Re: Im a slow head...
wilbur
>Hi Todd,
Sorry I wasn't more clear, although I tried hard to be as clear as I could in my last post.
Let me try again. Suppose in my shop I have three bench planes that I don't use at all. Their utility to me is zero. They could be seen as a drain on my shop, since my shop is small, and I have to use space to store them.
Suppose I sell those planes and use the money that I got for the planes to buy a 1-1/2" paring chisel. Why? I don't currently have a 1-1/2" paring chisel, and there were times that I could have used a 1-1/2" paring chisel, and didn't have one.
Now I have a tool that I actually will use, as opposed to three tools that just sit and get rusty in my shop. So the utility of my new 1-1/2" paring chisel is greater than the utility of those three planes, and I am in a better economic position than I was before, because my tools have more utility to me.
Note that the initial cost of buying those planes does not figure into this analysis at all. It doesn't matter if those planes cost me $5, $50, or were given to me for free. Whatever the initial cost of those planes, their utility is still zero, since I don't use them at all.
I think that what you keep doing in these types of discussions is confusing money with utility. Now, for someone like you, who is buying tools for resale, the initial price of those planes is important, because the utility of those same three bench planes to a seller of used tools completely relies on what profit you can make from those planes. But for other folks, especially those who are going to be using, not reselling, the tools they buy, it may not matter.
This is not a "way for a person to rationalise loosing [sic] money on something they are selling", as you put it, unless what you mean by "rationalise" is to engage in a rational decision making process. Nor is it an issue of whether money is important or not to any given person. The reason for this is that the goal in this scenario is not how much of a profit I will make on those planes. The goal instead is to take some useless items and turn them into something useful, in which case all I need to do is generate enough income from the sale to be able to finance my new purchase, and I will come out ahead. Certainly, one would want to maximize the income from such a sale, but again, what was originally paid for the planes does not factor into this. In this case, to obsess over what I originally paid for the bench planes that I don't use actually would be the irrational thing to do.
In other words, the advice and valuation of a tool from someone who is primarily a buyer and seller of used tools may be completely irrelevant to a woodworker who is purchasing that tool to use in their shop, because their incentives and priorities may be completely different from each other.
By the way, this concept is called an "opportunity cost". This is not some sort of esoteric theoretical economic theory. The idea of an opportunity cost is a basic principle of business and economics. It is so basic that it is taught in high school economics classes.
The idea of an opportunity cost also applies to the concept that a person is making more than they thought because the boss provides parking and air conditioning. There is the potential for the boss to be able to pay his employees more if he had the workplace temperature run in the low 90's during the summer and he passed the savings on his air conditioning bill to his employees in the form of a summertime raise. I doubt that many would take up such an offer, though.