Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

Posts

Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

#1

Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

Edward in Vancouver

>Am at wit's end. It only took me a week or so to learn how to put a decent enough edge on a plane iron to shave hair and make decent shavings, but a card scraper? I'm still at it and getting more frustrated, which makes me want to master it all the more.

I think my problems start at the filing stage. O.K. I got LV's "scraper set" for my B'day a few years back, file and file jig, holder, and variable burnisher. The card scrapers I use at work (chocoalte shop and bakery) are used to scrape clean the beech and maple topped tables,(suagar/caramel and chocoalte dry on hard, like glue, and no one likes a wet wood table) so a square clean edge with no hook works best, and these scrapers probably have rounded over edges from daily use.

1) I found I almost never got square edges when clamping the scraper in a vise and using the file jig as intended. There is an aprox 1" shoulder on the jig to guide the scraper and a relief channel just above the file. I found I wasn't filing a squre edge this way. I had better luck laying the jig on the bench and moving the scraper along the jig.

2) Stoning. I don't own any decent oil stones, but have an 800 and combination 1200/4000 water stones. And I found out the hard way that these are far too soft. By laying the stone on its side on the edge of my bench and guiding the scraper along the apron of my bench, I though I had a foolproof way of getting a 90 angle. Of course, I rounded over the edge, and scored my stones. How much pressure can or should you put on a waterstone?

3) Burnishing. Still haven't had much success with the variable burnisher. Alot of it has to do with clamping the scraper, my scrapers are only about 2" wide, and the burnisher sits about 1/3/4 high on the scraper, leaving next to no room to clamp the sucker in a vise. Try and experiment as I might, I can get some moderate shavings on soft maple, but more dust than shavings, irregardless if I put a 7, 10,or 12 degree hook. I don't own a "proper" burnisher --yet. I've tried the uusual stuff-- a wrist pin from a Volvo piston, with a diameter of somewhere around 3/4". The thing is hard enough for a hacksaw to skate over, but after studying any information I could get my hands on, the diameter is all wrong--too big. The burnisher in the LV jig is somewhere around 3/16" in diameter. I've got my "mayonnaise jar" saved up for the burnisher-- the tear drop shaped one, but which radius do you use for a card scraper?

I've got about 2 years worth of "pop. woodworking" and maybe a year's worth of "Woodworking" magazines, and I know Chris S. wrote a few articles about scrapers and sharpening, but can't find the article.

Can anyone direct me to some information about sharpening the elusive card scraper?

Re: Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

#2

step 1...forget the stoning

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I had a spell of similar failures. He is what worked for me.

The common way not to get a useful edge is to not file away all the dead edge, or rounded edge if it got rounded in stoning. A 10 X lens is mighty handy for seeing the state of things after filing and burnishing.

Don't push too hard on the file. It should be taking off tiny ribbons of metal and not chattering. If you don't feel the file teeth cutting then the file is probably dull. I use a very fine toothed 6" file.

I don't stone. It always ruined my filed edge and didn't yield a good burr. Maybe someday I will perfect this step.

Don't push too hard on the burnisher. Two moderate swipes work for me. A carbide router bit, 1/4", stuck in a dowel, makes a wonderful burnisher. Oil it slightly.

I suspect others use a more sophisticated technique that results in a more perfect and hence more durable edge. Don't fret perfection yet. Strive for something that works and then improve it later.

Re: Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

#3

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: What Bill said...Plus...

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>For filing, I use an 8" file. I ploughed a �" groove in a piece of hardwood, and put the edge of the file into the groove.

Lay the scraper flat on the wood, and drag it along the file a few times - like Bill says.

Skip the stoning, and go straight to the burnisher:

Lay the scraper on a flat surface, with its edge just hanging over. Pull the burnisher along the flat several times to pull an edge 'wire' out, then put the scraper upright in a vise and use the burnisher to turn the 'wire edge' outward. Start with the burnisher perpendicular to the edge, and then after only a couple strokes, tilt the burnisher downward by a few (maybe 5) degrees. One or two strokes in this position, and you're done.

When the scraper dulls, just re-burnish. You can usually get two or three re-burnishings before you need to completely resharpen.

Jim D.

Re: Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

#4

stoning is good

Chris Friesen

>I'm no expert by any means, but it stands to reason to me that honing both the flats and the edge of the scraper will give a better edge than just filing it.

Here's an article by Chris Schwarz:

http://www.popularwoodworking.com/article/A_Better_Way_to_Sharpen_Scrapers

and a video of him giving a talk on scrapers at the WIA conference.

http://sandal-woodsblog.com/2008/11/24/33-wia-scrapers-history-preparation-and-use-part-1/

http://sandal-woodsblog.com/2008/11/26/34-wia-scrapers-history-preparation-and-use-part-2/

http://sandal-woodsblog.com/2008/11/27/35-wia-scrapers-history-preparation-and-use-part-3/

Re: Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

#5

Only good stoning is good

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>My point is that it is easy for a novice, or myself, to screw up stoning and wind up with an edge that is impossible to roll a burr upon. Hence, some people will find that eliminating this step is beneficial. Skillfully done, stoning likely produces a more durable burr.

Re: Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

#6

scott grandstaff

Re: Only good stoning is good

Scott Grandstaff

>I use an old handsaw. (8 to 14 scrapers for a buck, just my style.)

Add a 6" single cut file, another 3 bucks shot.

And you're in.

Scraping is not "all about sharpening" guys.

More scraping and lot less fiddling.

Personally, I forget the stone and forget the burnisher altogether.

Drawfile and go. Takes 40 seconds.

I lay the scraper flat in my hand and run a fine file over the face on both sides until the old burr is gone.

There's 11 entire seconds wasted right there.

Then put the blade in the vise with 1/4" sticking up.

Drawfile.

Smooth, firm, even strokes until the file bites full and sweet all across with tiny shreds of metal falling by the wayside.

A new edge!

Take it out and use it.

When you dull the whole edge (remember to shift your grip and follow the edge and spin it around and use the backside too)

just repeat the above.

I scrape something just about everyday. Ebony or rosewood, hickory or even pine (softwood is the toughest, don't let anybody fool ya).

I've scraped cast iron! Lead, pewter, copper, brass,.......

all scrape, never mind.

Finding your stroke, the posture, angle and pressure, is more important than fussing over the edge forever.

Unless playing at sharpening is your hobby.

Goncalo Alves, rather dreaded in some circles as hard and soft in the same piece of wood, with grain reversals galore.

40 seconds to sharpen and another 20 seconds making these fluffs.

yours Scott


img

Re: Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

#7

Pictorial *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Edward

The debate should not be about Stoning verses Not Stoning. This misses the point. Both methods are valid, but should be used for different ends.

Stoning an edge creates a smooth surface, which leads to a smooth hook, and this facilitates a smooth finish (such as produced by a smoothing plane). Not Stoning, that is, just leaving the slightly ragged edge from a file, produces an edge that will remove waste aggresively but not leave a smooth surface (think of a jack plane).

The bottom line really is the surface that is left on the wood. Different timbers create different types of shavings, so you cannot always go by the shaving to say whether all is working well. For example, short-grained and interlinked timber generally create short, tight curlies.

In both approaches above a key element is the hook. When starting out, most overdo the hook by using too much force. A large hook is fragile and will bend to the wrong angle (and stop cutting).

The burnisher choice is important. A wide burnisher will word as will a thin burnisher. I prefer a thin rod (thanks again Tony!) because it requires less downforce. Use a "proper" burnisher (hardened, polished steel) rather than the back of a chisel. Modern steel used in cabinet (card) scrapers may be too hard for the chisel (which may also simply transfer nicks, etc to the edge of the scraper).

The choice of stone? Waterstones are fine for stoning if you don;t press too hard, and if you don;t need to remove too much steel. I prefer to use a diamond stone for the early stage, then finish on a waterstone (same level as a plane blade) ... when used for smoothing.

Below is a link to a Pictirial I wrote. This will hopefully make clearer what is require.

Regards from Perth

Derek


Preparing a Cabinet Scraper

Re: Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

#8

Re: Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>If you are having trouble getting a burr on a card scraper that is filed at 90 degrees, you might try grinding or filing the edge to 45 degrees and go for just one burr. Luthier's sharpen their scrapers this way and you can usually turn a bigger burr.

A filed scraper will be rougher than one that is stoned which produces a smoother finish.

Stephen

Re: Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

#9

I continue to be amazed........

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>....that the more professional someone is the less fretting they do to get a job done. I have been meaning to try going from file to scraping for some time. You just encouraged me to do it next time.

It could be that your burr only lasts half as long as one done with meticulous care. But then it only takes a few seconds and you are back in business. I would like to hear how you sharpen a plane and chisel.

Re: Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

#10

please explain ....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>How to you retrieve scraper pieces from a saw blade- cut, break, ???

Will you explain the technique of "draw filing"?

Re: Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

#11

Re: please explain ....

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Bill,

A hacksaw blade is as hard as a file. We sharpen our saws with a file and we can saw a handsaw blade with a hacksaw.

The way I do it is, I clamp the saw blade to a solid surface with a piece of wood under the saw blade. The sawing is done with the clamped blade overhanging the solid surface I have it clamped to. I have the blade clamped close to both sides of the scribed line I have on the blade. If you don't do all this clamping, the hacksaw blade will try to lift the handsaw blade on the back stroke. When you are sawing the handsaw blade, you are also sawing the piece of wood you have under the blade.

I do my clamping to the table of my radial arm saw. It could also be done with a 2 x 6 in a pattern makers vise.

Some people cut handsaw blades with a thin carborundum grinding wheel, but I prefer doing it the hard way.

Marv

Re: Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

#12

Re: Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

Alexander Grigoriev

>What I see is that current LV and other brand-name scrapers are quite hard, way harder than your handsaw steel. While the (no-name, chinese-made?) file that LV supplies in the kit works well on them, regular Nicholson brand mill file gets shiny and dull pretty much instantly.

Steel burhisher doesn't seem to work on these scrapers. I'm using LV's variable angle carbide burnisher. And, unfortunately, the carbide rod in it was not polished well; I had to apply much elbow grease to make it shine. Since the grinding marks left on the rod are almost in the direction of application to the scraper's edge, the marks are transferred to it.

Re: Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

#13

Re: step 1...forget the stoning

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>I do it both ways, Bill. (I'm talking about scrapers by the way). You're right that you can get your scraper to work with just a file. You're also right that honing is a good way to ruin a scraper.

My experience is that a rough filed scraper may be like 320 grit sand paper. The surface it leaves can have scratches in it. A honed scraper leaves a finer surface (like 600 grit paper or better - I'm guessing here).

One big difference between scrapers and sand paper is that the scrapers work way faster and there's no difference in the speed of work between the filed and the stoned scraper.

Stoning a scraper blade freehand really isn't that tough and it does produce a better result (maybe like the difference between ground and honed turning tools?). I think it's a worthwhile skill to learn. But I'm with you. If you are just starting out with scapers, skip the stones and the burnisher. And by all means don't feel you need to buy a bunch of jigs.

Adam

Re: Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

#14

It seems to me......

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>that a burr rolled on a polished edge would be more durable. Without the relatively coarse scratches from the file I would think there would be less tendency for the burr to fracture. Some good microscope pictures could shed light on this subject.

I use a scraper as an alternative to 60 grit sand paper, Actually, a scraper might remove wood at a faster clip than even 60 grit. My typical finishing schedule is incompatible with a planed or scrapped surface (too porous) so the finish off the scraper is irrelevant in my work. What ever it is, it gets sanded.

I will keep in mind that a refined scraper edge could be useful for scraping something already finished, like for removing a run. This is something I have not explored. After never getting a good burr from a honed (I should add faulty honed) edge I quite this step.

Re: Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

#15

draw filing

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>draw filing is holding the file across the work rather than along it and moving the file sideways to its length. You'll recognize immediately that, on a single-cut file, the file has to be moved so the teeth are cutting, not trailing. If I recall correctly (it's been years since my shop intro to metal work class - although I still have the cold chisel I made then), even double-cut files have a preferred direction.

Putting it another way, you hold the file as if it were a drawknife missing its handles, and pull it toward you (or push it away, I guess, but pulling always felt more right).

Draw filing can produce a smoother edge than straight or lengthwise filing.

Re: Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

#16

Re: stoning is good

ThomD

>"I'm no expert by any means, but it stands to reason to me that honing both the flats and the edge of the scraper will give a better edge than just filing it."

Probably true, but less great than one might think. One can sharpen steel razor sharp with a file, but we don't do it with cabinet grade tools because they are too hard, and there are different degrees of razor sharp. Blister pack tools are often drawn reasonably soft so they can be sharpened in the field with a file, not to mention axes, and broadheads. My favorite scrapers the Lee Valley one and the Sandvik can be filed, though I often grind them on a belt sander where even hard tools melt away. Further, the burnishing acts to smooth the surface.

The big issue is what happens next. In the vast majority of cases scraping is followed by sanding, just to even up the surface and provide an even tone. If that is the next step then a super smooth scrape is probably irrelevant and a two step prep will be much more efficient. If scraping is the final surface then the sharper the better.

Re: Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

#17

Think I got it.

Edward in Vancouver

>Not much time this weekend to keep on fooling around with scrapers--just an hour or so each evening. Which, is a good thing, since I can think through what I was doing right and wrong with scrapers, filing, stoning, and burnishing, during those long hours dipping and molding chocolate.

"As much pressure as spreading butter on bread" (from C. Schwartz's videos) Sage advice, very sage. And this is probably where I went wrong. I knew I was getting a burr, but probably I rolled it a bit too much, umm, "enthusiastically". Light pressure, smooth light even strokes, just a hint of a burr, and I was getting some decent curlies on maple, oak and even teak scraps.

Many thanks to all of you and all the advice

Re: Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

#19

scott grandstaff

Re: please explain .... *LINK*

Scott Grandstaff

>Yup, just pretend the file is a drawknife with no handles. Lay it flat on top of the scraper blade, square all around.

Now notice the teeth are angled so angle the file just a little to compensate, keeping it perpendicular to the edge.

That's it. You can push or pull at your pleasure just readjust your angle a little.

Remember your elbow swings in an arc so give extra attention to the ends of the scraper blade. Much better a convex edge than a concave with sharp scratching corners!! There are no bonus points awarded for perfectly straight across edges. A gentle arc is better anyway.

As far as a filed scraper cutting rough or fine?? Once again, that is right at your fingertips. You stand the scraper practically straight up and bend it mightily with your thumbs and push hard.... you are hogging curlies like 40 grit. Lay it nearly all the way over forward and push light you are cutting like 600 grit.

Right there at your pleasure.

In scraping you are constantly laying it over or pulling it back looking for the best angle.

You can scrape burl endgrain without tearing out if you find the right scraper angle and find the proper angle of attack down the grain. It varies in a heartbeat, so stay alert.

Oh, I cut old handsaws with a paper thin cutoff disk in a Dre--l tool. You can hacksaw them or scratch with a scriber and snap them but the thin disk is fastest and easiest by far.

A harder scraper is no bonus when you can cut what you need to, then resharpen in seconds.

They make hard tools for people who can't or really hate to sharpen. Since I sharpen quickly I don't mind much and would rather have a slightly softer tool. Lasts long enough for most jobs and resharpens in a snap, how you going to beat that?

You are right about other sharpening too.

I suffer the first sharpening of plane blades or chisels like anyone else. I like a flat black (not particularly fond of microbevels). That's because once you get a back flat I never expect to spend over about 90 seconds on a blade before getting back to work. No jigs no special stuff. Quickly done.

Grind, stone and strop. Sometimes only stone and strop but I do grind often. Fresh edge is best.

Freehand at the grinder and cut you a sweet even hollow grind. )OK that takes some practice. Try some just steel scraps a few times, old hinges anything for practice)

Coarse stone (very very coarse, Carborundum),

finer stone (medium), strop.

Sharp enough for a comfortable shave and good enough for me.

Expecting to have a perfect sharp tool for every job is not happening anyway. Nobody really has that kind of time in real life.

If you can work well, you can work with a less than perfect tool.

Once again, when you want to plane or chisel wood it's never "close your eyes and shove straight ahead". Change your angles of attack. Skew the tool. Vary your pressure. Front hand pressure, or more back hand, always moving and checking.

Never take a heavy cut first off. (never start your work in the center stage spotlight either, start at the back and work your way around) You could blow out at first swipe and have a lot more cutting to go, getting even again. Take a light cut and get a taste of the wood first.

Figure out how to cut the wood the way --it-- wants to be cut.

Your preference don't count for much.

You are not the boss here. The wood is.

yours Scott


img

stonebox closed

Re: Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

#20

Scrapers

paul womack

>I don't stone. It always ruined my filed edge and didn't yield a good burr.

It is very easy to round over the edge when stone, resulting in a sharp arris (well, 2 of them, actually), but a domed "edge" to the card.

This dome prevents the burnisher working to turn the edge.

I found this out the hard way, when "stoning" using SiC. Poor results.

Changing to India Stone/Arkansas fixed the issue for me.

BugBear

Re: Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

#21

I realize every profession has its dark moments

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>but working as a baker and chocolatier? WAY better than trying to decide how to respond to a legal complaint from an employee who is living in some alternate universe in which actual performance on the job is not required...

Bill, enjoyed 30 years in human resources; enjoying NOT being in it too

Re: Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

#22

As I think about it

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>the file teeth are probably approaching the metal at a shallower angle - like skewing a plane.

Funny how many commonalities different trades turn out to have.

Re: Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

#23

Re: I realize every profession has its dark moment

Edward in Vancouver

>Meh, 20 odd years of dealing with employees in the hospitality industry, 14 in B.C., Canada and it's not the legal sword rattling that gets to me. It's a worker's paradise here, so the ones in the alernate universe sic the Labour board and Worker's comp on the employer. I'm just a momp & pop, still put our repectable volume, but I keep employees to a bare bones minimum.

The scraper adventure was the prelude to "the installation". Two 4' soft maple display units for the chocoalte shop.

Re: Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

#24

C'mon

roninkokomo

>I really think way too much mystique surrounds this relatively simple task. There are several tutorials on line to be found that are very straightforward. I think one I have seen by Brian Boggs is the best. It really does take less than ten minutes. The most common fault in tuning a scraper is most men put WAY TOO MUCH pressure on the burnishing step.

Believe me... if I can learn this task very quickly.. you can to :)

Re: Sharpening the elusive $5.00 card scraper

#25

Re: As I think about it

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>In Weygers book I remember seeing how old-time mechanics were required to demonstrate their skill with files much the same way a woodworker would use chisels. Handtool skills were not skimped on.