rifle, pistol or some other persoal type weapon would be included. So a knife would be included.