Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Blade grind - flat vs cambered

Posts

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#26

Re: neophyte glue question

Dean J in MN

>I asked the guys in the Hay shop if they added anything (such as urea) to their hide glue for long joints, case dovetails, etc.

They do not. They enlist extra hands from the shop and work quickly. It is possible, with unmodified glue, to do long joints if you have everything ready and move quickly. Lay the long joints face-to-face, and use a big fat brush to quickly apply glue to both edges at once. Using a heavier application gives you a bit more working time, more mass to cool. Quickly fold the boards open and rub. Clamp if needed.

I've done that in my shop on long joints, it is possible. In fact I always do this for drawer bottoms if I need to glue up panels. I figure the more practice I get the better. What I can't do is get a dovetailed case together. I just don't have the helpers. So I modify my glue for case dovetails.

-Dean

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#27

Re: neophyte glue question

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Traditionally most larger shops had a glue room which was heated to allow for long and complex joinery such as chairs. If your shop or glue and work are 90 degrees F you have 10 minutes of open time, as the temp goes down, less time. In a 60 degree shop you have about 30 seconds of open time with hot hide glue.

There are many things you can add to hide glue to make it liquid at room temperature (liquid hide glue) and those date back to the early 1800's.

Stephen

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#28

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Thom,

Quoting from your post,

"So of what you have also said is kinda that a few thou here or there may not mater. "

I believe it is the opposite--that a few thou is crucial. My test is what I said above--the join line should literally disappear when the boards are brought together with little to no pressure applied.

So then the question becomes: What is the tolerance for an edge to disappear, prior to crushing it together with clamps? My guess is that the joint has to close to within a couple of thousandths everywhere for that to happen. If you figure a 1" wide edge, and that the pivot point of the plane is at the center of the edge (for simplicity's sake), then if the tolerance at the edge is 2 thou, then the angular error permitted the plane has to be on the order of arctan(0.002"/0.5") = arc tan (0.004)--which would require that the plane be held to less than a quarter of a degree off vertical, and consistently.

The math implies that extraordinary precision is required, yet as Moxon said (paraphrasing)--'for those accustomed to doing this task, it is thought to be no big deal'. Trying to resolve that paradox (difficult in theory vs. widely performed with success) leads me to two suppositions: (1) the cambered blade presents the blade to the work in a shallow arc, which allows us a slight bit of angular error, without changing the presentation of the blade to the work; and (2) any blade which is sharpened on stones is going to have at least a slight camber to it--only those sharpened on thick glass or granite are going to approximate 'dead flat'.

Wiley

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#29

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

ThomD

>"I believe it is the opposite--that a few thou is crucial. My test is what I said above--the join line should literally disappear when the boards are brought together with little to no pressure applied."

I would agree with that, as I sorta said in the part that followed the quote. I probably shouldn't have said a couple of thou, that is a pretty thick increment. I hope I didn't already tell this story, because telling twice kinda undermines my point... But I recently had to turn a < 3/8" stub on the metal lathe. I just eyeballed it and it came out .371" I was chuffed, but not totally stunned. I think we can feel and see a lot more than we let on. So yeah, 2 thou is a lot, five times the thickness of my thinnest shavings. (Or maybe not, see below)

My point was more theoretical, in the good sense. If you are talking about the subtle correction you are referring to. Something you don't appear to be overtly controlling, just suggesting it may be there, then it sounds like a difference that is in the rub. Very small. At some point the difference one might identify will fall within whatever the invisibility increment is. You are talking about something that you think is happening, but don't know is happening affecting stuff you can easily see, like ugly glue lines.

I do see what you are getting at, but it sounds like this random correction could just as easily work against as for. So we have something that is maybe in the tens (you reject 2 thou, probably with reason), essentially unmeasurable without a very nice toolroom level of measurement, and it is supposed to be compensating for errors that are easily in the thous or above - angular error. The reason this sounds attractive is that you believe there is an otherwise unexplainable result - really nice gluelines. So let's look at that.

I can think of two examples where results are way out of line with inputs:

1) Dovetails. I do ok when I am in practice. I can wow an audience. A Cosman wow for people who have never seen Cosman. :) The reality is that how I finish the parts can make a big difference to the presence of gaps. Usually the baseline of my cuts is good, but I can make it bad simply by how I plane of file the ends. I can also make it good. I am talking about post glue-up finishing, not filling in or patching holes. I don't think this is what happens when joining an edge because I do that totally differently, but I do think it shows that accuracy in parts is not the whole story. How we use glue and clamps can make a difference. That may tell us that more is happening than we at first see. But it is happening after all the joints are cut.

2) Soundboards. This is demanding edge joint work, and it requires accurate surfaces, but that is not all. The joint has to totally disappear, but it also has to be as strong as possible. One technique that works is to place the two pieces side by side, and just rub them till they take. At first they don't seem that tight, and aren't, but the glue pulls them together as they dry and the joint is ultimately invisible. So invisible that one better be careful to mark the joint because even the ends aren't always enough to show the position of the joint.

So who knows. There may be a variety of things that knit the edges together.

Note: I drew it out and a 2 thou eror on the edge of a pair of one inch boards 12 inches wide would cause a "cup" of .02" in the glued up pieces, which actually isn't all that bad. Another factor to consider.

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#30

Thanks

Jerome Bias

>

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#31

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Richard,

I suppose that the crusty old trade training I refer to is that I was trained by old German tradies and guys that probably are your age - ie: trained by those who went through an equivalent of the guild system.

We have specified syllabii (syllabus? syllabuses?) for trade training - students will be able to ...

They only stopped issuing trade texts to students here a couple of years ago in the trade schools, instead favouring a Collins Complete Manual of Woodworking.

I think that Joyce is a better text, personally.

Best regards,

ANdrew

[Who was speaking to his brother in Cambridge yesterday, who escaped the shutdown of SE England and made it home just in time. I'm not sure if I'd rather have our current hot spell (about 8 days above 36C and four or so above 42C) or the cold.]

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#32

Re: neophyte glue question

Greg B�tit, Crown Point, NY.

>They didn't have running water in the shop. They peed in the glue, and in addition to adding the needed thinning, found that it gave them more open time.

greg

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#33

Re: neophyte glue question

John Walkowiak

>You can use the Titebond liquid hide glue for long joints, or for any complicated glue up such as chairs. Tests in magazines over the years have shown it will produce a joint stronger than the wood. I have used it for about 25 years and have never had a failure with it. You do however have to clamp the work, and leave it in the clamps for at least overnight. It has a full cure in about 24 hours. Good luck.

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#34

I always thought ...

Hank Knight

>I always thought peeing in glue was an act of retribution.

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#35

Re: I always thought ...

Greg B�tit, Crown Point, NY.

>Perhaps. It seems like it falls within the bounds of human nature. But it *does* extend open time, regardless.

greg

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#36

Re: I always thought ...

Jerome Bias

>I guess that that answers my question of where does one pick up or order urea.

Jerome

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#37

glue question part 2

Jerome Bias

>Okay I get it that hide glue gels fast real fast. I like that about it sorta. Stephen mention 90degres, but Ihave been following the directions oon the can, which suggested I believe 160.

I don't quite get the issue of hide glue doing better when the surface is rough or if there is a hollow? Or perhaps it is PVA does better when there is a hollow?

Jerome

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#38

And...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>4 guys and case beer can fill a leaking car radiator in a pinch too

8^)

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#39

Re: glue question part 2

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>90 degrees should be the temperature of the shop, the glue needs to be 150 degrees in the glue pot. The water jacket will be hotter.

It helps if the surface has been roughened prior to gluing. As for hollows, you can use filler in hide glue to thicken it up for large gap filling.

The joints should be good prior to gluing. You shouldn't rely on the glue to correct a bad joint.

Stephen

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#40

Re: I always thought ...

Dean J in MN

>You can buy urea at your local greenhouse. The smallest I've found is a 5 pound bag, which is a few lifetimes worth of urea for this use.

-Dean