Re: Carving Chisel Recommendations
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Hi David,
I have Ashley Iles, Two Cherries, Pfeil, and a few Stubai. They're all good and the steel is all good, but there are differences. For example, the Stubai (that I have at least) are 'nosed', whereas all the others are square-shouldered.
Joel covers the differences between Ashley Iles and Two Cherries very well at his Tools for Working Wood website. It's a good read. I like the Ashley Iles round handles, for no particular reason--you might prefer the hexagonal or octagonal Two Cherries or Pfeil. As Joel points out, the Ashley Iles are a heavier gouge than Two Cherries (or Pfeil for that matter), and have a shorter bevel. I don't hold myself out as a carver, but when I've done carving, I preferred the longer flatter bevel of the Two Cherries and Pfeils. Of course, I can put a long bevel on an Ashley Iles, but it's a considerable amount of grinding.
Initial sharpness. Have you done much gouge sharpening? If not, you might want a couple of Pfeils because they come sharp from the factory, which teaches you what 'sharp' means in a gouge. It's the one drop-dead absolute requirement in a gouge. The Ashley Iles are very nearly sharp, meaning they only need a stropping to be sharp, which again gives you some idea of what your resharpenings should achieve. The Two Cherries have a decent bevel, but will need full honing--so if you buy them, your first task is going to be to sit down and spend some considerable amount of time sharpening them. No problem if you're an old hand at sharpening gouges, but a considerable task if you're new to it.
Sets. I really recommend you consider making up your initial set by buying individual chisels, such as those from Lee Grindinger's dirty dozen list. Those are all useful sizes. Every ready-made set I have ever seen has one or two really off the wall sizes. For example, there is a Two Cherries set which includes a 14mm veiner (No. 11). Well, maybe somebody will write in and say 'Wiley, you're nuts, a 14mm #11 is a gotta have gouge', but I don't think I would ever use that one. So IMO the economy to be achieved by buying a ready-made set is questionable.
Something you might consider. Get a couple each of Pfeil, Ashley Iles, Two Cherries, and find out which you prefer. There's no advantage in having all the handles look the same in the rack--in fact, when they're different, it's easier to spot the one you're looking for. Just be aware that the Swiss/German makes differ by one sweep from the comparable Sheffield sweep: For example, a #6 sweep Ashley Iles will be approximately the same as the #7 Pfeil or Two Cherries of the same width.
Wiley