Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

Posts

The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

#1

The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

Alan DuBoff

>Wiley said:

-----------

Can you tell us about your big home construction project? Looks like big progress is being made!

-----------

This is without a doubt, the most outrageous project I have ever taken on in my entire life...in some ways I have a hard time imagining a more outrageous midlife crisis...but I already have a sports car, so that was kinda out as I'm perfectly happy driving it...*lol*

I had been planning to build a log home for a piece of property I have on a lake in Northern California. Only I had been planning to have a log craftsman build the shell, and finish off the house. But life changes, and so do plans...;-) We were planning a much bigger 54'x54' round log timberframe, using SIPs on the outside. 3 stories plus a full walkout basement, this was a HUGE home...2500 sq.ft. main, 2500 sq.ft. basement, 1500 sq.ft. of open loft on 2nd floor, and 16'x16 lookout on the third. This also had full wrap around 10' porsches (another 2500 sq.ft if you add it up;-).

I found myself out of work back at the end of Jan., and got a decent severance from my employer, and had some stocks I had purchased through their employee program when I was working...and that is how I kick started this project. A good friend had died shortly after on Feb. 1st, and that got me thinking about what I wanted to do in life, what I wanted to leave for my family, etc...ultimately this project of mine will last for the rest of my life, making the cabinets, the built-ins, furniture, etc...

So, I decided if I could scale the home down in size, I might be able to take my severance/stock and leverage that to get a smaller, more reasonable home started, which I would build myself. I have also talked about doing a square log home with dovetails, since after all dovetails are the epitome of handcrafted for woodworkers, are they not? I truly admire them as much as anyone else...and while you spend a LOT of time on the joinery, the laterals are not scribed, they are chinked. So, as it turns out that is kinda like the ultimate dovetail project, heh? :-)

So, my good friend and Master Craftsman, Tim Bullock offered to help me give this a try. Tim had never done this before. He has been building homes for 31+ years, but had never tried to teach anyone to build their own home. This is like learning how to build furniture from Sam Maloof (RIP!), or creating Greene & Greene furniture with Jim Ipekjian, at least speaking for myself...I put Tim up there with the best of log craftsmen, worldwide.

My home is much smaller, 28'x32' (900 sq.ft. main) and rather than having 3 suites on the main floor, I have a bed/ba on each, basement, main, upper, so I still get a 3 bed, 3 ba home.

The problem is lifting the timbers, Tim works with timbers that are on average 18" - 24" tip to butt, and my logs will be milled to 8" thick. A full length 32 foot timber weighs in the neighborhood of 3000 lbs. The most cost effective way to do this is with a forklift, but to do so you need flat land as most forklifts do not operate well on rough terrain, although some do exist, if the terrain is really rough it is dangerous. My property is not flat so I could not build at the property. My plan from the get go was to rent a piece of land close to my house that I could access easily, that way when I do go back to work (yes, I HOPE/NEED to do that one day, and that day is coming;-) I can get to it and work on it.

I've been back to West Virginia twice, once for 3 or 4 days to get acquainted with the machines, process, work involved, and for Tim to see if I was capable of doing this. And then another 2 weeks to work on the sills, starter rounds, learn how to dovetail, peel, etc...

When I was back for 2 weeks I was able to get about 1/3rd of the logs done, but I still have quite a bit, not to mention the roof (ridge on 3 posts, timber rafters) and porches (cant/milled timber from same timbers). The home is built using Eastern White Pine, 8" thick, 18"-24" tip/butt.

This is where I left it, Tim is putting one more 32 foot full length log before he ships it, and has been getting my timber prep'd so we can ship out to Cali. Another 32 foot will go on the walkout side, where there are a couple sets of french doors, there is also a 12' piece in the center which is not on there, but it was not dovetailed, it is just plumbed.



So, then I was back in Cali for my kids graduations, my daughter graduated middle school going in high school next year, and my son graduated high school and was accepted and going to UCLA in the fall...(shameless plug for my son which I'm so proud of;-)

I then found a lot which is about 23 miles from my house, located in Morgan Hill, CA. I will "move-in" on July 1st. Looks a bit tattered but the landlord is clearing out the trucks for me, and I can move the abandoned trailer back there out of the way...I will set the pads up just as it was at Tim Bullock's yard in WV, and get the sills and logs setup on them, so I can finish the remaining work.


Then I solved the last complicated piece, how to lift these timbers???

I started to look around at forklifts, and let me tell you, there is a lot of BEAT forklifts for sale, these machines get put to the task and it's hard to find clean ones. I am very meticulous about my tools and machines typically, and this was no exception. I found this 2003 Cat forklift, 6,000# lift, single/double fork attachment, with 4 controls (lift up/dn, tilt in/out, sideshift for full fork assembly, and hydraulic fork movement). This has a really cool feature where you can move the forks from 28" - 84" wide, with a control in the cab.



I take posession of the forklift on July 1st also, I'm buying it from an independent builder that is going out of business.

Despite the machines and chainsaws used, at least 60-75 percent of this work is done with basic hand tools. For most of the dovetail work I roughed it out with a chainsaw and fitted and crafted the tails by hand using a 2" Barr framing chisel, a 60 1/2 la block plane, pencils/pens, levels, framing squares, scribe, etc...here's a log in the cradle being worked...


This is the greatest project I have ever taken on in my entire life, and for the first time I'm finally feeling I can pull this off.




img

Re: The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

#2

"full wrap around 10' porsches"

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I thought you said you already had a sports car? Now you're adding some to your house?

VERY impressive project, and pretty wood. You'll have a lot of which to be proud when you're done.

I hope your working space is well leveled and graded - that forklift looks like a warehouse lift. Most forklifts designed for use on dirt have larger tires.

Re: The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

#3

Re: "full wrap around 10' porsches"

ThomD

>I've never done anything like that, but there are a number of builders hereabouts. They seem to set the frame on blocks, and build the walls in a yard, then when it comes to putting the house together it is rather like a barn raising. They bring in big machines for a day and place everything over at the site. The building could be assembled on a "parking lot" if available, and you can run your lift around on level ground.

Have you looked over Mackie's books. He did round log buildings as far as I know, there are some interesting pictures and diagrams of alternative methods of lifting logs, though he also used machines. The Owner Built Log House was one of his more recent titles.

http://www.ballanmackie.com/

I think you are engaged in a form of woodworking ecumenicalism. The log notch and the furniture dovetail are pretty opposite ends of a spectrum that many guilds did their best to keep separate in the day when either mattered in a practical sense. You might get some of these for your next jaunt in the mountains:

http://www.blackdiamondequipment.com/gear/stoppers.php

There certainly is something about dovetails.

Re: The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

#4

dovetails

paul womack

>

I think I can see a gap!

Seriously - are those double dovetails (like infill planes), only possible since there one DT per workpiece?

BugBear

Re: The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

#5

Yeah, I fat fingered that one, heh?

Alan DuBoff

>I was gonna put a typo disclaimer, as that message was pretty long I knew there was bound to be a few...*lol*

That forklift is designed to drive on gravel, pack, or even loose dirt, it has pneumatic tires on it. These lifts have about 4"-6" under them.

The lifts for warehouse use will typically have cushion tires which will only sit about 3" off the ground. Those will not run on anything but flat surface, I'm told.

The guy I'm buying the forklift from was running it on gravel.

The yard I'm renting has gravel and is hard packed down from trucks driving over it. This lift will work fine on that. In fact, with the air tires on the front, I can lower the air pressure and drive this over mud, but if your not careful you can get yourself into trouble doing that...:-/

Regards,

Alan

Re: The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

#6

Have several of Mackie's books

Alan DuBoff

>Thom,

I am doing just as you describe, building on a flat lot, then moving it to my property a few hours away. I would build it on my property if it was flat, but my property is at the top of a bluff, on the shores of a lake. I will use a crane to do final assembly at the property, and that is when I will assemble the roof as well. I will build the roof on the ground. This is very common for handcrafted log homes, but them at the yard on pads, and the sills will sit right on top of the sub floor at final assembly.

Yes, I have several of Mackie's books, and he has always been a big advocate of hewn logs with dovetailed corners and in at least 2 of his books he does tout them highly, and encourages craftsmen to bring this style back, as it is one of the most sound. I believe it produces a corner that is about the most solid. I do layout the dovetail as he shows in his book "Notches Of All Kinds, A book of timber joinery.", and angles are not really used. You layout the dovetail with levels and rules, and drop the slop a given amount for the size logs one uses. In my case I am using 1" as the drop, and the logs are 8" thick. If I was using 10", I would have used a 1 1/2" drop.

Mackie single handedly brought log crafting alive again, it was on the verge of dying. Mackie built a house when he was 74 years old.

The book that quite a few folks get hooked on is "Building with Logs".

I'm not sure I understand your reference to the log notch and the furniture dovetail being at opposite ends of the spectrum. Log notch is pretty vague, there are many style of log notches, but Swedish Cope, Saddle Notch, Dovetail, Round Notch, Square Notch, OxHead, Blind Notch, Lap, Box, and most have some form of optional locking, IOW the notch is keyed.

There is some excitement in working on a log for several hours with hand tools, and then dropping it in place, it is magic watching a piece of timber that weighs 3000# drop into place with a nice fit...

This style of square logs with chinking with dovetailed corners was from the Appalachians. Many structures still exist today, but some have siding on them and it's hard to tell where they exist for certain. The homes were much smaller and many were added on to, so more of them are pieced together with various additions through the years.

Cheers,

Alan

Re: The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

#7

Re: dovetails

Alan DuBoff

>Paul,

There are some gaps if you could look really close at each one, they are not perfect. However, they fit surprisingly well and form a solid joint between the logs. If it becomes a problem I'll fill it with pine tar...*lol* Chinking material will go between the logs, a modern synthetic type.

These are quite different than the ones on planes that slide in and lock from both directions.

These are half dovetails. This is one of the best joints to use on a log home of all the ones that exist. What is unique about the half dovetail is that each side, top and bottom, are a flat surface, and are not compound. The slope always drops to the outside of the house, and the top one is needed to lock the log below it in place. If it wasn't for the log above it, the log itself would pull out of the joint. A full dovetail has a compound surface, and as such the joint is locked from both the top and the bottom.

That would seem that the full dovetail (with the compound surfaces) would be the preferred, but the half dovetail drains water away from the joint. The slope alternates which side of the corner it drops on, and the water follows the seam and drains the water away from the house. The full dovetail doesn't do that, and the compound allows some water to drain back towards the home. Hope that makes sense, it's getting late...If you look at the picture of the corner, notice how the top would allow the water to shed away to the left (front of house), and the bottom of that log does the same, sloping to the right (side of house).

Cheers,

Alan

Re: The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

#8

Now THAT is cool

roninkokomo

>

Re: The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

#9

Re: Yeah, I fat fingered that one, heh?

John in NM

>" In fact, with the air tires on the front, I can lower the air pressure and drive this over mud, but if your not careful you can get yourself into trouble doing that...:-/"

Yeah, that makes me cringe just thinking about it. Low tire pressure and variable center of gravity makes things interesting. I think I'd get a length of chain link fencing for mud traction before I'd mess with tire pressure. Though now that I think of it, that would only work with 4 wheel drive and rear wheel drive, it'd have to be something more rigid for a front wheel drive.

Re: The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

#10

Freudian typo

Alexander Grigoriev

>"Lost in translation":

"You're probably just having a mid-life crisis. Did you buy a Porsche yet?"

"No. But I was *thinking* about buying a Porshe"

Re: The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

#11

Re: Yeah, I fat fingered that one, heh?

Alan DuBoff

>John,

I don't plan on using this in the mud, to be honest, but my property has dirt and the pneumatic could come in handy if I need to fetch the logs up to the top of the property from the road, *if* the tractor trailer won't make it up.

Now, when I was back in West Virginia, there was PLENTY of rain, like TOO MUCH rain...and I'm not sure we could have done the work without the Cat loader we were using. The irony is that the huge 4wd tires on the Cat loader turn the mud into a sloshy slurry that just ends up being a huge mess...I pity folks in West Virginia, it sure rains a lot there...I guess that's why they call it the rainy season...:-/

This year just didn't let up on them...the worst year they've had in a long while.

This will be a great forklift for gravel/hard-pack. Runs for 8 hours on a 8 gal. tank of propane.

Regards,

Alan

Re: The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

#12

I'm very jealous, and that's great work!

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>I hope at some point in my life to do a log or timber framed home. Your work looks absolutely marvelous and it seems that you approached this very well. Please, keep us posted on the work and let us see the house as it goes up.

Best of luck as you move on!

Re: The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

#13

Re: Have several of Mackie's books

ThomD

>I figured you would have them I have bought at least one of the books and been given another, and I am not building a log home! Sounds like a wonderful project and in a wonderful part of the world. I have never particularly wanted to do a project like that because I so far have never really felt like setting down roots anywhere.

3000 pounds is pretty heavy. Be safe. There may be a way of rigging ropes to help snub a log automatically if it ever got away from you, if you are working alone.

Re: The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

#14

Re: Have several of Mackie's books

Alan DuBoff

>Thom,

Keep your eyes open on the used book stores, I have found 2 of the 3 Mackie books I have at used stores (Abe Books) for about $5/each. My copy of Building With Logs came from a library, it's a hard bound.

Tim Bullock had the same book on his coffee table in his livingroom which he had bought some 32 or more years ago. Great book.

I will certainly be taking my time and doing things safely, and will be working alone some of the time. But I will have help from time to time on pieces that require it. My first piece is getting the pads setup so I can reassemble the first couple rounds when the logs are shipped. My son is going to help with some of that before he heads off to college in Sept.

As I said, this is the most outrageous project I have ever taken on, thanks all for the kind words!

Regards,

Alan

Re: The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

#15

Didn't really think you were...

John in NM

>planning on using it in the mud that is... lowering the tire pressure just sounded like a line from the seller or something.

Looks like a handy thing to have around, even when the cabin is done, I bet you'll want to hang on to the forklift :)

Re: The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

#16

Staggering!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Alan,

What you're doing is a study in guts, gumption, and courage. The work to date looks very correct and sound. Do I understand that you're going to work the logs and fit them together into a house at Morgan HIll, then disassemble, and move the whole shooting match to the bluff over the lake, and reassemble it there? I hope there is a good security fence around the Morgan Hill site. Are you going to cut the windows in at Morgan Hill, or do that when you get to the final site?

You have my greatest admiration. Please keep the photos coming as the work progresses.

Wiley

Re: The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

#17

Re: Staggering!

Alan DuBoff

>Wiley,

Thanks for the kind word, sometimes I think this is a study in stupidity...:-)

I would say my friends are split, some thinking I won't finish it, and the rest thinking I can. I have pondered over this for a long long time, and this is actually one of the most economical ways to do this.

You pretty much understand it correctly, when I move it to the bluff over the lake, there will be a foundation and sub floor waiting for it. And I will have Tim Bullock helping me reassemble it. Also at that point the roof will go on as we will use a crane to reassemble.

The windows will be cut in Morgan Hill for the most part, but they could be cut after final assembly. But, just for the French doors alone, the 2 on the walkout side would be 8" thick x 6' x 7.5', which looks roughly to be about 300 board feet of timber for just a single French door. Better if I can set the windows and doors up ahead of time, and save that timber from being used to begin with. I don't know about all of my timber yet, Tim is still getting some of it ready for me.

I know it seems that I'll be moving the home a few times, but the work that was done back in West Virginia helped me understand how to setup the pads, and build it. If I was to finish building it in WV, it would cost me much more as I have to pay for machines and operators just to move the logs around. The forklift I will buy and will be able to use it as I need. The yard is fairly secluded, behind other lots off a highway. There is a shed with locking eye bolts, and a container with roll up door (will store the forklift in there). My landlord lives on the front property.

Yeah, it seems whacked to build it in Morgan Hill and move it again, but it's 20 minutes from my house, can get home easily, get there easily. I can get home and have my wife make me dinner. My property is 3 hours away, has no electricity, is not flat, etc...it also costs me almost as much as the rental yard to store the home in WV at Tim's yard. I'm not the first person to build with a forklift, that has been done before, but I probably am one of the first to go about doing it this way (WV/MH/Lake). Who would think to ship timber into the city to build it, and then turn around and ship it out. That piece is outside the box of conventional thinking.

After I get the pads setup, and have them level, and then get the timbers shipped out west, I will look for work and the home will become my hobby. At that point having the home 20 minutes away is a HUGE advantage.:-) And let's say I can't find work, having the home 20 minutes away is once again a HUGE advantage...*lol* Maybe I can finish it that much faster then...

Regards,

Alan

Re: The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

#18

Re: I'm very jealous, and that's great work!

Alan DuBoff

>Stephen Kirk wrote:

"I hope at some point in my life to do a log or timber framed home."

I could not encourage you enough, but it's a major undertaking, and I think it requires a unique person to want to do it. It is the ultimate project to take on, to build a dwelling to live in.

I'm starting to miss my timbers just thinking about them.:-) Hopefully coming together soon, July 1st is on the way, hopefully have a nice 4th with the family this year, and then drum up some work...I get the forklift on the 1st, along with the rental yard.

I have had a couple good friends doubt this over the past 9 years, asking how long I would believe I could build my own home. My reply has always been the same...till the day I die...I will be working on it until then.

Life is what we make of it, so seize the timber! :-)

Regards,

Alan

Re: The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

#19

Having a staging area

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Alan,

It struck me as most sensible, and probably essential, to have a staging area near home. You can work on the project, keep an eye on it, have someone else keeping an eye on it when you're not there, etc. The big pieces are all in place!

I see what you mean about the 'cut ins'. If you cut for the windows and doors in the first place, you don't waste the timber and you don't haul extra timber either. duhhh.

Please update us as this work progresses. It's an amazing project, and inspirational.

Wiley

Re: The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

#20

Re: Have several of Mackie's books

ThomD

>What I have done (I'm like the football player who never got rid of his jersey, except it is loads of climbing gear in my case) is run a rope from the heavy object up through a pulley with a few pounds counter weight on the far side of the pulley. There is then a mechanical ascender on the load side of the pulley. What happen is as the object goes up the counter weight pulls the rope tight, and the ascender (one way rope valve) snubs it if any weight comes on the rope. One problem with simplicity on this kind of thing is it only pays in. In practice for you what are doing, what would happen is the rope would tighten relentlessly as it went up, but only to the degree of the counter weight. There is significant stretch in the rope that as the log is placed it would probably stretch enough to seat the log. Or if it didn't you could simply use really light line to support a few inches of the rope, so that when it went down that would snap and allow a few inches to pay out. Probably not worth it, but if you get any pieces going high enough over your head you at least have an option. I think 2 ropes rigged this way would still be challenged to hold 3000# if it got to moving. The weak point is/was the ascenders, but there is doubtless something designed to do this kind of thing.

Re: The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

#21

Re: Having a staging area and Ryoba

Alan DuBoff

>Wiley,

Yes, I never really thought about it as being a staging area, but even in the case of a log craftsman building a home at his yard, it is also essentially a staging area for the final assembly at the client site.

One piece I've welcome your opinion on is a hand saw.

There is a task that a Japanese Ryoba comes in very handy. When the top of the tail is first laid out, 1/2" is taken off for the depth of the log. In my case my logs are 8" thick, so I measure the top shoulder of the tail to be 7 1/2". You do this so that you can fit the log back into the area after the tail has been cut. Often the distance is not perfect the outside. In that case a Ryoba works really well to take a small amount off the shoulder of the log below, as it doesn't have a back on it, and is used as a flush cutting saw essentially to fit the lower shoulder with the upper side. The idea is to bring both the inside AND outside areas of the joint to fit properly. By using the Ryoba one can take a very thin amount off with the log in place, on one side. I have been undercutting the shoulder in the middle so that the inside/outside have a tight fit (if that makes sense). If one side has any light as the log is fitted, you can take some down with he Ryoba while the log is in place.

Certainly I could get the RazorZ and be done with it, but I would really rather have a handcrafted tool if possible. Was thinking the 270mm would work nicely.

I was using a real POS back in WV, some cheap plastic handle big box impulse.

So, it's not something I want to spend a lot of money on, but would like something handcrafted if possible. Discussing this with a knowledgeable , I came down to the Chuyemon at Hida.

I may need to pull the handle away from the log in some cases, in order the clear as I saw.

I was also told that the most recent Chuyemon saws have been sent to Mitsukawa to be setup and they are nice. Not sure how true that is. I really just need it for this project.

Have you used any of those Ryobas?

Regards,

Alan

Re: The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

#22

Watched Dick Proenneke? *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I'd strongly recommend anyone undertaking such a project to watch the video below by Dick Proenneke. This is a much simpler project than Alan has planned, but it covers the basics pretty well.

Pam


Alone in the Wilderness

Re: The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

#23

Chuyemon ryoba--where is Manny?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Alan,

I have a 240mm Chuyemon, bought many years ago from Hida, and it is a good saw. I use it a lot for small carpentry jobs, mainly cross-cutting 2-by- __ stock. Based on the saw I own, I could recommend the brand. 270mm sounds good for size, and as a general rule, I would suggest buying the largest saw that will still make a fine enough cut for you.

Are you able to contact Manny about this saw? I would take his recommendation in a heartbeat. Maybe Pam or Wilbur can offer their thoughts......

Wiley

Re: The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

#24

Re: Chuyemon ryoba--where is Manny?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Chuyemon are great ryoba, the ones sold by Hida for cheap; but I don't see anything about this project to recommend a ryoba. For my timber frame project I bought a 400mm +/- crosscut (kataba?), single side cutting from Hida, a Mitsukawa. It works fine for cutting lengths.

Pam

Re: The ULTIMATE dovetail project...

#25

Re: Chuyemon ryoba--now that you mention Manny...

Alan DuBoff

>Wiley,

Yeah, Manny is friend, I've known him for a number of years. I did use one of Manny's Mistukawa Ryobos a fews years back at a BAG-A-THON (Bay Area Galoots). It cut well.

In fact, it was Manny who said the Chuyemon saws were not sharpened by Mitsukawa previously, and he sent his to get setup there, and it came back like a different saw. He thought they are being setup at Mitsukawa now...at least the ones Hida has. If money wasn't an object I would probably get the Mitsukawa, but I need to start focusing on solving issues so I can ship my timber. I'd like to have the pads setup before I ship, that way I can just setup when the logs get here. Then I can get a breather possibly.

FWIW, Manny's wife had a baby boy (Jonathan!) just a week or two ago, and he was really busy at work for the past week. He is just getting some time to see his new son this weekend I think...wanted to give him some breathing room...I'm going to try his saws before I buy, most likely.

Regards,

Alan