Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Pins first advice

Posts

Pins first advice

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

Pins first advice

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I learned to cut dovetails by cutting the tails first.Recently I found myself having to make new tails boards(sides)for a drawer,so I had to mark the tails off the existing pins.I clamped the pin board flat to the bench,inside up and holding the new side vertically against it I marked my new tails.I found this to be awkward.There must be a better way.Does anyone cut pins first? If so,how do you mark the tails off the pins?---Jack

Re: Pins first advice

#2

Re: Pins first advice

Joe Shelton

>Jack, I think it's easier to lay the tail board flat, and set the pins onto that board vertically. Frank Klausz does this so deftly that it's amazing.

I get tense over the the possibility of moving the two parts in relation to each other, so I've made a (dovetailed) right angle cradle, into which I align the two. That way, I get to hold them against a reference, instead of trusting gravity and a light touch with my pencil as I make the marks.

The real difference-maker is confidence from repetition. I don't get many reps.

Joe

Re: Pins first advice

#3

Re: Pins first advice

Dave Mount

>I'm a pins first guy on through dovetails because I watched Frank Klaus (on video) cut dovetails before teaching myself. I don't claim it's better, it's just how I learned.

Like Joe, I lay the tailboard on the bench and stand the pin board on end. For smallish work, I don't clamp anything -- the tail board should be content to stand on end, and I hold it in place at the baseline by holding the edges of both pin and tailboard with my thumb on one side and my middle finger on the other. For dovetailing boards wider than the span of thumb to middle finger, doing something more to hold things in place can be helpful.

If you want a crutch to insure alignment, I'd opt for clamping a batten across the baseline of the tails. That way you're registering on the baseline, which is the critical indexing point. I leave the endgrain slightly long on through dovetails, so the alignment is at the baseline, not at the end of the tailboard as in a right angle fixture. I guess you could make a right angle fixture so that the end of the tailboard could stick by the vertical face. It's a minor point, but marking from the end of the tailboard gives you slightly better access, since the angles are opening up instead of closing down as look at the joint.

I believe I saw somewhere that Rob Cosman advocates putting a shallow rebate on the inside of the tailboard to make the joint self aligning when marking. This does the same thing as putting a batten across the baseline. Logical enough, but never seemed worth the extra effort to me personally (I've never actually tried it).

Best,

Dave

Re: Pins first advice

#4

Re: Pins first advice *LINK*

charlie belden

>I'm of the Pins First school - scribed layout lines, not pencil, because it's easier to transfer lines from them to side grain on the tails boards - no getting into really tight spaces with a SINGLE bevel marking knife.

Keeping the two parts together, aligned correctly can be fun since the pin board may move while you're marking off them. Any twisting or sliding affects the results - usually very visibly.

I found Pony corner clamps really help.


Holding pins board to tails board for marking pins

Re: Pins first advice

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Pins first advice

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Corner clamps and rabbets both sound promising.I think I may have to practise this technique abit til I master a way that works for me.Thanks for the ideas---Jack

Re: Pins first advice

#6

Re: Pins first advice

Charles

>I don't find it awkward at all. I cut the joint pins first. This method will expose a pin board not square on its end and a tail board with warp across its face. If the pin board rocks on the tail board you've got a problem that needs fixin' especially in drawer stock.