Re: Pins first advice
Dave Mount
>I'm a pins first guy on through dovetails because I watched Frank Klaus (on video) cut dovetails before teaching myself. I don't claim it's better, it's just how I learned.
Like Joe, I lay the tailboard on the bench and stand the pin board on end. For smallish work, I don't clamp anything -- the tail board should be content to stand on end, and I hold it in place at the baseline by holding the edges of both pin and tailboard with my thumb on one side and my middle finger on the other. For dovetailing boards wider than the span of thumb to middle finger, doing something more to hold things in place can be helpful.
If you want a crutch to insure alignment, I'd opt for clamping a batten across the baseline of the tails. That way you're registering on the baseline, which is the critical indexing point. I leave the endgrain slightly long on through dovetails, so the alignment is at the baseline, not at the end of the tailboard as in a right angle fixture. I guess you could make a right angle fixture so that the end of the tailboard could stick by the vertical face. It's a minor point, but marking from the end of the tailboard gives you slightly better access, since the angles are opening up instead of closing down as look at the joint.
I believe I saw somewhere that Rob Cosman advocates putting a shallow rebate on the inside of the tailboard to make the joint self aligning when marking. This does the same thing as putting a batten across the baseline. Logical enough, but never seemed worth the extra effort to me personally (I've never actually tried it).
Best,
Dave