Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Old vs. New Saw

Posts

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#26

Yes.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Not that Ornette would necessarily choose a plastic horn, but he could.

Pam

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#27

Re: Old vs. New Saw

David Brown

>Thanks, everyone, for the excellent advice. I lean heavily toward a new saw. I'm always impressed with the knowledge here.

In the end, I know I would much rather work on wood than the tools, and I agree it's not that much considering the quality of the tool.

Cheers,

--Dave

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#28

Old DT saws are expensive and hard to find...

Alan DuBoff

>Adam wrote:

"18th c dt saws were as thin as the new saws are (and thinner than Disstons)."

Trying to find these saws can be difficult, they are few and far between, and when they do come up for sale on ebay they get bid up high. There are not a lot of these saws so even to find one takes some time and looking, in my experience. I only have a few old dovetail saws.

I don't like the boutique reference either, but I completely agree with you that the new saws are just better saws in general. I could be bias also as I make my own saws...but even other maker's saws to me are much better fit/finish than the older vintage saws I've seen. Especially in the split-nuts, modern split-nuts are much better than older ones that are often so thin it is easy to destroy them getting them out. One Beardshaw that I have was riveted and the heads peened, and the flat sides (head) fell out sometime over the past 200 years...this saw also has pins peened through the back, not sure if that is original, but the way they are peened makes me think they could be original. I digress, but suffice to say that old split-nuts can cause problems when trying to tighten them up snugly on the old saws, r&r the handles, or even remove the blades. That is probably the biggest caveat emptor on old saws, aside from the brittle steel that is found on some plates. The metal was not nearly as consistent as modern 1095 spring steel, in my experience. This was more so in the early part of the 19th century and older. Steel got pretty good about mid 19th century when Bessemer's process of using oxygen to force the impurities out of pig iron surfaced. At least in the saws I have from those eras...Few if any of my saws are 18th century, maybe only one, possibly two...but I can't imagine those 18th century saws being any more consistent than the early 19th century ones, and those were no consistent by any means.

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#29

Re: Re-rubish!

Todd Hughes

>Where are you looking that you haven't found a dovetail saw in 20 years of looking ?..and if you haven't seen any,...uhmm how are they priced 5X what the ones I find are. Sort of lost me there

But hey I understand what you are saying....I can't find a quality new made saw and I have been looking for years too ! I go to lots of flea markets and never saw one, never saw one at an estate auction either....sure lots of old saws but never one of these new ones

Always look along the road for a IT saw when I walk my dog...they don't exist! Got my oil changed yesterday and I asked the mechanics if they had one of those new LV saws ...they just looked at me Blank.

I have searched both my Bathroom and Kitchen for a Mike W. saw...no luck

I have come to the conclusions that these new saws simply do not exist...if they did I would have found one by now don't you think since I have been looking everywhere and have yet to see even one?...Todd

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#30

Wandering OT - My understanding

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>is that when he started out, all he could afford was a "student" plastic saxophone (Wikipedia says this, too), and got to like the sound. He's holding a plastic sax on the album cover of his earliest pivotal album, "The Shape of Jazz to Come." I can still remember listening to that as a high school trombone player - incredibly strange for the era, and, like really sharp cheddar, just incredibly tasty once you got used to it.

Not that any of this has to do with woodworking...

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#31

impressive

paul womack

>With all due appologies to my fellow contemporary saw makers, they are just saws.

Have you SEEN the various titles that people who make clay pots have come up with for themselves?!?!?

BugBear

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#32

Dovetail saws are rare...

Alan DuBoff

>Todd wrote:

"Where are you looking that you haven't found a dovetail saw in 20 years of looking ?"

Todd,

This is because real dovetail saws are rare, there are not a lot of them as they were very specialized and more people would use small carcass/tenon saws for the purpose.

A true dovetail saw with small teeth, thin plate, and overall light weight are just not plentiful. There are some but few. Most often what you call a dovetail saw is not really the same type of saw, it is more often a small carcass or small tenon saw.

For American saws, think Disston 70. I have a George Bishop that I would put in a similar class, but it is very unusual.

IMO, by the time America started producing a lot of saws, gent saws were taking over for those similar tasks. We do see quite a few of those. In fact, I even have one I bought from you for $25 that I use with little to no set on it to cut handsaw slots occasionally.

Regards,

Alan

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#33

On topic - My understanding

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I think what we're discussing has everything to do with woodworking, at least the woodworking we mostly discuss here. It's all about tools and how much we obsess about them. Do you remember that wonderful rocking horse a few years ago, carved by a forum member's (Mike?) brother with a single chisel?

Pam

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#34

Another plastic sax

wilbur

>Dizzy Gillespie, Charlie Parker, Bud Powell, Charles Mingus, and Max Roach, all play on the live jazz album, "Jazz at Massey Hall". Legend has it that Charlie Parker couldn't be found until just before the concert was due to start, when he showed up right on time -- without a sax. The only sax that could be found right then was a plastic one, which he used to make one of the greatest live jazz performances ever to be recorded.

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#35

Dude! I don't that slid by the sensors...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#36

I don't believe...lil too quick to post.

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#37

LOL! thanks Todd

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>