Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Saw sharpening info

Posts

Saw sharpening info

#1

Saw sharpening info

paul womack

>I believe that sharpening saws is a great skill, and one that can be learnt. It's not completely easy, but few worthwhile things are.

I taught myself (from web sources, mainly Taran) a while back, and whilst doing so I accumulated some references, and also made a few (doubtless unoriginal) discoveries.

I've taught a few couple of people to sharpen saws in person, and answered many questions on the subject, and also taken part in discussions.

Here's my webpage that collates some of this:

link to page of saw sharpening info

I hope this information is useful to someone.

BugBear

Re: Saw sharpening info

#2

Most helpful...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Thanks Bugbear for posting your link.

This is the most useful post of all the posts relating to the subject. Information that someone wanting to learn saw filing can actually use.

Thanks for taking the time to compile so much information in one place.

I'll put it on my favorites list and use it next time I get the question...."whats the best way for me to learn how to sharpen handsaws?"

Marv

Re: Saw sharpening info

#3

First, how about files themselves...

Alan DuBoff

>Paul,

That's an excellent page that has a great deal of information, but there are some basics that need to be searched through to find out some info. One of the first questions most folks have is on files themselves...

Files are available from a variety of makers, and the quality varies depending on which files one buys. Several of the makers have moved their manufacturing to different geos and the quality has varied.

In the U.S. we can find Nicholson files in most hardware stores, although we can't find the smaller sizes like 4 xx-slim or 5 xx-slim, you can find slightly larger ones (Home Depot, OSH, ACE, etc...).

Most folks end up buying online for this reason, as well as being able to get a better quality file. LN sells files, LV sells files, as does Tools For Working Wood, Vintage Saws, and a variety of others.

Pete Taran has always had good service and pricing for files, IMO, and tries to find the best available files, unlike some of the other sellers that can be sway by price, or tricked when a maker moves to a new geo unknowingly.

The common makers are Grobet, Bahco and Nicholson...to name a few.

Many of the Nicholson files (and rasps) are now made in Mexico or South America, and the quality has dropped on those. I have some Nicholson made in Mexico files I got from Lee Valley which can visually be compared to a Bahco which was made in Portugal, and there is a noticeable difference between the two visually, as well as in use the tang on the made in Mexico file is very soft. This leads me to believe the steel is not as strong.

The majority of sellers do not list the brand of file they sell, and the brands can change. Caveat Emptor on that one, best to ask before buying, most will answer.

Pete Taran has good prices on the Grobet, although you can save some and get Nicholsons, I recommend the Grobet from Vintage Saws.

Most folks need to buy a file or two, so this is a good place to start, by getting one, IMO.

Re: Saw sharpening info

#4

Next thing, you need a vise...

Alan DuBoff

>Not to be confused with a vice...which saws can be...:-)

To be able to sharpen a saw, you will need a vise. There are various types of older vintage (typically heavy cast iron) vises that are available on the used market.

Some folks will find satisfaction in making their own, there are a lot of tutorials on building them. I have been saying for a couple years that there is a big demand building for a quality modern handsaw vise, and as of recent I have heard a couple of them mention similar.

Mike Wenzloff said that he is working on a saw vise recently on another forum, that could prove to be useful for folks.

My theory on the demand is that there are a lot of modern saw makers whom are selling saws these days, and people need to sharpen those saws and need a vise. The more quality handsaws that are sold, the more desirable of a market exists for a vise. Without question, people like Wenzloff & Sons are selling hundreds of saws per month. This translates into a lot of demand for a saw vise. While vintage vises work, there has to be a cleaner, more efficient solution to securing a handsaw for sharpening.

It is also entirely possible to secure a saw by using 2 pieces of wood, in most modern woodworking vises, as shown in this pic of Mike Wenzloff.


By building a vise out of wood, you will be able to have a longer vise that can easily accommodate a full sized 28"-30" saw.

Of the vintage cast iron varieties, the Disston 3D is the preferable one as it has close to 13" jaws and can secure most backsaws without having to reposition. Most of the various vintage vises work pretty good, even if shorter. I have an E.C.Stearns vise that 10 1/2" jaws that works well also, the jaws close cleanly and it secures nicely. I also have 2 Disston 3D vises and what I use mostly, the heft of the jaws create a nice deadening grip to file against.

It helps if you can see the vise, but you can often tell the condition from pictures on the web.

It is very important to have your vise mounted or in a position that you are comfortable to work, that you have good lighting, and I prefer to sit while I file, so like a chair of the proper height.

There are many solutions to a saw vise, pick the one that works for you, and ensure that there is good lighting, and that you can be comfortable while filing. I will post on magnification later, want to get in the shop and do some work now...odd as that may seem to some...I do like to work in my shop when I can.

If you have any questions, hollar, and I'm sure there will be someone to answer.

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Saw sharpening info

#5

Saw sharpening info

paul womack

>Forums are helpful for discussion, but are not helpful for a beginner.

If you're new to a topic, the last thing you need is a bunch of experts arguing in detail, and passionately, about which of 3-4 variations is the best.

It's of great interest to the experts, but sails straight over a learner head, and causes confusion.

A beginner is going to have enough trouble (in the early stages) remembering all the details of a single method, let alone which detail goes with which variant method.

Further, information of a forum is only of use to the members of that forum.

There are many forums, and often the archives are not always easy to access.

So when I have detailed information that I hope will be of wide interest or utility, I prefer the greater permanence and accessibility of my website.

BugBear

Re: Saw sharpening info

#6

Dominic in Bucks County PA

Thanks for the info

Dominic in Bucks County PA

>Paul,

Thanks for posting these links. I've been thinking that learning to sharpen handsaws would be a cool thing to learn. And I have a couple old saws that I would not mind using as practice. I figure that I'd give learning to sharpen a shot. And if I mess up an old saw, who cares?

Along with the link you providedm I've been reading through all the great information on the Norse Woodsmith site

Marv and Alan's responses also reminded me that I need an assortment of files. Looking through my LV catalog shows that they carry the ones I need.

And I'm sure I have an article on making a wooden saw vice saved somewhere on my hard drive.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Saw sharpening info

#7

saw vise *LINK*

paul womack

>And I'm sure I have an article on making a wooden saw vice saved somewhere on my hard drive.

http://www.cianperez.com/Wood/WoodDocs/Wood_How_To/INDEX_How_To_pages/DarylWeir_SawVise.htm

http://www.norsewoodsmith.com/content/jaspers-wooden-saw-vise

http://www.cornishworkshop.co.uk/wwsawvice.html

http://www.forums.woodnet.net/ubbthreads/showflat.php?Cat=&Board=handtools&Number=3990135&Forum=f11&Words=%2Bpww%20%20%2Bsaw%20%2Bvise%20%2Bclass&Searchpage=0&Limit=100&Main=3981720&Search=true&where=bodysub&Name=&daterange=1&newerval=40&newertype=w&olderval=&oldertype=&bodyprev=1#Post3990135

BugBear


speed versus sharpness

Re: Saw sharpening info

#8

Couldn't agree more, on all points.

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>

Re: Saw sharpening info

#9

Re: Saw sharpening info

MikeW

>In part, maybe a great part, I agree.

However, have you ever tried to get a hold of the guy at Disston who wrote the instructions on Pete's web site to ask a question? It's darn hard.

I think that forums provide something static instructions do not: Encouragement to get started, communication once begun.

I see the static information as a more or less concise repository of what to do. But only in so far as the instructions go. As well, if one looks at *all* the instructions before one begins, they too can be a source of conflicting or at least not entirely complimentary instructions.

So while it is easy to merely point someone to a list of links, I believe that the forums can also be that which is missing from them--encouragement, feedback and follow-up.

I see this topic--saw sharpening--no differently than forum use in learning to hand plane, make moldings, joinery, or sharpening other woodworking widgets. I don't find it very helpful with these other topics to just write "go buy this book, read this web site's instructions" and so forth. It should be no different when advising one to sharpen a saw.

Often forum chatter combines "this and that" instruction with read this or that. This is because in a forum of many voices, it does help to combine both the living feedback and static information on those other topics. This should be the same with saw sharpening.

I believe by using both approaches--forum aid and static information--the person desiring to learn *whatever* obtains from each source that which is needed.

Take care, Mike

Re: Saw sharpening info

#10

Dominic in Bucks County PA

Re: saw vise

Dominic in Bucks County PA

>Thanks Paul! Daryl's was the one I was thinking about.

I took the liberty of converting these to live links for all those who may be interested in looking these over.


See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Saw sharpening info

#11

forums

paul womack

>So while it is easy to merely point someone to a list of links, I believe that the forums can also be that which is missing from them--encouragement, feedback and follow-up.

Yes, I agree entirely. Both forums and website have merits, and I believe they can be complimentry.

If someone asks "I want to sharpen a saw; how do I do it" I will simply point them at the (well known...) links.

If they then say "I don't understand the effect of rake" I will try to help. (to the best of my knowledge)

But I certainly wouldn't type up a whole saw-sharpening treatise into a forum (even if I had the expertise!)

I've even done the controversy thing - I think my approach to rake control is superior to Pete Taran's...

BugBear

Re: Saw sharpening info

#12

Another point to be made...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Even though there is helpful information scattered around in various forums regarding how to sharpen saws, knowing what I know about what's required both in knowledge and the need of tools and equipment, I would not begin my search for that information in a forum.

There is good information and bad information. It is impossible for a beginner to know the difference.

Good example is a post by Duboff about how he doesn't file two teeth at the same time....bad information..

Mr. Wenzloff who we all know is an expert on the subject follows up by explaining the right way to file a tooth.....Good information.

When a beginner reads the two posts, it has to be, at least to some degree, confusing. The beginner might not know Mr. Wenzloff's or Duboff's background. The beginner, not knowing much of anything about the small details of filing a saw, might not know what questions to ask.

Of course there are things that can be learned in a forum, no doubt about that. However, like so many things, there is a process, starting with step one and continuing on with all the following logical steps that leads to the end of the process. You just don't get that in a thread in a forum.

If the beginner seeks out the treatise written by Pete Taran, as one example, they will have access to the entire process spelled out in proper order.

I too have a better way of controlling rake angles, but Pete offers enough information to get a beginner to a point where they can in fact properly sharpen a saw.

The kind of information that Bugbear contributes here in this forum by posting a link to his website is the kind of information that is most helpful to those who have a desire to learn saw filing and are spending time in forums of this kind.

Marv

Re: Saw sharpening info

#13

I agree with you...

Alan DuBoff

>Mike wrote:

"I think that forums provide something static instructions do not: Encouragement to get started, communication once begun."

This is spot on, my friend. Unlike some of the others that have been discouraging folks from taking on sharpening their own saw, I rather like your stand on it, because forums are a good place to toss around ideas and help people.

People is welcome to dis anything I post, they commonly only posts some smarky reply anyway, so that doesn't bother me. I sharpen my own saws, and have taught myself how to do it with the information I have available. I don't care if my saws are not up to their specs, they work fine for me, and I have no fear to sharpen any of them, or even take them completely apart...I have even done that with a saw you made for me. I don't know what I was thinking, what if I couldn't have gotten it back together? What if I ruined the teeth...? I guess I was lucky...even considering I file the teeth wrong and disperse bad info on how I file one tooth at a time...

I have not once seen some of those encourage anyone to sharpen their own saw. A sad, but true statement. :-(

And I certainly don't think just tossing out half a dozen links to documents on the web is too much value, that often confuses folks also since the documents have different ideas and/or concepts they present.

Regards,

Alan

Re: Saw sharpening info

#14

And never use a saw file without a handle!

Alan DuBoff

>

Re: Saw sharpening info

#15

Would like to see your experience...

Alan DuBoff

>Dom,

Would like to see what type of experience you have when learning to sharpen, please do post here and/or get comments.

Mike Wenzloff has always been helpful and offers a lot of encouragement and great info, as witnessed here on WC. Since he is here, you can't ask for better help, IMO.

Regards,

Alan

Re: Saw sharpening info

#16

Now I'm confused...

Alan DuBoff

>Marv wrote:

"Of course there are things that can be learned in a forum, no doubt about that."

It was just yesterday that you (Marv) wrote:

"This, IMO, is not the place to teach others how to sharpen saws."

So what is it?

I rather like the view Mike takes, it's consistent. He has certainly been more encouraging to people to sharpen their saws as well, I really admire that in him.

Thanks for the distasteful comments Marv, much appreciated, and maybe I'll be able to return them one day.

Regards,

Alan

Re: Saw sharpening info

#17

Dominic in Bucks County PA

Re: Would like to see your experience...

Dominic in Bucks County PA

>Alan,

Thanks. I'll keep you up to date. I think I'll build the saw vice first. While I'm doing that I'll place the files on order. The last thing I'll need is a saw set.

Re: Saw sharpening info

#18

Speaking of sets...

Alan DuBoff

>Dom wrote:

"The last thing I'll need is a saw set."

Sets are yet another area that is not covered very well on the web, in the sense that most people recommend the Somax sets, and they work ok, but I have found out first hand that while they work well, the materials are not good they manufacture them with.

The older Disston 42X sets are good, and many prefer them, I have a couple myself, but one annoying thing I notice with mine is that it leaves marks on the blade where the anvil and/or back portion contact the blade. What people like most is that if you look in the attached picture, there is an adjustment screw to raise/lower the anvil, so in theory you could set any size tooth. In reality the size of the plunger determines what size teeth can be set, and the older Disston sets often have the plunger filed to accommodate smaller teeth, such as those on a dovetail saw, for instance.

The Somax has very soft metal for the cast portion, so the teeth do chew a groove over time.

What MikeW and sons do is replace the plunger which is also soft, with a vintage plunger (you need to file them a bit for smaller teeth and/or the blue Somax). Along the bottom, his son showed me how he added a piece of bronze where the metal was being chewed/grooved, to prevent the wear.

In addition, my Disston 42X is getting a groove in it also, they are not immune to wear over time, either.

For the casual user, this will not be a problem, it is only when you start setting more teeth that this wear will start to show.

This is yet another area that is not documented online, AFAIK, so pointing people to a document will not help them on this topic either. All the more reason an open forum is good to encourage discussion.

The Somax sets are a good place to start, and reasonably priced. I'm surprised that such poor quality metal was used in the manufacture of them, they are made in Japan.

I have attached a pic that shows this wear starting to happen on both the vintage Disstons and the Somax I use. But I will add that I have used the Disston way more, it was given to me as a gift for Galootaclaus 2005.


img

Re: Saw sharpening info

#19

Structural coherence

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I can't offer anything helpful on saw sharpening, since it remains on my list of things to learn...

but my sense is that, for those who learn from written material, books or online treatises are a mighty useful tool for learning a new skill set, because the author(s) has/have spent time, often lots of it, thinking out how to present the total subject in a coherent way. A forum, as others have commented, can be helpful for illuminating either consensus or diversity (or both) on a particular question, but it's not always the best place for coherence.

Imagine trying to convey here what Chris Schwarz spent hours assembling in his recent workshop book, for instance. Even if all his ideas were presented in one thread by Chris and others, they would hardly be presented in the structured way he did in the book.

The cracker barrel is a great way to learn new things, if the people sitting around it are smart, but it's got its own set of limitations.

Re: Saw sharpening info

#20

Do you send your saws out for sharpening???

Alan DuBoff

>Bill wrote:

"I can't offer anything helpful on saw sharpening, since it remains on my list of things to learn..."

Wow, I see you buying quite a few old tools, seems that you have even found quite a few saws in the wild...

Do you send them all out to be sharpened for you?

The economics of finding a saw for $5 and sending it out to be sharpened for $40-$50 don't seem to fit your style of finding them in the wild...

Have you read any of the online documents describing it? If not, there's tons of links posted in this thread.

Somehow it seems that shuffling people off to those well thought out documents has not been working too well, since many people don't seem to sharpen their own saws yet, even if they are aware of them.

Most of those same people sharpen their own chisels and plane irons. Do you sharpen your own chisels and hand plane irons, or do you send them out to be sharpened?

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Saw sharpening info

#21

Re: Saw sharpening info

David Brown

>I appreciate this info. But I want to ask about the Tom Law video on saw sharpening. I often do very well after watching a video. Has anyone seen this and is it worth the money and time if you want to learn to sharpen saws?

Thanks.

Re: Saw sharpening info

#22

Re: Saw sharpening info

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi David,

It's probably worth the money, but that of course is kind of a personal judgement after you view it.

Tom Law has probably filed more saws than any living human being. Watching his video, it seems that he has a calibrated wrist for maintaining rake angles. It appears that he does it strickly by feel and instinct. For a beginner, I would like for him to have expounded more on how to consistantly file the rake and fleam angles.

Other than that one critizism, I think the video is very helpful, but will not teach you everything you will need to know. Reading Pete Taran's treatise will actually be more helpful regarding the details.

Marv

Re: Saw sharpening info

#23

I guess I've been real lucky

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>or else my standards are low, but I have yet to need a saw sharpened.

Re: Saw sharpening info

#24

Re: Saw sharpening info

David Brown

>Thanks for the info!

Re: Saw sharpening info

#25

Wow, that is luck...

Alan DuBoff

>I have never been so lucky, my saws need sharpening when I use them.:-(

I would save those saws, they must be magic! :-)