Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

A Plane Sole Question

Posts

A Plane Sole Question

#1

A Plane Sole Question

dave brown

>Since my last Krenove/Finck style plane was such a success, I'm working on a few more.

My question is about how much of the plane sole to leave in front of the mouth vs. behind the mouth. Finck in his book suggests that it's not critical but if you like being exact to put 5/9 of the length of the sole behind the mouth, which would leave 4/9's in front. He says it's because it's harder to control the end of the cut since the plane is moving so you want more behind the mouth. Makes sense.

But...

I'm making a little block plane in the Krenov style. And my LV block plane has really very little length of the sole in front of the mouth. It's more like 1.5" out of 6.5". What's the reason for so little of the sole being in front of the mouth on a metal block plane? Should I do something similar in a wooden block plane or stick with something like Finck recommends?

Thanks in advance for any suggestions.

--Dave

P.S. Not to hijack my own thread before it starts, but I'm also interested in who uses cambered plane blades on planes that are not smooth planes. Anyone use it on a block plane?

Re: A Plane Sole Question

#2

Re: A Plane Sole Question

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I make Japanese dai 2/9 in back of the mouth (actually, back and front are reversed in Japanese planery, but I'll stick with western convention for this message), 7/9 in front. Of course, these planes are intended to be pulled, but I have no problems pushing them as well.

On cambering blades, generally the scrubs are the most cambered, drastically; and the camber works its way flat as you move toward smoothers.

Pam

Re: A Plane Sole Question

#3

Short soles in front of the blade

Steve Elliott

>I can think of two reasons for having the blade forward in the plane body, leaving only a short length of sole at the front. The first is to allow the plane to ride down into subtle depressions in the surface being planed. British smoothing planes typically have a shorter front sole than Bailey-style planes, and I find them better for removing minor areas of tearout. (Think of card scrapers and how useful they are for small problem areas.)

The second reason is to make the plane compact. Block planes are usually used one-handed and a longer front sole would make them unwieldy.

Too short a front sole can make it difficult to start a cut at the edge of the board without rounding off.

Re: A Plane Sole Question

#4

Name dropping and plane thinking

Adam Cherubini

>I had a beer with Jim Tolpin and we talked at length about this issue (how cool is that?). Apparently, he had recently discussed the issue with "The Schwarz".(That's 2 in one paragraph!)

Here's what Jim thought; He said he thought the Japanese had this figured right. The surface in front of the plane blade is not the same height as the surface behind it. Kinda like a power jointer. I recalled DC (Name drop #3)and others discsussing this here. On a Japanese plane, the sole behind the blade is often cut away. It's essentially irrelevant. The toe is pushed down during use and the heel sways in the breeze.

From my perspective, this is conversation that only a power tool user could love. Western planes work fine. I'm able to flatten boards with them. And I don't think too much about how they work. The whole notion of offset plane soles leads only to one ineviatble thought; LV micro adjusters that move toe and heels with respect to one another. (and then there's the metric hex head set screws that lock them in place) And I view that as at least one of the 4 horsemen of the apocalypse. Could be 2. The laser on the hand saw is another.

So as I sipped my beer (no Chris I don't remember what it was, that's how tired I was), I thought that maybe we only touch a few points on our planes. We may rock them back in use such that they only contact at the back of the heel, and some small area on the toe. And this could explain the wear we see on planes.

Theorhetically the friction (and wear) on a plane sole should be uniform. But we sure don't see that in reality. Toes could be worn on the drag back. Or from high spots about to become flat spots. But the wear on the back of the heel suggests planes may not be,.... er....planar in use.

So it may be that a long toe wouldn't do what you would think it would do (i.e. effect the effective length of the sole- as the blade move forward of the mid point, the effective sole length reduces, of so the theory goes. Pretty sure Rob Lee (that's 4) is a proponent of this theory. His long planes have their frogs moved aft for exactly this reason).

Adam

Re: A Plane Sole Question

#5

Re: The real answer

ThomD

>Is simple. When you cut a plane back to the absolute minimum you are left with a short infeed and a long outfeed on the western model. the basic stuff is the grip, the blade retention stuff, the bed. that is all to the rear of the mouth. The infeed and mouth are to the front but can be significantly reduced in size compared to the other stuff.

Fink is right that it doesn't mater. The first two planes I made 30 years ago were Krenov, and after that japanese. They all worked, so I often made planes with the mouth in the dead middle of the block since it worked as well as anything else. But if I wanted to cut a 16" plane back to 6" the proportion would have to change.

The mechanics of Japanese planes are different. you can't built a conventional looking Japanese plane in chisel format with no infeed since it takes meat fore and aft the mouth to retain the blade.

Re: A Plane Sole Question

#6

Re: Name dropping and plane thinking

ThomD

>"Here's what Jim thought; He said he thought the Japanese had this figured right. The surface in front of the plane blade is not the same height as the surface behind it. Kinda like a power jointer."

Kinda like the exact opposite of a power jointer. On the power jointer the outfeed is higher not lower. Did Topin actually say that? If so, incredible! The outfeed on the Japanese plane is lower (relative to cut height), not higher, as a result of a disadvantage of the system. The jaming of the blade into the plane dai causes variable curvature in the sole which is relieved by eliminating the outfeed. It isn't a serious disadvantage, but it becomes interesting when an outfeed is actually needed as on a jointer. There are reasons why it doesn't mater too much on a jointer.

Re: A Plane Sole Question

#7

Re: A Plane Sole Question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Dave said:

"I'm making a little block plane in the Krenov style. And my LV block plane has really very little length of the sole in front of the mouth. It's more like 1.5" out of 6.5". What's the reason for so little of the sole being in front of the mouth on a metal block plane? Should I do something similar in a wooden block plane or stick with something like Finck recommends?"

______

A metal block plane is bevel-up, usually bedded at 12 degrees; a few are at 20 degrees. As soon as you make the bevel-up/low bedding angle decision on a 6" long plane, you have decided to put the mouth forward. Because where else can the blade go? The only apparent way around the physical limitations would be to radically change the cutter design. Bottom line: the mouth is not placed forward because there is an advantage to it; it's forward because that's the solution to the design problem, given the initlal assumptions (BU; low angle; short plane).

But your Krenov plane will be bevel down, and not low angle. Therefore, you have more flexibility as to where to place the mouth, even on a short plane. I think Finck has it about right. If you ask me, having some length of registration forward of the mouth is good, especially for tasks like trimming end grain or pin ends, or simply making a chamfer, where you're coming in from off the board. Helps keep the lines straight. That's why I prefer Japanese planes for trimming drawer sides--long registration ahead of the blade.

Wiley

Re: A Plane Sole Question

#8

Re: Name dropping and plane thinking

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>Thom,

I may have gotten it wrong. I don't know jack about power jointers. And Jim Tolpin knows more about power jointers than any one man should.

Adam

Re: A Plane Sole Question

#9

Re: Name dropping and plane thinking

ThomD

>Seems to be working out pretty well for both of you.

Re: A Plane Sole Question

#10

He knows all three things?!

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: A Plane Sole Question

#11

Re: A Plane Sole Question

David Brown

>Thanks, Wiley. What you say makes sense about the bevel up design. I hadn't thought about that. My block plane is bevel down and a 45 degree cutting angle, so it is different than my LV block plane.

--Dave

Re: A Plane Sole Question

#12

Re: Name dropping and plane thinking

David Brown

>Adam,

I think you're right that one can get a bit over interested in theory. I was highly intimidated by the thought of building a plane for years. So much so that even though I bought the blade for it, I didn't do it until recently. Now, I'm planning on making a bunch because they're not that hard to make well and they work so well. But at the same time, I don't want to make a critical mistake. It doesn't sound like this is very critical.

On a different note, do you know what the historical practice regarding blade cambering was? DC and Schwarz have both indicated they sometimes camber the blades of even block planes. DC also suggests (I seem to remember) in one of his videos that he likes the camber in his #5 to help in squaring edges to faces because you can put the right part of the curve to get either a thicker or thinner shaving where you need a thicker or thinner shaving. I hope I'm not mis-representing him in this. But Finck shows planning technique in his book that is entirely based on straight plane blades and involves multiple passes, starting with say, the high part of the edge, then moving the plane over and cutting what was just cut and the part that wasn't, so you get it down to square because you took two (or more if needed) passes on the high spot, but only one on the low spot. I am curious what the historical practice is regarding cambered blades.

Thanks. I feel like I'm having a virtual beer with you. Have one on me.

--Dave

Re: A Plane Sole Question

#13

Re: A Plane Sole Question

Craig D

>Wiley wrote:

A metal block plane is bevel-up, usually bedded at 12 degrees; a few are at 20 degrees. As soon as you make the bevel-up/low bedding angle decision on a 6" long plane, you have decided to put the mouth forward.

-------------------

I must be missing something, here is a BU, 17%, 4" metal plane that that has the mouth close to centered.

Craig


img

Re: A Plane Sole Question

#14

Re: A Plane Sole Question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Craig,

Great counterexample! And a beautiful plane too. Did you make that one?

Wiley

Re: A Plane Sole Question

#15

Although

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>I suppose one could argue that the counterexample itself is a 6" long plane with the mouth approx. 1-1/2" from the front edge.

Wiley

Re: A Plane Sole Question

#16

Historical evidence of cambered irons

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>David,

Period furniture shows evidence of cambered plane irons almost universally. Of course moving fillesters, rabbets, maybe jointers would have had square blades, and tho it can be difficult to measure with certainty, I've seen features that look square and flat in rabbets and such.

You can poke around on the internet, search Chipstone's collections through the University of Wisconsin, Madison, and see undersides of pieces that pretty clearly show evidence of cambered planes of some sort.

Adam

Re: A Plane Sole Question

#17

Re: A Plane Sole Question

Craig D

>Wiley wrote:

>Craig, Great counterexample! And a beautiful plane too. Did you make that one?

>I suppose one could argue that the counterexample itself is a 6" long plane with the mouth approx. 1-1/2" from the front edge.

--

Thanks! Yes, I'm finishing it up now.

Actually, the plane is 4 3/8" long and the mouth is at 1 3/4", 40% from the front.

Craig

Re: A Plane Sole Question

#18

True, with one caveat

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>The Stanley/Record/Sargent/Union/etc. block planes all include an engineering decision to keep the adjuster mechanism mostly inboard to the body of the plane, something not possible on your VERY attractive design.

Re: A Plane Sole Question

#19

Re: Historical evidence of cambered irons

ThomD

>I don't know what your experience would indicate, but obviously the furniture clearly shows it but the planes don't. This is where one of those time capsule shops like maybe the Domini shop would be interesting. Or maybe just living in a part of the world with deeper roots. I have probably never seen an old plane with a cambered iron. Presumably because they all went through a hundred years or more of unskilled use before they got their next owner who knew what he was doing.

Re: A Plane Sole Question

#20

Show surfaces

David Cockey

>Do many 18th century pieces have scallops in the show surfaces in addition to undersides, etc? If not I assume it's difficult to determine how much camber if any was used in 18th century smoothing plane blades.

Re: A Plane Sole Question

#21

Re: Show surfaces

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>On 18th century show surfaces, sometimes you can see the evidence of curvature, but often you cannot. I cannot see the evidence of camber on surfaces that I have planed, even though they are finished with no scraping or abrasives whatsoever. The evidence of a camber on the iron is the fact that it does not cut all the way to the edges of the plane.

Re: A Plane Sole Question

#22

Re: Show surfaces

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>David,

The problem with 18th c show surfaces is that you can't be certain you are looking at the original surface. I was reading Sack a few weekends ago. His father wrote a preface and talked about refinishing old furniture by planing it.

One thing I never see are "gutters" or "plane tracks". This alone is not an indication that curved plane irons were used. But it's a valuable data point.

Adam

Re: A Plane Sole Question

#23

Re: Show surfaces

ThomD

>I did that to a teak table my parents have that had like .5mm teak veneer on it. You can learn a lot about faux finishing paricle board on a project like that.

Re: A Plane Sole Question

#24

Japanese planes

paul womack

>On a Japanese plane, the sole behind the blade is often cut away. It's essentially irrelevant. The toe is pushed down during use and the heel sways in the breeze.

That only true on smoothers, which are designed to take a thin shaving from a pre-flattened surface.

A japanese plane designed to flatten a surface has a heel, otherwise it would simply follow the existing contour, like the Japanese smoother.

While I'm posting, did you get any more information on the use-dates in the USA of pit frame saws?

BugBear

Re: A Plane Sole Question

#25

Re: Show surfaces------WebKitFormBoundaryv9GLaJFsA

Adam Cherubini, NJ------WebKitFormBoundaryv9GLaJFs

>David,

The problem with 18th c show surfaces is that you can't be certain you are looking at the original surface. I was reading Sack a few weekends ago. His father wrote a preface and talked about refinishing old furniture by planing it.

One thing I never see are "gutters" or "plane tracks". This alone is not an indication that curved plane irons were used. But it's a valuable data point.

Adam

------WebKitFormBoundaryv9GLaJFsAMP+ynuK