Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Hand Drills

Posts

Hand Drills

#1

Hand Drills

David Brown

>I know a lot of people collect hand drills like the Miller Falls one, but I was curious if they work well? I'm eyeing the pretty red and black and wondering if they have a lot of runout, either in the chuck or just because they are hand held. Is this something one gets to decorate the shop or are they practical tools? I'm trying to avoid wasting money on tools, so I was curious what people use for boring small holes. It seems they'd be faster than a brace?

Thanks for any advice.

--Dave

Re: Hand Drills

#2

runout

paul womack

>runout below 1/16" (!!) is not an issue with a hand held drill, since the tool isn't held in a fixed position for the runout to have anything to be defined relative to.

BugBear

Re: Hand Drills

#3

Re: runout

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>Runout is measured about the centerline of rotation. It's technically possible to have a run out problem between the chuck and the bit or the bit itself that would manifest in a less than gratifying drilling exerience.

I know what Bugbear is saying tho. In use, the handle of the (I think we're talking about an egg beater) drill can be the component with the runout problem.

Adam

Re: Hand Drills

#4

Nah...don't work,,,,

Todd Hughes

>at all and thats why only about 5 1/2 billion were sold for over a 100 years and today old ones are so scarce and hard to find.

Well known fact that no holes were ever drilled till the electric drill was perfected ....Todd

Re: Hand Drills

#5

Re: Hand Drills

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>so I was curious what people use for boring small holes. It seems they'd be faster than a brace?

Hi Dave

I enjoy using both eggbeaters and braces when I am not in a rush or needing precision. When in a rush, I will still grab my Panasonic. For the ultimate in precise orientation I use the drill press.

I often use an eggbeater to drill pilot holes in difficult places, which I can then more safely enlarge with a power drill ..



I keep an eggbeater and a brace each permanently fitted with a countersink. I find that doing them this way produces a far more accurate hole than one used in a powerdrill.

My favourite eggbeaters are a MF #2 and a MF #5. They are pretty indestructable, so a clean model will likely be a reliable purchase.

Now I want to comment/ask about speed. While I have read articles that recommend more speed = better performance, in my experience this does not matter much for screw holes. I can achieve the same depth with a brace almost as fast as I can with a power drill. The advantage of a brace or an eggbeater (using a twist drill bit) is that you can drill to a depth with greater care/precision than with a power drill. This is important when you want to sneak up on a depth.



The collection ...



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Hand Drills

#6

Hey Derek

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>The more I see of your work the more impressed I am. In contrast to your eye-catching tool space, mine is oh so very utilitarian. I need to get out to the shop more.

Re: Hand Drills

#7

Re: Hand Drills

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi David,

Any method of drilling has a tendency to runout, meaning that the drill bit isn't drilling exactly with you want it to.

If you are drilling in end grain for example, the drill will for sure want to runout if you want the hole to follow a particular grain instead of between the grain. This can even be a problem when using a drillpress.

If you need accuracy, use an awl or sharp scribe to locate the start of the hole. Then drill a pilot hole using a much smaller drill than the finished hole size drill.

Sometimes it is even necassary to use a drill jig, that is if you can clamp it to the work piece.

Always using sharp drills is a good idea too.

Marv

Re: Hand Drills

#8

Re: Hand Drills

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Derek,

Looks like you enjoy your tools as much as you enjoy using them.

Very impressive....

Marv

Re: Hand Drills

#9

Re: Hand Drills

paul womack

>Sometimes it is even necassary to use a drill jig, that is if you can clamp it to the work piece.

I have a small piece of 1/8" scrap mild steel sheet, with a few holes in the sizes I normally use drilled in it.

If I need an accurate hole, I clamp the sheet in place (light cramps), and drill though the hole with an egg beater.

I have no room in my shop for a drill press :-(

BugBear

Re: Hand Drills

#10

Re: Hand Drills *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>For small, relatively shallow holes (up to about 1/8", the sizes you might use for screws up to about #6, like for hardware), I am a major fan of pushdrills (see link, selected because it was the first one Google gave me). These are faster than a teenager who just got a driver's license and the car keys, and convenient as can be.

For holes at or above 1/4", I prefer a brace.

In between - and there are a surprising number of holes needed in between - a good eggbeater drill is just fine. Quality varies with these as with everything else, but a good drill with a long bearing with minimal play will work just fine. Examples: Millers Falls No. 2, Stanley 610 (my current favorite - the various thrust bearings reduce frictional losses), and similar.

That said, about 90% of the holes I create in wood, and 100% of the holes I create in metal, are made by killing electrons, using a cordless drill, hand drill with a cord, or drill press. My most frequently used tool for that 10% done by hand is the pushdrill, which is faster, more efficient, and safer than a power drill for the holes for which it is optimized.

I've thought some about why I often pick up the hand plane and chisels in preference to the belt sander and router, but don't drill many holes by hand, and have concluded that there are two related reasons: 1) the surfaces I can create with hand tools are visible in the finished project, while holes usually aren't; and 2) the material removal I do with the plane and chisel is most often peculiar to the project, shaped by design or correction of my mistakes, and requiring the exercise of you might call judgment and skill (if you could say that with a straight face about my work), while bored holes are all the same shape, varying only by diameter and depth.

But: these powered devices cost me money. If you're a garage sale fan, you can probably pick up an eggbeater drill cheaper than you could buy a decent corded drill at the Borg. In this area, I see decent eggbeaters regularly for $1-2; slightly less frequently, I see the old aluminum-bodied corded drills for a similar price, which defeats my argument, but these are not always ready to go as purchased (cords frayed, etc.).

Todd Hughes was a bit sarcastic - out of character, I know, he must not have had his coffee yet - but you could certainly drill all the holes you need in your woodworking for the rest of your life with a decent eggbeater, a decent brace, and bits to fit.


a bit about pushdrills

Re: Hand Drills

#11

Re: Hand Drills

ThomD

>I know that jigs are useful, and use them myself, but if one is responding to the OP, most jigs are probably a lot looser than the runout in most drills. You get them down to a few thou tightness and the drill bit won't be turning without oil!

I have oaccasionally milled wood, like doing a repair where one has a dowel that is harder than surrounding wood but won't come out. Mills are good because they don't follow the grain. But the average drilling job probably has more to do with the quality of the bit and the quality of the grain than it has to do with the drill.

Re: Hand Drills

#12

I find them useful......

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>for drilling pilot holes. When house trimming I mount the correct sized drill for each sized nail in use in each of my several models. I like ones with a total of 3 gears (one big and two small) as I think they run smoother. I just finished drilling pilot holes for brads with one. They have so much better control with a tiny #35 drill, for example, than a power drill. They are a must have tool in my shop.

For large holes I find them a poor substitute for a power hand drill.

Re: Hand Drills

#13

What is runout?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Hand Drills

#14

:)

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Hand Drills

#15

Re: What is runout?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>In a perfect spindle, the centerline of the spindle would not waver as the spindle rotated. Since perfection isn't going to happen any time soon, the term "runout" is often applied to spindles on which the runout exceeds whatever tolerance is appropriate to the tool (tolerance is lower, for instance, for toolmaker's lathes than for oilfield drills); people will say that a tool within the tolerances "doesn't have any runout."

In a chucked tool - eggbeater drill, drill press, router, lathe - runout is properly measured at the effective centerline of something chucked in the tool, since the chuck itself may have variations that result in the tool chucking up non-concentrically to the spindle.

This differs from play, in which the tolerance between the spindle and its bearings is high enough, whether from design, poor construction, or wear, that the spindle wobbles about within the bearing.

Runout will be consistent, since it expresses a lack of perfection in the spindle or chuck, and the imperfection remains in the same place on the spindle (absent new bending or other changes); play will not necessarily be consistent.

In my experience with eggbeater drills, play is more commonly an obvious issue than runout. It's part of why the Millers-Falls No. 2 is considered a desirable drill - it's got a long bearing just behind the chuck made of cast iron, and thus subject to lower wear than drills on which the bearing is shorter, further from the chuck (thus permitting any play to be exaggerated), or made from a soft metal that will wear faster.

Re: Hand Drills

#16

Never mind. Thanks, Marv.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Hand Drills

#17

Re: What is runout?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Thanks, Bill. I always assume that the resulting hole won't be exactly where I want it; but get close by punching a starter hole before drilling.

Pam

Re: Hand Drills

#18

Re: Hand Drills

Philip Duffy

>I used 2 different ones this morning and what I observed was that one of the bits was crooked! The other one was perfectly straight and the holes look clean as a whistle. There is a way to straighten a drill bit and I have used it many times. Chuck it up in a drill press; get a small hammer and tap on the drill bit as it turns at a pretty good speed. After a few taps it should be running pretty straight. This trick came from on old machinist friend of mine who is now a Master Gunsmith and quite a guy! Phil

Re: Hand Drills

#19

Re: What is runout?

Alex Grigoriev

>Can you believe that it's possible to mass-produce ball bearings with sub-micron runout and play. That's what we have in the computer hard drives.

Re: Hand Drills

#20

Re: Hand Drills

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Dave,

Run-out is usually something that occurs with fast turning motorized machinery after much use and wear, such as a lathe or milling machine or drillpress to mention only a few examples. A spindle will appear to be running true until pressure is applied. When pressure is applied, that's when the "run-out" shows up.

With a hand drill such as an eggbeater, because of it's very low RPM, there would have to be a huge amount of wear to the spindle and it's bearings in order to notice much, if any "run-out".

I took your question to mean, "will an eggbeater type drill, drill where you want it to drill and do it as accurately as a drill motor without the consideration of wear, etc.

If you get anything that resembles run-out in a hand tool, it would most likey be considered to be worn out.

Marv

Re: Hand Drills

#21

Re: What is runout?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hard drive mechanisms are unbelievably precise and reliable from a mechanical standpoint. Most rotate at 7200 RPM, some even faster and will run 24/7 and remain stable and accurate. If they vary a few microns, they will crash. They all have a life span though, so back up your stuff. Compare that to a Millers Falls No.2 eggbeater...*grin*

Marv

Pam, I'm sure you could give us all lessons on the subject of hard drive reliability. I've only been mess'n with the things since 1994 and I know less than zero about designing/writing software. I know a little about some machinery and can appreciate to a small degree what a hard drive does.

Re: Hand Drills

#22

Re: What is runout?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I'm primarily a software person, know very little about how hardware devices are built; but hard drive failure is so prevalent that I know a lot about swapping drives in notebooks and desktops (we haven't bought a new one of these for 10 years, only notebooks) and logic board failure in notebooks. One of the biggest problems is heat, which tells me we'll all be better off when we innovate ourselves out of electro-mechanical devices and start using pure electrical, such as flash memory. And then we can talk about biological memories.

I always buy extended warranties on the notebooks, and have always collected; although the latest MacBook I got last year seems hardier than usual.

Pam

Re: Hand Drills

#23

why does this work?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I saw a master turner (Alan Batty) do this on a lathe. He re-chucked something already round where the center had been "lost" on the tail end. At first it was substanitally out of center. With the lathe running at fairly high speed he rapidly tapped on the piece with a mallet and in short order it was centered to a few thousandths of an inch. I was so astonished that I forgot to ask how/why it worked or whether some secret tapping technique had been employed. Now I learn it works on drills. I am still flummoxed. It's right up there with the best magic tricks. What's the secret?

Re: Hand Drills

#24

OT....Laptops...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Didn't we used to call them "laptops"? I've never owned one. Anytime I spend lots of money I want something substantial if at all possible. I guess that's why I hate jewelry.

I've always felt that they were just trying to stuff way too much stuff into a small package with a notebook/laptop. Then there's that little bitty keyboard. I'm constantly fat-fingering this big one I have here. If it wasn't for the "backspace" button, you couldn't read this. I wear all the white lettering off that button in about 5 months.

Marv

Re: Hand Drills

#25

Re: why does this work?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Bill,

You have to be very quck and hit it on the rise. It's a matter of timing. If you don't hit it on the rise, you make it worse.

Marv