Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

E Bay Pricing Question

Posts

E Bay Pricing Question

#1

E Bay Pricing Question

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont, Canada

>Hi,

I am looking at the current selling prices for Stanley Bedrocks on Ebay, are the prices lower now that a few years ago? My impression is they are...hmmmmm

:-)

Thanks,

Jim

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#2

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

steve mackay

>I knda thought the same thing with Baileys. Seemed like the prices fell some and rebounded a couple months ago but not to the level of a year or two before. I always thought the high prices were due to New York Yuppie collectors though. Maybe hand planes just are'nt "cool" with that crowd any longer.

SteveM : Conspiracy Nutcase.

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#3

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

Todd Hughes

>I sold a 608 about a month ago that had been rejappaned and cleaned up and nothing really special and it went for $238 which I believe is about as high something like that would ever had done.

While prices go up and down on the ebay for different things personaly I feel right now they are pretty high for most tools as well as other items I sell.

Oftern what happens I think is that some things sell for a high price which causes a bunch to come out of the wood work flooding the market which then causes the price to be lowered....Todd

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#4

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont, Canada------WebKitForm

>Thanks Todd,

I had some of the same thoughts. I am looking at selling a few of my bench planes on EBay and was wondering what was the current economic enviornment for hand tools there.

Thanks,

Jim

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#5

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

Todd Hughes

>If you have good stuff and present them well then you will do well. In the past month or so I have sold more then a couple tools for the highest prices I have ever gotten for simular items on the ebay, and I have been on it for over 10 years.

The reason people don't do well on ebay is because they don't present thier stuff well with not enough photos and a weak short description. The better your presentation is the better it will sell....That and many sellers overpay for what they are selling so they think ebay prices are down when they don't get what they want. Remember you make your money when you buy the item.

Talked to a woman the other day who was telling me how bad Ebay was because none of her stuff even got a bid...I looked at the stuff and she was on the moon with what she thought it was worth and thier opening bid and of course had way overpaid when she bought it...any wonder she couldn't sell it?,,,,,Todd

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#6

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont, Canada------WebKitForm

>Great advice Todd,

Your thoughts on the purchase price is a good insight vs the selling price later.

Thank you for your input.

Take care,

Jim

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#7

Another way to look at it

wilbur

>Hi Jim,

If you're looking to sell your bench planes, odds are that you aren't using them, in which case they are space-occupying lesions, as we say in my field. If you sell them, that gets you cash to buy another tool that you need/want, or maybe a nice dinner, or some beer, all of which will be of more utility than those planes are right now.

So how much to try to sell them for? Well, certainly we all want as much as we can get for them. But if you sell these planes for what you paid for them, and here I'm assuming these are old Bailey or Bedrocks that you got used, your net profit is zero, but your overall cost for the plane is also zero.

If you sell them for more than you paid, then you get some profit, and I'm sure you'll be happy with that.

If you take a small loss on them, you can consider that loss to be the cost of renting that plane for the time you used it. And odds are that any loss you take will be quite small, if you bought those planes used in the first place.

But if you hang onto those planes without using them, you pay an opportunity cost of what you could sell them for if you put them on eBay right now, since that is money that you could use for other purposes, but can't, since it's tied up in those bench planes that you don't use.

So suppose that you bought three used Bailey/Bedrock bench planes for $250 total. You put them on eBay, and sell them for 80% of what you paid -- $200. One way to look at this is that you lost $50. Most would say that that's bad.

Another way to look at this is that if you had those three planes sitting around the shop for 3 years, you could say that you rented those planes for $5.55 a year apiece. That seems a bit better.

Yet another way to look at this is that if you took that $200 and bought, say, a 18 mm Tasai push chisel that you used all the time, you could say that you took 3 useless tools and turned them into a tool that you get a lot of use out of. In which case, you could easily argue that you came out ahead, even though the balance sheet shows a $50 loss.

My point is that focusing only on what you paid for a tool when you bought it and how much money you'll make when you sell the tool is only useful if you are in the business of buying and selling vintage tools. If you are a woodworker, other factors may be much more salient in helping you decide what to do with tools, especially those that you aren't using.

In any case, the price you paid for your bench planes when you first got them isn't anything you can do about now, anyway.

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#8

Wiley.. Just way too much good logic for one post

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#9

Re: Another way to look at it

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>So maybe the trick to obtaining happiness is to keep tools as long as it takes to forget what you paid for them? :)

Pam

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#10

Re: Another way to look at it

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont, Canada------WebKitForm

>LOL, I was thinking the same thing Pam...

:-)

take care,

Jim

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#11

Interesting consept Wilbur...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Like your thinking.

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#13

First time for everything . . .

steve mackay

>I agree with Pam ! Mine won't get sold off 'till I'm dead. And SWMBO has NO IDEA what I paid for 'em. If she gets a buck apeice she'll be over joyed !

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#14

Re: First time for everything . . .

ThomD

>I find in Canada I do better on craigslist and Kijiji. But I don't know if it would apply to smaller items like planes. Shipping is so high out of Canada that a 200 dollar purchase of any weight would get severely chopped up, and if a Canadian buys it the shipping can be even worse. I imagine that the average person who showed up to buy a plane face to face off C or K wouldn't be too scary, though i would sell my tatoo paraphenalia online.

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#15

Re: Another way to look at it

Victor P

>In accounting we call that a sunk cost. What you paid for the plane is a red herring. Those dollars are gone. It is what you can get for those planes today or the next day that matters. What are they worth to you if not producing? -0- Turn a non-performing asset into cash or whatever you can trade it for (that presumably has some value).

Cost Accounting 301 or was that Financial Accounting?

Victor - many years out of school

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#16

Re: Another way to look at it

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>An economist, at least of my persuasion, would tell you that the cost of the planes was a sunk cost. And that sunk costs stay sunk.

Like AOL, going on the market now for maybe 5% of it's original selling price. Nothing much that anyone can do about it, either.

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#17

Re: Another way to look at it

ThomD

>Well two things about that:

- That is a perfect example of why they call it The Dismal Science. It is precisely that kind of thinking that people try to overcome with self-deluding strategies like averaging down. It may be true but the more action oriented thing is an equally true idea that makes you feel better about going ahead.

- As far as it being true is concerned, we now have behavioral economics which says that some of the truths of economics are actually derived from an implausible analysis that assumes stuff like rationality. A lot of successful ebay trading strategies are based on assumptions of irrationality on customers, at least arguably they are.

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#18

Re: Another way to look at it

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Do you suppose this is a good time to reveal that I was an Econ major?

Pam

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#19

Im a slow head...

Todd Hughes

>so you sort of lost me with some of that but to me it sounds like a way for a person to rationalise loosing money on something they are selling....Lot of people that loose money on stuff think like this I guess and if it works for them and the moneys not important then god bless them. Is sort of like a boss pointing out to you that you are actually making more money then you thought since the companys not charging you for your cars parking space or to set in the air conditioning

Me...I spent my entire life buying and selling stuff and if I don't make a profit it is only because I failed and messed up. I could rationalise it in many ways but in the end it was because of a mistake on my part.

The only reason a person doesn't make money on what they sell is because they don't know enough about what they are selling...thats it period!...Because of this they pay to much, ignore condition, etc. and when they sell don't know where to sell or how to present it or even when to sell it.....Todd

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#20

Re: Im a slow head...

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Geesh, Todd, not everyone buys just to sell, some of us use those things we buy, at least for a while. Now there are all sorts of values each of us places on a given item, from buyer of the new to buyers of the slightly used, no way of telling whether an item will hold its value for the time we're using it.

Pam

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#21

Re: Another way to look at it

ThomD

>That's a good thing, Pam, though I am a little suprised. Now I was a Philosophy major, and I don't think that will surprise anyone. Still looking for that job where I get paid by the mouthfull.

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#22

Re: Im a slow head...

ThomD

>I think you are right about a lot of that Todd, but the average person is buying because they need something, and it is worth the amount to them they are paying, and they have other values in mind than comodity values. Then somewhere along the line they are changing horses. I never figured to be able to resell anything I had, since up here in Canada the market is much smaller, and not efficient by any measure. Then along came Ebay, and the local classified services, and they changed a lot. Now one can consider getting pretty good money for stuff one never bought to resell, and is just cluttering the place up. So people are torn about selling stuff, not in a good position of knowlege about any of it, and they may come around to selling some stuff they probably don't need any more, but that isn't the stuff they would really like to get rid of, it's just the more valuable end of the stuff they have to sell. So yeah, it is complicated, and not very business like. Obviously you are better off to think as clearly as possible about whatever you sell, when the time actually comes.

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#23

Re: Another way to look at it

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Econ is a lot philosophy if one so chooses. The best angle a philosophy major took that I've seen was this guy who'd got his degree and managed to convince the honchos in state government that he was god's gift to the state, started at a very high rank. Aaaarrrrrrgggggghhhhh.

Pam

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#24

Re: Im a slow head...

Victor Parisian

>OK Todd, point taken. However...

When you buy something to resale, there is always the risk of loss. How you deal with that risk is going to determine who survives as a reseller and who isn't.

Let's say that you have a significant amount of your money tied up in inventory of antique hand tools to resell, and that for whatever reason there has been a shift in the market. Today in America it's a general recession that is approaching depression proportions with widespread plant closings, high unemployment, bank failures, tight credit, uncertainty at every turn etc. You could have dumped all your inventory at a loss early on to convert that inventory to cash. With that pile of cash on hand, you sit back and wait for things to get worse(and they will). Once you see that the bottom is near (Antique Stanley planes selling for scrap iron prices might be an indicator) you pull the trigger and buy back everything that you sold six months or so earlier.

Now the market turns again, the recession is over, the banks start lending again, businesses start rehiring, the angels sing etc. The price of antique hand tools and planes etc starts to rise. You have plenty of inventory and maybe even some cash left over from when you sold out.

Did you loss any money by selling below cost?

Victor - in Hot and Humid Houston

Re: E Bay Pricing Question

#25

Re: Im a slow head...

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>One major problem here, Victor, you need to call the low and high. Very, very difficult to do. Could count on luck maybe.

Pam