We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>My Brese shooting board plane arrived today. I first got my hands on this baby at the Madison GA MWTCA Peach Meet in February when Ron brought it for a show-and-tell. I fell in love with it. It's a SERIOUS plane. I didn't weigh it, but it must be close to 7 pounds, and it's a beauty. I couldn't wait to get it to my shooting board, so I hurried down to the shop and gave it a go. I tried it on some 1/2" maple drawer sides and it's PERFECT! No wobbling like I was getting with my LA Jack. Just a smooth, steady cut. Then I tried it on some 5/4 cherry. Same results. No hacking like with the Jack. Just a nice, firm push that produced a micro-thin shaving and a perfectly square cut in both dimensions. Thanks Ron. I LOVE IT!
The plane is Brese Plane. Actually, the design of this plane was a cooperative effort between Ron Brese and Jameel Abraham, and I think Jameel had a hand in the construction of my plane. Ron's work is truly stunning. I have no affiliation with Brese Plane other than admiration, and I am proud to call both Ron and Jameel friends.
>Thanks, Wilbur. I've been using the shooting board with my LN low angle jack. It worked fine, but this plane is WAY better. The shooting board is nothing special, but several people over on Wood Net asked for photos of it. I'll post some this weekend.
I am a great fan of Alton Brown. His philosophy is that the only single-tasker allowed in the kitchen is the fire extinguisher. I have the same philosophy in the shop. To that end I have a LeeValley low angle jack plane. It shoots 5/4 walnut just fine, 1/2" stock effortlessly, and excels at more typical planing tasks.
We occasionally get new visitors at this Forum looking for basic information on hand tool usage. With them in mind...... while the plane described is likely the best plane for shooting, those with a multitasking philosophy will find the Lee Valley plane adequate.
Ron does superb metal work (I have his small smoother), and the design (of Ron and Jameel) and completed finish on this mitre plane, is simply sensational!
I wish you much fun and joy in using it my friend.
I asked Ron about the infill, which is a black-stained walnut, as I like the contrast effect against steel. How "black" did your infill turn out?
>I am a great fan of Alton Brown. His philosophy is that the only single-tasker allowed in the kitchen is the fire extinguisher. I have the same philosophy in the shop. To that end I have a LeeValley low angle jack plane. It shoots 5/4 walnut just fine, 1/2" stock effortlessly, and excels at more typical planing tasks.
I'm a fan of Alton Brown as well, and while I agree your LA Jack can do all those things, it can not do it as quickly as dedicated tools. You have to change the setup of that jack to excel at each task.
In a professional kitchen there are many single use tools, and to work quickly with hand tools you'd require the same. I'm not suggesting that everyone have a shop full of dedicated planes, just offering the other side of the Swiss-Army plane recommendations. Looking back at professional hand-tool shops one can't help but be envious of all the single-tasking tools they had. If only we had such items easily available to us today!
You realise that you are suggesting that we purchase fewer tools ...!!! That could get you banned from this forum! :)
.. I like to use as few tools as possible (in spite of the fact that I own a large number). It is a matter of pride that I attempt to extend my handskills as far as possible.
Nevertheless ... I also prefer to have specialist planes that may be used without modification. My LV LA Jack is one of the few multitaskers, ahnd even then it does so in a limited manner. It has two blades, a 25 degree bevel for shooting and a 50 degree bevel for use as a panel plane. Otherwise they are all single taskers, such as a #5 1/2 is set up for use as a fore plane. Another is set up as a scrub. I use several smoothers. Etc.
In reality who does not prefer single-use tools? Some may be used for different tasks, but they do so without altering a setting. In reality multitasking tools are a Royal pain in the watsit.
My plane is the same plane Ron uses for his product photogtraph on his web site. The infill in his photo looks closer to walnut than it does in "real life." The infill on my plane is pretty black. It's a pretty good color match for ebony, but the open grain of the walnut gives it away. The knob looks blacker than the infill with less grain color variation.
>I have no reason to doubt that the Brese plane works wondrous well.
But I am slightly perturbed by the extent of your difficulties with a LA Jack (presumably LN or LV).
I know that many people are getting excellent shooting performance from LA Jacks, and LA Jacks are often recommended for this, so your report seems unusual.
I have a Lie Nielsen low angle jack plane that has been my shooting plane for years. It works very well in that role. Like you, I find it to be the most versatile plane in my shop. In fact, it is my favorite plane, and and I have posted that opinion numerious times on this and other boards. It certainly functions better as a shooter than any of my bench planes, and I have probably used all of them at one time or another with my shooting board.
Like all multi-function tools, however, there are some compromises that affect is's performance as a shooter. First, I find its narrow sides make it prone to tipping, and I have to be careful to make sure I got a square cut in the vertical plane, especially on thick stock. To keep the sides of the plane flat on the board, I have to direct much of my hand pressure down toward the shooting board surface. Second, it is a fairly light-weight plane, and the weight simply isn't sufficient to carry it through a cut on thick stock. Even with a very sharp blade, I sometimes found myself hacking at thick stock to complete a cut. Having to direct much of trhe force down rather than forward, I'm sure, contributes to this problem. Third, it's not the most comfortable plane to use on it's side. Here I will note that I have never tried it with a "hot dog."
I don't want to magnify these issues out of proportion because I think a low angle jack is a fabulous design, and I would hate to discourage anyone from purchasing one. I am, however, at the fortunate place in my woodworking career where I can afford an occasional specialty tool. I believe "square" is one of the fundamental elements of good work. Consequently, I have been looking for a good, affordable shooting plane for some time. When Ron handed this plane to me at the Peach meet in Georgia, I knew my search was over. It solves all of my issues with the LA jack as a shooter: It is comfortable to use, it has a very large, flat registration surface that does not tip on the board, and it is very heavy. All in all, it is a dream to use.
>Paul, see my reponse to Bill Tindall above for details. I certainly didn't mean to disparage low angle, bevel up planes, and don't want to incite a firestorm here. I have enjoyed my LA jack as a shooter for years and I will continue to recommend it for that function. I wanted a dedicated shooter for the reasons I explained above and I was fortunate to find and purchase Ron's shooting plane. The LA jack is a wonderful plane, even as a shooter; but it is not designed to be a shooter and it doesn't function in that role as well as a plane specifically designed for shooting.
On the technical side of LA Jacks, the LV/Veritas and LN have some significant differences that influence their characteristics as shooting planes.
The LV is a longer, wider and heavier plane than the LN. The best analogy is one of comparing a #5 1/2 with a #5. I have used many planes happily on a shooting board, including the LN. It works very well in this regard. However, the LV does work better.
With a sharp blade, the LV is an excellent plane for the shooting board. Nevertheless it is still not a plane dedicated to the shooting board and is not expected to perform as well as one that is specially designed to shoot. My Stanley #51 is such a plane. Ron's (Hank's) mitre plane is another.
>"You realise that you are suggesting that we purchase fewer tools ...!!!"
I don't think that is the point. :)
I agree with Bill though, as he says, for beginers. But in addition, there are many costs to tools beyond the pruchase price, mostly in time, and also space, and further costs in dollars for maintenance and various rents. If you Derek, don't spend every working hour on your shop, then you are a super man. But for many, the fewer tools the better, or all time space and money gets sucked into the vortex. Beware of the man with one rifle.
That said I think one can leverage off many particular tools. The dominance of the table saw shows how squaring up can be one of those central function. I don't use my shooting board like that but I could see it at the center of the shop for some people.
>I think a key factor is the wide flat sides of the dedicated shooting planes, makes it a lot easier to square up and hold in square. Also the added weight. Also, I like a handle on the side for this task. I, of course, went for the Japanese and/or HNT versions (the try plane), both made of very heavy wood, with a nod to the Japanese for the bigger, heavier blades and a nod to HNT for the through-body handle(s); and have been very happy with my decision.
Are you talking about a 'standard' kanna used for shooting, or a purpose-made plane? I've never seen a kanna designed specificaly for shooting, though I know its common to shoot with any kanna in japanese carpentry. However, if there's a configuration or construction variation specifically for shooting, I'd be very interested in more details...
>It's a foregone conclusion that a plane specifically designed for a given task will work better than one that is not. Except to the extent it creates a burden in upkeep, etc...
I would wonder what the increment of performance would be. I have little difficulty maintaining square with a lower side plane, there is a lot of index to the plane. I can virtually do it without training wheels anyway, Keep in mind that when cutting back a surface to square, one only needs the last few passes to be perfect, which is not too much to ask of a more basic configuration.
The main advantage to a dedicated set-up appears to be the addition of a small increment of height in the workpiece. I prefer to treat that situation as a side, and I don't do a lot of it anyway. If I was in the business of making planes where the ends are a finished surface, or deep moldings, the appeal would be greater. Still I mostly use the shooting board for small stuff. Few people probably own a dedicated system capable of dealing with the full range a standard 12" chop saw offers.
I can also think off the top of my head of at least three ways of registering a plane with greater accuracy than the larger sides of a 4 square plane would allow... Hmm when is RL coming back from vacation?
Here are some data on one example. This is a Mosaku shooting plane. Red oak dai, 15-1/2" long. Blade width = 55mm. Cutting width = throat width = subblade width = 48mm. Bedding = 41-42 degrees.
Sole is dead flat--no waves at all.
The blade is offset to one side of the centerline in the dai. To put it another way, there is some extra dai width on one side of the blade. When the plane is set on edge for shooting (by a righthander pulling the plane), there is about 1/2" of dai width below the cutting edge, as opposed to the usual 1/4" of dai width outside the blade. I suppose this blade height off the lower edge is to accommodate the width of the stage that the work is sitting on--if the blade were set lower (at the usual level), you'd be shaving away some usable vertical reference during the run-in. I don't find this to be so important, but I have seen the same thing on another 15-1/2" kanna ("jack plane") as well, so perhaps this offset is consistently found on nagadai kanna.
>Yes, there are purpose built shooting kanna; but the feature differences with smoothers are subtle. The Mosaku I have is made of hon red oak, very dense, close to ironwood, has a blade 54 mm wide to help keep things stable, cheeks of differing widths for shooting one direction (there's a set of left and right handed shooters that I don't have), has a flat sole (vs stepped for smoothers), and is 15-18" long (my stuff is packed away, so can't measure for you).
Interesting that you both have Mosaku versions - I wonder if this is one of Kanda-san's 'exclusives' or if it is a traditional style I've just never run across?
The thicker sidewall is interesting - I suppose in addition to maintaining more reference surface on the beam or shooting board, it also allows the 'side' to be trued up many times.
Wiley - is your plane red oak (akagashi) as well? I would have thought that the j. white oak's slightly better wear properties would have made it the species of choice for such a design - but then again, I've never seen a hon-akagashi sample that I'd classify as being as hard as Pam's is.
Thanks both for the info. If either of you ever has the opportunity to photograph your plane, or comes across links to a version of it, I'd be interested in seeing it.