Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

E Bay Pricing Question

Posts

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#26

Re: Im a slow head...

Victor parisian

>You don't have to call the low or the high. You have to call somewhat close to lows or highs. But I'm no genius. I was trying to think of a very simplistic model for explaining when to dump inventory and not loose your shirt.

Victor - going to sleep on this one

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#27

Re: Im a slow head...

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yeah, but so many talk so casually about buying low and selling high when it's actually very difficult to achieve. That's why buying low usually means selling on the uptake after a low; but even then, you really can't tell whether that was the low or there's more to come. It sounds simplistic, but it's not.

Pam

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#28

Re: Im a slow head...

wilbur

>Hi Todd,

Sorry I wasn't more clear, although I tried hard to be as clear as I could in my last post.

Let me try again. Suppose in my shop I have three bench planes that I don't use at all. Their utility to me is zero. They could be seen as a drain on my shop, since my shop is small, and I have to use space to store them.

Suppose I sell those planes and use the money that I got for the planes to buy a 1-1/2" paring chisel. Why? I don't currently have a 1-1/2" paring chisel, and there were times that I could have used a 1-1/2" paring chisel, and didn't have one.

Now I have a tool that I actually will use, as opposed to three tools that just sit and get rusty in my shop. So the utility of my new 1-1/2" paring chisel is greater than the utility of those three planes, and I am in a better economic position than I was before, because my tools have more utility to me.

Note that the initial cost of buying those planes does not figure into this analysis at all. It doesn't matter if those planes cost me $5, $50, or were given to me for free. Whatever the initial cost of those planes, their utility is still zero, since I don't use them at all.

I think that what you keep doing in these types of discussions is confusing money with utility. Now, for someone like you, who is buying tools for resale, the initial price of those planes is important, because the utility of those same three bench planes to a seller of used tools completely relies on what profit you can make from those planes. But for other folks, especially those who are going to be using, not reselling, the tools they buy, it may not matter.

This is not a "way for a person to rationalise loosing [sic] money on something they are selling", as you put it, unless what you mean by "rationalise" is to engage in a rational decision making process. Nor is it an issue of whether money is important or not to any given person. The reason for this is that the goal in this scenario is not how much of a profit I will make on those planes. The goal instead is to take some useless items and turn them into something useful, in which case all I need to do is generate enough income from the sale to be able to finance my new purchase, and I will come out ahead. Certainly, one would want to maximize the income from such a sale, but again, what was originally paid for the planes does not factor into this. In this case, to obsess over what I originally paid for the bench planes that I don't use actually would be the irrational thing to do.

In other words, the advice and valuation of a tool from someone who is primarily a buyer and seller of used tools may be completely irrelevant to a woodworker who is purchasing that tool to use in their shop, because their incentives and priorities may be completely different from each other.

By the way, this concept is called an "opportunity cost". This is not some sort of esoteric theoretical economic theory. The idea of an opportunity cost is a basic principle of business and economics. It is so basic that it is taught in high school economics classes.

The idea of an opportunity cost also applies to the concept that a person is making more than they thought because the boss provides parking and air conditioning. There is the potential for the boss to be able to pay his employees more if he had the workplace temperature run in the low 90's during the summer and he passed the savings on his air conditioning bill to his employees in the form of a summertime raise. I doubt that many would take up such an offer, though.

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#29

Re: Im a slow head...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I think one of the elements that's causing people to miss each other on this one is the concept that the "you" in this example shouldn't have purchased the planes in the first place.

Well, perhaps not in the simple world of classic economics, which assumes an always rational, always knowledgeable person.

In my world (occasionally rational, rarely knowledgeable except in hindsight), the purchase of tools I didn't need after all occurs regularly. Since I primarily hunt rust (Sorry, Rob Lee, the several purchases from Lee Valley these last couple of years, while I was making big consulting bucks, are anomalous), I've seen the initial investment in these later-found-to-be-unneeded tools as tuition.

Now, if only I could get better at moving them on to someone else...

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#30

Re: Im a slow head...

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Classical economics proselytizes the classical market attitudes which have never been any good, to wit, that there are rational buyers and sellers with full knowledge. Those conditions never existed, never will, and were part of the reason that, while I enjoyed studying economics, I never considered it as a profession. Simply too full of ridiculous pronouncements that if one didn't repeat, one was ridiculed. Oh, yeah, and too many variables.

Pam

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#31

OT: definition of economics

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>My brother once told me - I think about the time he was taking his econ course - that economics is the study of faith systems.

His point then was that, if we all believe a currency is worth something, it is; but I think it may have more general application too.

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#32

Re: OT: definition of economics

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Not currency. It appears to be based on faith, but in fact the value can be calculated quite accurately. This was especially true in the old days when the gold standard held sway, but even today you can look at GDP (gross domestic product) and other data to figure out what the value should be. A minor faith component comes into play when, e.g., the Chinese continue buying our bonds because the US is still considered the safest place; but even that faith can be destroyed, and even if the value stays high.

Pam

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#33

Re: OT: The value of anything

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>Almost any item that has value to one person, or group, has a differential value to another. That's what exchange is based on. It's why Bill has such fun, and success, on the garage sale circuit. The folks he buys from are selling stuff in which they see rust, where Bill sees history, value, treasure. It's a niche.

So is the acquisition of Japanese tools. The aura is as much a part of the value as the physical implementation of the art and craft. And relatively few people see it.

Money is just an accepted medium of exchange. If faith breaks down, the money is of little to no value. See post-WWI Germany, or South American banana republics, or ...

Differential value, or views of the current and future, makes exchange viable. Now, making a living from this science is a challenge, but that's why it's called 'work'.

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#34

Minor faith

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I am reminded that, when I lived in Detroit, Canadian dimes were accepted in the Detroit stores as if they were one tenth of a US dollar. Clearly, these tokens were worth US$0.10 because everyone agreed they were (I have no idea what the exchange rate was at the time). When we returned to California, I had some left in my pocket, and was more startled than I should have been the first time a storeowner refused one.

I would also argue that the hyperinflation of the Weimar Republic was not necessarily based on German GDP.

Still, Pam, I appreciate that, in general, everyone's agreed that currency valuation can be based on metrics of various sorts.

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#35

Re: OT: The value of anything *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I don't know if any of you follow "The Wild Side" column in the NY Times, generally it's wonderful if one is into genetics and biology, that stuff. This week, they describe the Phillips machine, which mimics an economic system with hydraulics. Pretty cool stuff.

Pam


The Phillips Machine

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#36

Fascinating! Thanks for the link!

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#37

What I like about this machine

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Well, I like everything about it. Including the back story about Phillips' POW days and how he slipped and made a water heater for tea for his campmates.

But what I really, really like is that the driving force of the whole complex economic system is income. Income.

Thanks a lot, Pam!!

Wiley

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#38

That is really cool.

wilbur

>

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#39

Re: That is really cool.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Glad you guys enjoyed it. The machine really works,too, which leads me to wonder how Phillips learned so much economics inbetween the engineering.

Pam

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#40

Re: Im a slow head...

Todd Hughes

>"....Suppose I sell those planes and use the money that I got for the planes to buy a 1-1/2" paring chisel....

Now I have a tool that I actually will use, as opposed to three tools that just sit and get rusty in my shop. So the utility of my new 1-1/2" paring chisel is greater than the utility of those three planes, and I am in a better economic position than I was before, because my tools have more utility to me....

Note that the initial cost of buying those planes does not figure into this analysis at all. It doesn't matter if those planes cost me $5, $50, or were given to me for free. Whatever the initial cost of those planes, their utility is still zero, since I don't use them at all.

I think that what you keep doing in these types of discussions is confusing money with utility..."

The original post was about SELLING [I gots to think for MONEY!] the planes on the ebay and what they would bring and not at all about utility so I don't think it was me that was confusing money with utility...after all this was not a question at all about what tool would work best etc, but was about Ebay PRICING....uhmmm.....Money

Even if as you say it is somehow about selling the planes to get a more useful tool I sure don't know how you can say it doesn't matter what you paid for the plane you are selling...if as you say you are selling these tools to use the money to get more useful tools it is very important because it is the money from the selling that you are using to buy the more useful tools

Lets say you had $50 originaly to spend on tools and you bought 1 plane for that and you sell it for $25...after all remember you said it makes no difference what you paid right? Now you have $25 to spend on maybe one chisel...you not only didn't make money but you "lost" money...and you say this doesn't matter?

Lets say you were a little smarter when you first spent that $50 and instead of over paying on the one plane you bought 5 planes that you later sold for $20 each......so now you have $100 to buy a set of 4 chisels which you just got to figure are of more utility then just your one $25 chisel

To me this is really pretty simple but then that is what I do... buy and sell stuff...

The only way you come out ahead is by selling the stuff for more then you paid for it, can rationalise it away when you don't but thats are you are doing trying to rationalise why you didn't make a profit which I think should always be a persons goal when they sell something......Todd

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#41

Re: Im a slow head...

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Opportunity costs are all about profit, maybe not right this minute. Suppose Wilbur were a professional woodworker who'd bought several tools that suited his use when he bought them, but now that he's a pro, they don't. So what does he do? Sell those tools for what he can get, thus freeing up storage (very important cost) and providing funds to buy tools that will help him make more money. Doesn't mean he made money on the sale itself, but the sale provides the means for making more money that he could have before.

Pam

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#42

Economics and Business...

Greg B�tit, Crown Point, NY

>...are what they change their majors to when they transfer out of engineering. The president of Norwich University actually made the statement at an Engineering convocation that the only reason the school supported these majors was so that people who couldn't handle the engineering curriculum had someplace to go. :) Really, he said that!

greg -running and ducking

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#43

Re: Economics and Business...

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I agree. It was amazing how dull a very high percentage of the business majors were, couldn't even do basic math. Don't think it happens like that today, what with all the entrance requirements and competition.

Pam

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#44

Re: Im a slow head...

Victor Parisian

>Todd, this is slightly off topic but germane to the discussion.

How many times a year do you turn your inventory? (Gross sales / average inventory level is a good estimate) Just curious, I intuit that the fewer times you turn your inventory the greater your chances of a serious loss when the market turns on you.

Victor in Hot and Humid Houston

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#45

Doesn't make sense

Todd Hughes

>"How many times a year do you turn your inventory? (Gross sales / average inventory level is a good estimate) Just curious, I intuit that the fewer times you turn your inventory the greater your chances of a serious loss when the market turns on you"

No offense but a question like this shows that the asker has no idea about the antique or old tool selling bussiness...We are not talking about selling new cordless drills where you might buy 20 at wholesale prices to sell and that you want to turn over befor you get stuck with them when the new models come out but rather buying items that are not being made any more and that [we hope] will continue to go up in vaule.

I try to sell the stuff I buy as soon as I can not because I worry about the market turning on me but because I have to much junk now and if I don't sell it soon things tend to get buried and lost. I also like to get my money back as soon as possiable but that isn't really that important with most items. Doesn't really cost me anything if I don't sell something right away as long as I do sell it. If you keep it most things become worth more in my experance. I came across the other day some Stanley chisels in a box from about 10 years ago when I used to sell them for $10 each. Today I will probably get 4 times that. Imagine 10 years ago I paid less then $5 for them and didn't cost me anything to set them in the box.

In my experance selling stuff, and I sell alot, it is very unusual for me to not to make a good profit on what I sell and that is because I know what to pay for the stuff...You really do make your money when you buy it

Like I said Im a slow head and I am sure lots of people can point out all kinds of reasons from Economics 101 why you should do that or this....I say thats nice...go out and make a living buying and selling stuff like this and report back on how you do [grin]....Todd

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#46

Re: Doesn't make sense

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I think we all admire your ability to run such a business, certainly not something I'd be good at, which is why we are trying to help you make it an even better business. Like when we advocated Paypal years before you had to give in. So, resistance is futile. :)

Pam