Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

Posts

Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#1

Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

James Watriss

>Hi all,

I hate to be the guy who posts political action stuff in a public forum. But it seemed to me that most woodworkers I know do carry knives of one sort or another. And it was recently brought to my attention that this right is now under threat from a piece of legislation proposed by the US Customs agency that would redefine any knife that can be opened with one hand to be considered a switchblade knife... and the wording can be interpreted in other ways to cover even more knives.

More information here:

http://www.kniferights.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=76&Itemid=150

I'm not a gun nut, I'm not usually a militant anything, but I do use a knife every day, so this really bothers me. I am aware that in other countries, like Great Britain, it's illegal to own even a locking knife. And I'd hate to have that happen here.

Again, I apologize for being "that guy." But if this hits home for any of you, I would ask that you spread the word. I know that pocket knives have a mixed public image, but they're one of the most fundamental tools that we have as humans, and I'd hate to see them taken away. I figured that those of you in the hand tool world might have similar feelings.

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#2

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>After the American Civil War, folding pocket knives were made for veterans missing an arm or hand and were designed to be opened with one hand. There are originals and someone is also making reproductions of these unique knives.

The end of one blade was blunt (slightly concave) so it could be opened by placing the concave end against the top of the pocket and opening the blade. The sharp pointy blade had a large fingernail notch that was pierced through the blade to ease its opening with one hand.

I am not sure it would fall under the category, but I hope not.

Stephen

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#4

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do

ThomD

>This is why the gun guys aren't wacko, because ultimately the guys riding the desks are after everything.

Anywho, this was predictable. The page you linked shows this is brought on by "assisted opening knives". These are knives that have a spring mechanism like a switchblade, but no switch. The end result is a knife that works exactly like a SB. Technically there are differences. Tactically, none. This distinct knife type has circumvented the switchblade rule, and obviously the rule ought to have been removed since it is stupid in the first place. But I guess they chose this push back instead.

So get your Rainbow Leek now!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E3ofaq30UcY

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#5

Re: By the way...

ThomD

>I always get a kick out of the police reports where they mention some bad guy was arrested and he was found with all these dangerous things in his house, a bunch of knives, etc... I have so many hundreds of things I could use to cut a person in hald, starting with my Battle axe (Ok broadaxe, a fellah can dream), that if I ever get turned in the rhetoric will be awesome. And it will all be stuff for my woodworking hobby.

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#6

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do

Alan DuBoff

>Unfortunately, there are things in life that happen through the course of evolution, some for the better, and some for the worse.

Modern knives are truly like a switchblade, in regards to how they can be opened quickly. I'm sure the number of casualties with knives probably correlate to such modern knives.

I don't think that most pocket knives which woodworkers COULD have, will need to be the modern quick opening knives.

I belong to a metalworking group that meets once a month, and one guy makes some of these modern style knives. They are certainly dangerous weapons, IMO. If you are a woodworker that has taken a liking to these modern knives, that would probably be leaning towards the worse...I carry a small swiss army knife, and have had several taken away at the airport. You would think I would learn, well, I think I have now...but I just carry it in my pocket all the time, and never had a problem at the airport until 911.

Much of these bills that effect these things are driven by larger events like 911, and certainly anything to do with customs...

Regards,

Alan

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#7

Re: Pocket knives being threatened

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Just stop flying and don't brandish your knives in public, all will be well.

Pam

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#8

Re: Pocket knives being threatened

Hank Knight

>C'mon Pam. What's the point of carrying a knife if you can't brandish it in public? ;>)

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#9

Beats me, I no longer carry even a...

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>pocket knife or nail clippers or anything else the airlines trashed; but then I haven't flown in 5 years, just too tedious, eagerly awaiting high speed rail, who'll probably take away my magnets. :)

Pam

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#10

Re: Beats me, I no longer carry even a...

Todd Stock

>Lots of real-life situations require one-hand opening knives - any mariner headed offshore or climber headed up needs at least one knife that will cut a halyard, sheet, or line in an emergency. I never carried a Leatherman when sailing until they designed a one-hand opening version (the Wave), and now carry that tool as well as a fixed blade Myerchin when aboard. As the old saying goes, when your nether parts are caught in the main sheet is not the time to be trying to open a pocket knife.

I'll be happy to send a note to the Nannycrats pushing this.

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#11

Re: Beats me, I no longer carry even a...

Alexander Grigoriev

>This is Customs, career position; not "nannycrats" or "repudlicans", even though the person involved might have been seated by the previous administration...

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#12

Re: Beats me, I no longer carry even a...

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yeah, well, give them an inch (Patriot act anyone?) and they'll take a mile.

Pam

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#13

Re: Beats me, I no longer carry even a...

joel

>I put my pocketknive in with checked luggage. For the occasional time where I find myself needing a knife in-flight, I always bring a block of steel and grinder in my carry-on.

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#14

and a small coal forge and bucket...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>of rendered lamb's fat, I assume, for quenching.

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#15

Reminds me of one time when

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>my wife and I had tickets to tour the White House, back in 1983. I've carried a pocket knife of one form or another nearly all my life, and this day was no exception. We were just about to go through the security screening when it occurred to me that the Capitol police might not like my Buck folder...

Bruce, who has 2 in his pockets as he types this.

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#16

Re: and a small coal forge and bucket...

joel

>Whale oil. I can get rendered lamb fat anywhere but you got to travel without own whale oil.

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#17

Re: Beats me, I no longer carry even a...

Todd Stock

>Nannycrat = Nanny + Bureaucrat...no party affiliation.

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#18

Re: Beats me, I no longer carry even a...

Ray Binnicker

>Pam,

Anyone can listen to my phone conversations anytime they want !! "I" don't have anything to hide.

Ray Binnicker

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#19

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do

Ray Binnicker

>In the end, the only folks who will abide by any of the these new, ridiculus, rules/laws are us, the honest folk. The bad guys will still keep/get/own/use any means necessary to perform their bad deeds.

Ray Binnicker

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#20

:) I could mention the time in fall, 2002,....

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>when I had to carry all my luggage around the Smithsonian because no one would check them. The guards got all upset when I groused about there eventually being nothing to protect if they kept on in that direction.

Pam

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#21

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do

Paul Kierstead

>I've always found the idea that a pocket knife is a weapon to be quite curious. A piece of rebar is much more effective, and would only be illegal if you actually whacked someone with it. I've carried a pocket knife all my life since about 10 years old (including school, oh horrors) and would miss not carrying one greatly.

Of course, this sort of foolishness is an end-run around the law; customs gets to do all sorts of whacky things at the border which appears to have become an entirely rights-free zone. They make up idiotic rules which basically can't be challenged since the item isn't "in" the country yet. So, they might manage to stop the import of such things, but probably won't get far in *possession* rules.

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#22

Not needed...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>We're softer than Oak.

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#23

A well regulated Militia ....

Hank Knight

>"A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed."

I wonder why no one has argued that the Second Amendment guarantees the right to carry pocket knives?

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#24

Alarmist ,..aint goping to happen

Todd Hughes

>I don't buy it that the Goverment is going to make it against the law for you to have a folding knife like a Buck 110 that you can open with one hand.

Some obscure regulation gets put out that has zero chance of becoming law and let alone enforced and then a group like this knife rights one makes hay with it by scaring people into thinking the goverment is going to take away thier pocket knives....I just don't think it is going to happen anytime soon in the US of America

Right now I can go to the flea market and for $5 buy some made in China full automatic switch blade which you got to think are already banned from importation so whats up with that.Don't know how the steel is but actually mmade pretty well by the way

I sort of collect switch blades and carried ones for years, last one was a modern one by Paragon was about a $200 knife I bought from a guy at the flea market for $10. The spring came off the blade and I switched back to carring my Gerber Covert Folder which is just as fast or faster to open as a switch blade. This is the knife I carry everyday. Is a "fighting" knife but works to cut string and open chip bags too, gives some comfort knowing I do have it on me. Sometimes I carry a small pen knife folder too.

I wouldn't want to get into a situation where I would have to defend myself with a knife but you never know and like to be prepared. I have been stabbed befor, guy put an ice pick right through my hand pinning it to the bar. I pulled it out and knocked him out with a beer mug....Todd


img

Re: Pocket knives being threatened... sorry to do this

#25

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Pocket knife ban -and ridiculous things

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>Adding to the absurd nature of this - On yesterday's noon news the talking heads were discussing a recent arrest made when a man was found inside a closed store.

In addition to trespassing charges, he was charged with "Possession of Burglary Tools," - GLOVES AND A FLASHLIGHT!!! I guess that makes virtually all of us potential burglary arrestees...