WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Traditional Woodworking in China

Posts

Traditional Woodworking in China

#1

Chris Scholz

Traditional Woodworking in China

Chris Scholz

>

A few weeks ago I had the distinct honor to meet a traditional Chinese woodworker. From outside it looks like just another garage shop, inside you find a workbench, stashes of wood sticks (think frame and panel), various furniture components in pre- half- and semi-finished stage, hand-tools, neatly arranged in a wooden toolbox and, last but not least, Liu Shifu (Shifu: respectful title for Master craftsman, Liu: last name).

When we entered the shop Master Liu was busy pounding mortises into a rail that was soon to become a yigui (yi: cloth, gui: cabinet).




Liu Shifu was so kind to open his toolbox and spread the contents on his workbench, All tools were made by Liu Shifu himself, whatever was needed for a specific project. Liu Shifu explained the use of various planes for various purposes, the importance of different bedding angles; he demonstrated his collection of hollows and rounds, molding planes, chisels, amazing stuff, indeed




Folks, it is a fact, Chinese planes are pushed and not pulled. In fact, Chinese woodworkers are highly trained professionals, who went through many years of apprenticeship. Position of the feet relative to the board and workbench, position of the hand on the plane body, pressure distribution of the hands during the planing motion, all of this this all seems to be arbitrary at first sight but is highly trained. If you ever get the opportunity to see two Shifu work next to each other, no doubt, the motions will be exactly the same. (An interesting contrast to our own whatever works approach).




Thank you for listening.


Chris Scholz, Arlington, TX

www.Galoot-Tools.com

Re: Traditional Woodworking in China

#2

Re: Traditional Woodworking in China

ThomD

>Chris, do you have any better resolution pics? Nothing nuts, I am on dial-up. I couldn't open your site. I am interested in Chinese woodwork from the few articles that appeared in the original FWW. I like their planes. Chinese woodworking tools don't seem as sophisticated as Japanese ones, but the output, from temples to musical instruments to boats is probably better in China.

Re: Traditional Woodworking in China

#3

Re: Traditional Woodworking in China--Saws

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hello Chris,

A very interesting report!

Was Master Liu using any saws?--I think I see some sawdust in one of the photos, in addition to plane shavings. If so, what is the style of the Chinese handsaw, and is it pull or push?

Thanks, Wiley

Re: Traditional Woodworking in China

#4

Re: Traditional Woodworking in China

Tony - Memphis

>Wow, very neat. Thanks for the post. Very interesting.

Tony

Re: Traditional Woodworking in China

#5

Chris Scholz

Re: Traditional Woodworking in China--Saws

Chris Scholz

>Wiley,

thanks. The saws I have seen in China are frame-saws. For rough carpentry you also see various types of "regular hand saws". I say they act on the push stroke and I am sticking with it.

Having said that, we had a heated discussion with Zhou Shifu if the saws act on the push stroke or on both push and pull stroke. This was after a few glasses of baijiu (literally: white alcohol, i.e. fairly strong liquor, sort of an initialization ritual before visiting Liu Shifu.) I was lucky that he got drunk way faster than I was, otherwise there would not have been a single reasonably well exposed and in focus photograph.)

Few pictures on saws some time later...

Chris

Re: Traditional Woodworking in China

#6

Chris Scholz

Re: Traditional Woodworking in China

Chris Scholz

>Thom,

Will be happy to send you higher resolution pictures.

Well, as good as it gets, that is. It's been pretty dark and my gear is not up to the latest and greatest full-frame giga-pixel level (ok, I admit, it's mostly my photographic skill).

I have a few more modules that I'd like to post, probably best if I put that all on a memory-stick and mail to you in a couple of weeks?

Chris

Re: Traditional Woodworking in China

#7

Great teaser, keep it coming, Chris. Thanks.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Traditional Woodworking in China

#8

Ditto!

wilbur

>

Re: Traditional Woodworking in China

#9

Thanks Chris

roninkokomo

>Really cool stuff!!

Re: Traditional Woodworking in China

#10

For the first time

Ron Bauman

>I'm not embarrassed by the state of my shop. I've got stuff all over the place and leaning up against everything. Thanks Chris and Liu Shifu.

Re: Traditional Woodworking in China

#11

Re: Traditional Woodworking in China

ThomD

>Thanks Chris!

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.