Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

Posts

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#26

restricted choice

paul womack

>How could a 17" wide bench NOT be tippy?

Depends how often the forces applied are in the narrow axis.

If you're continually chopping down, and planing along, the narrowness would be a non-issue.

Context is all.

BugBear

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#27

No not cynical...

Bob Demers

>Probably just hit the proverbial nail on its shank, or is it the head ? :-)

That we like it or not, they all have to cater to where they feel the money is.

Fortunately for us, Pop WW and Woodworking mag are, IMHO, filing the void very well for me. I must remember to look up the new issue of Woodwork today, hope its on the newstand in my neck of the woods yet.

Bob

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#28

I guess I'm stupid . . .

John H. in Baltimore

>because my bench is 17" wide. ;)

Actually, width is not the only factor in determining "tippyness". Lowering the center of gravity improves stability. I have a planing beam used for outdoor work that I store across my bench's side stretchers. Plenty of ballast weight and no tipping.

In fact, my bench is a Roubo as illustrated in Landis. The laminated top is 5" thick. I chose not to include front and back stretchers (for greater storage flexibility underneath). Even without these stretchers,the bench doesn't rack at all. I guess the 5" dovetails & mortises through the top provide sufficient resistance against racking.

If anyone would like to see pictures of the bench, let me know and I can try to post some tonight.

Thanks,

John

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#29

Re: I guess I'm stupid . . .

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I have to agree with you, John. I think with a sturdy, heavy bench this is not a problem. One of the Dominy benches has a top made of a single piece of red oak 5 1/2 X 17 1/2 x !2'. There is a 2 X 11 board fastened on the back for a wider work area, but the back legs are still under the main beam, not supporting the extra board. That is to say, the base is only 17 1/2 at the floor. It rather looks like the extra board was added at a later date. Some how the Dominys were able to use this bench for 150 years or so.

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#30

Since you mentioed cynicism Bill....

Dave Anderson NH

>It brings to mind the comments that are common about paranoia.

1) Just because you are paranoid it doesn't mean some one isn't out to get you.

2) Paranoia is nothing but a heightened awareness of reality.

3) Of course I'm paranoid, but am I being paranoid enough?

All three easily work if you repalce the word paranoia with cynicism.

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#31

Pictures--Yes!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi John,

Pictures of your bench would be great! Please post. Many here are building or planning to build a Roubo-type bench, and your photos, plus any remarks you might make on construction would help them a lot.

Wiley

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#32

My wife says

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>a cynic is an idealist who's been disappointed too many times.

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#33

Got to thinking today

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Our younger son refused to learn to read until second grade - just couldn't see the point of it - the reading specialist, a little British lady with the size and enthusiasm of a sparkplug, got him past the initial resistance, and then he zoomed along.

Once he had the basics down, what got him zooming was a set of (reprinted) McGuffey readers we bought for him (he was and is something of a history buff, which meant reading them by kerosene lantern). I was struck, in reading through them with him, how high the expectations were - no "Oh, Dick and Jane, See Spot Run" stuff. Real literature, even if carefully selected for reading level - and, even there, each level introduced something that made him work toward the next level.

I think good teaching must have an aspirational component - it's not enough to help the student master the techniques, the teaching needs to inspire the student to stretch. FWW in its youth had a lot of aspirational articles, although I will acknowledge that some of what they asked us to aspire to now looks rather dated. It doesn't so much feel that way these days to me.