WWKD
David Brown
>Occasionally, I forget myself and start thinking out loud. Today I was in the middle of talking with my wife about the wooden plane I'm making and what issues I might find myself in if I made some others and then later bought new irons (I only have 1 Hock Iron). Would I have to make a new wedge? Would small changes in the thickness of the blade make the mouth opening too wide or too narrow? Would it be better to wait until I could afford to buy irons and then make more planes?
She looks up and says, "WWKD".
"Indeed," I say.
"That's just so you know I listen to some of what you talk about." She smiled.
"Indeed."
The K is for Krenov. I'd explained that when his eyesight failed, he started making planes. I'm guessing he would buy the irons first, but it's just a guess.
I'm working on a plane in the Krenov style using David Finck's excellent book. Finck is very little mentioned on this board (according to the search) and after getting my plane done to the point it makes shavings, I can't exactly understand why there isn't more discussion on the wooden planes that are relatively easily made and so far in my experience cut better and adjust easier than any metal plane I own (3 Lee Valleys, 1 Stanley). When I say better I mean a thinner shaving than I've ever gotten before. It makes me wish I had a digital caliper to get a .000" reading. I mean these are so thin, it's unbelievable. According to my dial caliper they measure less than .0005. It also cuts well when the shaving is thick, say up to .006". And no chatter so far, no matter what I do. End grain, face grain, hard maple, oak, it does it all. And the adjustments are so easy. I probably don't get as good shavings with my metal body planes simply because I don't have the patience to get them adjusted perfectly. But this one adjusts with just a few taps and each tap moves the blade just enough so the shavings get thicker/thinner (depending on whether I'm tapping the blade or the back of the plane body) a dependable .0005 inches or less if I tap really lightly. I'm using an 8 oz. hammer for adjustment (not an official plane adjustment hammer, but rather a steel chisel hammer). So easy.
Right now my plane is in that stage where I need to cut it to final shape. So it's really just a big square block, but it cuts so well all I can do in my shop is take shavings with it. It's just amazing. But when the novelty wears off it will become a smoother, around 9" long. The blade is a little narrow at 1 3/4" wide, but I've had the blade for years meaning to make the plane.
So I want to make a few more (jointer and a block plane), and just have a few questions. Irons for Krenov style planes (at least from Ron Hock and David Finck) are max 2" wide, but metal jointers are wider, up to 2 5/8" wide (blades). Metal ones are also obviously heavier. Do wood jointers work as well as metal ones (I know this question opens me up because they used to only have wood jointers and seem to have done okay). Also, has any one made Krenov style planes with lower or steeper angles for the blade? Do the blades still wedge tightly?
Sorry for the long post, but I'm excited. Thanks for any information.
--Dave
P.S. Just for curiosity, I decided to try it without a chip breaker so I made a thicker wedge and it cuts just as well without the chip breaker. It sort of surprised me, but I know chip breakers are a fairly modern contrivance.



