Metate...do we really want to go there again?
Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.
>Hi Pam
Metate...Metate...Metate..three times :))
It has just occured to me that when we speak of sharpening a western style saw we should refer to three different catagories. One catagory would be fairly new saws that have had their teeth dulled. (Japanese saws could be in this catagory.)
The second catagory would be saws that are beyond dull. These would be the old guys that have been beat to death, neglected and abused and filed by people who knew basically nothing about the basics of filing saws.
A third catagory would be saws that include all the above plus having badly rusted plates, bent and kinked and dented and pitted with handles that are broken, cracked, little or no finish, screws that won't tighten plus anything one might imagine. These are usually the kind of saws I see at flea markets and yardsales. Sow ears.
Catagories two and three are the kind of saws I spend a lot of time on.
I hate to say this, but I think I have to agree with Mr. Duboff when he says anyone using a saw should be able to sharpen it. However, lets limit that rule to saws in catagory one. The other two catagories is a whole different ballgame.
Catagory one allows you to just grab a file, clamp the saw between two pieces of wood and just file the teeth using the existing rake and fleam angles and file the teeth so they have sharp points again. This can be done several times. After a few sharpenings, resetting the teeth becomes part of the process.
When filing saws in catagory two, you are getting into major jointing, missing teeth, a tooth edge that looks like a roller coaster, rake and fleam angles all over the place, etc. etc. With these saws one must employ all the skills required to file saws.
Catagory three includes saws that most people would ignore and allow to return to the good earth from whence they came. Being selective, I will bring some of these saws back to life.
Tom Law, in his video demonstrated how to sharpen saws in catagory one and how to "file" some of the saws in catagory two.
Catagory two and three require what we might refer to as a "saw doctor"....."metate"? opps..thats four.
I hope this helps all of us as we discuss the subject of sharpening/filing western style saws. We seem to have a need to get into this discussion about every three or four months. Each time repeating most everything we discussed before. Almost as if we had never discussed it. I find it a bit amusing. We humans are an odd lot, aren't we? :)
Marv