Re: Blade grind - flat vs cambered
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Hi Andrew and all,
I edge joint one board at a time; if you match plane, that is a different situation and of course requires a very straight blade.
I use a 26" fairly narrow (2" blade) woodie jointer. With mild camber, like probably a couple thousandths. This would mean that for a 4/4 or 5/4 board, there would be maybe a thousandth of camber across the edge of the board. Indeed, I wonder if most people don't in fact have this level of camber even on their "straight-bladed" planes, just because stones tend to live a more or less concave existence.
As for procedure, let's say we're starting with a roughsawn edge. Right from the band mill, with hair all over the board. I start with a 20" moderate-camber fore plane (not real heavy camber, a little more than a try plane), and attack the high line, wherever it might wander. Maybe 8 to 10 thousandths shavings. Get any convexity out of the length of the edge, and get the edge sorta/kinda/pretty square. Once the full length and width of the edge is showing plane marks, the edge is within reach of the jointer.
Switch to the jointer, and plane from the inside out. At this point I'm not trying to follow the high line, but rather am focusing on holding the plane vertical as I work from the inside toward a full-length full-width shaving. Shavings in the 1-2 thou range.
Key thing: watch the shaving. It will tell you most of what you need to know about the condition of the board. Every other pass, I quickly run a small bevel-edge square down the edge for ground truth. Takes less than 10 strokes with the jointer, once I'm done conditioning the edge with the fore plane.
Test the edge against the adjoining edge: I want to hear a solid clack sound, and see the join line disappear along the full length with light finger pressure. If it doesn't, I will get the board back on edge and find the flaw with the little square--this may cost another 1 or 2 strokes. Process goes very quickly, especially when you get a rhythm going after the first two or three edges.
Issue: I am curious as to exactly what camber does, and what amount of camber is best. Mr. Charlesworth has said in the past that he is talking about 5 thou on either side of the centerline of the blade. So if this is a 2-1/2" typical jointer blade, and we're planing a 1" wide edge, then the edge is seeing maybe 2 thou of camber in the center of the blade.
Thom said a very interesting thing. He said he'd like to see a notch in the middle of the camber, and see exactly what the trace of the blade is along the edge. That thought brings me to my theory (may or may not be original, I don't know).
Theory: what camber really does is provide a little bit of forgiveness against the need to hold the plane dead vertical (and a flat blade dead horizontal) over an edge as you plane. In other words, the cambered blade is an arc of a big circle. If the plane wavers just a _little_ bit from dead vertical, and the blade just a _little_ bit from dead horizontal, the blade will rotate a tad as it cuts, and Thom's notch will wander from the centerline of the edge. But if this movement is small, then the blade will still present itself to the wood just as if there had been no movement--you're making the identical cut, but with a slightly different segment of the blade arc. So rather than facet the edge, the cambered blade will keep the center of the edge slightly below grade. This is what I mean by camber providing a little forgiveness.
But as I said above, I suspect almost everyone has a bit of camber in every bench plane blade they own. Just due to the nature of sharpening.
Wiley