Re: KISS the wedge is the better screw.
ThomD
>There is no more learning curve with a Krenov plane than there is with say a record plane, and overall I find it easier to adjust. To get good results, one needs a pretty level bed, correct wedge, clean blade. One needs a hammer of the correct weight and feel. I prefer softer hammers like nylon, don't like brass, you will find something you like.
I place the first two fingers of my left hand in the mouth of the plane so they push up a little. I drop the blade in so it rest on my fingers. As long as you don't slide your fingers relative to the blade you won't be cut, but I am sure you could figure out a way of doing this without fingers if it scares you. I then press the wedge in by hand until it holds the blade. Take my fingers away, and tap the wedge so it firmly holds the blade (and take it down a little also).
One of the keys is that while you want the wedge to retain the blade, if you push it in too hard then the blade doesn't adjust accurately. Just be aware that brute force isn't the key. Once everything is ready, start taping on the blade, and checking the cut, until it cuts the way you want it to. The adjustment is very precise, and does not take a master craftsman. There is zero backlash, and if the blade breaks loose it won't damage the work, it simply backs out of it. Normally it is best to start short of the depth you want and work up to it. The blade can be backed out, but normally if I gets too deep I prefer to start over. Same really with screw adjusts.
The point of the fingers is to get the blade real close to cutting so that the tap and try process does not get tedious. What doesn't work so well is that if you have the blade set too high the tension you have on the wedge to move the blade a lot, is not good for moving it very small amounts. I can get the blade out, sharpened, and back to work with less effort with a wedge than with mechanical types. A Norris type adjuster is great also, but no practical advantage and slow in it's own way. It is critical to develop a feel for the initial blade projection, the wedge set, and the hammer weight so that one can make precise adjustments. But it shouldn't take for ever for this to happen if you are looking for the right kind of indicators.
While a screw mechanism seems very scientific compared to a hammer, the reality is that a properly weighted hammer will only press the blade down so much per tap. It is completely predictable. Screws on the other hand have to be very well made, few planes actually have good tolerances in all their fittings. There are still issues with the friction required to break screws over, and how much the blade will move, any backlash, tendency to loosen etc... All the issues about setting up pre-loads in the system, are exactly the same, and generally worse. There is a whole class of musical instruments called percussion instruments, from pianos to drums. These are very expressive instruments even though they are hit with a hammer.
Funny thing about screws. The History channel did the history of torture a few weeks, back, and one of the things that I found amusing was that when thumb screws came out they were regarded as highly sophisticated, apparently machine screws were at the time something special. Rather as electro torture, or chemical, or psych methods would seem advanced in the last century. Seems this reverence for the screw is still there in the plane business. I certainly see screws as very accurate on something like the slides of a milling machine, but most planes don't really get there. Mostly one can accurately with a plane as much in spite of the adjustment's quality as because of them. Wedges are still the class of the field. I suppose technically the wedge and screw are relatives, but most wedges are zero tolerance in fit, and most screws are pretty sloppy. What gives machine tools their supreme accuracy is a wedge that is adjusted by a stack of screws. It is more reminiscent of the plane wedge than it is the screw adjuster.