HA!
James Watriss
>I read it to be witty sarcasm. : )
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
HA!
James Watriss
>I read it to be witty sarcasm. : )
Comparisons aside, maybe they make a fair point
James Watriss
>I will confess that I think they make a fair point.
I wouldn't ever try to take anything away from PW. I think Schwartz, Lang, and Cherubini are doing a great job. But if you read Schwartz' blog, he does make reference occasionally to the hordes of wives who want his head on a stick for convincing their husbands to go buy the latest and greatest infill plane, Blue spruce chisel, or other fancy widget or gizmo. I'll be plain, I think he has great taste in fancy tools. An acrylic-infused quilted maple mallet? Oh, heavens, I need some new shorts... be right back...
I also think that Jim Krenov would have a much different perspective on the topic.
To be fair, Schwartz' blog has lately delved into the topic of how to spot and rescue older Bailey planes and their clones. But I bet if you dangled that Brese shooting board plane in front of him, he'd take the hammer to a few more Stanleys.
Having worked the counter at the fancy stores, I can say first hand that I met many people who were convinced that they had to have what the magazine had mentioned in that month's review. And I dare say that there's a small rash of fancy tool collecting going on, disguised as a woodworking hobby. Finally, something you can collect where it's ok to take it out of the packaging!
I think I can do without 3 or 4 articles from FWW on the latest and greatest way to cut joinery that's been around for hundreds of years. Dovetails can be made with everything from $600 worth of Blue Spruce and Glen Drake, to an old hacksaw and a sharpened screwdriver from a yard sale.
In the end, the job of the PW guys is to put out a magazine. They do their work to sell the magazine, and that's respectable. And I think they come at it from the level of many hobbyists, and that's really cool. It's something most people can relate to.
On the other hand, FWW used to put out articles from the guys we all aspire to. Articles from the people that, if they were in town, I think we'd all be there with open ears, just to hear them say hi.
There's a difference between reading about woodworking from celebrity authors, and reading about the work of celebrity woodworkers with justly earned reputations for their woodworking. Those who come down from the mountain once in a while to impart some of their hard-earned wisdom will always get top billing, in my book.
Maloof said he ran his workshops, wrote articles, and did the DVD to save woodworkers from having to spend the time trying to learn from scratch, the things that he had figured out. There were things he learned trying to fill orders... not pages. He gave this information out to be generous, not because it was his job.
In the end, the letter from the editor is written to his audience of readers, just as are the things we read in PW. And I think it has just as much authority, or as little, for all of the same reasons.
Choose the work that's rewarding to you. Aspire to whatever level appeals. Seek your information accordingly, and question everything, while you search for your own answers on the topic.
Re: Like THAT happens with me! ;)
Glenn Madsen near San Francisco
>
you write....
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>"letters from the editor" that I would read.
Re: you write....
James Watriss
>All I need now is a magazine... ;)
Maybe Pop. Woodworking
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>would be interested in having you show how you made that nice inlay on the cherry chest (hope I'm remembering correctly). That's something a lot of people would be interested in reading about.
Wiley
"FWW used to put out articles ....."
David Cockey
>I agree, but FWW seems to be changing. Interesting that several posters have talked about what FWW used to be, not what it is today. To me it's still a decent magazine but not what it used to be.
Recently Mike Dunbar, Mario Rodgriguez, Peter Follensbee and Roy Underhill have had articles in .... Popular Woodworking. All folks with skills and knowledge I'd like to have. And in his blog Follensbee says he liked both the way the article appeared and how he was treated. Seems there is a shift underway.
Re: "FWW used to put out articles ....."
ThomD
>Thing in this field is that to a large extent a lot of the superior older articles, and books are still relevant today. It's not like reading the daily news. I think over the years the stuff angled for the amateur of modest ambitions has got vastly better, like Chris'workbench book, while the stuff aimed at the person with unrestricted ambitions is non-existant or has moved to vertical publications like American Woodturner and some stuff from the furniture society, or video (still not fully played out). I'm not sure of a great book that has been published in a decade, doubtless a few, but not like the half dozen a year that used to come out.
Perhaps the turnning point in books was the Scott Landis book on Workbenches. It was a very good book, still the best on it's topic. It signaled a degree of specialization, intense editing, and magazine styling, that had not been done before (?) in the field. Nothing was the same afterwards, with FWW focusing in the future on the formula rather than the content. Just a thought.
good point
roninkokomo
>There is a telling point suggested in your note. There are only so many articles that a guys needs to read on "Cutting Tails first" or "How to tune your Card Scraper" So for some of geezers who are really interested in hand tool woodworking... you will soon run out of reasons to buy a magazine... except to look at others work... And there are lots of places to do that.
Like voting in elementary
mckay
>This reminds me of a story of a 2nd grade class where one of the students brought in a kitten. The question was asked if the cat was a boy or a girl. Many opinions were given, but no consensus was reached. One young mans suggestion was to "vote" on the sex of the animal.
This argument is much like that vote. No matter which way you go there will be a difference of opinion. I personally like both magazines.
I really DO NOT like PW web page. When you look at "boring" in the dictionary, the PW web site is given as the defininition. FWW on the other hand has what I would consider a great web page. There is something for all levels. I marvel at the abilities of some of the projects that are presented by people in the gallery.
That said I hope all continue in this economy so that I can lust, drool and desire new tools and new projects!