Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

Posts

FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

#1

FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

David Cockey

>Is Fine Woodworking worried about the competition from Ohio?

The August 2009 issue of Fine Woodworking arrived today, and the letter from the editor, Asa Chrisiana, is titled "Beware of Hero Worship". He starts by saying when he first came to FW he was intimidated by the big names, but has noticed that "the best woodworkers are usually the most humble." He then talks about Phil Lowe who is "never preachy; he only says, 'This is how I do it.'"

Next he shifts gears to "Fine Woodworking magazine used 77 different authors last year - a mix of hobbyists and pros..." Then "So beware of hero worship. You might start to think you need all the top-rated tools plus weeks of classes with a big-name guy before you can build another piece." The concluding paragraph advocates following you own insticts and ideas, etc.

Perhaps it doesn't have anything to do with Popular Woodworking and Woodworking magazines, but the line about "Fine Woodworking used 77 different authors ...." seems to be an implied comparison, and Popular Woodworking certainly uses fewer authors with their small, full time staff directly responsible for much more of the content than Fine Woodworking. Woodworking is almost completely an in-house production.

The hero worship comments could be read as directly related to the regard Chris Schwarz is held in by many serious woodworkers and some of the significant hand tool makers.

Other thoughts?

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

#2

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

Martin from Texas

>I thought it was a little coincidental that they had an article about wood grain. Didn't I just see one in Woodworking? The Woodworking one was excellent, have not read the one in FWW.

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

#3

Probably coincidental

David Cockey

>It's probably coincidental given the lead times for publication of FW, let alone getting the article written. There could have been common or similar root stimuli behind the articles though.

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

#4

beats me....don't care

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I didn't read the editorial. I seldom read any editorial because I seldom find any useful insights in editorials. I think they are a waste of magazine space, especially so in Cook's magazine. Well, actually I do read what stands for an editorial in the Lee Valley catalogs. They are short and do provide useful/interesting information.

That said, a magazine that draws on the expertise of 76 authors per year is going to offer more breadth of perspective than one that draws on what ever smaller number. Such a magazine could have more long term staying power and broader appeal. So in this regard a valid advertising point has been made, though not sufficient to induce me to subscribe.

As far as "Hero worship" I don't know what that means nor why it is to be avoided. If it means "hold in awe" then I hero worship the yearly Cartousche winners and there is no way in hell that I will ever approach their work even with unlimited tools and unlimited instruction. But, it doesn't prevent me from doing what I can and stretching skills along the way. I didn't need the editor to help me come to these realizations.

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

#5

Life is good!

Roy Anderson

>I love competition. Popular Woodworking magazine is a better magazine that it used to be, Fine Woodworking can only be forced to keep up with the competition and life is good for us woodworkers.

As for hero worship, the only hero I have is St. Roy of Underhill, who got me interested in traditional woodworking and kept me inspired so many years ago when EVERYONE ELSE that I know thought I was out of my ever-loving mind to want to work with those klunky old hand tools. All the other great woodworkers have my respect and I sure enjoy learning from them, but there is only one hero.

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

#6

Roy ..... PW

David Cockey

>Hmmm ..... Who did Roy recently write an article for, the first magazine article I can remember from him? Popular Woodworking ..... Hmmm

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

#7

breadth of perspective

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>"That said, a magazine that draws on the expertise of 76 authors per year is going to offer more breadth of perspective"

Objectively, it's not neccessarily the case that more writers equals a greater number of perspectives. It could be just more people saying the same thing.

Adam

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

#8

Peter Follansbee

David Cockey

>Peter Follansbee is another traditional woodworker who I have a lot of respect for. His blogs http://pfollansbee.wordpress.com/ tend to be mini-tutorials on 16th/17th century woodworking and show considerable reasearch and thought. He recently had an article published in Popular Woodworking and in a blog said "I was quite pleased with the treatment I received there, and the printed result." I suspect we may see more from here there, particularly with the demise of Woodwork magazine where he previously published.

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

#9

Re: breadth of perspective

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yeah, after all it's still a small set of editors who choose which articles will be published.

Pam

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

#10

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I take some classes on occasion from one of the authors that writes for FWW. He wrote for Woodwork when it existed, and does some for some of the others, too. His private comments about working with the FWW people are interesting, to say the least.

A teacher can approach things at different levels. Our groups are more constructive explorations of different areas, not so much top-down dissertations on the perceived realities of some subjects. And they flow from class to class, adding new people, and from time to time, shedding a few, and growing as we go.

All the world's knowledge is to be found in one place, certainly.

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

#11

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>All the world's knowledge is to be found in one place, certainly.

And that would be San Francisco? Marin? :)

Pam

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

#12

Re: breadth of perspective

Tony - Memphis

>God point Pam. And based on what I've heard from the "author's," the editors have a pretty heavy hand on what the final article looks/reads like. I'm really getting bored with all the ww rags though. In that particular issue, I did enjoy the article by Mark Arnold on veneering. But, they have run that almost identical article before by another author (probably a couple, actually). I agree with him on Phil though, Phil is a really nice guy - confident, but humble. Funny though, I took a class from him once and there was a lady in the class that I got to be good buddies with....there were a couple of folks who idolized Phil and it drove her nuts! In contrast, I took a class from another well known woodworker/educator/author who was completely opposite - my way is it! Come to think of it, I've about had my fill of classes too. At some point, you just gotta DO IT. Sorry to ramble...

Tony - Humility comes easy for me - just take a look at my work!

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

#13

Re: they do more than choose. . .

Dave Mount

>. . .or at least they did in the 90's. I friend of mine and I had an article in FWW back in the late 90's. He'd come up with a slick way of making Stickley-style legs and I wrote an article about it and we submitted it as a jointly authored article. Although they accepted and published the article, we came to find out that's not the way it usually worked. Usually the person shown as the author had the concept for the article, but it was actually written by one of the staff editors.

In our case, the submitted article was about a Mission sofa table, with a sidebar on how to make the legs. The published article was only about the legs; only a partial photo of the table ended up in the article. However, almost all of the writing in the final article was from the original submission, just rearranged.

Although they exerted a lot of control over the article, the editor we worked with was very pleasant. In the end, I ended up just being acknowledged, because FWW's style is first person from the woodworker (even if it's ghost written). They sent me some nice coffee table books, and years later a copy of a book which reprinted the original article.

FWW has undergone a number of changes since those days, I don't know if their process may have changed as well.

Dave

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

#14

Re: they do more than choose. . .

Tony - Memphis

>One day, in class with " ", one of the class members asked him a question about his finishing schedule. He wanted to know something about a particular polyurethane he used. The instructor looked at him like he was crazy and said I don't use that stuff, I finish everything with good old shellac. The student challenged him and they went and found the article (it was in FWW), and sure enough, they had quoted the instructor as saying he used some particular poly. The instructor was very surprised, to say the least. He stood there scratching his head wondering where the heck they got that from. He figured he had probably mentioned that in some cases, he would apply one coat of poly over the shellac for a tabletop that would be abused. That was pretty funny. The article showed him as the author too!

I used to be in the race car parts biz. We worked with a lot of magazine writers. Obviously, it was to our benefit to get some free advertising via the articles. We performed testing and such and provided data. All I can say is don't believe everything you read! Especially in that business.

Congrats on being published, btw. That's pretty cool.

Tony

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

#15

Re: FW - how to make the real money

ThomD

>Maybe, though the big names tend not to be magazine editors as much as the big names in the craft itself. CS is also very approachable not a distant hero figure, and I am not too sure what exactly he has written about that is new to the magazines. He is really good at what he does, without a doubt. If I was looking at a career in print he might be a big influence. If you are selling magazines and books, and not original furniture you are kinda a post modern influence, moreso than a real maker.

FW used to use plenty of big names. I try not to buy the magazines any more so I don't know who is what these days. But FWW made names like Frantz Klaus, Ian Kirby, etc... who write for other magazines these days. And put out stuff for already big names like Maloof, Krenov, Fortuen, etc...

I don't know where the business is these days, but FWW was the indisputed force, and still probably published more important woodworking books and tapes than any other source, published 100% of the seminal article. I think Tauton did two to three turns on any subject before the others even showed up. But Taunton discovered that a huge pile of money could be made from the architectural market. Compare the Tolpin paperback on how to run a nomadic kitchen cabinet business with his various glossy home style books. I don't know whether the Tauton brand hinges on whether they publish the next great Japanese woodworking book or not. If it does I wish they would get back to it.

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

#16

Re: they do more than choose. . .

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Add my congrats, too, Dave.

Of course they do more than choose, but choosing was all that was necessary to note that even with a large number of industry heroes from which to choose, the choice is made by a few editors, and there is not necessarily a wider berth of opinion.

If I were to try to publish, for various reasons, including fame and fortune :), I think I'd go with Chris as the editor/publisher I most respect. He still has the constraints that go with his business, but my guess is he does his best to allow a writer to self-represent.

Pam

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

#17

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

Greg B�tit, Crown Point, NY

>I think he mistakenly left out the word "not". Read: "All the World's knowledge of wood working is not to be found in one place."

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

#18

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>You're probably right, I wasn't familiar with the quote.

Pam

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

#19

Re: they do more than choose. . .

ThomD

>It must be almost weird for the editors to come across people who can write.

There are people who have influenced me greatly, and in many cases it is on the basis of a half dozen articles, that just hit the stuff I was working on at the time. It is always funny to meet the people and realize how transient in their lives that stuff is, while the people that read the articles can sometimes quote whole passages, and in addition have made all manner of extrapolations.

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

#20

Oh AMEN!!!!!!

roninkokomo

>

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

#21

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I wasn't quoting, I didn't think. But I did screw up what I wrote. ;)

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

#22

:)

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

#23

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

Charles

>Fine Woodworking has reached its nadir with Christiana at the helm. I'm not sure that having 77 authors, with a few exceptions, spewing pap the FW editors want is anything to brag about.

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

#24

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

Thomas S Stockton

>David

I think your reading way to much between the lines. The magazine industry is one of the hardest hit segments of the current economy. They are hearing footsteps from all over and probably worried about competition from all directions. If they start mimicking articles thats when they are fearing a certain publication. Why do you think they have a readers gallery, American woodworker under Ellis had a really successful one and Aww was gaining market-share so they felt like they needed one also. The same goes for projects they used to not really have very many project articles, other magazines did and it became popular so they have them also now. In some ways FWW has gone from an innovator to just another magazine. In Fww case I'm personally not that impressed with the furniture their editors have made. The bulk of the nice work is done by the contributing editors who actually have careers making furniture and need to keep producing at a high level.

Another poster mentioned Frank Klaus and Ian Kirby and said Fww made their reputations. Authors like this made FWW what it was not the other way around. Both had excellent reputations long before they wrote for the magazine. Being well known is great but woodworkers aren't generally going to buy your furniture, these guys did it because they feel the need to pass on their knowledge and are great teachers.

Tom

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

#25

Re: FW hearing foot steps from Ohio?

David Cockey

>Thomas, my comments were in direct response to the editor's letter in the recent issue. Portions of them, particularly the comments about "heros", seem to be a reaction to something. I was speculating that it might be PWW.

I've subscribed to FWW for almost 30 years and have saved all the issues. For a long time it was clearly distinct from other woodworking magazines, aimed at the "serious" woodworkers, and the only one I ever read. Over the last several years I've noticed a significant change as FWW seems to be trying to draw in a broader audience. The same thing seems to be happening to sister magazine Fine Homebuilding. Perhaps Taunton has made a concious decision to modify their course. Interestinly my wife who isn't a woodworker but has enjoyed reading FWW (and who subscribed to FHB) recently remarked she finds less which interests her in FWW and more in PWW.