Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

chisel

Posts

Re: chisel

#26

Calling Dave Burnard!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Adam,

I'm pretty sure that Harrelson believes that your explanation is the origin of the hollow. I'm recalling from a forum discussion several years ago (which I can't find now), but I'm pretty sure it was Harrelson who brought that theory forward.

Even today, among some of the cognoscenti, a blackened hollow is more desired than the modern machined hollow, or even the modern throwback to the old days, the scraped hollow. The blackened hollow would seem to hark back to the post heat treat and unscraped state.

Perhaps Dave Burnard could comment further on this.

Wiley

Re: chisel

#27

you are correct

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Steel hardness and abrasion resistance are independent steel properties. Abrasion resistance can be imparted by inclusion of alloying elements that make abrasion resistant carbides, for example vanadium. With modern sharpening technology the steel on the back of a Japanese chisel presents no particular challenge to abrading. The hollow may now be the equivalent of the nib on an old western saw.

Re: chisel

#28

Re: hollow backed chisels

wilbur

>Hi Adam,

So I went back to read through Toshio Odate's book again, and noted a few things.

1. He states that the hollow is for both "faster sharpening and to maintain flatness". In hindsight, this should not be a huge surprise -- why shouldn't a feature of a tool serve two purposes?

2. Here's a summary of his description of making a Japanese plane blade -- not a chisel, but the basic process is the same:

Heat the soft steel layer, add flux to it to prepare for the forge welding. Place the hard steel layer on, and forge weld it at 900-950�C while simultaneously making it the proper width and thickness.

Cool it to 800-900�C, and form the rough shape with more hammering. This is one of the main steps that distinguish the cheap Japanese tools from the expensive ones. Cheaper tools are die-stamped, and skip this step. My bet is that this step plays a main role in the formation of the metal crystals in the tool, and the more hammering, the finer the crystals are, which probably leads to being able to take a sharper edge.

Shear the piece to length.

Anneal the tool by reheating to 750-770�C for 8-10 hours.

Roughly grind the back of the tool and form the upper part. The hollow in the back is hammered out (this was a surprise to me), and the edges and the top are ground to shape. At this point, "any distortion is straightened out". Finish grinding and lapping are done here.

The tool is coated with a mixture of stone powder and a carbonizing mud. Depending on the particular hard layer, the blade might be also packed in charcoal to add more carbon to the steel. It's tempered by heating to 800�C and quenched in water. Part of the purpose of the coating is to help the tool cool more uniformly when plunged into the water, and part of the purpose is to give Japanese tools their color.

Distortion is again straightened out, and annealing is done by heating in oil to 170�C, and slowly cooled.

Finally, the back of the tool is again finished with waterstones, as well as the edges of the tool, and the bevel side sharpened.

As far as the cutting ability of natural abrasives, I've played around a little with coarser natural Japanese waterstones, and they cut faster than I thought they would. I'll have to play around some more. But even with modern abrasives, I find flattening the back to be one of my least favorite things to do.

Re: chisel

#29

Hi N orm, Or can a call you Mr. Thomas...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Seeing in this long stream of posts no one has answered your question.

The back of Japanese chisels are made to be flattened every time you sharpen the cutting edge. So I reality the hollow always remains the same. Kinda like Led Zeppelin.