Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

Posts

Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#1

Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I just finished the latest issue, and was motivated to send the following letter to the editors:

"I was disappointed in Chris Gochnour's articles on plane use. First, his illustrations are exclusively of bedrock-type planes, though he mentions briefly that Bailey-type planes require a different approach to adjusting the frog; no reference is made to the Veritas adjusters. In the "Fundamentals" article, he suggests setting the plane for a shaving "0.001 in to 0.002 in. thick, that's near full width and tapers to nothing at its edges." After 35 years of trying to learn to use hand tools, I've realized that a shaving tapered across its width is created by a cutting iron that's curved or cambered across some portion of its width, so I went to the sharpening video referenced in the article, expecting some discussion of the various camber patterns for different plane irons, only to be disappointed (the video itself was fine - just limited).

"Then, in the 'Plane Like a Pro' article (p. 46ff), he apparently intends the jack plane to be set up for coarser shavings than the smooth plane, as when he states (p. 47), '...start with a jack to remove heavy mill marks and finish with the smoother...' But if the innocent beginner sets the planes according to the instructions in the earlier article - the only place where plane settings are discussed - the jack plane will be minimally more effective than the smoother. There will be a lot of those 0.001-0.002" shavings on the shop floor before the mill marks and clamp dings are gone.

"Come on, folks. You know better than that."

I cruised back through recent magazines, and was unable to find an article on sharpening. An article on plane use that doesn't start with sharpening the iron is a little like teaching your 16 year old child to drive by explaining how to observe the traffic laws and plan a cross-country trip without practicing starting and stopping.

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#2

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

ThomD

>People might not get that since it has been pretty bad for a long time. They don't seem to have the bench depth to actually spot erors any more, and haven't had it for 10 years. If you look at all the big names in Woodworking showmaship these days, most of them started with FWW. Not sure what happened. But it makes you wonder if the people who objected to colour weren't on to something. :)

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#3

Logical error

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I remember the early color issues - the Pennsy painted chest pictures would not have been the same in black and white.

I don't know that there's a connection between the move to color and the loss of quality. The resurgence of woodworking during the last 30 years has had some interesting impacts, not all of them positive (as always with this sort of thing). There was a time when FWW was more or less alone, but they made some dumb decisions in response to the competition. Perhaps the failure of "Home Furniture" was part of a decision to turn away from leadership in the field and dumb it down. But jeez - there's a distinction between focusing on the beginner and offering trash!

Interestingly, Fine Homebuilding has held up in quality. I can't speak for the rest of the Taunton magazines, since what I know about sewing can be held in a small thimble, my gardening skills are limited to digging stuff up for LOML, and high grade food for me is paying more than $10 for the entree at a restaurant.

There was a time when Popular Woodworking wasn't much of a magazine, but the publishers hired competent editors, who have changed the magazine dramatically. In my opinion, it now occupies much of the niche that once belonged to FWW.

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#4

Re: Logical error

Tim Caley

>Is it just my imagination, but has anyone else noticed that articles that are in Popular Woodworking seem to show up in Fine Woodworking a couple of months later with a slightly different twist? Popular Woodworking does a great series on workbenches, Chris Schwarz writes a great book on the subject, Fine Woodworking follows with quite a few articles on benches. PW has an article by Rob Millard on inlays, this month FW has one? Not the same construction method, but similar idea. I've done no research, no actual comparisons, just an observation. What do you'all think?

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#5

What do I think?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I think that my anal retentive nature wouldn't let me stop taking FWW, just because I'm afraid I might miss something. I generally leaf through it and if I go back a second time, it's almost unusual

But the mag that I truly look forward to is Pop Woodworking.

Bruce

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#6

Re: What do I think?

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I think that the editors at PopWood have gone out of their way to be people, much like us. They talk about their discoveries, their foibles, their challenges. They seem human. They post here, and on blogs, and write books. They hold shows when traditional wood shows are faltering, and sell out the place, and have people clambering for more, places, times, and instances. They start a new magazine without advertising, and make it a success, at least in the minds of many of us put off by much advertising.

Taunton is still figuring out this new century. It differs from the old one, in many ways.

I'm looking forward to the Woodwork issue being on the shelf soon. I let my subscription lapse.

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#7

Re: Logical error

ThomD

>I was joking. What people sensed was that "their magazine" was being forced to bend to market forces, not to make it any better. They were right to fear that and the magazine was swollowed up, but not for a long time thereafter. Many of my favorite issues were colour, and I prefer colour. The link, if tenuous, is that real FW, is probably a severe minority activity like B&W photography. However, wood itself is colourful...

Your right about the painted chests. I think there was a perception that painted chests had no reason to be in FWW, or painted anything. And while I liked that article, in general it's not like radio adapting to rap music, paint has not taken over. It was a double kind of slap, change the mag format, in order to allow the unspeakable in the mag.

There are magazines that go through uncomfortable backflips. Canoe magazine has virtually zero % canoe content any longer. To the extent they now publish a canoeing annual to cover something other than kayaks. That is somewhat what happened to FWW, it stopped being about FW. Possibly the word "Fine" is an unfortunate choice, it seems to create an elitism backlash. But it stopped being about FW, for better or worse.

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#8

Re: Logical error

ThomD

>I doubt it. FWW was first, on most subjects. They may have published two books on benches before Chris got around to it or anyone else. The first Roubo bench plan was in the Landis book decades ago. It's the better plan and anyone with a nice one ton chunk of oak can prove it to themselves.

The lead time for mag articles is quite a bit longer than a few issues, and to bother to copy someone else's work would assume the segment for both magazines is the same, which seems unlikely.

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#9

Re: Logical error

Tim Caley

>I agree with you on the history of FW. I'm just speaking in terms of the last year or two. And I'm not saying that they are plagerizing (sp?). It just seems me to that PW is the one that is pushing the agenda of what goes in print these days.

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#10

Re: What do I think?

Paul Kierstead

>Actually, in some ways, FWW is way ahead in this century over many, many other magazines. Their web site is chock full of content, including all the magazine content and new, web site only, content which is updated frequently. As a "publisher", their willingness to adopt to the new environment has quite impressed me. They still are somewhat unwilling to directly engage their customer, but I think many publishers (and especially) authors) like the more one-way approach to communicating.

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#11

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

Paul Kierstead

>Damn webkit problems ate my first reply.

Do you really think handplaning can be covered even remotely completely in a single article? Of course it can't, and any attempt to do so is bound to be pretty dismal. Now of course one might say they shouldn't try then. Well I might agree but I am somewhat sympathetic to the authors and publishers. They probably get lots of requests, and have surveys, focus groups, etc. all which drive them to do this. Now I always hope any creator will step up, take a risk and do what is best instead of following a formula, but really a bigg-ish publisher like Taunton (well, big for their genre) isn't the best vehicle for that, and it is somewhat understandable why.

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#12

My concern is that it's misleading

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>If a newcomer to hand tools follows the instructions in the articles, s/he will be no further ahead than if s/he just fumbles around. I don't know what the answer is, except perhaps a series of articles.

I certainly agree that it can't all be covered in one article, or even two - both the authors of "Planecraft," and Garrett Hack, in "The Handplane Book," devote a chapter each, or more, to sharpening alone, and even then aren't altogether complete - shoot, Leonard Lee managed to do a whole book on the subject (as did Popular Science back in the early 1960's - the Pop Sci book supplements Leonard Lee's quite well, should someone find it at a garage sale).

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#13

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

Hank Knight

>I agree, Paul.

I looked through my new FWW mag last week and found the articles index interesting. I finally got to sit down last night and read Gochnour's article. My first impression was utter disappointment, like Bill's. But when I though about it, I realized that Gochnour probably did about as well as he could in the space he had. It would take a whole issue - or more - to cover all the nuances that go into really successful hand planing.

I am left with two thoughts: First, I think many of us have come a long way down the hand tool path since we picked up our first copy of FWW, and it now takes a fine level of subtlety to get our attention (Gochnour didn't get there for most of us); and Second, while the article may have excited some to pick up a hand plane for the first time, it probably did them a disservice becuse it made it look too simple. At the very least I think the article should have alluded to the the fact set up for .001 shavings that feather to nothing at the edges requires a level of precision set-up and sharpening that is beyond the scope of the article, and directed the reader to some other sources for further research.

I'm not ready to scrap my FWW subscription, but I think they can do better.

My $.02'

Hank

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#14

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>My opinion is that the article never did belong in Fine Woodworking. The magazine title says all it should - FINE Woodworking.

A 'beginner' or 'novice' level article like this one belongs in a different magazine - like maybe American Woodworker, or BH&G's Wood magazine.

FWW used to be renowned for its upper level articles and works. Now, it's dumbing down to a much more 'entry level' format. Next thing you know, they'll be putting plans and patterns in the centerfold...

Jim D.

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#15

I scrapped this one a year ago

Paul M.

>I got sick of FWW about two years ago, and my subscription finally ran out about this time last year. I've glanced at issues a couple of times at the local bookstore, but never thought that any issues were worth taking home. I'm completely done with tablesaw and router reviews, and that's about all that's left in FWW.

I'm content with "Woodwork" and Lee Valley catalogs. I've dropped everything else relating to woodworking.

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#16

One note on Landis....

Christopher Schwarz

>I'm don't disputing Thom's assessment of my plan for a Roubo, but I wouldn't build it as suggested in Landis. I interviewed Rob Tarule about his Roubo bench last year and he said it was too narrow and tippy at 17-1/4".

So if you are going to follow the plan, you should stick to Roubo's original instructions to make it 20" to 25" wide.

And Thom, I would quite like to hear about the deficiencies offline. Send me an e-mail at my address above.

Chris

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#17

...."Fine Homebuilding has held up"....

cooper suter

>I can't agree w/that.

I've let both lapse, but for me it's FHB that more consistently disappoints; it's all about Martha Stewart type graphics and homeowner/handyman how-to articles.

I started w/Fine Homebuilding over 20 years ago.

I used to subscribe to both, and always read them cover to cover.

Now I can skim an issue while in line at the local general store and it's less than once a year I feel an issue merits purchasing.

I've currently got half a dozen banana boxes full of old FWW and FHB in the bathroom at my shop, I think they'll hold me for awhile.

Coop

(Who's back in the workbench business; hit an industrial auction a week and a half ago, five trailer loads later (not counting the two semis to Jim Crammonds company), and I've still got a couple more benches to get. Keep buying Kia's, it's an auction slaughter in the industrial heartland right now. I've never seen entire factories being sold off at this rate before.)

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#18

Sign of the times.

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I just recieved the latest copy of FWW yesterday. It came with a cover wrap that was an advertisement for Jet. That spoke volumes to me.

The FWW of old would never have stooped to wrapping their magazine in an ad. Now they do. Like others have indicated here, I am dissapointed with the direction FWW has taken. But I have a hunch it's a sign of the times. I think the internet etc. has taken its toll on print media. Nowadays they appear to be scrambling for business. Looks to me that FWW has had to resort to morphing to a publication for the masses, I assume to garner as much readership as possible. Unfortunately that has damaged them in the eyes of long time subscribers and serious woodworkers, myself included.

After the last year of recieving FWW I have, for the first time, considered not renewing my subscription. I sometimes wonder if FWW is in danger of losing more subscriptions to disappointed serious woodworkers than they gain from the new hobbyist woodworkers they seem to be catering to these days? Time will tell.

Tom

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#19

Re: Sign of the times.

Dave Anderson NH

>Yeah, What Tommy said. I just let my subscription lapse and have already received at least 4 notices and warnings that if I wait to renew I'll miss an issue. Of course I suppose I could send them a note saying I intend to miss at least the next 30-40 issues. I don't have any beef with the editors or the magazine staff, in fact I've met many of them and they are really wonderful folks. Unfortunately, what they sell no longer interests me very much.

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#20

I am, alas cynically, reminded of TV

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>There are frequently articles about the TV folks developing shows for the 18-34 age demographic (although, if you ask me, they're mostly developing for the 12-14 mental demographic), because that age group spends way more money than, say, the 60-70 age demographic, which latter group mostly owns what it needs already.

I do find myself wondering if FWW writes how it does because the long-time woodworkers mostly have the kit already, while newcomers need to build it up.

Then I wonder if I've just acquired too much cynicism over the years.

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#21

Re: One note on Landis....

Charles

>It's a bench for a millwork shop. It's for big heavy parts for the doors, mantles, posts, and mouldings that were popular in the day. For fine cabinet and furnituremaking, it's overkill and doesn't have nearly the parts holding capability found on a standard European bench(Frid, Klaus, et al.)

If a bench is a tool, and furnituremaking is what you do, a "Roubo" is the wrong tool for the job.

Never understood what all the kerfuffle was about.

Did you ask Tarule why it took so long to figure out his was tippy? Why no mention was made of it in the Landis book? Did he mention it and it was edited out?

My curiosity would have been killing me.... inquiring minds..... and all that stuff.

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#22

Re: One note on Landis....

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>How could a 17" wide bench NOT be tippy? That is if it isn't bolted to a wall. A 17" wide workbench is just basically stupid! Am I missing something here?

Marv

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#23

Re: One note on Landis....

Charles

>I agree, but you'd have thought it the cat's pajamas in the Landis book. Either that or I've totally forgotten that it was mentioned in the book (I don't think it was).

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#24

Not cynical enough.

Victor P

>

Re: Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was

#25

I have to agree with Tommy and Bill...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I too just received the add laden copy of the rag. I was not impressed, I thought it might be a free addition of one of the rags I'd dropped trying to get me to come back. Seems like a lot of changes are going around the WW publications recently. The nice one is that I received the latest Woodwork today, very nice. I might be dropping 1 of my three rags soon.