FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?
David Cockey
>Is Fine Woodworking worried about the competition from Ohio?
The August 2009 issue of Fine Woodworking arrived today, and the letter from the editor, Asa Chrisiana, is titled "Beware of Hero Worship". He starts by saying when he first came to FW he was intimidated by the big names, but has noticed that "the best woodworkers are usually the most humble." He then talks about Phil Lowe who is "never preachy; he only says, 'This is how I do it.'"
Next he shifts gears to "Fine Woodworking magazine used 77 different authors last year - a mix of hobbyists and pros..." Then "So beware of hero worship. You might start to think you need all the top-rated tools plus weeks of classes with a big-name guy before you can build another piece." The concluding paragraph advocates following you own insticts and ideas, etc.
Perhaps it doesn't have anything to do with Popular Woodworking and Woodworking magazines, but the line about "Fine Woodworking used 77 different authors ...." seems to be an implied comparison, and Popular Woodworking certainly uses fewer authors with their small, full time staff directly responsible for much more of the content than Fine Woodworking. Woodworking is almost completely an in-house production.
The hero worship comments could be read as directly related to the regard Chris Schwarz is held in by many serious woodworkers and some of the significant hand tool makers.
Other thoughts?



