Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plane

Posts

Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plane

#1

Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plane

James Watriss

>So, I feel like taking on an idiot project. Here's my idea.

I feel like taking an old #8 and chopping it down to make a very wide super-smoother. Like a 4 1/2, but wider. The lateral adjustment pin thing has really got me spun up, and I want to see just what can be done.

BUT, I don't want to pay for a new #8 on ebay, just to slaughter it like a... well, like something you'd slaughter on such a whim, I suppose.

Ultimately, the end goal is to write up an article about it for the archives here, and possibly, if the thing works out, maybe I'll put it up on the Bene auction.

Todd? Anyone? I'm sure someone has a source...

Re: Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plane

#2

Re: Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plan

Ted

>I did that with a damaged Stanley #6 a few years back. Cut off the front and back and installed an overstuffed paduak infill. It made a great smoother.

Re: Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plane

#3

Just say no

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>there's just something about this that sounds like " hey I'm thinking of shooting up drugs, what do you guys think?" I'm sure there is a #8 user out there with a chipped corner or broken side. and it might make a nice smoother... if you replace the blade and chip breaker. So why not start with the blade and chip breaker and build a smoother around it and leave that beat up old #8 to live on as beat up user jointer plane. Don't get me wrong, I like rat rods. I'm just not infavor of taking something that is useable and making something less usable or less desireable out of it.

Robin

Re: Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plane

#4

Re: Just say no

Ted

>I respectfully disagree. I can see where one would object to disfiguring a plane which is in good condition. However, if you have a damaged plane where the front or back is broken off or it has other damaged which realistically can not be repaired, I see no reason why it should not be used as a project to make a better plane.

I did this with a Stanley #6 and it is now one of my best smooth planes. It is the plane that I go to for the thinnest chatter free shavings in the worst woods. If your plane is broken, fix it. If fixing it means to heavily modify it to make something better, I see no problem with that.

Re: Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plane

#5

Re: Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plan

ralph johnson

>ted

i have a busted 606 that was welded backed to together badly. i have been thinking about doing the same thing to it. how long did you make yours and do you have any pics of it

thanks

Re: Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plane

#6

Just say yes

David Miller from Iowa

>I also disagree - do as you want with your own stuff

Re: Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plane

#7

Re: Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plan *LINK*

Ted

>Have a look at pictures 10 and 11 in this write up I did when building a desk for my son. I used a #6, which was plenty big enough. It is a very heavy plane, something over 6 lbs. I don't know that I would want to do this with a #8. It's a little longer than a regular Stanley 4 1/2, but feels about twice the weight. I kept the frog and adjuster, but fixed the frog in place and it butts up against the rear infill so the support for the iron is much better than with a regular Stanley plane.

Ted


Building David's desk. (Stanley Infill)

Re: Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plane

#8

Re: Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plan

Todd Hughes

>Ive seen a couple old ones done like that over the years. I just figured some guy got tired of having some big 8 and cut it back to something he liked better.

... I remember one was actually a pre laterial that was done very well and I had some trouble figuring exactly what it was I was looking at. Unfortunatly the seller had a problem with knowing what it was too and wanted an arm and a leg for it so I passed.

No bad 8s that I want to sell...I'd look on ebay for rough ones and pick it up there....have some fun and ask the seller to cut off the last couple inches to make it asier to ship !....Todd

Re: Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plane

#9

Good one Todd. :>)

Victor Parisian

>

Re: Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plane

#10

HA!!!

James Watriss

>Man, that's funny... I actually laughed out loud.

I'll be getting milage out of that one for days...

Re: Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plane

#11

You got me wrong...

James Watriss

>This is why I was looking specifically for one that's already broken. I'm not about to disfigure a perfectly good, working plane.

Re: Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plane

#12

Re: Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plan

Kevin Fellows

>I've got a #8 with the last inch broken off, if you feel like dealing with the cost of shipping from New Zealand.

Re: Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plane

#13

Easier to Pack

Todd Hughes

>I used to buy a good bit of junk Pewter to cast pewter bolsters on some knives I made. Anyway Im at this estate auction and I buy a couple junk pewter plates for $2 and they bring them back to me. I had a box of stuff and they wouldn't fit so I bent them double and slid them in the box. Old woman setting next to me shocked asked me why in the world did I just do that ?.I told her I often bend them up like that to make it easier to pack and when I get home I just unbend them...no trouble. She looks at me and says "Really?...I wouldn't have thought you would be able to do that!"...Sure no trouble do it all the time.

Right About then another buyer drops this glass plate and a big crash as it breaks into about 10 pieces which he picks up and puts in a bag. I told the woman next to me..."looks like he is doing the same thing as me, eh?"....Todd

Re: Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plane

#14

Re: Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plan

Victor P

>Ah, the long lost and almost forgotten Stanley 7-1/2. That's a keeper and worth a small fortune.

Victor in Houston

Re: Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plane

#15

Handles fitting

paul womack

>I feel like taking an old #8 and chopping it down to make a very wide super-smoother.

I've seen a #6 length #8 (if you see what I mean)

BugBear

Re: Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plane

#16

shorter

paul womack

>have some fun and ask the seller to cut off the last couple inches to make it easier to ship !....Todd

At least you can cut off the piece wit the hang-hole.

I mean, we KNOW that hang-holes devalue tools, right?

BugBear

Re: Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plane

#17

ROFLMAO

Bob Demers

>

Re: Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plane

#18

But LN makes a 7.5...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>He's has a 7 3/4...

Much rarer 8^)

Re: Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plane

#19

If you do this project

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I'll be interested in photos. I've got a No. 6 Bedrock body that I picked up for $1 - just the body, no frog, wood, anything - that, I later learned, turns up at the back end pretty considerably. I've kept it in case I ever had time for my own idiot project, making an infill 4-1/2 or so. So you'll either be an inspiration or a useful warning...

Re: Looking for a beat up, possibly broken #8 plane

#20

Still looking for a donor...

James Watriss

>But I'll be sure and document everything very well when I do this.