LV Knock off? *LINK*
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA
>Just saw this in a JWW email. Looks familiar...
Scraper
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
LV Knock off? *LINK*
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA
>Just saw this in a JWW email. Looks familiar...
Scraper
Re: LV Knock off?
Rob Lee
>Yes -
It's a direct theft of an original design.
Made in China - and JWW knows it's ripped off.
Wonder why the unemployment rate is what it is in North America... a lot of of it is rooted in greed, and self interest... and it will continue as long as the behaviour is rewarded.
Rob Lee
What is your definition of BOYCOT?
Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.
>Rob,
Yes, greed is the driving force. However, it's on both sides. The main reason for our higher manufacturing cost relates directly to greed. Investors want higher and higher return on their investments. What we have is a self-defeating system and ya jist cain't fix stupid.
Marv
Re: What is your definition of BOYCOT?
Norman
>This is scary and troublesome, for it will stifle
ingenuity!
A company (LV) goes to all the trouble and expense of designing a new product and within a year or two we see blatant knock-offs being imported. Is it because China doesn't respect N. American design patents?
Didn't it used to be illegal to sell Rolex knockoffs.. Rowexes?
Norman ( staring at the screen in amazement)
You only copy the best
Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX
>I figure the quality of the knockoff will be about or below what it's priced at. No thanks, that's a false economy.
Re: What is your definition of BOYCOT?
Norman
>"The main reason for our higher manufacturing cost relates directly to greed"
Hmmm..
It costs more to run a manufacturing business in N. America. The overhead, environmental factors, taxes, pay, benefits are what drive the costs up. I would not say it is greed, just higher costs related to higher expenses here. The higher priced products manufactured here are relatively priced to N. American incomes and our standard of life, nothing unusual here. The imported , low priced stuff skew everything because their price points are not normal, but considerably lower. This makes the N. American versions appear to be pricey, let's not even get into quality here. So this skew is what is killing manufacturing in N. America. Company designs product, has in manufactured overseas and saves a ton of money because consumers are increasingly expecting this.
We have to ask ourselves, is this what we want? What legacy are we leaving behind here, when it isn't even worth designing an original product and manufacturing it here. What will the future look like?
The manufacturing landscape will disappear and we're left with what, office and service jobs. A country is defined by it's GDP, service and office work don't contribute very much to this. Manufacturing and exports define the country, and we're slowly destroying this. "We" is the collective of N. Americans.
This also doesn't justify having everything manufactured overseas.
The larger problem in my opinion is that consumers aren't willing to pay more for quality, not all consumers mind you but a large percentage. If the product is ok looking and appears to do the job, this is all they demand. This comes back to the disposable society we live in, where the mindset on purchases is that the product will only really last a few years at the most, so why pay more.
So it does come back to the consumer I'm afraid and the importance of changing the disposable mindset to purchasing quality and longevity instead. My fear is also that the lower priced imports set a price trend that will be insurmountable if it continues, as N. American manufacturing dissapears, the odds of it returning here will be out of the question.... even with robots,CNC etc.
Having said all this, I don't know of a good solution except maybe for heavy import tariffs if the product is a blatant copy of a North American design, this will be punitive but level the playing field in regards to price somewhat.
Norman
Re: LV Knock off?
James Watriss
>So, sorry to throw you under the bus like this Rob, but why are you still allowing them to carry Veritas products?
Respect?
Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.
>China has no respect for anything when it comes to copying anything they know will sell in America.
All they have to do is continue to supply companies in America like Harbor Freight, Enco, Jet, Grizzly, plus a thousand other companies that sell mainly Chinese made products. Who is to blame? Is it China or those of us who flock to these cut rate outlets where we can buy most anything for half the price of American made products?
China could not do what they do, if we didn't buy their stuff. And it's not only China. It's our own greedy corporations who set up shop overseas.
Wall*Mart contributes a great deal to the problem.
Marv
Re: LV Knock off?
Rob Lee
>James -
JWW is not a Veritas customer.
Rob
Re: What is your definition of BOYCOT?
Rob Lee
>Norman -
Chinese suppliers are not always the bad guys. For the most part - they will make whatever they are asked to make. Chinese firms copy each other more than they do North American Suppliers.
Production moves to China because North American firms move it there - not because of the Chinese. The pursuit of lower costs in order to increase margins (or market share) and assure investors/owners of maximised profit does it. And - we all (directly or indirectly) own the stocks, or support/reward the firms that follow that course of action.
It's a basic conflict between societal and economic goals.... and self-interest usually sides with economics.
Cheers -
Rob
Re: What is your definition of BOYCOT?------WebKit
Chris Scholz------WebKitFormBoundaryAAjbAA6eAAPKAA
>Not quite. That is not some sort of conspiracy of China against N. America. China is a hyper competitive place, they to whatever gives you an advantage over the competition (in the shop next door).
BTW, the Chinese patent law is said to be quite strong and very enforable, copyright law is an entirely different topic though.
Chris, coincientially in Gaunzhou, Guandong, China
------WebKitFormBoundaryAAjbAA6eAAPKAA+Z
Re: What is your definition of BOYCOT?
Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont
>Perfectly said...
take care,
Jim
Re: What is your definition of BOYCOT?
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>I think this is a basic conflict, probably age old, between creators and sellers. Sellers want the best product at the cheapest price because they know the majority of potential customers don't know, don't even want to know, anything about the product they're buying.
Creators need to satisfy an internal governor that drives them to make the best, most elegant, product possible. These products attract the very small percentage of customers who do know about the product.
This is not always how markets are defined (upscale/downscale), but it often is. The better strategy for the creators is to innovate ahead of the sellers' ability to copy. With something like a scraper, pretty hard to do. My empathy is with you; but this is a condition of being human.
Pam
FWIW, I haven't bought from JWW for a long, long while, probably 6 or 7 years (they sold me two cleanup chisels, each of which broke with hardly any encouragement, only took back the first one).
Pam
The issue is simple...
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>When a country doesn't provide for its population, whether it be environmental protection, product inspection (anyone for lead-laced window blinds, melamine milk formula, toys with lead paint, etc.?), health, workplace safety, decent salaries, etc., and on top of that manipulates its exchange rate to keep the labor costs down, then it's no surprise that they eat the lunch of more mature industrialized countries that provide a minimum standard of living and care for all its citizens...
Yet we allow these countries to come in and sell anything they want. Worse yet, too many corporations from here don't even bother to try producing here anymore, they offshore all production to those countries (all in the name of short-term profits).
We hear the economists' credo that free trade is good for all, to justify the current situation. Well, I'm an economist by trade, and you won't hear that one from me. The rationale behind the free trade concept is so flimsy and unrealistic that it is ridiculous.
In the past there was the argument that industrialized countries has much higher knowledge and human capital, and therefore developing countries could not replicate the products made here. Not anymore. China can produce anything we can make here, and the technological superiority that we enjoyed now just gets transfered there along with the production.
Until the day we can get China to free up its exchange rate and/or we charge tariffs commensurate with the unfair advantage we allow them to have, manufacturing in industrialized countries will be like trying to fill a bath with the plug removed. You can't win. And the longer we fail to remedy the situation the worse the situation will be for our children...
DC
Re: The issue is simple...
Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.
>denis,
You said,
Until the day we can get China to free up its exchange rate and/or we charge tariffs commensurate with the unfair advantage we allow them to have, manufacturing in industrialized countries will be like trying to fill a bath with the plug removed. You can't win. And the longer we fail to remedy the situation the worse the situation will be for our children...
------------------------------------------
Everything you said is spot on, including the above conclusion to your post....However, what you said in your conclusion will not happen. Those in this country with the responsibility to do what needs to be done have their eye on the wrong balls, of which they have none.
The situation will not only be worse for our children, it will be worse for us as well. Those who are in a position to make change are mainly a bunch of greedy crooks and or people who are just not doing their job.
I have been predicting for years that our overall economic system is like stacking blocks of wood, (have to keep this relating to wood)we keeping stacking one block on top of the next, eventually it will topple. I'm afraid the stack has toppled. What we are dealing with now is a bunch of blocks scattered around in disaray. We were stupid enough to stack the blocks until they toppled over and we are too stupid to fix the problem that has only become more complex than it was before.
Marv
Re: The issue is simple...
ThomD
>I think one has to be careful what one wishes for. China is quite likely to change it's currency practices in the medium term, and that may not be a comfortable experience in the dollar zone.
Speaking of currency, that is potentially a problem here on the Canadian side. There was a huge expansion followed by a contraction of the value of the Canadian dollar along with the oil bubble just recently. That would make it difficult to deal with a Canadian supplier and many US companies may have been forced to look for alternatives. Managing this problem is a challenge to say the least, and I consider LV one of the good guys. Oneway managed the problem by subsidizing the US market while running much higher prices in Canada, and guarding the retail price lists like a hawk. Very tough environment for exporters.
That is one of the problems with high value economies, they can't eat the currency changes. I used to get the JWW catalog every year, back in the early 80s and forward, and when the Yen ballooned about 3 fold against the US dollar the prices in the JWW catalog were hardly affected. I always wondered whether they had a mountain of chisels to draw from, or just how much of a mark-up there was to deal with. Kinda inexplicable, because when the internet came along I was able to find Japanese prices occasionally and they weren't dirt cheap lower.
Re: What is your definition of BOYCOT?
Tom MacGregor
>After having a job outsourced to China and some health problems I chose to boycott my former lifestyle. I buy less stuff of better quality from the most local vendors possible - whether from next door or across the country. This applies to everything from tools to groceries. I avoid buying on credit. I fix stuff when it breaks and do without some of the extras. I'm thinner, healthier and getting out of debt. After 35 years of trying to change the world I finally realized that the best way to do it was to change myself.
Isin't it patented?
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA
>When I worked at Plantronics Inc. designing headsets we went after ANYBODY who tried to infringe on our patents. Especially the design patents. Got lawyers?
Re: Isin't it patented?
Rob Lee
>Yup - got lawyers...
You want to suck all the fun out of an occupation - spend your time dealing with lawsuits. Been there (still there!) done that.
We spend more than half a million of your dollars on legal fees every year... and I say your dollars, 'cause it get passed straight through in product pricing.
In many cases though - the cost of litigation are far greater that the product sales not that that changes how we'll react.
Cheers -
Rob
Interesting times ahead
Ellis Walentine
>Another variable in this equation is the cost of energy. It takes a lot of fuel to move all this stuff across the Pacific. As the price of oil goes up, the cost of transporting Chinese goods to North America will make them less competitive and encourage American manufacturers and entrepreneurs. It might take a while for this to happen, but I think it's heading in that direction.
Ellis
Re: Isin't it patented?
Brent Smith in Montreal
>Looks like the job is up to us.
We have to make a point of buying from the company that actually innovates as opposed to copies. As Rob said, the dollar cost in fighting these lowlifes is covered by us, the woodworkers. If we buy from the rip off artists, why would the innovators want to keep spending money on development and testing new ideas.
Just look at how the quality of most things we buy has been dumbed down over the last decade or so. This is directly due to the fact that we, the consumers, are willing to buy substandard merchandise if it means saving a few dollars on initial purchase. What do you think will happen to the remaining quality if the few companies that are willing to spend time and money on developing and manufacturing high quality product give up on it because we would rather buy the cheaper copy? Can you see having to replace your hammer every year or two because they're such low quality that the nails destroy the head after a bit of use?
No to copies?
Todd Hughes
>"We have to make a point of buying from the company that actually innovates as opposed to copies..."
OH OH! you aint talking about boycotting LN planes now are you since they are obvious copys of the original Stanleys right down to the numbering and flat sides of the bedrock planes ?
Personaly I could care less about any of this stuff..what is important to me is getting the best quality for the dollar. If they can make the item for less in China and it will do the job the same then that is what I am buying. If it is a copy of somebodys else item that is something for them and the law to worry about...not me
Its like those people that won't shop in Walmart but will buy the exact same thing someplace else for more and think they are doing something....Its not my job to worry about such things, Im looking out for myself!....Todd
Re: Interesting times ahead
Todd Hughes
>I bet it cost less to bring a tractor trailer full of tools from china on a ship then is does to bring it down from Canada driving it. Transport by ship is very cheap and higher fuel prices will affect ground transport much more I think...
...In any case how much of the price in a tool like this do you think is transport cost?...Sure cant be much when I see simular size and weight stuff from China being sold in the dollar store for a buck....Todd
Re: Silver linings
ThomD
>When LV first started to bring out their own tools, 30 years agoish, as a local I was pretty exited and swore to myself I would buy every one of them. Wasn't long before I realized I would have to be more choosey, as the floodgates of new tools opened. This scraper was one tool I easily felt I could do without, but all this talk about people copying it does make a fellah take a second look to see what all the fuss is about.
Re: I have a Bolex for you!
ThomD
>"If they can make the item for less in China and it will do the job the same then that is what I am buying. If it is a copy of somebodys else item that is something for them and the law to worry about...not me"
- It's rare they make it with the same quality, they are perfectly capable, they buy more CNC machines than the rest of the world put together, but that isn't the business plan yet. In the metalworking field the tools aren't only not quite as good they tend to be scandalously unsafe.
- Since the product job for most people is more complex than some utilitarian execution of a task, the copies don't function as well. A closer example would be whether the local "professional" did the job as effectively as a spouse, there are a range of complex relationships tied up in consumer behaviour that aren't fully delivered upon by a Bolex watch, no mater how good.
- I broadly agree with you that our role is to play the part of consumer, not fathom the legal ramifications of all this stuff. I would exclude from that situations where I know something represents a theft, even if it hasn't been fully litigated. But that would have to be a clear situation not just someone idea of "hey look what they are doing"
- I think the Wal-Mart example falls flat, some people don't like their business model, but outsourcing is a perfectly legal thing. Patent/trademark wise where I feel taken advantage of is when someone sells their brand to the highest bidder in China and it ends up on a Wal-Mart shelf with nothing other than the famous brand's label on it.