Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

I'll never worry about square again!

Posts

Re: I'll never worry about square again!

#26

Pics?

wilbur

>Wiley or Pam,

I'd also be really interested in seeing pictures of your Mosaku planes with the offset blade. I've never seen one myself.

Re: I'll never worry about square again!

#27

Raney, Wilbur, and Pam *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>And all,

I don't have a digital camera, am being cheap about cameras, but went into the Wayback Machine about 2003, and found the old entry from Harrelson Stanley's website. That link is attached.

Yes, mine is the hon red dai, and it is really dense, heavy wood. I suspect Pam and I have the same plane. It is an excellent shooter. When I checked mine for sole flatness yesterday, I noticed that it had gone just a hair concave, but I don't think I'll mess with it until late July when it's seen some heat and dryness. Our weather has been fairly humid now for close to a month.

You can see the offset in Hap's photo. There's an extra 1/4" on one side. Raney may have nailed it in saying that it allows for lots of truing, although I've never seen a dai deflect in that plane. But then there's lots that I haven't seen, and Raney's suggestion rings true to me.

Wiley


Mosaku shooting plane, circa 2003

Re: I'll never worry about square again!

#28

Re: Raney, Wilbur, and Pam

wilbur

>Thanks for the link!

Do you think that the offset might have something to do with the method of converting a planing beam into a shooting board by nailing a straight strip of hardwood on the side of the planing beam? I've never seen this setup in person, but the photos and diagrams I've seen make it look like that the strip is attached deeper than the offset on a typical shooting board, like Hank's. In that case, you would want the blade set even farther away from the edge of the plane on that side, otherwise too much of the blade would be riding against the side of the beam.

Re: I'll never worry about square again!

#29

Re: Raney, Wilbur, and Pam

Raney

>Thanks Wiley for digging that up.

Wilbur, I think your suggestion makes some sense, but it presupposes that planing beam shooting add-ons were designed for a plane built like the Mosaku. My feeling, though, would be that the taked strips we've seen, most esp. in Odate, seem to have been made expressly to use the standard medium finish planes the shokunin already posessed... so if the extra width were an improvement, why wouldn't Odate simply have moved his 'shooting strip' a bit higher on the beam if he was shooting with his 'normal' smoothing or jointing kanna? Unless he was using a plane configured like this one and I just missed it - but I don't think he was.

I found it interesting that Hap's description mentions that the blade width should be kept under 55mm to prevent unwanted movement... I'm not sure I'm wrapping my head around why the movement concerns for a shooting plane would be any different than they would for any smoothing or jointing kanna...

Re: I'll never worry about square again!

#30

Re: Raney, Wilbur, and Pam

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>You make a good point, Raney, about whether the narrow width is more critical on a shooting plane. Cupping or bowing across the width will present the same problems to a smooth plane as to a shooting plane.

If we were talking about concavity or convexity in the length, the smoother will be less sensitive than the shooting plane to seasonal movement, because the waves in the sole of the smoother will tend to cancel these movements out so long as they are small, as they would be from day to day. Whereas the shooting plane, with a flat sole, would have to be retrued every day, even if it just moved a little. However, as you point out, what does this have to do with the narrow width?

I kinda think that the shooting plane wants to be narrow, because how much 8/4+ wood are you going to be shooting with that plane? It is inherently simpler to maintain the dai and the iron on a narrower plane. And the narrower plane would be easier (for me at least!) to keep plumb on a 1-1/4" edge than a 65 or 70mm plane would be.

Good point you made!

Wiley

Re: I'll never worry about square again!

#31

Re: this and that

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>First, Wilbur, I mounted my adjustable planing beamlette to the back of my bench about 3/8" from the top so I could use the beamlette itself as the base for shooting very long pieces resting on the bench. This all works fine since it was OK with me if a bit of the bench were planed off. I made a more regular shooting board for shorter pieces. The Mosaku does a fine job both with the bench/beamlette and the regular shooting board; and that extra 1/4" comes in very handy on the bench.

As to Japanese practice, I don't know for sure, but I think the Japanese tend toward one finely tuned dai for one particular type of task. So I think every carpenter had a Mosaku like plane for squaring off boards. Likewise, I think the Japanese carpenters are very particular about their tools and that they considered it important that a shooting plane blade remain squared up so that when they planed a board they didn't have to worry very much about a non-square result. Logically, a narrower blade is more stable, as is a narrower dai.

Pam

Re: I'll never worry about square again!

#32

WOW Hank...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>CHA-CHING! That's a plane I'll never own...:^(

Guess that will help in finishing up the Huntsman eh?

Stunning. Is it dovetailed? I can't tell by the pictures.

Re: I'll never worry about square again!

#33

Re: WOW Hank...

Hank Knight

>Hi, Scott.

Ron Brese puts his planes together with screws and then files and laps them flush. They disappear in the process, like dovetails. I understand that Karl Holtey is using the process now. There was a Holtey exhibit at the Woodworking in America event in Berea that showed the various steps in the process.

You hit it on the head. The shooter's first task was squaring up drawer fronts and sides for the hunt board. If I don't finish it soon, LOML is going to be looking for another furniture maker to take over my shop!

Hank