Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

LV Knock off? *LINK*

Posts

Re: LV Knock off? *LINK*

#26

Re: No to copies?

Rob Lee

>Todd -

Despite looking out for yourself - you still operate under a set of rules...(I think.... :) )

This is kinda like someone at a flea market makin' an offer to a seller on a tool I'm holding in my hand... it may be in their best interest to make an offer before I do - but some things just aren't done by civilized people...or firms.

:)

Cheers -

Rob

Re: LV Knock off? *LINK*

#27

Re: No to copies?

Brent Smith in Montreal

>"OH OH! you aint talking about boycotting LN planes now are you since they are obvious copys of the original Stanleys right down to the numbering and flat sides of the bedrock planes ?"

I'd say you're stretching things a bit there......considering they can't be bought from the original designer or company anymore.

I guess we all have our own way of looking at things. Personally, I prefer to give my money to the guy that worked for it.

Re: LV Knock off? *LINK*

#28

Re: No to copies?

ThomD

>The one nuance that I have heard about is that some in the east believe that the copyright thing only protects a few western economies that are trying to protect their last 100 years when a lot of the foundation ideas were lifted from the east and elsewhere. The greed that infused the patent system when the focus shifted from driving innovation and the public good to just unlimited rights without recognizing earlier rights probably made some cynical. The Disney thing where their rights keep getting extended, though they lifted many classic stories elsewhere.

OT to the specifics of this case.

Re: LV Knock off? *LINK*

#29

Re: No to copies?

Todd Hughes

>"I'd say you're stretching things a bit there......considering they can't be bought from the original designer or company anymore"

Hmmm...Maybe in that case you might be able to buy these foreign made copies of LV and LN tools in a few years with a clear conscious, ...eh? [grin]

I don't see how a tool not being sold by its original company any longer has anything to do with a new made tool that is using it's exact same design being not a copy.

You set down and make a chair from a set of plans taken from an original 18th century Windsor chair....and you would say you didn't make a copy of an 18th century windsor chair because you can't buy a new one from it's maker ?... Todd

Re: LV Knock off? *LINK*

#30

Reaching out again eh?

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Patents last only 10 years. Anytime AFTER that is fair game. Besides I don't believe Windsor chairs were patented...

Re: LV Knock off? *LINK*

#31

Re: No to copies?

Brent Smith in Montreal

>Sorry Todd, but I'll still have to disagree with you. Making, or selling, a copy of something that's not available from the OM anymore isn't really relevant to the situation this thread is dealing with, or to my stance of not buying from companies that blatantly copy designs currently on the market from the people that actually designed it.

Re: LV Knock off? *LINK*

#32

Re: Reaching out again eh?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Scott,

Speaking of patents....a number of years ago I researched the mechinations involved with getting a patent on a large wheelbarrow hand brake I had designed and built a prototype. The cost for patent searches and other related costs was prohibitive. Not to mention the fact that a large corporation could infringe on my patent and it would cost me even more to fight it. Patent laws are complicated and a dummy like me shouldn't be messing with it without a patent attorney, more costs. I ended up abandoning the entire project. I still have the wheelbarrow with the hand brake. I can easily walk down a steep slope with it fully loaded without it pulling me down the slope slipping and sliding. I got a patent disclosure but I'm not sure how long that is good for.

A patent is of no use when a company with hotshot lawyers and lots of money wants to copy your idea. Reminds me of the intermittent windshield wipers that Ford tried to steal from the inventor. The inventor finally won his case but it took him like ten years to do it.

Marv

Re: LV Knock off? *LINK*

#33

The case we're talking about

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>could hardly be clearer. Japan Woodworker, or its agent or middleman, has bought or otherwise acquired an example of Lee Valley's original design scraper with in-patent feature(s), taken it to an offshore manufacturer and hired the production of X number of copies. Even the cutters are identical in form, if not in quality.

It is the grossest of behavior. JWW is going to rightly lose reputation here, and I hope that Robin takes them to the mat on this one.

Wiley

Re: LV Knock off? *LINK*

#34

Re: The case we're talking about

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Rob would have to chime in on this, but I'm wondering if it is possible to obtain a patent on a scraper? It's not what the thing looks like, it's the tool's function. It has to be patentable.

Marv

Re: LV Knock off? *LINK*

#35

Hear Hear!

Paul Kierstead

>

Re: LV Knock off? *LINK*

#36

Re: No to copies?

Paul Kierstead

>I gotta say Todd, I thought you knew planes, but apparently you wouldn't be able to tell an LN from a Stanley, in a picture at least, unless you could see the badge. I am disappointed.

Re: LV Knock off? *LINK*

#37

Re: No to copies?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>No, it's not like those who refuse to buy from Walmart. I'd get into this, but Wiley would sanction my posts for high political content. I don't consider this a political issue at all, but I'm real tired of playing these games.

Pam

Re: LV Knock off? *LINK*

#38

I

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Interluctable property. Sorry for the spelling. I'm sure Google search will point the way. What it means is that once you've let everybody it's your idea no one can patent it. It's your idea and it's common knowledge. It doesn't mean you can go after anyone that might use your idea, they just can't patent it.

Re: LV Knock off? *LINK*

#39

It's all about design Marv...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Scrapers have been patented. Stanley is a fine example. LV took the "design" to a new level and that's what was patented. It's not about function, but HOW it functions. Hope this shades a bit of light on the subject...

Re: LV Knock off? *LINK*

#40

Good.

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: LV Knock off? *LINK*

#41

The shades of light is blinding....

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>

Re: LV Knock off? *LINK*

#42

Re: The case we're talking about

Rob Lee

>Marv -

I can only speak in generic terms - as I cannot discuss specific infractions publically...

The are basically two type of patents - utility, and design.

A utility patent (the stronger one) registers a non-obvious idea. A good example would be something like post-it notes...the specific shape or size doesn't matter - the entire idea is protected.

A design patent (prefixed with a "D") registers a specific implementation of an idea - sort of like a copyright. Something like an ipod case might be covered by a design patent.

There are other intellectual property concepts (like trade dress) that are not patents, but are also actionable - to protect a firm from some offerering that's deceptive to the consumer, one that would lead the consumer to beleive the product was made by the original manufacturer...

Cheers -

Rob

Re: LV Knock off? *LINK*

#43

Now THAT makes sense

roninkokomo

>

Re: LV Knock off? *LINK*

#44

Re: Reaching out again eh?

ThomD

>I always figure the outlet for people like us Marv, is LV. I have a couple of ideas a year for tools I would wish were available if I wasn't able to make them myself, and I always think I should take them to LV. The moment passes, but they spare the little guy with good ideas from having to worry about all that red tape. My brother in law is a IP attorney in Ottawa, but it would probably still make more sense to go through LV.