Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

OT - lost skills

Posts

Re: OT - lost skills

#26

Re: On Topic - lost skills

James Watriss

>I think there's still some ferreting out of information, but I think you raise a valid point, Most of my friends who are masters or PhD students complain pretty regularly about students who use very little besides wikipedia to do their research.

And really, when it comes to practical matters, like woodworking, or anything else that's physical and hands-on, there's still a pretty big learning curve when it comes to organizing work and figuring out how things actually function in the real, non-theoretical world.

By way of example, Sam Maloof did his level best to spread his information around. He lectured, wrote a book, and Taunton put out a book that describes the fundamentals of how he builds his chairs. I've seen a few imitations at craft shows, but by and large, even with that much information out there, I haven't seen that many imitators, even among the recreational set. Brian Boggs is teaching classes, and so on.

Having the information is one thing. Having the will, the know-how, the hands-on experience, (at anything, really) and the ability to experiment until you get it right... that's still a time and effort-intensive undertaking.

I think, to summarize, that just about anybody can build a chair. But not everybody can do it skillfully, efficiently, and successfully, in a way that would enable them to make a living. The information is all out there. But there's still a lot of work to learn how to do things well.

Re: OT - lost skills

#27

Re: I understand Pam's point, though

James Watriss

>Yeah, it didn't come across as snippy to me, really. Not to rehash old experiences, but usually, it's a lot more obvious when she's in a snippy mood.

"...be sure you know what you're talking about and don't assume the world started when you did."

I think it's a really good point to ponder, really, especially on a board that focuses on something like woodworking. I still have to pull my head around once in a while when I'm looking at old furniture, architecture, or other evidences of societies gone by. It's so easy to think of the here and now as the pinnacle of technology and forget that it's not the pinnacle of human intelligence or effort. There have always been very smart, hands-on people in the world, it's easy sometimes to forget that they brought about a lot of interesting and creative solutions when it came to building and making things. And frequently, it was through a lot of hard work. It's easy to think "Well, yeah, but we've been working in stone, or wood, for thousands of years... surely we're past that by now, and onto newer and more advanced things..." It all seems so dated, and non-challenging, somehow.

There's so much old architecture and engineering that we haven't quite figured out... things like Stonehenge, or how the greeks managed to make the floor of the acropolis slope ever so slightly, so that no water would pool in the middle of the floor. A lot of old, forgotten knowledge, used to do things that would really get modern stone-masons scratching their heads. How did they manage to do it with such simple tools? Or were the practices, theory, and execution a little more advanced than their primitive surroundings would lead us to believe.

Computers... I'm a computer nimrod. But I'm sure there was a lot of head scratching, and trial and error, and lessons carried forward by programmers working on all kinds of things, from writing languages, to writing things in languages. I'm sure the computer world is just like anything else... a few really smart people, a bunch of hard workers, and probably run in many cases by people who were able to BS just well enough to impress the right person.

Re: OT - lost skills

#28

Re: Well, that sounded a bit snippy :

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yeah, it did, which is why I put the smilie in there. Pretend that we're at a bar trading fake insults in good fun, we're not completely sober, .... :) <- smilie

Pam

Re: OT - lost skills

#29

Re: OT - lost skills

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Joe

I wrote two theses on an old Royal typewriter. Each time a cut-and-paste was completed, the whole page had to be re-typed. After proof-reading, any errors required that the page be aligned so that the Tipexed letter(s) could be over-typed .. precisely. Remember that?

Later, I was in private practice and responsible not only for typing my own reports, but for preparing invoices fotr patients (I was a one-man show). I would hire a typist to do some of the reports. The invoices had to be begun afresh each time with all information.

Later still, I began using computers and Master Copies made invoicing a dramatically brief event, while reports were prepared as they were written, and then simply printed. I now just cannot contemplate how I survived pre-computers!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: OT - lost skills

#30

Re: OT - lost skills

Victor P

>Bill,

You sure did kick an ant hill with your posting.

I remember setting points frequently in my college days.

As a young accountant I was doing consolidation accounting for a group of 27 companies on three different consolidation levels on huge spreadsheets, I could get most of the reports required off of the computer, but the real hairy ones like the Statement of Changes in Financial Position had to be computed by hand, then typed, proof read, retyped and sent off to printers.

I do not miss the bad old days.

Victor in Houston

Re: OT - lost skills

#31

One of the advantages of computers

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>We used to have a cartoon tacked up in the office just above the sole (tractor-feed!) printer: man on a telephone, caption something like: "Rest assured, madam, even now high speed computers are either resolving or greatly complicating your problem."

Re: OT - lost skills

#32

One other thing;-)

Dan Donaldson

>Relating to your original post, they say that "they don't make cars like they used to" and I, for one, am sure glad of that ;-) One hundred K miles before a major tuneup. almost never get flats unless you hit something; in a crash, the car may sustain a lot of damage, but you have a good chance of walking away (a good tradeoff, in my opinion ;-)) and a lot of other things.

Re: OT - lost skills

#33

Re: One other thing;-)

Alex Grigoriev

>Yes, they complain that the bumper crimples too easily. Not knowing that this is what saves them from excessive collision shock. It's cheaper to replace the bumper, than to pay for neck injury.

And some people are nostalgic for their 1950s-1960s gas-stinking monsters. I'm glad there's too little of those left, because otherwise it would be impossible to breath in any area with traffic. Even driving behind one such car is a quite bad experience.

Re: OT - lost skills

#34

Re: Well, that sounded a bit snippy :

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Ok, I'm pretending we're at a bar, peanut shells two inches deep on the floor, the place smells like beer and urine. We're sitting just around the corner from the restrooms with their doors gapping open and I can hear a toilet flush. "Jeeez, she could have at least shut the door."

We have an accumulation of empty long neck beer bottles lining the small tippy table we are sitting at, hmmmmm...most are on your side. Old hand tools hanging from rusty old nails on the rough sawn, open beam structure that supports a corragated tin roof. Cobwebs as old as the tools, no doubt spun by spiders of earlier generations.

Egads, what time is it? Hey I gotta git go'n, didn't realize it was so late. Thanks for the beers. You can sure put'm away. Need a ride?

:)Smilie

Re: OT - lost skills

#35

Re: OT - lost skills

Richard Darjes

>I have a similar experience. In 1983 I typed the first draft of my masters thesis on a 1927 Underwood (with the wide carriage no less - I had pinkies of steel from shifting to print capital letters). The second was on a DEC10 mini computer using a teletype terminal and the last draft was done on an original IBM PC and printed on a daisy wheel printer (aprox one page per minute with background noise like a machine gun). That IBM PC didn't even have a hard drive - I had to store the thesis on a 5 1/4" floppy. Those were the days!

Re: OT - lost skills

#36

No debate there

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I appreciate the old beasties for what they are - but for daily use, give me our (old, according to the current thinking) 1996 Volvo sedan.

In addition to minimal maintenance, I still giggle when the central locking locks and unlocks everything with one key.

Re: OT - lost skills

#37

Having been the not-so-proud owner of a 1972 Pinto

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I'm just glad I can drive down the road without the prospect of my gas tank exploding!

Bruce, also glad that the new cars = better cars.