Sigh - Fine Woodworking is NOT the mag it was
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>I just finished the latest issue, and was motivated to send the following letter to the editors:
"I was disappointed in Chris Gochnour's articles on plane use. First, his illustrations are exclusively of bedrock-type planes, though he mentions briefly that Bailey-type planes require a different approach to adjusting the frog; no reference is made to the Veritas adjusters. In the "Fundamentals" article, he suggests setting the plane for a shaving "0.001 in to 0.002 in. thick, that's near full width and tapers to nothing at its edges." After 35 years of trying to learn to use hand tools, I've realized that a shaving tapered across its width is created by a cutting iron that's curved or cambered across some portion of its width, so I went to the sharpening video referenced in the article, expecting some discussion of the various camber patterns for different plane irons, only to be disappointed (the video itself was fine - just limited).
"Then, in the 'Plane Like a Pro' article (p. 46ff), he apparently intends the jack plane to be set up for coarser shavings than the smooth plane, as when he states (p. 47), '...start with a jack to remove heavy mill marks and finish with the smoother...' But if the innocent beginner sets the planes according to the instructions in the earlier article - the only place where plane settings are discussed - the jack plane will be minimally more effective than the smoother. There will be a lot of those 0.001-0.002" shavings on the shop floor before the mill marks and clamp dings are gone.
"Come on, folks. You know better than that."
I cruised back through recent magazines, and was unable to find an article on sharpening. An article on plane use that doesn't start with sharpening the iron is a little like teaching your 16 year old child to drive by explaining how to observe the traffic laws and plan a cross-country trip without practicing starting and stopping.



