Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Characteristics of Sitka spruce?

Posts

Characteristics of Sitka spruce?

#1

Characteristics of Sitka spruce?

Dave Mount

>A friend asked if I'd help him make a traditional Greenland kayak paddle. He'd bought a board from a local dealer that was ostensibly Sitka spruce, but this particular dealer is not one I have a lot of respect for, enough so that I wouldn't assume they know what they're talking about, nor that they would be troubled by selling a board as something it's not.

I'd never had or worked with Sitka spruce so I didn't really know what to expect. When he brought the board into the shop, it looked a lot like soft maple to me, similar grain and texture. I was suspicious, but didn't want to be too negative so I didn't say anything to him about my reservations.

Because it was 4/4 flatsawn stock, I needed to rip the board into pieces and laminate the blank to build up the needed shaft (excuse me, "loom") thickness and to get the grain in the correct orientation. Doing so exposed edge grain, and I was surprised to see pronounced rays, something like a cross between beech and maple -- rays about the size of beech, but with a distribution more like maple. Anyway, I really wasn't expecting this ray fleck and that got me to haul out Hoadley's "Identifying Wood". Hoadley said that the Sitka heartwood had a pinkish brown tinge (which this did), but didn't have anything definitive on how pronounced the ray fleck would be. The density was listed as 0.40, compared to maple at 0.46 to 0.60 depending on species. I carefully measured and weighed a small offcut and got a calculated density of 0.406, which was a good match to the Sitka spec and notably lower than maple. At this point I decided to just go with it, rather than take the time to prepare a good endgrain sample, which is what I needed to do anything more definitive.

Anyway, the question is, for those that know Sitka spruce, does it have the kind of pronounced ray fleck that I'm describing?

Thanks.

Dave

Re: Characteristics of Sitka spruce?

#3

It looks like spruce?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have a neighbor that builds mandolins and he buys what he says is Sitka spruce and it sure looks the same as the spruce that grows in northern NY. If you can find some local spruce of acceptable clarity it should do fine. The stuff that grows in NY makes fine paddles. I think the main thing with Sitka is that it grows to gigantic size and hence getting a clear piece is easy.

Re: Characteristics of Sitka spruce?

#4

Sounds like Sycamore

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Characteristics of Sitka spruce?

#5

Re: Yes it does. . .

Dave Mount

>. . .except the rays are not as noticeable on the flatsawn face, and there is less overall color variation.

Thanks!!

Re: Characteristics of Sitka spruce?

#6

Re: Characteristics of Sitka spruce?

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>Spruce does have noticeable ray flecking that is best seen on the quarter sawn view. it is not as wild as sycamore or even beech but it is present. perhaps the best way to id spruce from maple or some other light colored wood would be by the smell. It is hard to describe and you either like it or hate it but I find it pleasant. hawever when ripping a lot of strips or planing a bunch of boards the scent becomes over powering in my small shop.

Sitka and engleman spruce are very similar and to an untrained eye even norway and colorado spruce will look the same. the biggest difference is size and age with sitka and engleman being larger and with growth rings that can look like the pages of a book.

Robin

Re: Characteristics of Sitka spruce?

#7

Re: Not like our white spruce. . .

Dave Mount

>Hi Bill--

White spruce is the only spruce we commonly get in lumber form up here in northern MN and this "Sitka spruce" does not look or work like it. The rays in white spruce are barely noticeable and aren't appreciably different in color from the rest. As Stephen said, this stuff looks like sycamore on the flatsawn face. Our white spruce is generally cork light, this "Sitka spruce" seems much denser, even though it wasn't growing slowly.

We have black spruce up here too, in the bogs, but it is usually found on poor sites (bogs) and most of it is too small for saw bolts -- it usually goes for pulp I believe. It seems much denser, perhaps because it grows slowly.

Best,

Dave

Re: Characteristics of Sitka spruce?

#8

Re: I meant QS face

Dave Mount

>I said it looks like sycamore on the flatsawn face, but I meant on a QS face.

I may have to take an endgrain slice and look at it under magnification.

Dave

Re: Characteristics of Sitka spruce?

#9

Re: Characteristics of Sitka spruce?

ThomD

>As a boatbuilding wood the spruces can be interchanged. So can similar woods that have similar weight and ME. Spruce is great stuff because it is resistant to spliting compared to woods like fur. Developing a sellection of samples from ME tests is a good way to substitute woods for equivalent uses.

Re: Characteristics of Sitka spruce?

#10

Re: Stephen's right -- it's sycamore

Dave Mount

>Tonight I did some more investigation and I'm absolutely certain the wood is not Sitka spruce, and I'm 99% sure it is sycamore. I addition to just the appearance as shown in this and the following pictures, I did a clean end grain cut and looked at the end grain with a eye loupe. It is very much like what Hoadley shows as sycamore, and nothing like Sitka. On the QS face, the ray fleck looks like sycamore, and a picture I found on the web of quartered Sitka shows both an absence of pronounced rays and a contrasting latewood color, which the mystery wood does not have.

Turns out he paid $9 a foot for his "Sitka spruce", whereas plainsawn sycamore runs $2-3 top end retail. He'll be paying a return visit to that wood dealer. . .

Best

Dave

This is a shot of a QS strip in the paddle; the light wood is the mystery wood, QS in the top strip (the darker wood is Western red cedar), more rifty in the others.


img

Re: Characteristics of Sitka spruce?

#11

Re: Known QS Sycamore sample

Dave Mount

>Here's a piece I know to be sycamore (because I sawed the log myself).


img

Re: Characteristics of Sitka spruce?

#12

Re: QS Sitka example

Dave Mount

>For reference, here's pic of QS Sitka from the web. Photo credit is:

http://www.wood-database.com/wp-content/uploads/sitka-spruce.jpg


img

Re: Characteristics of Sitka spruce?

#13

Re: QS Sitka example

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>Dave, once again I want to point out my post to you above. The bearclaw is Sitka spruce. I have seen many soundboards with a lot of ray in it, though I can't say I've seen fleck. The QS sample you're showing from the web is without the ray. That doesn't mean you can't get it with rays.

Re: Characteristics of Sitka spruce?

#14

Re: QS Sitka example

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Sitka spruce that is dead on quarter sawn will have a pretty good ray display. The rays are about as wide as maple, but very thin, so that they are more sensitive to how carefully the board is cut. My harpsichord soundboard is glued up of several quartered pieces; I would guess only 30 percent of the area has noticeable fleck, which can appear and disappear along the length of the same board.

It is hard to identify woods with just pictures, but I think the lack of darker latewood bands makes me think it is not spruce. Sitka spruce should look a little like a very refined yellow pine. The top plate of a violin is also made of spruce.

Re: Characteristics of Sitka spruce?

#15

Re: Not the same kind of figure *LINK*

Dave Mount

>Hi Patrick--

I wasn't ignoring your post, but bear claw figure is not the kind of figure this wood is showing, it's definitely ray fleck. I put a link below to a guitar site with an image of bearclaw Sitka spruce; you can compare that to the figure in the wood from the paddle shown in a previous post.

Best,

Dave


Link to bear claw Sitka Spruce image

Re: Characteristics of Sitka spruce?

#16

I don't have a clue...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Thanks for sleuthing! I know know more than I ever have about Spruce and Sycamore.

Makes me wanna play with some...

Re: Characteristics of Sitka spruce?

#17

Re: I don't have a clue...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I don't know. If I was building musical instruments, the working characteristics of the spruce are far nicer than the (limited) sycamore I've worked.

The spruce is 'softer' feeling, less brittle, more responsive to hand tools. That is all by 'feel', with no scientific backing whatsoever.

There's a nice small chunk of QS sycamore in my wood rack, given me by a friend, that needs to be made into pretty boxes one day...

Re: Characteristics of Sitka spruce?

#18

Thanks Glenn.

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I have a clue!