Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

How do you make drawer sides?

Posts

Re: How do you make drawer sides?

#26

Better pictures...

James Watriss

>Can be seen at http://jameswatriss.blogspot.com/

I'd try reformatting for here, but on the blog, click on any of the photos, and you get them full size... much better for the details.

Re: How do you make drawer sides?

#27

Re: What I did for now

James Watriss

>On the one hand, I'm itching to make all kinds of arguments, about how those two tools are good for so many things besides just resawing...

But in the end, I think you sound pretty happy about the way you're doing things. That's good enough for me.

Re: How do you make drawer sides?

#28

James, I know where you're going

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>I've managed to do certain tasks without a bandsaw or planer by using other tools. I still see a bandsaw as being a worthwhile addition and would use it mostly for resawing. What? Am I contridicting myself? No, not really. I think there are certain boards that cry out for bookmatched use, which would require resawing to adapt them. Years ago my first power tool purchase was a radial drill press and a table saw. I had originally intended to get a bandsaw and let some fool magazine article talk me out of it. I've regretted it ever since. The table saw that is, not the radial drill press. Since then I've shyed away from power tools more and more. What I have seen with planers is that they don't seem to work as well as expected, need more maintaining than other power tools, make hideous amounts of dust and cause deafness in short order. For the most part, I don't try to get boards down to a specific thickness, rather, I try to keep them as thick as possible. Why do I want to build something with handtools only to have it look like I used power tools because everything is 3/4" and exact in thickness. Lastly I would like to apologize to you if my last response sounded shrill.

Re: How do you make drawer sides?

#29

Re: James, I know where you're going

James Watriss

>No apologies necessary. It didn't sound shrill. It was a no nonsense numerical argument... and if the numbers make sense to buy thinner stock than deal with knife changes, dust collection, annoyed neighbors, ringing ears, snipe, and always wishing you had just that extra inch of planing capacity... hey, no worries.

I think power tools are good things to have around. But I'm in the opening stages of firing up my second not-at-home shop, and for me, the numbers have to make sense, too. It makes sense to me to be able to thickness everything as needed, to be able to resaw parts and thickness those as needed, and do more than that, too. It's faster and easier for me to grab another stick from the lumber rack than to go back to the source, and wait while they get it ready for me.

I don't know you well enough to know what place woodworking holds in your life. For me it may be a lifelong vocation, or a stepping stone, or something else... but it's something I'll always enjoy.

I think it reminds me of learning math, in a way. In the opening stages, there's a lot of grunt work, learning what works, and how, and why. And after that, there's a huge paring down to get back to what's really necessary, and what's relevant, having made all the previous safaris. I've been on a woodworking safari for a while now, and while I always itch at the endless possibilities, I'm starting to pare back slowly. I can't say what the end result will look like. So I'm not about to tell anyone what it should look like for them.

In this particular case, I have a long-standing quirk. I hate relying too much on other people. So it feels unnatural for me to think that outside vendors should do that kind of work for me, even if the numbers line up. So, I apologize to you if you felt like I was "laying it down," and defining your work for you. I have a tendency to fall into lecture mode sometimes, and while it's mostly just my opinion, it sometimes comes across as what I think is dogmatic truth. Another quirk, I guess... I talk that way because I'm used to the idea that people are naturally going to question me automatically.

Re: How do you make drawer sides?

#30

a nit to pick

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Your said,"Why do I want to build something with handtools only to have it look like I used power tools".

I am willing to accept anyone's approach to woodworking and how they justify it, to themselves, is their business. What I don't accept is what seems to be a justification that is based on a premise that entirely hand tool made furniture looks, or otherwise is, better. Through SAPFM I have come to meet reproduction woodworkers that make furniture that rivals anything ever made in quality and appearance. Check out Alf Sharp's web site if you doubt this statement, or sites of the other Cartouche winners, or the SAPFM website. The fact that they use power tools to do their "apprentice work" has no bearing on the final appearance or quality. For the most part their customers are unwilling to pay the 30% extra (to quote Alf Sharp) to have something where the grunt work is all done by hand, when no one can tell the difference in the finished product.

For anyone reading this exchange that is still formulating their approach to woodworking, there are sound personal arguments for whatever tools you choose to use. But be assured, the tools you use are not the determining factor of the quality of the stuff you will build It will be your skill and dedication to using them. (tool choice probably will be the determining factor in the amount of stuff you can build).

Re: How do you make drawer sides?

#31

I think he makes a fair point, Bill

James Watriss

>I'm with you, there are some amazing pieces of period reproduction work that are outstanding, and the builders use machines for a lot of the basic work.

But there's also a distinct class of work that's technically custom work, but it's mostly done with jigs and machinery that may require a lot of setup, but require little skill. Or maybe there's a small hand-carved detail here and there. Either way, it's clear that the things were made with less attention given to final appearance and artistic merit than to quick profitability at craft shows. Made with real wooden dowels, and the like.

There is (thankfully) a lot of work done, and machines were used in the doing. But there's also a lot of work that was predominantly done by machines, operated by jig collectors, that stands out as being machine made. And his commentary that it's typically made with stock that is of uniform thickness is a pretty clear indicator of that type of work. Uniform stock thicknesses, uniformly cut dovetails, molded edges or "tombstone" doors that don't have corners, because the router bit can't fit into the corner, and they don't want to carve the detail by hand... There's a lot of that out there. And it's the stuff we're all trying to get away from.

At least, that's the point I took away.

Re: How do you make drawer sides?

#32

Re: a nit to pick

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I agree that basically there's no inherent qualitative difference between machine made and hand made. After all, the wood probably doesn't care which saw cuts it.

However, along with power tool work usually come inferior joinery, plywood (a lot of sapfm guys are into veneering plywood), biscuits, and the like. Also what come are a lot of noise and sawdust, not exactly environmentally pleasant things.

So, no inherent differences, but usually qualitative differences none the less.

Pam

Re: How do you make drawer sides?

#33

Thanks! Ummm that's quite a shop too.

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>