Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Saw sharpening info

Posts

Re: Saw sharpening info

#26

Re: Saw sharpening info

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Very good assessment. I got this video because I've got a few western saws that needed help and because I simply didn't believe that I had to send a saw off to be sharpened. The video helped very much in describing the sequence of events and the goals of each event, which allowed me to spiff up the western saws. It also gave me the courage to approach the Japanese saws, whereupon I realized that sharpening wasn't the only job done by the metate (Hah!); but sharpen them I did. I'm probably better off leaving the tensioning and such to the metate (What? Twice in one post?).

Pam

Re: Saw sharpening info

#27

Well, all of our mileage varies...as they say...

Alan DuBoff

>Dave,

IMO, the Tom Law video is one of the better references for handsaw sharpening, and for me, Tom Law describes and shows how to sharpen a saw as good or better than any of the other reference/text available.

The video is slightly outdated these days, but it is a great reference.

In fact, I follow many of the points that Tom Law points out, where the document on Vintage Saws has some opposing points. As an example, the document on Pete Taran's site says to file from the heel of the saw, always. Where Tom Law always files from the toe, I do as well as it seems to make sense to file into the teeth from the direction they will be cutting. I have not seen a better description of shaping the teeth and how to file, Tom Law explains that not only as good, but better than any other reference I have seen.

I also don't care for the little aerodynamic attachments or blocks of wood, because it seems to me that Tom Law had it right in the sense that you should really be watching where you are filing, at the cutting edge, rather than the front of the file. So, in that regard I find those contraptions to be distracting. On the Vintage Saws reference, they recommend using such said contraption.

For me, the Tom Law video was more help than any other document I have seen, and the Vintage Saws document was the first one I read. I think that document is a good place to start, but speaking for myself, the Tom Law video was more helpful.

Seems a better modern video could be put together these days, but nobody has done it, most likely since it is so dangerous to sharpen your own saw without destroying it, that folks might feel there isn't a very big market for it...:-/

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Saw sharpening info

#28

Metate...do we really want to go there again?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Pam

Metate...Metate...Metate..three times :))

It has just occured to me that when we speak of sharpening a western style saw we should refer to three different catagories. One catagory would be fairly new saws that have had their teeth dulled. (Japanese saws could be in this catagory.)

The second catagory would be saws that are beyond dull. These would be the old guys that have been beat to death, neglected and abused and filed by people who knew basically nothing about the basics of filing saws.

A third catagory would be saws that include all the above plus having badly rusted plates, bent and kinked and dented and pitted with handles that are broken, cracked, little or no finish, screws that won't tighten plus anything one might imagine. These are usually the kind of saws I see at flea markets and yardsales. Sow ears.

Catagories two and three are the kind of saws I spend a lot of time on.

I hate to say this, but I think I have to agree with Mr. Duboff when he says anyone using a saw should be able to sharpen it. However, lets limit that rule to saws in catagory one. The other two catagories is a whole different ballgame.

Catagory one allows you to just grab a file, clamp the saw between two pieces of wood and just file the teeth using the existing rake and fleam angles and file the teeth so they have sharp points again. This can be done several times. After a few sharpenings, resetting the teeth becomes part of the process.

When filing saws in catagory two, you are getting into major jointing, missing teeth, a tooth edge that looks like a roller coaster, rake and fleam angles all over the place, etc. etc. With these saws one must employ all the skills required to file saws.

Catagory three includes saws that most people would ignore and allow to return to the good earth from whence they came. Being selective, I will bring some of these saws back to life.

Tom Law, in his video demonstrated how to sharpen saws in catagory one and how to "file" some of the saws in catagory two.

Catagory two and three require what we might refer to as a "saw doctor"....."metate"? opps..thats four.

I hope this helps all of us as we discuss the subject of sharpening/filing western style saws. We seem to have a need to get into this discussion about every three or four months. Each time repeating most everything we discussed before. Almost as if we had never discussed it. I find it a bit amusing. We humans are an odd lot, aren't we? :)

Marv

Re: Saw sharpening info

#29

Re: Metate...yes we do

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Mainly because I don't like to see perfectly serviceable words made pariah like "bipartisanship" and "dreaded Ton-Ton Macoute" have become, so distorted that now they're laughable. If someone were to tell us the correct word for Japanese saw sharpening with sophisticated tuning, I'd be happy to use it; but since the Metate themselves use "metate," I don't expect that to happen.

I agree with you. I personally haven't had my hands on anything worse than a number one with a touch of rust developed in my shop/storage. However, there are some saws that are faulty right out of the box; and those usually need more than sharpening to work properly.

Pam

Re: Saw sharpening info

#30

Re: Saw sharpening info *LINK*

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi David,

If you have never sharpened a saw and want to learn, start with reading and following the step by step instructions that Pete Taran has so clearly spelled out for the beginner. Pete at one time had a business making backsaws and has filed thousands of western style saws of all kinds. He is far more knowledgable on the subject than "most" everyone posting in this thread.

Go to Bugbear's website where he has compiled some of the more useful and popular treatise for beginners. Not only beginners, but even those who unfortunately have wondered off in wrong directions with their sharpening methods. Bugbear includes in his list, Leif Hanson's treatise on filing saws.

Leif has a way of communicating in writing such that most anyone can easily understand. Leif also will direct you to Pete Taran's treatise. When you go to Leif's website, you will find all kinds of good woodworking stuff there. A very informative and fasinating website. And you can use his blog to ask questions and he will actually respond either in the blog or directly to you via email.

It really doesn't matter if you start filing from the toe end or from the handle end of a saw. Either way, you will be turning the saw and will be filing from the opposite end anyway. You will be filing in both directions, no matter which end you start on. It's true that your line of sight will be aimed at one side of the tooth or the other, but excellent filing can be accomplished either way.

As for the so called "contraptions" that Pete Taran instructs you to use for controlling rake angles. For the beginner, it's a good idea to do as he instructs. It will give you a sense of what the file is doing with the angle of the cutting edge of the tooth. It's not a "contraption". It's a very useful tool, even though there are a few better ways to control rake angles. You are not expected to focus on the rake angle block at the far end of the file. It is only meant as a reference. You still must focus on the tooth being filed.

Keep in mind, if all you are doing is filing new points on a fairly new saw that has become dull, all you need to do is to file using the same angles that the teeth were originally filed. You won't need a rake angle block for this or a gauge for controlling the fleam or bevel angle when filing crosscut teeth. Rip teeth are usually filed without the bevel angle.

To become an all around saw filer, you will need to learn all the steps that you will read in the various treatise.

Once you have read the treatise and have done some filing of saws, you will be better equiped to relate to what Tom Law teaches in his video.

Good luck and have fun,

Marv


Bugbear's website

Re: Saw sharpening info

#31

Re: Metate...yes we do

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>I was trying to be humorous with the "metate" thing. Sorry,

You are so right about new saws fresh out of the box not being what they can or should be. I should have pointed that out when mentioning sharpening by following the original angles. Some or all of those angles are inconsistant on a new saw, especially if it's a production made saw as apposed to a saw that is hand made, one at a time such as you would get from Andrew Lunn for example.

Marv

Re: Saw sharpening info

#32

Re: Saw sharpening info

MikeW

>Good morning Pam,

I think that part of Marv's 3rd category would be appropriate to apply the concepts behind the word Metate to describe revitalizing a western saw.

That is, straightening is a retensioning process. Skipping the other issues present in that third category but including the sharpening of the other two categories, and tuning for the user's intended purpose...those processes are behind the mechanics of Metate.

I do believe that there is more involved, perhaps, with Metate done on Eastern saws by people like Grable and yourself who respect the traditions. But if Metate is "reduced" to the rude mechanics of what is done...

Take care, Mike

One who loves all saws and processes behind them...

Re: Saw sharpening info

#33

You missed my alternative explanation

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>which is more likely: low standards.

Re: Saw sharpening info

#34

Me, too, forgot to add the smilies. :)

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>But there is a serious side to generally funny things like title inflation and bent words and prohibited words. Just ask Lenny Bruce or George Carlin (I know, unfortunately they're both dead).

Pam

Re: Saw sharpening info

#35

Re: Saw sharpening info

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yeah, while I agree that a metate addresses all three components, I'm not in any way, shape or form a metate. I'll leave that to Mark Grable, who's got most of the right tools (apparently he's having a hard time finding files these days) and studied with Miyano dai Endo, a master.

Pam

Re: Saw sharpening info

#36

Hi Alan, May I ask why?

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: Saw sharpening info

#37

In regards to my question about file handles...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>It doesn't appear that there is a handle being used in this pic.

Re: Saw sharpening info

#38

Re: In regards to my question about file handles..

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hey Scott,

I heard from an unreliable source that Mike W. is planning to produce that innovative saw vise and will be offering one with each backsaw he sells. *grin*

Marv

Re: Saw sharpening info

#39

The tang will stab you in the palm.:-(

Alan DuBoff

>

Re: Saw sharpening info

#40

No.

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Only if you use them aggressively. Filing to me is a lot like sawing... Let the tool do the work.

I use to play the violin. I tend to hold files like bows. No puncher wounds here. Yes, that works with the rough ones like a no. 49 also.

Re: Saw sharpening info

#41

Huh!?!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: Saw sharpening info

#42

Tom Law

paul womack

>I think the Tom Law video would make an excellence source AFTER you've read one of the web write ups - thus using Tom to illustrate information.

Tom doesn't give enough information in his commentary to describe the "why" and "how" of the "what".

But in terms of illustrating what's involved, it's very good.

It's most helpful seeing (and hearing) a file being used.

But sometimes, I think Tom's a little too good, which makes him unconscious of some of the things he's doing.

Nobody is ever going to learn to play piano by watching Horowitz perform.

BugBear

Re: Saw sharpening info

#43

Re: Tom Law

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Bugbear,

My first impression after viewing Tom Law's video for the first time was pretty much the same as yours. While it was very interesting to watch an old filing pro do what he did for a living, I found it just a bit lacking in the area of how to maintain consistant rake and fleam angles. After all, the video is mainly for the beginner.

I would also like to have seen and heard him explain how to prevent "big tooth-little tooth" syndrome. This is a common problem, not only for the beginner, but also for anyone who files handsaws.

Marv

Re: Saw sharpening info

#44

Re: Tom Law

Peter Evans

>I have attended a number of saw sharpening workshops (I organise the programme for TTTG.org.au) and the expertise of the instructors* is a key problem. The experts have been doing it for so long that they have difficulty explaining the process.

I have sharpened quite a number of saws, and consider myself a beginner, perhaps compounded by my generally poor coordination. After my sight (already reduced due to aging) declined significantly I especially realised my beginner status, because I found filing cross cut near impossible.

The experts do not need to see what they are doing, they can almost do it with their eyes shut. Perhaps an experienced, but not expert, person is the ideal instructor; someone who still needs to think about what they are doing and remembers the learning curve - and the critical requirement of good lighting**. And as mentioned above, can clearly explain and demonstrate cross cut filing. Rip is straightforward, even for dovetail saws, even with my reduced sight.

I have the Law video and think it is good, plus as said in previous messages supplemented by the online sources. Used by a moderately experienced instructor to assist beginners, I think it could be the basis of a learning workshop. Law does show very clearly that filing jigs are counter-productive which is very useful advice.

I do not think there is any source that is truly designed for complete beginners and I have looked at many - old and modern. There is no substitute for a live instructor.

* the instructors are truly experts having sharpened hundreds of saws over many years since they were youngsters. One did admit to me that he occasionally mucked it up, so still human.

** Payson in his book makes a strong point on lighting, to the extent that even as an expert he cannot file in inadequate light.

Cheers

Peter in Sydney

Re: Saw sharpening info

#45

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Tom Law(the music)

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I especially enjoy the musical saw at the end of that video.---Jack

Re: Saw sharpening info

#46

Musical saw

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>My younger son plays saw, and, as always when he takes up a new subject, I learn a great deal from him, including that there are entire companies devoted to making musical saws, and that there were even more of them in the heyday of the musical saw. These saws resemble Disstons to about the degree that a painted saw represents a Disston.

Another very, very small cultural niche. He went to one saw gathering down south, and there were maybe 40 people there.