Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Old vs. New Saw

Posts

Old vs. New Saw

#1

Old vs. New Saw

David Brown------WebKitFormBoundary8hK4rUu9u+yJA72

>This is a "if money is no object" type of question. It always is, of course.

If you could buy a brand new premium dovetail saw from Lie-Nielsen or get an older saw and either have it refurbished or do it yourself, which would you prefer?

The benefit of the new saw seems obvious -- high quality tool, but it comes at a high price in terms of money.

The benefit of the old tool, if I refurbish it myself, is a high quality tool, but it comes at a price of learning how to refurbish it and the time it takes to do it. It also might come with a new skill, if successful. Is it really hard to learn?

Your thoughts?

-Dave

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#2

Re: Old vs. New Saw

ThomD

>I think "hard" is often not the point. Craftsmen come in two varieties, folks who are pretty much beginners, and folks who have mastered some skill, and given time and devotion pretty much know that they can pick up any other. But sometimes the road is a long one.

It was prohibitive for me to buy stuff off ebay, what with all the costs bringing it to Canada. Other than the bay, I have yet to see a decent candidate for refurbishment. If you commonly run across such saws that would be at least a solution to the first hurdle.

If you can get the candidate saw, then you could certainly try your hand at the making, it really depends whether you want to make saws, or make joints. I like to do bits of everything, but I know the cost is often really high, either in dollars on in skill that slowly come together over a long period.

Other options would be the Lee Valley saw, which is cheap, and while it is a little wacky looking, all the wackiness seems to fall into place for me, so I can put up with it. It is certainly a better cutter than most, and better than most first time reconditioned saws are likely to be. Another option is making one from a kit. There was a nice kit someone had completed and showed here a few months ago, forget the make.

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#3

Re: Old vs. New Saw

L. Hanson

>I'd love to have a brand new saw. Nothing wrong with the reputable makers out there today... I drool over MikeW's, Veritas, Andrew Lunn's, Gramercy, et. al..

Of course, then I wouldn't have so many... I'm still deciding on whether that's a good thing or not...

;-)

I love fixing up an old backsaw - it's good therapy. I've done my share of it, and there's a little pride that comes from a job well done. Doesn't have to cost a lot, either.

Come down to what you want to do - if you enjoy working on old tools, it's satisfying to do. If you'd rather put it straight to wood - well, there it is. Have some fun with it, that's the point!

Leif

Norse Woodsmith

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#4

First saw?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi David,

Where you are on the learning curve? Thinking back, it is of great benefit to have a first saw which is right when you get it. One problem with self-teaching is that you can only guess whether your learning is paying off, because there is nothing to compare with.

If you have one saw that you know is right when you get it, and I mean it has been hand-filed by someone who knows what they're doing, then you're in better position to get a restoration candidate and learn to bring it up to snuff. Because you have some basis for evaluating the results.

Now the 'new' saw could be an LV Wenzloff or a Gramercy or an LN or a Lunn, or it could be bought off Ebay from a reconditioner, like Marv Werner, so that you're not buying a project saw. There are quite a few options, and I hope someone will fill in the names I am leaving out.

Anyway, I suggest getting a saw that you know has been filed right. One thing to consider is this--even when you buy a new perfect saw, it will only be its perfect new self until it's time for the first re-sharpening--then it's down to you, or you send it out. But the advantage of buying a sharp, well-jointed, and well-set saw is, you learn what a saw is supposed to feel like, so you don't have to guess while you're learning the skills.

Wiley

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#5

How about both?

Alan DuBoff

>David,

I say get whatever is available to you. If you can find some vintage saws reasonable, snatch 'em up and look at reconditioning them. But some of the prices these days are fairly high if you do have to recondition them. I wouldn't want to pay $75 for a saw that needs to be tuned up and/or needs a jointing, shaping, and sharpening...and some saws require more work, could have a kink (I just fixed one like that), or be badly pitted, or have a loose handle, or have the back smashed down at the toe from being dropped...nothing that can't be fixed, but sometimes the older handle are difficult to tighten up nicely...all of them vary...

If you can afford to get some new ones, nothing wrong with them either.

I find that most all new saws have better fit/finish than the vintage ones, but that is certainly subjective. Most older saws need to be tuned up properly when found, so it does require a certain amount of time, skill, and willingness...this all translates to cost in the end, IMO.

OTOH, some folks don't care for new saws. Whatever it is that floats your boat, best to have a quiver of saws for the tasks that you want to do with them. My $0.02...

Dare I say you should learn how to sharpen a handsaw first and foremost, but I might sound like a broken record...and folks might start piling on with stories of destroyed saws from folks that tried so...If your worried about the cost of a new saw and would be afraid to sharpen it, I'd recommend something you wouldn't mind taking a file to...

This is in reference to western style handsaws.

Regards,

Alan

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#6

knowledge

paul womack

>Getting the knowledge to correctly evaluate an old saw, and then fully restore it is a non-trivial exercise.

Very satisfying, but non trivial. I think it took me about 3 years to go from "I quite fancy learning about saws" to actually doing a decent job, but I did it in a very "spread out" fashion. My first attempt at sharpening a 14 tpi cross cut had such a bad result I didn't try again for 6 months.

If you simply want a good saw, BUY ONE. You can learn later.

You can either buy new (LN, LV, Mike Wenzloff and many others, in this new Golden Age), or get an old (some might say classic) saw restored by an expert.

I believe Daryl Weir sells "super tuned" old saws on eBay, and Mark Harrell (TechnoPrimitives) provides a similar service.

BugBear

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#7

Re: Old vs. New Saw

Pedder

>Hi David,

if you want to use a dovetail saw, buy one! And buy a cheap gents saw to learn how to sharpen.

I liked the idea of making saws from the moment I saw Leif's site for the first time. I started buying old saws, many files, a vise (actually three of them), special lights, exotic woods and modern saw screws. Until now I might have paid the money for a full set of Kenyons without owning one of them. But I'm able to sharpen saws and make handles.

Cheers

Pedder

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#8

Re: Old vs. New Saw

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>David,

The problem with old saws is that you can't always get something comparable to the new saws. For example, I and others make saws you can't buy as antiques. In general, our dts saws are thinner. We make longer back saws with thinner blades than are readily available seond hand. Our long saws have more meat on their blades, better handles etc.

I restored I think a couple hundred saws before I decided to start making my own. Because I make saws commercially, money is almost no object for me. I have some really fine antique saws and my pick of modern made saws including a Wenzloff rip saw, I have the new LV etc etc. I prefer the new boutique saws* (sorry Mike) over the antiques. They are just plain better saws.

You have to remember; so many of the saws on the second hand market were made for carpenters, not furniture makers. That's also true of molding plane, by the way. So you shouldn't expect to find great dt's. None of us redesigned back saws. We're just copying saws from a time when saws were made for men who built furniture entirely by hand and needed specialty saws. 18th c dt saws were as thin as the new saws are (and thinner than Disstons).

So if you want a dt saw, just buy a new one. They really aren't that much money. If funds are tight, I'd recommend picking up an old Disston d7 rip saw (something with a straight back). I found a short tool box saw by Atkins that I really like. Keep your eyes peeled for a 20" saw. And it's easier to sharpen large teeth. These saws are good and new long saws are expensive. But I don't think an old Disston is a match for a new Wenzloff or Cherubini. Our saws cut wood faster and are nicer to use. The handles are nicer, the hang angles, the weigth of the blades, the balance are all superior. I have my choice and I use new saws even when no one is looking.

You could ask the exact same question about planes. I think most folks here would advise you to buy new LV or LN planes. I don't think it's a terrible idea to restore an old #5 jack plane. But I think you are probably better off buying a new wherever possible.

Adam

* Mike Wenzloff doesn't like the term boutique saws. I'm not using the term to needle him. I just don't know what else to call the new saws. I intend the term "boutique" to exclude Crown and maybe Garlick, Pax, Lynx, etc.

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#9

Refurbish?

Todd Hughes

>Buy an old high quality saw that is in excellent condition. Not a rare or expensive tool , even in the old tool hell I live in I see them all the time and most times can be bought for $10 or less at your local flea market, antique shop or auction. Might need to be sharpened, but you know what?...that very expensive new repo saw will too sooner or later... and you will have to either learn to do it yourself or send it out to be done.

Refurbish?..Tuning?..Hard to do?..to much time?...Sometimes it sounds like you guys are pulling a rusted model T out of the woods to rebuild instead of taking about 15 min. to clean up an old saw. Don't buy rusted, pitted up or broken saws and about all you will have to do is take a sanding block to the blade, clean and oil the handle. Lots of saws won't even need this

All this whinning about..."waaa! that old saw ain't got sharp teeth...oh what will I do?"...So where do these guys throw away those new saws when they get dull and they buy the new sharp ones? ...or maybe they just don't use them enough so they ever get dull...eh?......Todd

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#10

knowledge

paul womack

>* Mike Wenzloff doesn't like the term boutique saws. I'm not using the term to needle him. I just don't know what else to call the new saws. I intend the term "boutique" to exclude Crown and maybe Garlick, Pax, Lynx, etc.

Might I suggest "Artisan made" ?

BugBear

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#11

I agree with Todd

roninkokomo

>

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#12

Re: Old vs. New Saw

Brian in Ottawa

>Try the new Lee Valley saw. You may be pleasantly surprised. Those who have tried it, in my informal survey, loved it, including in side by side comparisons with other top saws.

Disclaimer: I work for Lee Valley but my objective opinion is that it is a superiour saw.

Looks are not the issue in my opinion. Some like it and some do not.

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#13

Adam, can you please post us a link

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>to your saws. Many will be interested.

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#14

Re: Old vs. New Saw

patrick gibbons, katy, tx

>I have both an old Simonds and an old Disston which are filed for dovetails though both are really small back saws. I recently was trying to cut dovetails in 1/4" stock and found both saws lacking. They're just too thick. I bought the two Zona saws that Lee Valley sells and they were much, much better. They were thin and, though slow, left a fine finish. I didn't like that they cut on the pull. They're also inexpensive yet not cheap. I feel that new saws are the best way to go now. They're made for the kind of work most of us do, they're made well and they're ready to go out of the box.

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#15

Here in old-tool heaven,

Chuck Nickerson

>used saws of questionable initial quality and in bad current shape cost $25+. In restoring an old tool, you preserve and honor the past. In buying a new quality tool, you support and honor the present. Which of those two floats your boat?

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#16

Re: Adam, can you please post us a link *LINK*

Adam Cherubini

>Thanks Wiley. Just to be clear, I'm still filling orders, so I'm not accepting new orders at present. And my latest saws are a little bit better looking. But this will give some idea of what my saws look like.


Adam's Saws

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#17

Re: Re-rubish!

ThomD

>Todd, you are not in tool hell. I am not an old tool nut, but I have been looking for a decent DT saw for, maybe 20 years. I have yet to see a single useable one, and often the prices are 5x what you quote. The reason people refurbish is because they are stuck with the junk. Imagine you were walking by box upon box of minty dovetails saws for 10 bucks, do you think the average person would be purchasing crummy ones covered with rust and refurbishing them if there was an abundant supply? Do you think new dovetails saws from a half dozen sources would be manufactured today if they were just lying on the street waiting to be picked up. Do you think Franz KLauzs would have bought new Independence saws for everyone in his shop, had decent antiques been thick on the ground?

I am becoming a hand at getting machine tools. It took me 2 years to find my first decent lathe, etc... Just last week I got given a milling machine and a surface grinder. Now it is more like a mater of turning the tap off than turning it on. But it cost several years, a few bad buys, etc... to get to that point. Most people are still milling around the chinese machine tool suppliers. Also I have all my time to myself, I would not get any of these deals, even the early bad ones if I was still working. Doubtless there is someone local who is getting the same deal on DT saws, but it's pointless to pretend that anyone can do it.

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#18

Re: knowledge

MikeW

>* Mike Wenzloff doesn't like the term boutique saws...

Might I suggest "Artisan made" ?

Hah, sorry BB, don't like that either.

How about simply new saws. I realize this does not distinguish between the current new saw makers who make good saws versus the softer steel and over-set saws out of England. However, I don't think making a distinction can be summed up in a word like artisan or boutique.

With all due appologies to my fellow contemporary saw makers, they are just saws.

Take care, Mike

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#19

Re: Old vs. New Saw

ThomD

>I don't work for LV, and I agree that it cuts really well. You can do the work with this saw. It is better than at least one saw I paid 200 for and took back. It's a bit like a K-car. It works and is as reliable as a Japanese car of the day, but at that point the Japanese had moved on to providing a range of affinity details, like exhausts tunned to a particular sound, and interior design. Same with the dt saw, the next thing is a custom made saw to your stile of cutting and the work you do.

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#20

OT terminology

Adam Cherubini

>Artisan or artisanal are good words.

In my defense, I think here on the East coast of US, "boutique" doesn't have the ladies' handbag connotation it may have elsewhere. You could have a "boutique" wine or liquor store, indicating that the shop specializes in particularly high quality wines or provides specialized services. A boutique car dealership may specialize in italian or german automobiles.

Artisan is good. We have "artisanal" or "craft" beers, or "artisanal" cheese. I think "artisanal" only means made with craftsmanship. I think artisan is synonomous with "craftsman".

Peronsally, I think the term connotes an artistic crafts person, which fits Mike Wenzloff. I think there's a difference between being an furniture artisan, a person who might design furniture or who can express artistic sensibilities, and a person who is an excellent builder. Furniture maker George Nakashima was an artisan. Norm Abrams is not. He's a fine craftsman to be sure (and in my opinion, doesn't deserve the ribbing he gets from folks like us).

So I'm saying this is how I feel about the word artisan, and how I think others I know feel. But this isn't the definition of the word. We are all artisans. Maybe that is what has prevented me from applying this non-descriptive word to Mike Wenzloff. He much better fits my version of the word than the actual dictionary definition.

Adam

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#21

Re: Old vs. New Saw

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>In whatever skill activity you engage, a general rule (I made this up but assume that others have also made up a similar rule) is that the more skillful one is, the cruder the tools can be. Not that the experienced worker will always choose the cruder tool, but she can if desired.

This applies in software development, housework, woodworking, metal working, etc. An beginning woodworker should buy a tool that will work properly right out of the box. An experienced woodworker can buy whatever she prefers.

Pam

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#22

Re: OT terminology

MikeW

>No defense necessary, Adam. My quirks are just that, mine.

I think we all have certain views of how words do or do not apply, the situations to apply them, etc. For me, all I do is make saws. I do apply the descriptor "saw maker."

fwiw, we make killer wines around the ol' home. Good wine in every sense. But I personally would not apply the term "artisan, "craft," or "botique" to the brew. It is just wine.

Take care my friend.

Mike

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#23

Re: OT terminology

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yeah, but then what about all those sanitation engineers and data entry analysts? :)

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#24

I'm reminded, in a funny way,

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>of one of the presidents of the university at which I used to work. He commented once, with a certain bemusement, that, if he asked for something, he'd get it - but he always gave the impression that he was one of the workers whose job title happened to be "university president," while other workers had job titles like "carpenter" or "lecturer." I ran into him in the bookstore once - he'd gone out to get a card for someone, or something - the only president I remember in 30 years who, if he needed a card for someone's birthday, would go buy one, rather than sending his secretary out to get it.

Re: Old vs. New Saw

#25

Watching a good worker use junky tools

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>It can be really impressive watching a good worker use poor tools to do outstanding work...like listening to Ornette Coleman make beautiful music from a plastic saxophone.