Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

WWKD

Posts

WWKD

#1

WWKD

David Brown

>Occasionally, I forget myself and start thinking out loud. Today I was in the middle of talking with my wife about the wooden plane I'm making and what issues I might find myself in if I made some others and then later bought new irons (I only have 1 Hock Iron). Would I have to make a new wedge? Would small changes in the thickness of the blade make the mouth opening too wide or too narrow? Would it be better to wait until I could afford to buy irons and then make more planes?

She looks up and says, "WWKD".

"Indeed," I say.

"That's just so you know I listen to some of what you talk about." She smiled.

"Indeed."

The K is for Krenov. I'd explained that when his eyesight failed, he started making planes. I'm guessing he would buy the irons first, but it's just a guess.

I'm working on a plane in the Krenov style using David Finck's excellent book. Finck is very little mentioned on this board (according to the search) and after getting my plane done to the point it makes shavings, I can't exactly understand why there isn't more discussion on the wooden planes that are relatively easily made and so far in my experience cut better and adjust easier than any metal plane I own (3 Lee Valleys, 1 Stanley). When I say better I mean a thinner shaving than I've ever gotten before. It makes me wish I had a digital caliper to get a .000" reading. I mean these are so thin, it's unbelievable. According to my dial caliper they measure less than .0005. It also cuts well when the shaving is thick, say up to .006". And no chatter so far, no matter what I do. End grain, face grain, hard maple, oak, it does it all. And the adjustments are so easy. I probably don't get as good shavings with my metal body planes simply because I don't have the patience to get them adjusted perfectly. But this one adjusts with just a few taps and each tap moves the blade just enough so the shavings get thicker/thinner (depending on whether I'm tapping the blade or the back of the plane body) a dependable .0005 inches or less if I tap really lightly. I'm using an 8 oz. hammer for adjustment (not an official plane adjustment hammer, but rather a steel chisel hammer). So easy.

Right now my plane is in that stage where I need to cut it to final shape. So it's really just a big square block, but it cuts so well all I can do in my shop is take shavings with it. It's just amazing. But when the novelty wears off it will become a smoother, around 9" long. The blade is a little narrow at 1 3/4" wide, but I've had the blade for years meaning to make the plane.

So I want to make a few more (jointer and a block plane), and just have a few questions. Irons for Krenov style planes (at least from Ron Hock and David Finck) are max 2" wide, but metal jointers are wider, up to 2 5/8" wide (blades). Metal ones are also obviously heavier. Do wood jointers work as well as metal ones (I know this question opens me up because they used to only have wood jointers and seem to have done okay). Also, has any one made Krenov style planes with lower or steeper angles for the blade? Do the blades still wedge tightly?

Sorry for the long post, but I'm excited. Thanks for any information.

--Dave

P.S. Just for curiosity, I decided to try it without a chip breaker so I made a thicker wedge and it cuts just as well without the chip breaker. It sort of surprised me, but I know chip breakers are a fairly modern contrivance.

Re: WWKD

#2

Re: WWKD

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yes, I've used wooden jointers, the most traditional are C&W and an ECE 701. I've also used Japanese short jointers. All work extremely well. Can't help you much with blades, since I make Japanese planes and the blades are relatively huge.

However, I often make two or three dai per blade (set if I use a subblade), each with different bedding angles for different woods. They also work fine. Everyone says don't do this, but danged if I know why, unless the dai would deform once the blade is removed. To protect against this, I make place holding blade copies of desert ironwood to insert in the "empty" dai.

P

Re: WWKD

#3

I have a collection

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>These style planes are an inexpensive means to having planes for special functions or to see what planes you actually will use. I have planes bedded at 35 and 50 degrees and they work fine. Originally I thought it would be frugal to have one iron and move it from plane to plane as needed. My impatience thwarted this plan. I find it nuisance enough adjusting any plane that a plane not ready to use became a plane not used.

I wound up making my own irons from 1/4" tool steel with out a chip breaker. The steel is readily available and some versions (O-1) could be heat treated by any of the vast number of people that make knives.

I came to the conclusion that a simple rounded rectangular prism was the best shape. I experimented with various sculptured shaped and concluded they wern't worth the effort.

My most used Krenov planes are the block variety, bedded 35, 45, and 50 degrees. I need to make a jointer but haven't yet.

The one plane I have

Re: WWKD

#4

Re: WWKD

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Chip breaker is a machinist's term for a device which breaks the chip (woodworkers would say shaving) into pieces to avoid tangles. However we have been using double iron planes for more than 250 years- not really a modern idea. Top iron and cap iron are more traditional terms for the second iron. Generally one has to adjust the wedge when getting a new iron for a traditional plane. Maybe for a Krenov style plane it would not be so important.

Re: WWKD

#5

Re: WWKD

Thomas S Stockton

>David,

Lots of questions, WWKD he would probably tell you make planes and experiment with what you have. If a plane doesn't work you really are not out much and you have learned a lot in the process, plus they burn real well in the bbq.

I took one of College of the Redwoods summer courses years ago and the irons we used were Stanley block plane irons and we made our own chip breakers. They worked well not as nice as a Hock iron but good enough that you could get your plane working real nice. At that time if you looked at Krenov's personal planes he used many different irons that he got here and there not worrying about brand names but how well they worked.

The hardest part about scrounging irons is that they need to be fairly short and also have a slot to hold the chipbreaker screw which is why block plane irons are popular. If you eliminate the chipbreaker you possibly have more iron choices.

Does a steel plane work better that a wood one as a jointer? that is just personal opinion, for hogging off lots of material quickly I think the extra weight of an steel plane is an advantage. But for edge jointing a wooden plane with a tight mouth opening is a better choice for me. You really don't need a jointer plane wider than 2" unless your jointing up really heavy timbers and then an extra 5/8ths probably won't help much.

Tom

Re: WWKD

#6

Jointer

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi David,

Wooden jointers are a favorite plane with me. Thinking particularly of edge jointing, a woodie has the advantage of being light and manueverable on the board. It responds instantly to touch and thumb pressure, whereas a metal jointer has more momentum and therefore is less response to touch. The woodie shape is also conducive to sensing level and plumb. A big question is whether you like to do match planing to edge join, or whether you prefer to do each edge singly.

I prefer to do each edge singly. I have two woodie jointers, one is 30" long with 2-1/2" blade, and one is 26" long with 2" blade. They're both really good, but the one I reach for almost every time is the 26"/2" one. I find that the narrower width is perfect for jointing one edge at a time. If you prefer match planing, then the wider plane is pretty much essential, of course. Balance is very important, so you want the tote well into the middle of the plane, and not close to the near end. C&W follow traditional practice and offset the tote a little--for example, if you're right handed, the tote will be offset a little to the right, so that it balances against your lead left hand.

Considering the try plane task of flattening a board, I still like the woodie, but here a better case can be made for the momentum of the heavier metal plane.

Wiley

Re: WWKD

#7

recommendations?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>What size jointer would you recommend just for 4/4 lumber?

Re: WWKD

#8

length

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I don't recall anything in Finck's plane arsenal that was 26" long. I'll check with him to be sure. Given that you advocate diddling with pressure on the plane to remove material where needed to maintain an orthogonal edge wouldn't the same be true to get the edge straight? Hence, a very long plane would not be necessary, or even very handy?

These questions could be in two contexts- fixing an edge that is nearly straight (for those that rely on the merits of a power jointer, or for straightening from rough were substantial departure from straight would be encountered.

Re: WWKD

#9

Longer vs. shorter plane for edge jointing

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Bill,

Yes, i bias the plane with thumb pressure from my lead hand in order to get an orthogonal edge. However, there is no 'diddling' to get the edge straight in the length (with one important exception I'll get to). Just as an aside, and this is speaking of using thumb pressure or other similar methods for making infinitesimal adjustments....I have noticed many times there is a meme that runs through edge jointing discussions that goes like this--get a long plane and run it down the board and the board gets straight. It's like it's automatic or mechanical if you have the correct plane. What I have noticed is very different--edge jointing is more akin to sculpting; it's all about touch. But the longer plane really does work for you, in getting the profile right in the length.

What I want to do in the length is never test anything--the shaving will tell all. This is true for both a machine jointed board, or a board from the retail hardwood store, or a rough board from the sawmill. The difference is that on a roughsawn board, you start with the fore plane, whereas on a board that is already milled and in pretty good shape, you can start with the try plane or jointer.

For working the length, the shaving tells all, so there's no diddling. Start in the middle of the board and work outwards towards the ends. What the longer plane does is give you a perfect light spring. I used to check flatness in the length with a milled edge level--no more. Just start planing the middle third of the board. Plane til no shaving comes up; then back up and work the middle two thirds of the board til no shaving; then back up and go full length until the blade just scrapes in the middle, but takes no shaving. Blade depth is set for a little thicker than 1 thou. This is almost done--I said there was just one diddle and it comes now. Make one more pass that starts 1/2" from the near end and stops 1/2" from the far end. Now you're done. This last pass prevents the odd effect of having a little bump just inbound from each end, and assures the board ends won't separate or show a join line, since moisture loss will be greatest at the ends.

Anyway, Bill, the point I was trying to get to in answer to your question is that the longer plane avoids any need for diddling, because you will get the correct spring in the length without working at it, provided only that one planes from the inside out.

In principle, if you're starting with a machine-jointed edge, and just want to detail it with

a hand plane, almost any length plane--even a smoother--will get the jointer ripples out, if there are any. But a longer plane, like 20" to 30", will give you the right spring of about one shaving thickness on each board. In certain situations where you don't want any spring, then it's easy not to have spring, just by taking an extra pass end to end, until you get an even shaving the full length. It's all about reading the shaving til you have the profile you want.

Wiley

Re: WWKD

#10

Re: recommendations?

Thomas S Stockton

>My wooden jointer is 16" long with a 1 1/2" iron,works well for me.

Tom

Re: WWKD

#11

Re: Longer vs. shorter plane for edge jointing

David Brown

>Wiley and Bill,

This was really interesting to think about. Finck suggests a making a jointer at 17" in length, somewhat shorter than the 26-30" inch ones Wiley uses.

In the end, I will probably make a jointer that is around 20" and uses a 1 3/4" edge. My thinking is that I already have that size blade and I can keep one blade straight and put a camber on one. Then I can swap them out in different size planes for whatever I need.

My only concern about longer jointers is flattening the sole. I don't have a long flat surface and I'm thinking how to do that. My current thought is to laminate some wood together so I have 8/4 or so in thickness and then work it to get it as flat as possible. Then use a long belt sander sand paper to flatten it. I know the wood won't stay flat, so I'd have to get it flat every time I need to flatten the sole, but I can't think of any other approach that is as cheap (which I am).

Thanks.

--Dave

Re: WWKD

#12

Re: Longer vs. shorter plane for edge jointing *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Dave,

A short jointer, 20" with 1-3/4" blade, is a most useful plane! It's wonderful. By some incredible coincidence, I recently took delivery of one with those exact specifications from Clark & Williams. It's a no-regret plane IMO, and if you decide you want something longer, then get a longer block and make yourself another one.

Flat.....A sheet of plate glass is flat. Virtually all glass you can buy is made by the float glass process. It's really flat. Check with your local glass place and see if they stock 1/2". If not, see if they stock 3/8"--that's the next best. Buy an offcut out of their shorts pile (which they will have). You can get a good price, especially if they don't have to cut into a new sheet of glass stock. Put it on a reasonably flat place for support, and it will serve well. If you do this, get them to debur the edges on their belt sander before you take it home.

However.....Here's an investment in flatness that you will never regret. A granite plate. It's good for so many things I can't remember them all--maintaining woodies flat is just one item. Check flatness of drawers and frames on it. Rebevel a blade on it. Put a square on it, and then you have the definition of a right angle to test cabinet doors and such. Anyway, you can get a 12x18, 3" thick, Grade B plate, with a tight flatness spec and a lab printout to confirm the spec--for as low as $30. Delivery in US = $44, if you can pick up at truck terminal. Out the door for $74. Not so heavy you can't carry it yourself. See attached link. I have no financial interest in Grizzly or anyone else. Key fact: A 12"x18" plate has a 21.5" diagonal, which would be just right for maintaining your 20" jointer.

Wiley


Granite plate (Grizzly Industrial)

Re: WWKD

#13

Re: recommendations?

David Brown

>Tom,

Thanks for the information. I was thinking of a 20" long jointer, but maybe I'l make one that is 17" long, which is what Finck recommends.

--Dave

Re: WWKD

#14

Re: recommendations? The real truth

ThomD

>(answering some stuff from throughout the thread)

Krenov made short jointers, but he also largely made small pieces. He also did a lot of bookmatching. That works out like this:

- The plane length, and target shaving thickness, and degree of spring in the board all have to be matched/tuned. One may not want the board to end up with spring, but it will start out that way for the easiest transition to a straight edge.

- Book matches tend to be low aspect ratio pieces so the they are edgewise extremely inflexible (a piece 8"x18" is essentially inflexible, but compressible). So a sprung edge will not spring. This requires a reasonably fine shaving in a short plane, with difficult wood. Almost a finishing plane cut in a jointer format. But if you want to do something like make cherry table tops all day long, want to remove a decent shaving and most of your boards are long and thin, then you want a longer plane. Don't just copy what some guy copied from someone else. Match your specific work, at least for best results. The shorter you make a plane the lighter the cut you can take for a same degree of spring, so unless you want to work slowly for a specific reason, longer jointers will get the work done faster because they can take a thicker shaving. Jointing makes a finished surface, but it isn't usually a finishing cut, so it really doesn't need to be a light cut for the most part. Since it takes about 45 minutes to make a Krenov plane , you don't really have to choose which one.

The reason Krenov planes aren't based on 2.375" plane blades is because that is a handful in a handleless plane, with some height. A wider blade is good for jointer boards in pairs, so there is a use to metal planes with wider blades. And again his pieces were small where a panel might be 5/8".

I did a test of metal and wood jointers of standard specifications for these pages several years back and the defection was essentially identical for a given pressure. An few thou. Which makes sense given the fact that there is probably some practical minimum required stiffness. But wood and metal planes are not different in flexibility or receptivity to body english. In fact my tests were with maple and beech planes. Krenov style hardwood planes might be stiffer than the average metal plane, being made of tropical woods.

I would point out that most custom knifemaker probably don't send their O1 out. They heat treat it themselves, along with most any steel they can. Better knifemakers mostly send out steels they can't heat treat like many stainlesses, etc... If you look at something like the ABS, a lot of what they teach, and the coveted Master Smith designation is related to home heat treating. That's were the action is. Production makers send stuff because they are into volume, or if they are mostly SS stock reduction makers. O1 is one of the easiest steels to successfully heat treat that there is.

Re: WWKD

#15

A thought on local granite plate source

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Given that they are so cheap I'll bet that the Griz variety may be no different than granite counter top material. So. another cheap alternative to flat and large could be to stop by the counter top store for a "scrap".

Re: WWKD

#16

Thomas...Wiley.....more questions

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Wiley explained his approach to getting a glueable edge with a relatively long plane. It would seem that what he does would not be amenable to using a shorter plane, or maybe not. Does, in fact, the technique to get a straight edge differ with use of a shorter plane ?

Personally I think the sprung edge is an artifact from a past situation. It clearly is not necessary for successful edge gluing with modern glue and KD lumber as evidenced by the fact that furniture factories don't need it to make successful joints on furniture shipped across the land. Never-the-less a straight edge is necessary. Being able to correct and refine an edge from a power jointer would be a handy skill to have.

Re: WWKD

#17

Surface Plates

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>You can be sure that 18th cabinetmakers and joiners did not try to stuff surface plates into tool chests that were already crowded and heavy. If you want an approach that is cheap and effective, use a smoothing plane, a straight edge and a pair of winding sticks. Make your own straight edge and winding sticks out of hardwood. Contrary to popular belief one can get a straight edge much more accurate than the plane that is truing it.

Re: WWKD

#18

Jointer

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Do wood jointers work as well as metal ones ... Also, has any one made Krenov style planes with lower or steeper angles for the blade? Do the blades still wedge tightly? .......Just for curiosity, I decided to try it without a chip breaker so I made a thicker wedge and it cuts just as well without the chip breaker.

Hi Dave

Although not strictly Krenov planes, the non-laminated HNT Gordon designs are bedded at 60 degrees and blades are held securely with wedges.



These use 1/4" thick blades without a cap iron.

Regarding a jointer, below is my 30" with laminated construction. This is also bedded at 60 degrees. Where it differs from the typical Krenov plane is that it uses a lever cap in place of a wedge. The blade is a 2" wide, 3/16" thick Hock sans cap iron.



Jarrah and ebonized tote.

This is my go-to jointer. Other choices include a Stanley #7 and Veritas BUJ, both excellent planes. I like the lightness and balance of the woodie.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: WWKD

#19

About factories and sprung edges...

John in NM

>I don't think you can make the claim that factories don't need to spring edge joints Bill. I'd say its more accurate to say that they have a pretty good idea of what the American consumer expects for life span and don't need to make edge joints any better than they do to meet those expectations. I've had to fix enough of these problems to still spring my joints. Its just so easy to do.

Of course my location may affect my observations. Air drying out here is far better than kiln drying, just takes longer. Air dried lumber typically won't even register on my meter after about 6 months (neither would kiln dried of course, I just don't meter it). And we see extreme humidity swings throughout the year. From ~5% RH in the winter and spring to peaks of +70% in the summer. Summer days will vary from 20% to 70% depending on storm activity. I know these figures aren't much compared to the months of 100% RH seen in the south, but the point is that the swings stress long edge joints, perhaps that's why I've seen enough failures to make me dispute the claim that factories actually know what they're doing.

Re: WWKD

#20

flat *LINK*

paul womack

>Given that they are so cheap I'll bet that the Griz variety may be no different than granite counter top material.

Err. I'll take that bet.

BugBear


FWW review

Re: WWKD

#21

wrong link, Bugbear

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>unless there's some subtle reference in the Footprint chisel review?

Re: WWKD

#22

browser (cache) trouble!

paul womack

>

Re: WWKD

#23

Re: A thought on local granite plate source

Ted

>I've tried the dumpster diving route to a cheap surface plate and was very disappointed. I've seen pieces with dips in them that were obvious to the naked eye. If you take this route, make sure you bring a straight edge with you to check the quality of your finds.

Ted

Re: WWKD

#24

Re: Thomas...Wiley....2 or 3 more cents

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Regarding sprung joints.....Our climate is mild. There are exceedingly dry weeks and exceedingly wet weeks, but there are not exceedingly dry or wet seasons. A finished piece of furniture will not have time during an extreme period to shrink or expand to match the ambient condition. It spends its life wandering within a narrow range of movement. Might not be the case elsewhere.

Given our mild climate, I use an amount of spring that is positive, but that can be closed with finger pressure (not clamping). This works out to about one shaving thickness in a 3- or 4-foot 4/4 board that is 5 to 7 inches wide. There are exceptions: If the board is 9 inches wide, I shoot for near-zero spring but am careful to make sure that each pair of boards is closed up tight at the ends. Same thing with thicker boards, like 5/4 or better, which are on the shortish side--again, the test is that if it takes clamp pressure to close the boards up, that is more spring than required for my climate.

Two overriding considerations.....One, what works in So. Calif. may not be right in eastern Tennessee or parts of New Mexico, or anywhere else. Second thing is knowing where the risk is. There's no such thing as 'dead straight'. I use 1-shaving's worth of spring to make sure it's a little concave--because convex is intolerable.

Long plane/short plane on machined edge....IF one is starting with an edge which has been power jointed, and IF it is already profiled just the way you want in terms of spring vs. no spring, then what is left is a smoothing operation. One pass with your favorite smoother should do the job. The only thing is to take care with the entry cut (pressure at the nose) and the exit cut (pressure at the heel), to avoid sniping one end or the other. But that is a lot of 'ifs': Suppose you want to be sure of the profile off the power jointer,. Then a longer plane, like a No. 6 or 7 length, can confirm the degree of straightness left by the power jointer--start with a stopped shaving in the middle of the board. Then go end to end and read the shaving--the full-length shaving should be a little thinner in the middle than at the ends. If this doesn't happen, then the board was a little convex at the outset. The longer plane will provide a more diagnostic shaving than a shorter plane.

Wiley

Re: WWKD

#25

clarification of question

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The smoothness of the edge from a power jointer is just fine for gluing and needs no smoothing refinement. I have made thousands of them and the adhesive bond does not fail using yellow glue. I regard it as folklore that a power jointed edge is unsatisfactory for gluing and the practice of hundreds of cabinet shops suggest I am correct.

You may be assuming that it is trivial to get a straight edge on a 3' board using a 5' power jointer. However, I rarely get an edge from a power jointer as straight as what you attain with your hand planing technique. If it is "sprung" and I can close it with moderate clamp pressure I judge it acceptable and glue it. But more common is that the ends will occasionally gap a small amount. A convex edge can to tedious to remove with a power jointer. If I was proficient at edge jointing with a hand plane this would be the preferred way to fix a slightly convex edge.

I understand the clear description of how you use the long plane to achieve a straight edge. Others use much smaller length planes to accomplish this task and it remains unclear if the same technique would be successful using a shorter plane or whether some other technique is preferred.