chisel
N orm
>Question? Why are the flat side of Japanese chisels hollow ground? It seems to me that this limits how many times you can sharpen them. Norm,Camillus NY
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
chisel
N orm
>Question? Why are the flat side of Japanese chisels hollow ground? It seems to me that this limits how many times you can sharpen them. Norm,Camillus NY
Re: chisel
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>All chisels have a built in limited number of sharpening events in them, so that's a true statement that also applies to western chisels.
What the ground hollow allows is faster back flattening.
Pam
Re: chisel
wilbur
>Japanese chisels are made with two types of steel forge welded together. The bottom layer is really really really hard, and takes a very sharp edge. It is also somewhat brittle, and the chisel would easily break if that's all the chisel was made out of. The top layer is softer, and provides cushioning for the bottom layer, which takes care of the brittleness issue.
The bottom hard layer is so hard that if you were working on flattening the back, it would take you forever if the back of the Japanese chisel was completely flat like a western chisel. The hollow is put in so that you only have to remove a minimal amount of the super hard steel to achieve a flat area on the back.
In actual use, you don't have to worry about sharpening the bevel into the hollow for the most part. In the process of sharpening, you'll wind up working on the back, which removes metal, which moves the edge of the hollow back away from the edge. The only time the hollow might be an immediate issue is if the chisel gets chipped, and you have to remove a lot of metal all at once to get rid of the chip. There is a process called "tapping out" that can be used in this situation.
The other thing is that the hollow looks deeper than it actually is. I once measured the hollow of my Japanese chisels, and was very surprised to find that the hollow is on the order of 1/64". I would have sworn that it was deeper before I measured it.
Wilbur...as usual you have
Stuart Hough
>made things less mysterious. I have always wondered about the hollow...now it makes perfect sense!
Re: Hollow argument
ThomD
>It doesn't really make that much sense because the explanation given which is the official explanation to the extent that there is one, presupposes two things that are based on slop:
These are the best chisels in the world, but we really really care how long it take to do the first flattening of the back and subjugate the overall design to that fact;
and we come from a culture that really doesn't much like doing a decent job of flattening, polishing etc...
Whereas, the design of Japanese tools is pretty much without compromise, and their willingness to sharpen until the cows come home is about as developed as it gets. Think sword polishers, after you think for a moment of the idea that Japanese tool makers are the descendants of sword makers post the ban on swords.
What makes sense is that the hollow balances out the amount of the area of the back of the blade with the bevel side of the blade. This is important cause it makes both surfaces similarly sticky to a given stone, at least compared to not doing it, and makes it possible to bring both sides up to a similar polish without needing a different sequence for the front and back of the blade.
As an aside, when I started with the woodworking thing, and the knife thing back in the late 70s, two things one rarely hears about today were typical about western sharpening then. One is that one did not go back and forth on the bevel (let alone side to side), one read arguments about whether one should sharpen towards the edge or away from it. The other was the idea that one prepped the back and thereafter rarely touched it unless is got all marked up, and needed repolishing. One was told to simply sharpen the bevel for the most part. So it is easy to imagine how the idea that a hollow is for making a back easy to prep got a start in the west. The treatment of the Japanese chisel faces has always been more bilateral.
This also all plays into the idea that multi hollow chisels are less efficient (not sure where the Zeitgeist is on that), since they add back in a lot of steel, particularly as wear starts that doesn't do much for the chisel's sharpening. So the trade-off is that one gets some largely illusory additional cutting stability, which apparently is only required by a minority of craftsmen, but gives up some of the sharpening advantage of the single hollow.
Hollow grinding?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>What is the opinion on hollow grinding J chisels?
David Charlesworth is a fan of doing so. I have done a couple this way on my Tormek (keeps the heat down - I would not try it on my half-speed grinder). I have not experienced any problems with chipping or loss of temper, and there is the advantage of super quick rehoning of a (coplanar) microbevel over the slower honing of a full face. However this is very much non-traditional and I have reserved this as an experiment with a few, cheaper chisels only.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Hollow argument
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>And then it could be a holdover from habits formed when steel was very, very expensive. Of course, that explanation requires a good way to remove the steel in the hollow so it could have been reused, better than the grinding that's reputed to be used today.
Pam
Re: Hollow grinding?
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>I don't do it, because I prefer using stones to grinders and because I think it could remove needed support for the edge (I have no idea whether this is true or not).
Pam
Re: Hollow grinding?
Brent Smith, Montreal
>I don't do it for 2 reasons. First, because traditionally it's not done that way. Second, while I will take Western chisels to a wheel, I enjoy working my Japanese chisels over the stones. Neither reason is based in practicality, but just the way I feel about it.
Re: Hollow grinding?
wilbur
>Hi Derek,
I've put a Japanese chisel on a Tormek for three situations:
1. I wanted to change the bevel angle, and the Tormek was a faster way to do it.
2. I needed to do some major rehab on a nick
3. When I found it hard to sharpen the bevel side because the bevel had become convex, due to my crappy sharpening technique.
I've also done the same thing with plane blades.
The main arguments I've heard against hollow grinds on a Japanese blade has to do with the support that the soft layer provides to the hard layer. Supposedly, the hollow will remove some of the soft layer, making the hard layer more prone to chips/cracks since the soft layer isn't there for support. I haven't really found that to be true, although I would guess if you really stressed a hollow ground Japanese chisel (chopping tropical wood end grain) you might see a difference.
The second issue is changing the temper with grinding. On a Tormek or other water-based system that's not going to be an issue, but it could very well be an issue with a dry wheel grinder. My understanding is that the high carbon steel used in Japanese chisels can lose their temper more quickly if overheated than, say, A2 steel.
I do think that Japanese chisels and plane blades look much nicer without the hollow grind. :@)
Re: Hollow grinding?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>My understanding is that the high carbon steel used in Japanese chisels can lose their temper more quickly if overheated than, say, A2 steel.
Hi Wilbur
One must be careful when grinding any blade, Western or Japanese. I have 1/8" and 1/4" Matsumura dovetail chisels in which I ground the sides to a sharp arris on a belt sander. The temper was not affected.
I do think that Japanese chisels and plane blades look much nicer without the hollow grind.
I have 6 Kiyohisa slicks arriving shortly (beep .. beep). They will most definitely be respected in the traditional way.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Hollow grinding?
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Hi Derek,
You're in good company, in addition to Mr. Charlesworth. Krenov describes doing it in one of his books, and shows a picture. He didn't say what he used for grinding, but the hollow is fairly shallow. Harrelson at one time hollow ground with a Tormek, and may still for all I know--worth asking him sometime.
That is a meep meep on the Kiyohisa's. I'm waiting for slicks also.
Wiley
Hi Wiley ...
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>... I did not know that about JK or Harrelson. I must look up the info in JK's books. As far as I recall, he did all his grinding with a 6" hand grinder. That would not have left a shallow hollow (as would the Tormek's 10" wheel).
With regard the Kiyohisa slicks, I knew that you were also waiting on some! That is why I mentioned it - I thought it would grab your attention. I've been waiting about 12 months so far. I assume you are also getting them through So? Are yours to be Mentori (my preference) or Shinogi style?
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Hi Wiley ... *LINK*
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Derek,
You are exactly right about the 6" wheel. I was wrong. Krenov shows photo of hollow-ground Japanese chisels on pp. 115 and 148 of The Fine Art of Cabinetmaking. It was the bottom photo on p. 148 that stuck in my head--it appears a shallow cut, and I made the wrong inference. So thanks.
Yes, I ordered the mentori style (flat back, beveled). From So (link below for those interested). I had earlier obtained a singleton Kiyohisa, a chu tataki, and its simplicity is its beauty. The steel is great, as far as I have tested it so far. Hard but not brittle. He tempers to 180C (~356F), which I think would bring the white steel #1 out to about Rc64.
Please post photos of yours when they arrive. I don't have a delivery date on mine.
Re: Hi Wiley ...
Raney
>Shhhhhh. Keep it down - I'm in the process of setting up an order with So for those slicks as well... are you fellows trying to start a run on me? A year + is long enough!
Re: Hollow grinding?
ThomD
>I don't hollow grind Japanese chisels, even if I was treating them as disposable, because one is left with a super hard edge, and a super soft edge resting on the stone while sharpening the bevel. This virtually guarantees that the edge will not be worked properly, or the sharpening will be awkward since one will have to bias the front, which is not something one does in good sharpening. If one were doing all the sharpening in a jig it would be manageable, though I would still prefer to just use something like an LV jig if I could get it to hold a chisel properly. I would prefer a microbevel approach.
I wouldn't go screaming out of the building if I ended up with a hollow grind I just don't see the point.
It is pretty easy to avoid drawing the temper on a dry grinder, so that wouldn't worry me at this stage.
At a more refined level, there is the whole thing where Japanese carpenters say stuff like sharpening once on a Shapton would ruin years of conditioning they have invested in their chisels. I don't get that, but I wouldn't utterly dismiss it since there is more out there to learn. But obviously at that level the kind of shortcuts we are talking about would be anathema.
The Japanese make chisels with HSS blades that are excellent, planes also. Dick's sold the most recent ones I saw, though I couldn't get on their website last time I tried. HSS chisles should subjugate themselves to automated sharpening rather well. Flat grinding on a proper belt sander is normally preferable for any of this kind of work.
Re: Hollow grinding?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>I don't hollow grind Japanese chisels, even if I was treating them as disposable, because one is left with a super hard edge, and a super soft edge resting on the stone while sharpening the bevel. This virtually guarantees that the edge will not be worked properly, or the sharpening will be awkward since one will have to bias the front
Hi Thom
When I first read this I thought, "that is so logical". Upon reflection (not practice), my conclusion was that this situation should apply similarly to a flat bevel - that is, the soft steel support will abrade faster than the hard steel. In theory again, what would make a hollow grind work is if you grind to the very edge of the hard steel. The resulting honing creates a microbevel, that is, very little of the hard steel needs to be removed. Moving the hand pressure forward to the bevel edge and lightening up at the hand end helps also to enable the abrading to take place where it is wanted.
I agree with you that there is so much to learn about Japanese blades and metalurgy and that I/we simply cannot appreciate these issues at this time. Perhaps never. For me hollow grinding of J chisels is limited to a few on an experimental basis. For the rest, what I like about the flat bevels is that the traditional full face honing is a time for quiet reflection, not a quick, harried swipe over a stone or strop to get back to work ASAP.
With regard a secondary bevel - you noted that you add one. The Krenov pictures (I looked up Wiley's references) show him using a secondary bevel on his J chisels - I try to avoid these on chisels that will be used for paring. Chopping is different. With paring there is going to be a need to use the chisel bevel down at some point, and a secondary bevel will remove the coplanarity (is there such a term?) of the bevel face. Yes I know that you can use a chisel BD with a secondary microbevel, but the addition of one makes the task more difficult.
Regards from Perth
Derek
hardness vsease of sharpening
Frank D. in Montreal
>I still wonder if Japanese chisels would be so hard to flatten if the backs were flat. While the hard steel on Japanese chisels is harder than the steel on most western chisels (RC 63-5 vs RC 60-2), IME it sharpens easier than steels that are usually softer, like A2 and stainless (often RC 58-60).
I grind my Japanese chisels
Steve Elliott
>I've been grinding my Japanese chisels on a Tormek for quite a few years now and they seem to perform just as well as they did when sharpened solely on waterstones.
I found out the hard way that too much pressure on the stone can cause chipping of the hard steel edge, but that only happened to me once.
My chisels get hard use at my job where speed is a big concern. I do all my sharpening at home on my own time because I'm very particular about getting things just right. After grinding a chisel I only hone on my finest waterstone for about 30 seconds freehand and have a wonderfully sharp edge. By the time I sharpen again I've usually put at least a few small nicks in the edge and want to grind a little to speed up the sharpening process.
As for arguments that the quality of the steel is affected by use of the "wrong" stone I prefer not to get drawn into the discussion. My experience has been that a carefully ground and honed edge works as well as any edge I've ever used, and I've spent some time exploring sharpening methods and the resulting edge quality. For me speed trumps the other possible issues.
Re: Hollow grinding?
ThomD
>I agree it is a mater of degree. But that still is an important effect in this case. It's tough to get all the weight out because of hte handle weight I like to press down in the middle of the bevel.
Another issue, not sure if this has been mentioned, but the theory goes the Japanese choose old iron from chains and such for the iron in better tools because it helps keeps the stone clean. So if one ground away a lot of the iron, one would be undermining a thing one paid for in the chisel.
I can't recall if this has been clarified, but I have not ground back on a wheel my chisels on the odd occasion they have been chipped. I use a green stone for the most part, I have occasionally reground whole chisels though. I would not be adverse to hollow grinding to take a chip out. A hollow grind is a survivable condition in a Japanese chisel (at least at our level, if not the grand master level), it just isn't optimal for the type. Of course there are variables. Good chisels vs. high quality ones. Temp hollows vs, permanent. Hand sharpening vs. machine or jigs. HSS vs other stuff. No one right answer except in general.
"Moving the hand pressure forward to the bevel edge and lightening up at the hand end helps also to enable the abrading to take place where it is wanted."
That to me is a micro bevel kind of thinking (no harm no foul). What I am thinking when sharpening is that I am leveling the whole bevel to a flat, not rounding forward. Whether there is any meaningful difference is another mater. I just want stuff to be flat when I want it to be flat. That's craftsmanship ability to aim and acheive a given result which in my case is the whole bevel thing. If anything I am trying to hollow out the center of the bevel, and letting the rest fall in place.
"For the rest, what I like about the flat bevels is that the traditional full face honing is a time for quiet reflection, not a quick, harried swipe over a stone or strop to get back to work ASAP."
Ideally all the work would fall into some kind of patient acceptance of the actual time required to get the thing that needs to be done without either playing it up or down. Unfortunately I have kinda lost sight of balance in my work, I like to go off in too many directions.
I rarely ever use a micro bevel though I did modify some Jap. chisels that were surplus, to a Krenov pattern to see what he was on about. They really do work wonderfully, better than the DT chisels. I don't think the point there is micro bevels, as for sharpening, it is to have a minimal bevel. Krenov has a concern about the chisels diving. He uses (at time of publishing anyway) a fence for alignment. He is after perfect dovetails in hard woods. Using a guide along with a chisel with a fairly non-existent bevel is one option. It works well though there are doubtless other options. Another method I tried was a chisel that tapers right to the point, and has only the minimal required bevel to have sufficient edge durability. This is mostly a technique for medium softish woods that can be pierced in a few wacks. Small bevel doesn't equal micro bevel.
While people are going to do whatever they want with Japanese tools, and like you, Derek, I have experimented from time to time. There is enough content in the Japanese tool experience that I want to spend most of my time getting at what is there rather than applying my stuff on top. I guess I respect what they are up to enough not to mess with it. I was salvaging some parts off a horizontal mill today to use on something I am building. This project is one where I can let my creativity reign, but even with these rusted shut hulks, I do have some qualms about wrecking the old machine to salvage parts I need. Silly really. Probably goes back to having been brought up to not turn down the corners on books. :)
Re: Long row to hoe
ThomD
>Another reason why the argument that hollows are to make a chisel easier to flatten seems incomplete is that over the life of a chisel one will actually have to remove far more metal from the back. One will essentially not just be removing whatever imperfections are there in the flat back, but all the steel required to eliminate the hollow itself, and then some. That makes no sense. If the backs are so hard they require hollows but the hollows require removing far more of the back, where is the logic?
One could argue it is like buying on credit, costs more in the long run, but at least one can get in. But overall that would be just one more argument of the type that suggest the reason is because of compromise, not uncompromising pursuit of excellence.
If one accepts my explanation that the hollow is for sharpening then the hollow makes sense whether it is in HSS or Japanese steel. Of course the culture that created these things was reputedly not all that interested in questions and answers, so unless reasons have been preserved somewhere, we really don't have much to go on for sure. I do think that the it's-easy-to-flatten explanation, really reeks of someone explaining a benefit to a newbie at a time when all chisels required a lot of prep work, in the pre-modern LN and LV, etc... age.
Re: I grind my Japanese chisels
ThomD
>"I found out the hard way that too much pressure on the stone can cause chipping of the hard steel edge, but that only happened to me once."
If I was trying to design the perfect chisel for you, I would wonder why a laminated chisel would be of any help to you. Possibly slightly faster to grind on your tomek, but you have apparently undermined the edge a little. It all works great for you, which is what counts.
"By the time I sharpen again I've usually put at least a few small nicks in the edge and want to grind a little to speed up the sharpening process."
This sounds like you are whipping through steel. I have chisels that cost me... well too much, I don't grind those ones because it's like drinking a fine wine with two straws. I almost "never" get nicks, because I don't ever pry. I rarely get them when I do pry. The sequence you describe is a little more like how I would do western tools. Kinda like what I do with machine tools. There the tool is a little 88 cent piece of HSS steel and it gives good service, and none of these issues ever come up, pure utility.
"As for arguments that the quality of the steel is affected by use of the "wrong" stone I prefer not to get drawn into the discussion. My experience has been that a carefully ground and honed edge works as well as any edge I've ever used, and I've spent some time exploring sharpening methods and the resulting edge quality. For me speed trumps the other possible issues."
In fairlness you would have to analyse whether emphasizing speed of sharpening will actually get you more of the other goods at the same time. I have no real idea what these people with their natural stones are talking about. I have a few myself, but nothing like the investment that would be required to go down this path. Maybe Dave B. has done it. I really don't get what could be done to a chisel that couldn't be reversed in the next sharpening. Why it would mater if someone switched from a natural stone to a sharpening on a King, and then back again. I can think of three possible issues, but it would be pure speculation. I am willing to keep an open mind, because I have seen so many cases where the missing issue comes to light eventually, but I sure don't know what it is in this case.
Re: OK now the ironic bit.... $$
ThomD
>I'm selling my Lee Valley water stone grinding wheel thing today. Shot the pictures this afternoon when I came across it in it's NOS condition. I would never sell it except I have never really been able to come up with a place to put it. Always seems to be something else that edges it out for the bench space.
Tool maintenance over time
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Hi All,
Here's what I glean from talking to folks who are the most immersed in the traditional ways. And it's not written down that I know of, because as Thom says, this is a culture where you get with the program, and don't bother your betters with questions. Plus there is a very strong 'arts and mysteries' culture among the smiths, for example--they hold their intellectual property close. It's a competitive business.
But here's what I gather, for whatever it is worth to anyone....The traditional japanese methods result in the best total economy and efficiency over time. They're not thinking about 'gotta get this blade sharp'. Or 'gee, sharpening takes too much time.' They're sharpening nuts over there--there's no issue about whether the blade is gonna be sharp, or if work is involved. Their methods are about managing the edge and the back flatness and the flatness of the neck junction with the back, and even the sharpening stones--over time.
So that, at no time do they pick up a chisel and its got a rounded back and a rounded bevel, and it has become a project. Those conditions come about because of saving time this minute, and paying for it later. They pay up front to keep the tool right.
Some examples....This thread started out with a question about what happens when you sharpen down to the hollow. Well, the reality turns out to be that the real problem is in keeping the hollow, and not sharpening it away. The Japanese, and a number of American practitioners, will tap out a chisel regularly to preserve the hollow. The object is a flat plane consisting of the entire back, and the junction at the neck, along with a little clearance in the shank. The hollow permits flatness to happen. If there is no hollow, then it's like lapping anything else--you go from flat to convex as sure as night follows day. If you want to make something flat by lapping it, first make it concave. And stop lapping while it is still concave, before it rolls over into convexity. It's managing for the long term. Same thing with flat bevels--they're flat bevel nuts over there. A flat bevel is easy to keep flat, and therefore easy to sharpen. But as soon as that bevel starts rolling over into convexity, then you have a big maintenance problem--their view is, don't go there. Keep it flat. No extra bevels. I'm speaking of chisels, but it's same thing with plane blades. Flat bevel at 25 degrees equals good clearance for a 40-degree bedded plane that is planing wood with springback. Start collecting extra bevels and its the same thing as rounding the bevel--you're losing clearance, and headed for a big project of reflattening. Solution: Don't go there, stay flat.
Plane sole maintenance is easier for the long-term if done their way--use hollows. You don't want bumps to spring up in the sole ahead of or behind the blade. Using hollows, you have two flats to maintain, and that's it. Yeah, you have to maintain the hollows in good shape, but their thought is to pay the dues up front and don't let the tool turn into a project over time.
The hollow on the chisel is about maintaining the flatness of the back (up through the neck) over time. Concavity ensures that the things you want coplanar, stay coplanar.
Wiley ....... just my take from what I've gathered over time
What is the efficient way to work.
Re: hollow backed chisels
Adam Cherubini, NJ
>Wilbur,
I made a couple of chisels. Before heat treating, I lapped the annealed steel backs flat. During the quenching phase of heat treating, small tools can distort. Pretty sure Japanese smiths need to use some sort of water or brine as a quenchant to achieve the high Rc hardnesses they get. Water causes the most distortion. Lapping out even .010" of hardned steel is a HUGE DRAG! .010" is not a lot of distortion.
So what I'm thinking is, is it possible Japanese smiths tapped out the backs when the tools were annealed to save THEMSELVES time flattening? Keep in mind that like everybody else, Japan didn't have great coarse abrasives. Naturally occuring abrasives are slow cutting when coarse.
If you guys think sharpening the back of a japanese chisel takes along time, imagine how long it would take the smith if he needed to remove .010 caused by a water quench. They didn't have special surface grinders. My guess is this was done for manufacturing. Thoughts?
Adam