Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

Posts

Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

#1

Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

James Watriss

>So, 3 or 4 years ago, I ordered a few of the Imai sword steel chisels from Kayoko. They're wonderful, and when I heard she'd retired, I remember being glad, because it sounded like it was well earned.

But I was using one of these this afternoon, and I'm really craving a few more sizes. Does anyone know where to look? I just emailed hida tool, and we'll see where it goes from there, but I figured I'd ask if anyone had any ideas.

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

#2

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

dburnard

>Hida Tool is Imai-san's sole US distributor now. I heard there was some confusion during the transition period where some of the folks at Hida were not aware of these chisels - hopefully that has been corrected in the mean time. They are still a special order item.

If for some reason Hida is still having trouble taking orders for these chisels, you should drop Kayoko a note so she can look into the situation.

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

#3

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

Howard Pollack

>Hi-

Hida will special order them for you (so they tell me). The Imai regular chisels are available from Hida directly. Do you have a sense of the difference? Thanks -Howard

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

#4

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where? *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>If either of the above suggestions don't work for you, you might try Iida. Tomohito-san deals with most of the major blacksmiths personally.


Iida Tool

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

#5

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

James Watriss

>Thanks, Pam... I remember hearing about lida, but hadn't actually gone over to look at what they have. I'll keep that in mind if hida can't find them...

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

#6

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

James Watriss

>Thanks, Howard. Good to know... I'll await their response.

As for whether or not I can tell the difference, it's hard to gauge. I haven't cut so many hundreds of drawers, and I can't tell you conclusively that I'd feel the difference between these and one of Imai's other chisels. Nor could I tell you how many more strokes or hours these chisels will last over something else, except that they'd outlast the Marples chisels by several weeks.

I started woodworking full time as a student 4 years ago, and took a week class on Japanese tools from John Reed Fox in Maine during my first summer vacation. After I told him I was at North Bennet, he recommended these. I also picked up (what I was told was) a Mitsukawa ryoba, and rip cut dozuki. The dozuki is a dream. Later that year, the ryoba caught in a cut and the corner tore. But the steel feels much different than that of the dozuki, which is very flexible, and silky feeling, so maybe there are different grades of saw from that maker. (The ryoba came in a printed, orange cloth cover, and the dozuki came in a paper sleeve, so maybe the difference in packaging is also telling... or maybe I was just a fumbling jerk who broke his saw.) I was mortified, and felt really, really bad about tearing that saw, but I kept the piece that tore off, and I still use the saw. It works well enough, but I think I like the Takumi ryoba saw from Woodcraft better. The Mitsukawa rip dozuki is the best saw I own.

Being a new guy back then, I certainly didn't know any better about chisels. I'd been cutting dovetails and doing a lot of side work on my own using Marples, and then Pfeil bench chisels... and both are good enough, though I certainly liked the swiss chisels much better. As I was going through school, someone gave me a set of Lie-Nielsen chisels, and I was enthralled. I'd used the sword steel chisels, and some other (much cheaper) Kumagoro Japanese chisels that I picked up at Rockler,and I liked them well enough. In retrospect, and having recently handled some tools that I'd sharpened back then and not used much since, I don't think I knew enough about sharpening then to really understand the difference. one of the Kumagoros from Rockler chipped when I was DT'ing some white oak. I'm not sure if it was from my zealous whaling away, or the wrong honing angle, or what.

Almost 4 years later, I've done a lot more work. Graduated North Bennet, opened up my own shop, still love the craft. I still like the L-N chisels, but I've started using my japanese chisels more. The chisels from Rockler are still pretty decent, I guess, but the sword steel chisels are a dream. They take a much nicer edge than the L-N A-2 is capable of, and they feel sharper to me than the other chisels I have. But the other thing I've noticed is that I respect them a lot more. The L-N chisels look and feel machine made, and they're nice enough, and they're certainly very tough chisels, but I still have no qualms about scraping glue off with them if there's a nook or cranny I can't get to.

The Imai chisels are a thing of beauty, by contrast, and that's on top of taking and holding a much finer edge. I'm sure there's a clearer explanation in some psychological sense, but overall, they feel like a tool with a soul. And so I really can't just whale away like I can with the Lie-Nielsens. Well, I can, and I'm sure they'd take the pounding, but the point is that I feel like I'm much more attentive, and careful in my work, and I feel like I still have to aspire to these tools, even though I think I've done some pretty good work in my career so far. I can put a really sharp edge on these tools. But I think they're sharpening me, too.

That's the difference I feel. I'm not sure if that's quite the answer you were looking for.

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

#7

Don't know if you've ever been there, but..

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>It's a mom and pop store. Very small, but one can spend hours in it. They might be a little slow but the service is great considering these thing travel a slow boat and are hand made.

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

#8

Dozuki vs Ryoba

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>James, these are very different tools, handle differently, cut differently, etc. I think it's because the dozuki is stiffer and meets the wood more firmly, but I'm no expert in this regard. If it makes you feel any better, I broke two ryoba before I got the hang of it, primarily due to excessive force.

Pam

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

#9

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

wilbur

>To my knowledge, one other difference between the regular Imai chisels and the sword steel chisels is that the hard layer steel in the sword steel chisels has a slightly higher carbon content, which theoretically means that the chisel would keep an edge longer, and perhaps can be sharpened to a finer degree.

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

#10

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

Alan DuBoff

>Wilbur,

Do you know if the tool steel in the sword steel chisels is oil hardening steel?

Some folks make the mistake of comparing the white/blue steel to oil/air hardening, but both white and blue are oil hardening steels, AFAIK. While the blue steel holds an edge more similar to A2, as an example, it is still an oil hardening steel where the A2 is air hardening. In fact I have heard the white/blue is in reference to the paper the manufacture wraps the steel in for shipping.

Do you know if the sword steel is also oil hardening, like the blue steel?

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

#11

Your shaving horse

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Meant to ask you the other day if you built that shaving horse in your shop photo.

Pam

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

#12

Re: Your shaving horse

James Watriss

>Yes, I did... I'd wrapped it up a day or two before posting it, and stuck it in there to see who'd notice. : )

It's pretty much directly from the Boggs article, I can talk about it more if people are interested.

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

#13

Re: Your shaving horse

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I'm very interested in the interior of the gear box. I also like the Boggs horse, the one from his DVD.

Pam

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

#14

White and blue steels, water and oil

wilbur

>Hi Alan,

I think that the "sword steel" description of the Imai sword steel chisels might be more a reference to the layered Damascus pattern in the soft layer. The hard layer is still white steel.

You are right about the origin of the white/blue steel names. It really is based on the paper that is used to wrap the steel when it comes from Hitachi. I think what is sometimes missed is that there are grades of white and blue steel as well. To my knowledge, white steel is a high carbon steel, and is actually water hardened. Blue steel has alloys added to it to increase wear resistance. Blue steel is primarily water hardened, but at least one of the blue steel varieties can be oil hardened. They say that water hardening is better for the blue steels, though.

So in a nutshell, my guess is that the Imai sword steel chisels are water hardened.

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

#15

Re: White and blue steels, water and oil

Alan DuBoff

>Wilbur,

I just thought of something you might be able to shed some light on, or someone else for that matter.

On Japanese chisels, the tool steel layer appears to be a channel, where the sides are squared at the outer edges, and the softer steel fits inside. What I wasn't sure of is if the makers buy the white/tool steel in the u-shaped channel or not, do you know?

Me and a blacksmith friend were talking about this recently, but it was something he hadn't noticed before until I mentioned it, and he was also curious how they do that. In theory, you would need to forge out any air pockets inside the channel, unless they buy the soft/hard steel laminated already, but I kinda doubt that.

Some look like they could be forged over, and the edge rolled over, but others are very clean and square that I have seen.

Do you know how the steel is laminated?

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

#16

Re: White and blue steels, water and oil *LINK*

wilbur

>Hi Alan,

The two layers are forge welded (I think that's the term). They are heated up and pounded together with a hammer. Then the final chisel/plane blade shape is ground from the forge welded blank.

The U-shape is a result of the pounding. The two layers start out being flat.

There's a nice online movie of a Japanese plane blade being made, which will show how this process goes way better than I can describe, even if the audio is all in Japanese, which I don't speak.


How to make a Japanese plane blade

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

#17

Re: Your shaving horse

James Watriss

>No gear box, just a toggle that fits into the notches cut into the lower jaw stem. Pivots around a bolt that's just out of the picture, but if you draw a line at 45 degrees back and down, it's about there, buried wherever in the body. Jaw can't come down without the toggle pushing harder into the notch... and that's all there is.


img

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

#18

Re: White and blue steels, water and oil

ThomD

>In a simpler time there were formulas given for the white and blue steel in books. I had a Japanese tool book many years ago that had the formulas, and there have been som online also.

White #1 1.2-1.3%, Mn 0.2-0.3%

Blue #1 1.2-1.3%, Mn 0.2-0.3% , Cr 0.3-0.5%, W 1.5-2.0%

Super Blue: C 1.4-1.5%, Mn 0.2-0.3%, Cr 0.3-0.5%, W 2.0-2.5%, Mo 0.3-0.5%, V 0.3-0.5%

Most non-makers put far too high an emphasis on the steel types used, not talking here about Japanese stuff in particular. In the knife biz the availability of steel in quantity is an on again off again thing. Normally one can adjust the heat treatment process to deal with fairly gross differences. Not to say one could span the difference between HSS and a simple carbon steel, but at the same time the market will learn to appreaciate a certain brand like 440C stainless, and reams will get written about how other 440s are just for cheap knives, but if the squeeze is on the availability of 440C the industry adapts a lot faster that the marketing.

Whether a steel is nominally a water hardening or oil hardening is not really important where Japanese laminated tools are concerned. There is always some variability in those issues. What is less variable is that the nose diagram for a particular steel will map how quickly it needs to be cooled in order to harden to a given degree. But the rate of cooling can vary depending on the shape of the object. How it is put in the water (interrupted quench or even the angle of entry), and in the case of Japanese tools the fact there is a big lump of iron scabbed onto the tool steel.

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

#19

It appears, also, that you can switch platens

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>or whatever you might call the piece on which the work rests - is that true? Could you substitute, for the V-grooved surface, a flat one, for instance, by removing the toothed vertical piece altogether and substituting another?

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

#20

Re: White and blue steels, water and oil

Alan DuBoff

>Wilbur,

Thanks, that link is very helpful, but I don't see what I was curious about yet, as the plane blades do not appear to have that.

The NokoGiri video is helpful and answers some of the Qs I have been wondering about Japanese saws. No Nomi video though...:-(

That is a great site, I do speak some Japanese, what I don't understand I can have my wife help with...:-)

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

#21

Re: White and blue steels, water and oil

Alan DuBoff

>ThomD wrote:

"Whether a steel is nominally a water hardening or oil hardening is not really important where Japanese laminated tools are concerned."

I wasn't as concerned with water or oil as much as I was oil or air. I can easily harden steel with oil, so to work with O1 is a plus. However, working A2 is not as easy, although people do it and have systems to do it, for me using oil hardening steel is much more common and easier to work with in my modest shop.

Thanks for posting those properties on the different steels used in Japan, I'm tucking that away for future reference.

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

#22

Re: It appears, also, that you can switch platens

James Watriss

>I'm sure you could, if you wanted, to. Not sure why you'd need to, though, unless you wanted something smaller, or better access for shaping things like cabriole legs, maybe.

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

#23

Re: Your shaving horse

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Thanks, James, it looks so simple; but in the DVD Boggs seems to make a point of NOT showing it in detail that I'd thought perhaps it was tricky.

Pam

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

#24

Re: Your shaving horse

James Watriss

>I think, if it's the DVD that I have, (drawknives and spokeshaves) it may not be so sinister sounding. He's already put the plans in their entirety... or at least, enough to be able to assemble the horse... in an article from way back when, in Fine WoodWorking. So, for the DVD, he may simply have been trying to put the focus on the blades/tools, and not trying to hide the details of something he'd already put out there. At the time, it wasn't a Lie-Nielsen product, so they probably weren't too concerned with the details, either.

Re: Kayoko's Imai sword steel chisels... where?

#25

Re: White and blue steels, water and oil

ThomD

>My point about the Japanese steel is that joining it to iron makes the composite into a water hardening steel. The generally stubby shape of the blades doesn't hurt either. I don't know how they make the saws. That part is pretty amazing.

I oil harden O1 also, though the pot of oil I have will eventually probably spill over the floor. I would like to try out Goop, it works well for the same range of steels and consists of lard mixed with equalish amounts of parafin wax, a little beeswax (mix of old candles), and then cut to about 1/4 hydraulic fluid. It remains solid, doesn't go rancid, isn't attractive to animals, hardens blades real hard according to Goddard. Doesn't seem to need to be pre-heated like oil. But for now I have the oil...

O1 can be water hardened, though thin blades will almost certainly crack. I cracked a plane blade water hardening it, it cracked where I stopped dipping it into the water, which was about where the colour ran out. The using part of the blade was fine. That sounds like a manageable problem. The other problem is that O1 is cheap enough but expensive for random unecesarry "scientific" fiddling around. Kind of thing one would want to do with junk steels.