Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Blade grind - flat vs cambered

Posts

Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#1

Blade grind - flat vs cambered

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi All,

I started this as a response to the previous post on the use of a No.6 plane, but it may be better as a separate discussion topic.

For a while, I've been seeing reference to the use of cambered blades being advocated for edge jointing.

Cambered blades are used to hog off huge amounts of wood quickly in my trade training.

For the finer work, the blade was ground flat, with the corners relieved. A flat blade grind is needed to get a glue joint.

I just checked a few of my reference books.

* Joyce recommends exactly the same as my trade training;

* A 1950's copy of Record 'Planecraft' recommends exactly the same as my trade training - camber was 1/32" to 1/64" in jack planes;

* Charles Hayward recommends the cambered blade for trying edges;

* Leonard Lee advocates straight ground blades with rounded corners for planing surfaces wider than the blade, straight ground blades otherwise.

It appears that there may have been two schools of thought in trade during the first part of the 20th century. My trade training appears to be the more traditional stream.

In the post below, I referred to removing the high point of an edge when squaring an edge by running the plane so that the blade only cuts half of the width.

This is an alternative to using a slightly cambered iron as advocated widely on the internet through many forums. The end result is the same.

Has edge jointing with a cambered blade caused anyone more problems than is solved, or has it made it that much easier and quicker?

CHeers,

Andrew

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#2

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

Ace Karner

>I find it makes it quicker, I use a #5 with a camber to get it square and then make a clean up pass with my HNT Gordon jointer.

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#3

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

ThomD

>This is the lattest fad, post Charlesworth video, that makes a good case for cambered blade as a means of squaring up edges (if that is the right expression for a curves edge that is tangent squared to the edge of a board. They also claim these concave curved edges make nice glue joints. It would be interesting to nick a blade in the center and then look at how centered the nick track really was when jointing, which is related to how consitantly tangent squared it would be. I would feel better about the whole thing if one didn't get so many posts from people who seem unaware there are 5 or so other ways of getting an edge square otherwise. But what works for some, obviously does work.

Concerns are that concave edges will have too much pressure and may be glue starved. Another is that the glue joint will open up if the board is subsequently planed for thickness.

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#4

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi THom,

Many ways to get to Rome, I suppose.

I was highlighting that there seemed to be two distinct schools of thought. I'd say that traditional was square-ground blades, but it is a guess.

Best regards on our national day,

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#5

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Andrew and all,

I edge joint one board at a time; if you match plane, that is a different situation and of course requires a very straight blade.

I use a 26" fairly narrow (2" blade) woodie jointer. With mild camber, like probably a couple thousandths. This would mean that for a 4/4 or 5/4 board, there would be maybe a thousandth of camber across the edge of the board. Indeed, I wonder if most people don't in fact have this level of camber even on their "straight-bladed" planes, just because stones tend to live a more or less concave existence.

As for procedure, let's say we're starting with a roughsawn edge. Right from the band mill, with hair all over the board. I start with a 20" moderate-camber fore plane (not real heavy camber, a little more than a try plane), and attack the high line, wherever it might wander. Maybe 8 to 10 thousandths shavings. Get any convexity out of the length of the edge, and get the edge sorta/kinda/pretty square. Once the full length and width of the edge is showing plane marks, the edge is within reach of the jointer.

Switch to the jointer, and plane from the inside out. At this point I'm not trying to follow the high line, but rather am focusing on holding the plane vertical as I work from the inside toward a full-length full-width shaving. Shavings in the 1-2 thou range.

Key thing: watch the shaving. It will tell you most of what you need to know about the condition of the board. Every other pass, I quickly run a small bevel-edge square down the edge for ground truth. Takes less than 10 strokes with the jointer, once I'm done conditioning the edge with the fore plane.

Test the edge against the adjoining edge: I want to hear a solid clack sound, and see the join line disappear along the full length with light finger pressure. If it doesn't, I will get the board back on edge and find the flaw with the little square--this may cost another 1 or 2 strokes. Process goes very quickly, especially when you get a rhythm going after the first two or three edges.

Issue: I am curious as to exactly what camber does, and what amount of camber is best. Mr. Charlesworth has said in the past that he is talking about 5 thou on either side of the centerline of the blade. So if this is a 2-1/2" typical jointer blade, and we're planing a 1" wide edge, then the edge is seeing maybe 2 thou of camber in the center of the blade.

Thom said a very interesting thing. He said he'd like to see a notch in the middle of the camber, and see exactly what the trace of the blade is along the edge. That thought brings me to my theory (may or may not be original, I don't know).

Theory: what camber really does is provide a little bit of forgiveness against the need to hold the plane dead vertical (and a flat blade dead horizontal) over an edge as you plane. In other words, the cambered blade is an arc of a big circle. If the plane wavers just a _little_ bit from dead vertical, and the blade just a _little_ bit from dead horizontal, the blade will rotate a tad as it cuts, and Thom's notch will wander from the centerline of the edge. But if this movement is small, then the blade will still present itself to the wood just as if there had been no movement--you're making the identical cut, but with a slightly different segment of the blade arc. So rather than facet the edge, the cambered blade will keep the center of the edge slightly below grade. This is what I mean by camber providing a little forgiveness.

But as I said above, I suspect almost everyone has a bit of camber in every bench plane blade they own. Just due to the nature of sharpening.

Wiley

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#6

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

Chris Friesen

>I'm not sure about your theory. The point of the cambered-edge technique is to position the plane side to side such that the deepest part of the camber cuts the high point of the edge while still allowing the plane to ride flat on the out-of-true edge. In this scenario, you don't need to hold the plane level.

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#7

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

R Payne

>Some where, a long time ago, I came across the term "self jigging tool". (It may have been from Roy Underhill) Anyway, the idea of a self jigging tool is one which, by the nature of the tool design, will tend to follow its previous path. This may be the real advantage of a cambered plane. To make it act like a self jigging tool and allow for the plane to follow itself requiring the first few strokes to be made carefully then the subsequent passes will stay on course with perhaps less need for great care not to create an error. If this makes any sense. Or I may just be totally confused on the subject.

ron

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#8

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

Adam Cherubini

>"For a while, I've been seeing reference to the use of cambered blades being advocated for edge jointing."

There may be some confusion here for folks, Andrew. I think many guys use the term "jointing" for squaring or creating an edge to edge butt "joint" interchangeably. Likewise, every groove is a dado to some people.

In my shop these are two very different operations that call for two very different tools.

Here's how it works in my shop:

The surface planes are the smoother, jack plane and try plane. All have rounded irons for working broad faces of stock without "gutters".

Deneb Pulchalski from LN says you don't need a rounded iron if your plane is only taking a .001 or .002 thick shaving.

So my 30"+ long jointer is not technically a surface plane. It's a fitting plane (I'm using Mercer's definitions, tho i don't know in which category he placed the jointer). Like all fitting planes, it has a perfectly flat iron (like rabbets, dadoes, fillesters, match planes, routers etc) I don't use my jointer to work faces, only edges. I prefer that it be wider than any stock I plane (including match planing).

So I think when folks talk about using cambered irons to "joint" they mean the power tool "jointing". That said, the pressure required for PVA is so high that the concave edge probably closes. When gluing with hot hide, the concavity is probably beneficial.

To be clear- I only hot hide short or thin joints. For table long joints, I match plane (using my jointer) and use whatever Titebond product FWW gave away at the last Williamsburg conference.

Speaking of confusing language, when I think traditional hand tool usage, I think of a time when everyone used hand tools to make stuff. I don't think of Joyce or other 20th c authors as presenting traditional techniques. I not suggestintg Andrew is using the term incorrectly. But rather, this, in my mind, is just another example of an ambiguous word many of us (me, in this case) don't think of as being ambiguous.

We need Don McConnell to look this up. This might be a nice magazine article for him. I think Nicholson called edge planing "shooting" and what we call surface planing "facing". What I don't know is whether he used the term "jointing" as distinct from "shooting". I know that early refrences to jointers often include the term "glewing", and that try planes and "glewing jointers" show up on the same document (I think I know of at least 2 such inventories). This suggests to me that my usage may be similar to what was done in the 18th c in at least some shops.

I think by the time Joyce came along, guys were probably squaring up edges on machines, which really confuses things. IIRC, Andrew has said his tradtional trade practice had him using the #6 almost exclusively. Do I have that right? That's certainly not an 18th c or early 19th c tradition. I can see how it would make sense in a shop with power tools though.

Adam

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#9

Thanks Adam, correct

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Adam,

Thanks for the thoughtful input.

What you say makes sense - edge 'jointing' is now an ambiguous term.

Yes, I'm referring to a cabinemaking shop where the stock prep is done with machines.

CHeers,

Andrew

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#10

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

paul womack

>In the post below, I referred to removing the high point of an edge when squaring an edge by running the plane so that the blade only cuts half of the width.

This is an alternative to using a slightly cambered iron as advocated widely on the internet through many forums. The end result is the same.


I too read some older reference books. Most of them don't describe jointing in enough detail (for our purposes). Many of them say "plane, then check with a try square, and fix any errors", which is not very helpful.

Hasluck (1900's IIRC) very clearly shows the use of the cambered blade.

Another book (memory fails me) shows the horrible notion of "just" keeping the plane perfectly vertical (somehow...), so uses neither partial width shavings nor tapered shavings.

BugBear

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#11

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Another book (memory fails me) shows the horrible notion of "just" keeping the plane perfectly vertical (somehow...), so uses neither partial width shavings nor tapered shavings.

This may be a lot easier with wooden jointers, probably due to their tall, square nature. Not that I'd buy a book based on the above statement... :)

Pam

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#12

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

wilbur

>One trick I've picked up for keeping the plane "perfectly vertical" when edge planing is to close my eyes while planing. There's something about removing visual cues that makes your innate sense of balance better. Try it -- you might be happily surprised with the results.

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#13

Nicholson

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Nicholson does not use the word jointing. He says the jointer "is used principally for planing straight edges [sticks for ascertaining flatness], and the edges of boards, so as to make them join together; this operation is called shooting, and the edge itself is said to be shot." Interestingly, Nicholson advises match planing for making straight edges, but boards to be joined are planed individually.

I think smoothing planes work best with a small camber even when taking shavings less than .001. Of course if you are going to sand the surface, it doesn't much matter.

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#14

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Paul,

Hope that all is well over your end of the world.

What I've described is what I was taught by an old German tradesman - their tradition, I suppose.

Hasluck and Charles Hayward say to use a cambered blade for edge planing, the Record Planecraft and Joyce recommend the straight edge on a jointer plane.

Drawing a long bow, I'd suggest that perhaps as Hasluck and Hayward were writing primarily for the gentleman woodworker at the turn of the last century, perhaps its a distinction for edge jointing (shooting straight) that occurred about then. My supposition, nothing else.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#15

Don

Larry Williams

>Don was digging in all his references thinking about posting, then the ice hit. He'd like to still post something but I don't know when he'll be able to.

We got the brunt of the ice storm. Got hammered by 3" of ice. I've got Internet back, still have my phone line lying on the ground and the power is literally hanging by a thread right now.

Don hasn't had power since Tuesday afternoon and won't have Internet connection until the cables are repaired. I just got back from his place because the roads are finally passable. I've seen bad storms in my life but nothing like this. The up side is that we probably have fire wood for the next five years right outside the door.

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#16

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

Sgian Dubh

>Andrew, I've never found it makes much difference which way the blade is sharpened to the ability of a plane or myself to create a good edge joint in panel glue ups; straight or curved blades work just fine. As long as I know which form the cutting edge has I just adapt my technique to suit.

You might wonder why I come across the different blade edge profile. The answer is simple. My own planes used for creating an edge joint have a straight blade edge with a bevel at each corner. In use I tilt the plane or hold it square to the flat faces, take a full width shaving, half width shaving as required or stopped shaving as required.

On the other hand I use a lot of other people's planes too. They are owned by learners that I teach. I come across all sorts of cutting edge profiles, including straight, straight'ish, convex, concave and even serpentine! To save myself the time consuming task of going through a whole lesson in sharpening, including a demonstration, I usually just adapt my technique to suit the plane in my hand. As long as it's sharp I seem to be able to manage for the most part, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#17

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Richard,

I re-read my original post - looks as though trade practice is to grind a straight edge. My training was identical, ie: grind straight and relieve the corners.

Agree with you - tradesmen should be able to use what's at hand. I've had slightly better success/quicker results with the straight blades on edge jointing, personally, however. Perhaps it's my plane grip - I ended up with a combination grip between wooden plane grip and metal plane grip, where I'm not holding the rear tote as much as pushing against it while pressing down hard to keep the sole of the plane in contact with the timber. It works for me but I'll guarantee you'll never find this one in any textbook.

It's eminently possible to achieve a satisfactory edge with either technique.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#18

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

Sgian Dubh

>"It's eminently possible to achieve a satisfactory edge with either technique.

It is, and with a variety of profiles on the edge of the blade.

I'm not sure nowadays what the term trade training really means. The old guild system and apprenticeships are pretty much dead and buried. I learnt a lot from the tradesmen I worked with as a daft wee laddie, but they also passed on some pretty ropey practices and myths. I started training in the early 1970s which was when the old systems and training schemes had really disappeared some ten or fifteen years earlier during the late 1950s or early 1960s.

I believe I was given a generally pretty solid grounding in furniture making techniques, but I learnt very little real theory and science behind quite a few of the things we did. It is only through a career since of questioning the validity of just about everything I learn or hear about that I can say now that not only am I competent woodworker, but I can back it up with in-depth knowledge gained through academic research and experimentation.

This is somewhat at variance to some of the half-baked rumours and other urban myths/legends put about by some people. Some of those people write, for instance, woodworking blogs and other efforts at navel gazing, supposition, wild guesswork, and a twelve or twenty four month career as an amateur or part-time woodworker. It has taken me thirty five years in the business to learn what I have learned, and and I keep on finding new things; perhaps more accurately some of those new things are old things that are just new to me, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#19

AMEN!! Feynman's lecture to science teachers

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Feynman's famous lecture to science teachers..... "This phenomenon of having a memory for the race, of having an accumulated knowledge passable from one generation to another, was new in the world--but it had a disease in it: it was possible to pass on ideas which were not profitable for the race. The race has ideas, but they are not necessarily profitable.

So there came a time in which the ideas, although accumulated very slowly, were all accumulations not only of practical and useful things, but great accumulations of all types of prejudices, and strange and odd beliefs.

Then a way of avoiding the disease was discovered. This is to doubt that what is being passed from the past is in fact true, and to try to find out ab initio again from experience what the situation is, rather than trusting the experience of the past in the form in which it is passed down. And that is what science is: the result of the discovery that it is worthwhile rechecking by new direct experience, and not necessarily trusting the [human] race['s] experience from the past. I see it that way. That is my best definition."

I will send a copy of the whole lecture to anyone interested. Ignore spam message should you write for it.

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#20

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

ThomD

>Your theory is interesting. My theory would be if the plane drifts to the right, it tends to tip that way, thereby shifting the centerpoint from which the radial line eminates. So maters would just get worse. So of what you have also said is kinda that a few thou here or there may not mater. They certainly can, but one can also catch a break and it all works out. That would be in the same world where essentially it doesn't make any difference, so I probably wouldn't hunt out the cambered blade.

I think curved blades were traditional, and that they work as described by Charlesworth. A lot of things are tradtional, and therefore worked also. I have never really seen any evidence they were used on jointers to control the transverse condition, but collecting that kind of tidbit isn't my strength.

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#21

Re: AMEN!! Feynman's lecture to science teachers

ThomD

>That makes some sense, but:

- Sounds like a proximity issue. If you were talking to someone who was standing right next to you clearly doing the thing, and you could actually see what was being done (a big if), doubt would seem unecesarry. Our direct tradition is highly filtered, normally by people who have no idea. So I am not sure the passing down method is all that bad. I taught my daughters how to ride a bike, and I really know how to do it with wide knowledge from long experience, and it seems to be working for them fine at the level they have absorbed. The real "tragedy" isn't that they didn't sufficiently question the advice given, it is that they are in no way able to fully grasp (or care about) what I could tell them.

- "And that is what science is: the result of the discovery that it is worthwhile rechecking by new direct experience, and not necessarily trusting the [human] race['s] experience from the past. I see it that way. That is my best definition."

He is obviously just selling something. Science operates in relation to the unknown. That is a category that expands beyond what is reported in the past.

One might say:

"And that is what science is: the realization that what is scientific fact today will be rechecked in the future and given new names and explanations at that time, and not necessarily trusting the [human] race['s] conclusions in the present."

- Science is sometimes very poor at explaining things that have been brilliantly done by non-scientific means in the past. While science sometimes triumphs (in a sense always, since by definition it converts it's mistakes into new theries), it is noteworthy how often a single scientist of technologist, with all the power of organized learning, will not be able to discern the subtle means in an apparently simple old tool. In fact, often a lot of scientists whole faculties can't figure these subtle technologies out.

- The scientific method is extremely powerful, science is a whole other thing. Tommorows erors in perception nicely organized, with politics, etc... to boot.

- Largely in amateur hands, science is just a rhetorical device. Like quoting an absent expert friend.

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#22

neophyte glue question

Jerome Bias

>Why change from hide glue to PVA glue for long joints. Which I am assuming is any joint longer than say 2'. Does hide glue tend to fail after this point?

Jerome

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#23

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

paul womack

>Speaking of confusing language, when I think traditional hand tool usage, I think of a time when everyone used hand tools to make stuff.

A period that lasted around 3000 years!

I suspect you're thinking of a narrower period, and I suspect I even know which period :-)

BugBear

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#24

Re: neophyte glue question

Dean J in MN

>Hide glue is more than strong enough for any long joint --the issues is open time. Hot hide glue, with no additives (such as urea), simply has too short of a working time to get the glue on a long joint and get the pieces together before it gels. It can be done with a few extra hands and warm shop temps, but it is easier to use PVA (or add urea to your hot hide glue).

If you are a one man shop (like mine) you'll find yourself needing the time on long joints. PVA works well, but you can use liquid hide glue, or add urea to your hot hide glue. I find about 16% urea (percent by weight) gives me nearly 2 minutes working time.

-Dean

Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered

#25

Re: neophyte glue question

wilbur

>This sort of begs the question: what did they do back in the day? There certainly seem to be old furniture pieces with long edge joints that were made back when hide glue was the only gluing option.

I'm sure Stephen will enlighten up on something that you can add to hide glue for this application. Hopefully it won't involve bodily fluids. :@)