Re: Old vs. New Saw
Adam Cherubini, NJ
>David,
The problem with old saws is that you can't always get something comparable to the new saws. For example, I and others make saws you can't buy as antiques. In general, our dts saws are thinner. We make longer back saws with thinner blades than are readily available seond hand. Our long saws have more meat on their blades, better handles etc.
I restored I think a couple hundred saws before I decided to start making my own. Because I make saws commercially, money is almost no object for me. I have some really fine antique saws and my pick of modern made saws including a Wenzloff rip saw, I have the new LV etc etc. I prefer the new boutique saws* (sorry Mike) over the antiques. They are just plain better saws.
You have to remember; so many of the saws on the second hand market were made for carpenters, not furniture makers. That's also true of molding plane, by the way. So you shouldn't expect to find great dt's. None of us redesigned back saws. We're just copying saws from a time when saws were made for men who built furniture entirely by hand and needed specialty saws. 18th c dt saws were as thin as the new saws are (and thinner than Disstons).
So if you want a dt saw, just buy a new one. They really aren't that much money. If funds are tight, I'd recommend picking up an old Disston d7 rip saw (something with a straight back). I found a short tool box saw by Atkins that I really like. Keep your eyes peeled for a 20" saw. And it's easier to sharpen large teeth. These saws are good and new long saws are expensive. But I don't think an old Disston is a match for a new Wenzloff or Cherubini. Our saws cut wood faster and are nicer to use. The handles are nicer, the hang angles, the weigth of the blades, the balance are all superior. I have my choice and I use new saws even when no one is looking.
You could ask the exact same question about planes. I think most folks here would advise you to buy new LV or LN planes. I don't think it's a terrible idea to restore an old #5 jack plane. But I think you are probably better off buying a new wherever possible.
Adam
* Mike Wenzloff doesn't like the term boutique saws. I'm not using the term to needle him. I just don't know what else to call the new saws. I intend the term "boutique" to exclude Crown and maybe Garlick, Pax, Lynx, etc.