Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Carving Chisel Recommendations

Posts

Carving Chisel Recommendations

#1

Carving Chisel Recommendations

David

>I figure I'm going to open a can of worms with this one, but if too many crawl out I guess I can always go fishing.

I'm looking to buy a set of carving chisels and am unsure of which to get. I prefer longer chisels (London Pattern?) and thus have been looking at Sorby and Ashley Iles. I've also considered Two Cherries and Pfeil which are about the same size. I realize I'm looking at two different systems, which at this point doesn't matter much to me. My concern has to do with overall quality. From what I've been able to find, Sorby and Iles seem to have better finish from the factory.

Does anyone have experience or suggestions regarding any of these brands? (or others that you may feel are superior?)

I usually have no problem rehabing old chisels but would like to start with something new this time (besides, they're a birthday present!).

This also may sound stupid, but is there any reason to get straight edged carving chisels if one has good bench chisels?

Re: Carving Chisel Recommendations

#2

Re: Carving Chisel Recommendations *LINK*

Dan Donaldson

>I use mostly the Pfiel and like them, but most any of the brands would be ok if you like the feel. A straight carving tool is usually sharpened from both sides, more like a knife rather than a chisel. This allows you to run the cut up and out of the material rather than diving in. I would think carefully before I bought a set. Make sure that the set includes the tools that you will use the most.

The attached link is to a page that Lee Grindinger put together that tells a lot about carving tools and gives his list of the first 12 you should buy and why.


Lee's Dirty Dozen

Re: Carving Chisel Recommendations

#3

Re: Carving Chisel Recommendations

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi David,

I have Ashley Iles, Two Cherries, Pfeil, and a few Stubai. They're all good and the steel is all good, but there are differences. For example, the Stubai (that I have at least) are 'nosed', whereas all the others are square-shouldered.

Joel covers the differences between Ashley Iles and Two Cherries very well at his Tools for Working Wood website. It's a good read. I like the Ashley Iles round handles, for no particular reason--you might prefer the hexagonal or octagonal Two Cherries or Pfeil. As Joel points out, the Ashley Iles are a heavier gouge than Two Cherries (or Pfeil for that matter), and have a shorter bevel. I don't hold myself out as a carver, but when I've done carving, I preferred the longer flatter bevel of the Two Cherries and Pfeils. Of course, I can put a long bevel on an Ashley Iles, but it's a considerable amount of grinding.

Initial sharpness. Have you done much gouge sharpening? If not, you might want a couple of Pfeils because they come sharp from the factory, which teaches you what 'sharp' means in a gouge. It's the one drop-dead absolute requirement in a gouge. The Ashley Iles are very nearly sharp, meaning they only need a stropping to be sharp, which again gives you some idea of what your resharpenings should achieve. The Two Cherries have a decent bevel, but will need full honing--so if you buy them, your first task is going to be to sit down and spend some considerable amount of time sharpening them. No problem if you're an old hand at sharpening gouges, but a considerable task if you're new to it.

Sets. I really recommend you consider making up your initial set by buying individual chisels, such as those from Lee Grindinger's dirty dozen list. Those are all useful sizes. Every ready-made set I have ever seen has one or two really off the wall sizes. For example, there is a Two Cherries set which includes a 14mm veiner (No. 11). Well, maybe somebody will write in and say 'Wiley, you're nuts, a 14mm #11 is a gotta have gouge', but I don't think I would ever use that one. So IMO the economy to be achieved by buying a ready-made set is questionable.

Something you might consider. Get a couple each of Pfeil, Ashley Iles, Two Cherries, and find out which you prefer. There's no advantage in having all the handles look the same in the rack--in fact, when they're different, it's easier to spot the one you're looking for. Just be aware that the Swiss/German makes differ by one sweep from the comparable Sheffield sweep: For example, a #6 sweep Ashley Iles will be approximately the same as the #7 Pfeil or Two Cherries of the same width.

Wiley

Re: Carving Chisel Recommendations

#4

Re: Carving Chisel Recommendations

David

>These are really good points. Part of my research led me to Lee Grindinger's website as well as a couple of others. Sharp, really sharp, from the start is kind of important. I've got little experience sharpening gouges and those I've done haven't been really sharp (unlike the plane iron I sliced my thumb open with yesterday while wiping it down, but that's another story).

I think putting together my first set is the way to go.

Thanks,

DGW

Re: Carving Chisel Recommendations

#5

Re: Carving Chisel Recommendations *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Mostly I have Dastra, Addis, and Takahashi; and love them all. Nothing wrong with the few Pfeils and Stubai I've got either. But they're all very different and intended for different uses. For example: a full set of spoon gouges by Addis; really tiny Dastras; big spoon type gouges by Takahashi (and one by Tasai); and more regular gouges by Dastra, Pfeil, and Stubai. They all work with aplomb, hold edges forever. Most are used that I obtained on ebay. It was delightful watching for them and using them after arrival.

So, try a couple or three as you need them (I'd watch out for used Sorby and Taylor, though, as they had some tempering problems a few years ago). As your needs change, get some more.

Pam


Takahashi chisels

Re: Carving Chisel Recommendations

#6

Re: Carving Chisel Recommendations

Tony - Memphis

>I've been using the Pfeil for several years. Never had an issue with them. I tried the Taylor brand initially, but had problems with those holding an edge. I returned them and bought the Pfeil.

I'd be cautious buying a "set" of carving chisels. What you nedd really depends on what you want to carve. I would start with a particular project (pick a good magazine step-by-step article or a book) and buy whta is needed. At ~$30 ea, you'd hate to end up with tools you don't use. I'd invest in a good set of oil stones too. If you do much carving, you'll need to know how to sharpen the tools. Sharp tools make a big difference in carving.

Good luck with it. I'm no expert, but I enjoy carving. I have no idea what you want to carve, but Woodcarving magazine has good follow along articles. There have been a few good articles in FWW too. My interest is in 18th century furniture carving, so I have carved some ball and clae feet, fans, a few leaves, medallions, etc.

Oh, there is an outfit or two in Canada that sell Pfeil cheaper than Woodcraft - even with shipping. Of course, it seems like woodworking companies have been pretty generous with their free shipping offers lately. Anything to help us spend our money during these rough times. Hope it works!

Tony

Re: Carving Chisel Recommendations

#7

Re: Carving Chisel Recommendations

David

>I think part of my problem is not knowing what I want to carve. Largely I've been thinking about adding decorative geometrics to flat pieces or carvings to accent larger elements, similar to how you'd see a carving that mimics the cloud lift on a Greene and Greene piece. Also to add relief to curved elements. From there, who knows.

I do appreciate everyone's suggestions.

Re: Carving Chisel Recommendations

#8

Re: Carving Chisel Recommendations

Pat Riley

>Quite a while ago, Lee recommended Lamp Brand chisels to me. You can get them from woodcarverssupply.com. I don't have many carving tools to compare with. But when I buy more, I will be buying Lamp brand