Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

Posts

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#26

Re: Specialty Plane Question

David Brown

>Thanks again to everyone for contributing to this topic. I found it very interesting and I learned a lot.

--Dave

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#27

unfortunate copy

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I think the ad copy is a bit unfortunate. It implies that an adjuster is necessary for a bench plane and superfluous for this match plane. Neither is quite true; an adjuster can be beneficial for both.

I have made thousands of grooves with my 45 plane, which has a screw adjuster. And maybe a thousand drawers so far. The exact depth of cut is not crucial for the outcome. But when you are making grooves for six drawers, for example, it is nice to have the depth of cut right in the sweet spot where you are taking the most with each pass that you can take without strain. Strain is a big issue when you are constantly doing handwork. I think the plane would have been marginally better with an adjuster and perhaps the business about "heavy stock removal" should have been left out.

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#28

What the heck is SAS?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Joking, we use it at in my team to compile the results of our simulations (1600 standard tables and graphs), and also for estimating equations and data manipulation.

DC

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#29

Re: I think that's what I said. :)

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>The 3/4" stock issue has no bearing on the depth adjustment issue... working thinner or thicker stock with a #48 or the new L-N will result in an offset tongue, rather than any difference in depth of cut (as correctly noted in MikeW's post).

I never said it did. I said that it impacted the need for a depth stop and emphasized that by saying that the depth of cut for 3/4" tongue and grove should be a specific amount and only that amount. It all depends on what one calls depth adjustment. I call it the depth of the cut. You don't. Big whoop.

As to blade projection, it is my experience that a given plane cuts more smoothly/better at one blade projection than at all others. What's more, I've found that that blade projection is more easily found using a hard wood blade setting block than in any other way, for both metal and wooden planes. I'll admit that the blade projection adjusters may be handy on metal planes, but certainly not essential.

The Stanley original used a slightly different blade design, but both have a 'stop' consisting of the body casting itself. This is simplicity itself...plane until the work grounds on the casting, and each tongue will be of the same depth assuming the blade is not reset. I've had several #48s, and they all worked well, although the tongue and groove only center on 7/8" stock, versus L-N's 3/4" stock. Other than the fence pivot loosening (something LN addressed with materials use), these planes are just about perfect.

I am no fan of Stanley planes, don't use them, absolutely hate the few I've tried to use; so whatever you say will have to go. I neither dispute nor confirm. LN's versions of Stanley planes have worked great for me, especially the LA jack; so of them I am a fan.

Re: cost engineering at L-N: Good chuckle there...I don't think it enters Tom's mind to consider other tool makers as competition; he does what he sees as needing doing, and charges what he thinks his customers should be willing to pay and what he needs to keep his doors open and his manufacturing in Maine.

I admire Tom and think he does the right things to make his planes work well, work with elan, and last a long time. I'm not all that sure about his use of A2 blades.

Pam

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#30

Re: jammed with shavings

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Whenever a plane jams with shavings I sharpen the blade as a first resolution. This has always worked for me.

Pam

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#31

Re: to claify..

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>The report of cancer causing wood dust a year or three ago has certainly been a catalyst for more movement to hand tools ever since.

Pam

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#32

Re: to claify..

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Haven't moved to some version of Wolfram yet? :) What's your application area?

Pam

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#33

Re: to claify..

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Can you tell me more about Wolfram? We're looking into Stata for regression analysis, SAS we use for handling large (up to 100 GB) datasets.

DC

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#34

OT Mathematica *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>No, not really. I used SAS for a while years and years ago and only know Mathematica from the outside looking in. Mathematica may be too education oriented for business; but Jack has spent a lot of time with it, read Wolfram's book, likes it a lot.

Generally I'd design and program any math processing needed on datasets myself because of large dataset problems.

Pam


Wolfram's Mathematica

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#35

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

Philip Edwards

>Dave

The Youtube video is mine - and yes, it really is that simple to adjust and set a wooden plane. The secret is a well fitting wedge - that way you don't need to put excessive pressure on it.

Best regards

Phil

www.phillyplanes.co.uk


Adjusting Wooden Planes

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#36

Early adjustable planes

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>There were a couple of patents in 1857 for metallic adjustment on wooden planes. People been fiddling for years.

Stephen

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#37

OT SAS

David Brown

>I use SAS for data analysis of pharmaceutical data, clinical trials results basically. I was a but surprised that someone else uses this, even if only some. I use it extensively.

Cheers.

--Dave

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#38

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

David Brown

>Phil, thanks for the link. It was a great video and a wonderful looking plane. But it's not the video I saw. I tracked down the video I saw and the link is below, for anyone who might be interested.

Phil, I am curious about the weight of the wooden mallet you use for adjustments because many people suggest a brass hammer for adjustments.

Cheers,

--Dave


you tube wooden plane video

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#39

Re: OT SAS

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>An enormous number of people have been using SAS for years, I even see it specified in job classifieds now and then, among other useless applications specified (not that SAS is useless, just that any software developer could pick it up poste haste, reminds me of the ads for Java programmers with 5 years experience when Java had only been shipping for 2 years, let's hear it for HR).

Pam

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#40

Adjustment

paul womack

>I think there are two requirements for depth adjustment.

One is controlling rate of stock removal (probably compared with force required to push the tool!).

The other is quality of surface.

The former requires comparitively coarse depth adjustment, the latter fine (down in the thous) adjustment.

The only surfaces that matter (a great deal) are show surfaces; since most "specialist" planes (e.g. groove, dado, rebate) are generating joint surfaces, that can answer well enough without fine adjustment. It can be a convenience to have it, but I think its a question of "want" not "need".

BugBear

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#41

Alternate phrasing...

John in NM

>Perhaps what Bill means is that the presence of an adjuster makes the tool more "mentally approachable" to the novice. I'd have been appalled at the thought of whacking a nice old wood plane with a hammer (or tapping it with a mallet for those who prefer it without the hyperbole) when I first started fooling with hand tools. The adjuster is intuitively obvious, so leading to experimentation, which of course leads to experience and skills.