Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

Posts

Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#1

Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

David Brown

>By specialty planes, I mean not normal bench planes, like the 4, 5, 6, etc..

My question is about depth adjustments. I know that some specialty planes like the record 043 have no depth adjuster, while others such as the stanley 45 have depth adjusters.

I saw the advertising copy for the new Lie-Nielsen tongue and groove plane and it says "Since this is a heavy stock removal tool no depth adjuster is needed."

Since the stanley 45 has tongue and groove cutters and a depth adjuster, I guess I'm curious when planes don't need it?

Having asked this question, I realize that old wooden planes of old have no depth adjuster and the were used for any amount of stock removal.

I don't really know anything about this type of plane. I have never actually seen a specialty plane, but I've been eyeing the record 044s that sometimes come up on e-bay and I was curious about this statement. If anyone has any thoughts on this, I'd be interested to hear about them.

Thanks and have a good weekend.

--Dave


Tongue and groove

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#2

Need? Let me express a strong opinion here

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Scrub planes don't need depth adjustment.

Other than that, I think just about any plane benefits from depth adjustment, because, except for the scrub, the ability to set the plane for fine work is encountered often enough that the precision of adjustment is awfully nice. I will make one exception to that blanket statement (see below).

I own a Stanley 78 duplex rabbet (depth adjuster on the main, but not the bullnose, frog), the Sargent riff on the duplex rabbet (no adjusters), and a Stanley 289 (no adjuster).

Stanley would have had a heck of a time fitting an adjuster into the plane for the bullnose position - the plane would have been several inches longer. They clearly decided the bullnose uses were infrequent enough to leave it off (a judgment I have found to be true).

The Sargent was a lowball version of the Stanley, so they sacrificed features to meet a price point (or, as is said now, "value engineered" it). I don't know why Stanley opted not to have an adjuster on the 289, but I sure wish that particular engineer had been shouted down, and they'd put on an adjuster.

Record's 043 is so small that an adjuster might have been hard to fit, and, anyway, it was a low-end tool - thus, no adjuster.

I find myself suspecting that L-N either couldn't figure out how to install an adjuster or couldn't make it fit within the production costs for the price they'd decided to set; so developed the ad copy to make that decision sound like the right move. However, maybe I'm just too cynical; I've been told I can get that way.

My exception to my general desire (other than scrub planes) to see adjusters: The Stanley/Record(Kunz/Anant/who knows who else) 151 spokeshave, with the two knurled adjusters, can be awkward in tight spots. I find the 51/52 shaves, although the setting by guess requires a little artfulness, far better: little sports cars by comparison. While I've never handled them, I would probably find the L-N shaves desirable for the same reason.

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#3

One additional note

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>It is, though, feasible on almost any plane to learn to adjust it by guess. It does take practice.

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#4

Re: Specialty Plane Question

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>Lately, I've been working more with some wooden planes. Some of these from Steve Knight, of Portland, OR, and some of my own building, using Sir James' designs.

Adjusting for depth, with those wooden planes, is done with a small hammer from Chester Tool Works. A few taps and raps, and things are adjusted...

Stuff is simpler, sometimes, when you build it that way. ;-)

Disclaimer: No rabbeting or plow planes in current working inventory. For that, we plug in.

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#5

Re: Specialty Plane Question

David Brown

>Glenn (or anybody else who uses Krenov style wooden planes),

Making a Krenov type plane (based on David Finck's book) is on my very short list of projects. I'm just curious how the learning curve was for setting the planes up to take a cut. I saw a video on you tube of someone working a wooden plane (looked like an HNT Gordon? Is that the name?) and he set it up pretty quickly. Really just a few taps, some test cuts, a few more taps and he was ready to go. If the video was to be believed, the user was really comfortable getting the plane ready to cut. It was probably faster than I can do with my LV plane. I was curious how many years it took to get to that point of speed in set up. I assume the first time was probably a very long time of tapping and adjusting and it gets quicker with experience. Was this your experience?

Thanks.

--Dave

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#6

Re: Specialty Plane Question

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>On the depth adjuster: It doesn't seem to be needed. The LN is intended to be used in 3/4" thick material, thus the depth should be n, no more, no less.

On the HNT planes, they're extremely easy to adjust and use. Piece of cake, especially if you use a hard wood setting block.

Caveat, I use mostly wooden planes, Japanese, European, and HNT, but have no financial interest in any of them.

Pam

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#7

Depth of cut

David Cockey

>I believe the original question is around setting the depth of cut as in how far the blade projects below the sole and thus how thick a shaving is produced. All hand planes need the ability to set this. A tongue and groove plane is used to remove wood to produce the tongue and groove. A high quality finish on the planned surfaces is not needed since the surfaces will be hidden with the tongue and groove is assembled. Thus very precise adjustment of the blade projection such as needed with a smoothing plane isn't generally required with a tongue and groove plane. However, it is possible with some practice to very precisely set the blade projection without a mechanical adjuster. Tapping is the traditional method. An alternative is set the plane on a flat surface with put sheets of paper with a thickness equal to the desired blade projection undet the sole ahead of the blade. Then slide the blade down until it contacts the surface.

Two other interpertations of depth of cut might be made. One is the position of the tongue and groove relative to the surface of the board. This is preset in the design of this plane by the position of the fence, and in the model linked is centered on a 3/4" board. The other potential interpertation is the depth of the tongues and groove. This is essentially preset by the design of the plane, though it will be affected by the blade projection is small compared to the overall depth.

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#8

Stanley 48

David Cockey

>The Lie-Nielsen tongue and groove plane is based on the Stanley 48, which also doesn't have adjusters. Lots of Stanley 48's were sold as were the smaller 49 over 65 years.

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#9

Alternative cynical view

David Cockey

>Some folks (not me) contend that no plane needs an adjuster, planes worked fine for centuries without adjusters, and adjusters are just ploys by the plane makers to increase profits by inducing buyers to spend more money for something they don't really need.

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#10

Re: Depth of cut

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Clearly I interpreted the question as having nothing to do with blade projection, since usually "depth adjusting" relates to the depth of cut/stop. Only David Brown knows for sure. :)

Pam

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#11

Re: Depth of cut

MikeW

>Hi Pam,

These planes are self-regulating for depth of cut--there are no adjustable depth stops.

For the OP or whomever...setting the blade projection *might* take once or twice to get the feel, but that's about it. And, different woods "like" lesser or can take more blade projection than other woods. A couple cuts on a piece of scrap of the target wood is never a bad idea to get a feel for blade projection.

The LN plane is wonderfully made.

Take care, Mike

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#12

could it be.......

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>that woodworking is so popular because things like adjusters enable persons with limited time to learn, and do, to be able to make nice stuff without a several year apprenticeship?

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#13

Re: could it be.......

MikeW

>Here's a crotchity reply for which I may have to apologize for...

"could it be.......that woodworking is so popular because things like adjusters enable persons with limited time to learn, and do, to be able to make nice stuff without a several year apprenticeship?"

Several years? To learn to adjust a plane without an adjuster quickly and accurately?

Now, there are certain skill-based processes like marquetry that can take some time to become accomplished at. But mechanical processes? Mechanical processes are something most brain-dead monkeys* can become adept at (or at least functional at) in short order.

Take care, Mike

*my apologies to monkeys...

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#14

Re: Depth of cut

David Brown

>Thanks, everyone, for the thoughts. And funny replies about monkeys. I believe I look like one most days in my shop. Oook.

I was primarily curious about the adjustment that regulates the shaving thickness. I was quoting from Lie-Nielsen, but in context (which I didn't include) this was clearly what they meant when referring to a "depth adjuster" since the plane is designed to center on 3/4" stock. My original question is essentially, why do some planes have it and some don't?

It makes sense that smoothness of the resulting surface matters less when the joint is not exposed as much, and so fine adjustment is not critical. I recently used a shoulder plane to cut some rabbits (I sometimes wish I was from England so I could say rebate, which sounds far less violent) and I set the plane up for a very thick cut just so it wouldn't take so long. If you are taking really thick shavings the ability to set it .001 thicker or thiner matters less I guess. And it also makes sense the thought that sometimes it's hard to put the adjuster on the plane given the manufacturing processes. And marketers will be marketers.

Lastly, I'm sure it's a great plane and I hope no one thinks my question in any way was meant to imply the Lie-Nielsen plane was in any way deficient. Not until I use one (which is very unlikely) would I express an opinion on that specific plane.

Also, does anyone know when screw type adjusters first showed up on planes? Was it the Norris type smoother? Just curious.

--Dave

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#15

I think that's what I said. :)

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#16

Re: KISS the wedge is the better screw.

ThomD

>There is no more learning curve with a Krenov plane than there is with say a record plane, and overall I find it easier to adjust. To get good results, one needs a pretty level bed, correct wedge, clean blade. One needs a hammer of the correct weight and feel. I prefer softer hammers like nylon, don't like brass, you will find something you like.

I place the first two fingers of my left hand in the mouth of the plane so they push up a little. I drop the blade in so it rest on my fingers. As long as you don't slide your fingers relative to the blade you won't be cut, but I am sure you could figure out a way of doing this without fingers if it scares you. I then press the wedge in by hand until it holds the blade. Take my fingers away, and tap the wedge so it firmly holds the blade (and take it down a little also).

One of the keys is that while you want the wedge to retain the blade, if you push it in too hard then the blade doesn't adjust accurately. Just be aware that brute force isn't the key. Once everything is ready, start taping on the blade, and checking the cut, until it cuts the way you want it to. The adjustment is very precise, and does not take a master craftsman. There is zero backlash, and if the blade breaks loose it won't damage the work, it simply backs out of it. Normally it is best to start short of the depth you want and work up to it. The blade can be backed out, but normally if I gets too deep I prefer to start over. Same really with screw adjusts.

The point of the fingers is to get the blade real close to cutting so that the tap and try process does not get tedious. What doesn't work so well is that if you have the blade set too high the tension you have on the wedge to move the blade a lot, is not good for moving it very small amounts. I can get the blade out, sharpened, and back to work with less effort with a wedge than with mechanical types. A Norris type adjuster is great also, but no practical advantage and slow in it's own way. It is critical to develop a feel for the initial blade projection, the wedge set, and the hammer weight so that one can make precise adjustments. But it shouldn't take for ever for this to happen if you are looking for the right kind of indicators.

While a screw mechanism seems very scientific compared to a hammer, the reality is that a properly weighted hammer will only press the blade down so much per tap. It is completely predictable. Screws on the other hand have to be very well made, few planes actually have good tolerances in all their fittings. There are still issues with the friction required to break screws over, and how much the blade will move, any backlash, tendency to loosen etc... All the issues about setting up pre-loads in the system, are exactly the same, and generally worse. There is a whole class of musical instruments called percussion instruments, from pianos to drums. These are very expressive instruments even though they are hit with a hammer.

Funny thing about screws. The History channel did the history of torture a few weeks, back, and one of the things that I found amusing was that when thumb screws came out they were regarded as highly sophisticated, apparently machine screws were at the time something special. Rather as electro torture, or chemical, or psych methods would seem advanced in the last century. Seems this reverence for the screw is still there in the plane business. I certainly see screws as very accurate on something like the slides of a milling machine, but most planes don't really get there. Mostly one can accurately with a plane as much in spite of the adjustment's quality as because of them. Wedges are still the class of the field. I suppose technically the wedge and screw are relatives, but most wedges are zero tolerance in fit, and most screws are pretty sloppy. What gives machine tools their supreme accuracy is a wedge that is adjusted by a stack of screws. It is more reminiscent of the plane wedge than it is the screw adjuster.

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#17

Re: Depth of cut

MikeW

>Hello David,

My comment about it being a good tool was because of trying one out. The monkey comment? Well, we call ourselves sick saw monkeys...

I have a pair of woodies, one for the tongue, one for the groove. Both with adjustable fences on the bottom (think moving fillister type of fence). The hardest part of using them is simply setting the fences equally (which is easy-peasy).

Really, match planes such as mine, the original Stanley or the LN repop are what I would consider coarse tools. As such, I doubt anyone would need to set the planes for less than a 10 thou shaving regardless of the wood. Most often one would set them heavier. So the range of acceptable cutting depth is so large that an adjuster would be superfulous. In fact, I would reckon an adjuster would slow down setting up.

Once set for cutting following honing, I doubt I change cutter depth adjustments much at all. I do set the tongue cutter less proud than the groove blade, but that is due to the fact one can see the shoulders on the show-side of the wood where they meet the face of a given board. So for me, having it set to take a little bit less shaving minimizes any surprises as regards grain splitting on the show face.

All that to say, in the context of a match plane, some planes do not "require" an adjuster because they fall into a coarse tool designation. And if they do not add to functionality or facilitate faster set up, they are truly unneeded.

It probably took some marketing genius to figure out they could add adjusters to planes to distinguish themselves from the competition, charge accordingly, all the while hyping some sort of improvement over the non-adjuster planes.

(Then again, only a couple of my hundred or so planes have adjusters anyway so I feel adjusters are simply an unnecessary component to use.)

Take care, Mike

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#18

to claify..

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>"things like adjusters" I meant adjusters to be an example of things that have made tasks easier by mechanical invention/adaptation, the sum of which makes making stuff easier to master today than in 1750. While any one of them alone would not be a significant impediment, the sum of these seemingly simple tasks is daunting. I propose that it is these mechanical things that have enabled the popularity of woodworking today. What is your hypothesis?

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#19

Re: Depth of cut

Joel

>In the 1830's there was an increasing demand for planes of all sorts and wooden wedged planes are very difficult to mass produce in any quality without serious amounts of skilled labor.

In the US Hazard Knowles patented the first iron body plane (1823?) but it was wedged. It took another 40 years before Bailey perfected the iron body plane which not only was mass produceable it also has a fabulous adjuster - which it needed because there was no longer a wedged iron.

THere are a few plane adjuster patents in England mostly dating to the 1890's and later. The Norris adjuster - the only commerically successful infill adjustment dates from 1913.

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#20

Re: Specialty Plane Question

Glenn Madsen

>So now you've seen a bunch of answers from folks probably more experienced than I am. And I haven't read those yet, but will in a moment.

I have a problem with my current plane with the throat jamming. I'm trimming the end grain maple of the body to clean it up, and get the shavings through. Hard maple files slowly, and I'm in the middle of some other projects. If you get the geometry right, it goes quickly. If you do, as I do, fudge a little, and trim to fit, it can take longer. Not as long as it might with brass, but longer. I'm going to try a power tool after the next round of strip abrasives, and see. Right now it cuts well, but jams almost immediately.

David Finck's book is a good one, if you can get a copy. I sold mine to someone who wanted it badly last year...

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#21

Re: to claify..

MikeW

>Hmm. The popularity of woodworking today. I think the popularity has been on a slow simmer since the early 1900s. Picked up some steam in the late 1940s, gained some momentum in the 1950s to 1960s, but hit a growth stride in the later 1970s. I think that growth really began the climb to where we are now in the later 1990s.

So why? Dunno, really. Could be as simple as making stuff with one's own hands.

Certainly more woodworking is done today via machine-based processes than hand tool based. Why? And why is hand tool woodworking seemingly in a growth phase anyway? Does the fact most metal planes today have adjusters have anything to do with woodworking growth in general? And why should hand saws, planes without adjusters, etc., be in any way as popular as they are? As goes hand planes, I would suspect that in the last 10 years as many non-adjuster planes (or more) have been sold as ones with an adjuster. If so, why?

I think that at least from the 1950s onward, much hobby woodworking was done in America with some degree of machinery. Maybe that is your point--machinery is adjustable and preclude more complex hand-eye adjustment. Therefore hobby woodworking could be seen as a direct growth of consumer-grade machinery evolution.

But again, I am uncertain that explains the ever present growth of hand tool woodworking, adjusters or no.

Take care, Mike

who is about to drill for some depth stops on a hand saw tonight...

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#22

Re: I think that's what I said. :)

Todd Stock

>The 3/4" stock issue has no bearing on the depth adjustment issue... working thinner or thicker stock with a #48 or the new L-N will result in an offset tongue, rather than any difference in depth of cut (as correctly noted in MikeW's post).

The Stanley original used a slightly different blade design, but both have a 'stop' consisting of the body casting itself. This is simplicity itself...plane until the work grounds on the casting, and each tongue will be of the same depth assuming the blade is not reset. I've had several #48s, and they all worked well, although the tongue and groove only center on 7/8" stock, versus L-N's 3/4" stock. Other than the fence pivot loosening (something LN addressed with materials use), these planes are just about perfect.

Re: cost engineering at L-N: Good chuckle there...I don't think it enters Tom's mind to consider other tool makers as competition; he does what he sees as needing doing, and charges what he thinks his customers should be willing to pay and what he needs to keep his doors open and his manufacturing in Maine.

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#23

Re: Depth of cut

David Brown

>Joel,

Thanks for this information. It was really interesting and I was a bit surprised that the norris was relatively recent. For some reason, probably because it's part wood and part metal, I thought it was older.

--Dave

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#24

Re: to claify..

David Brown

>Interesting thoughts about the popularity of woodworking. I'll jump in with a thought. The increasing nature of our workforce as service or white collar workers means that many people spend a huge amount of time working with mental type gadgets like computers which are inherently unsatisfying. But crafts in general and woodworking in particular have a tangible result that is satisfying. So maybe because fewer people are working for a living with their hands, they want to work with their hands as a hobby.

That's certainly my story. Computers all day (SAS programming, in case anyone knows what that is or is interested), so I want to work with my hands some in the evening.

Cheers,

--Dave

Re: Specialty Plane Question *LINK*

#25

Re: KISS the wedge is the better screw.

David Brown

>This was a great post and when I make my krenov style plane, I'll come back to it.

--Dave