Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Addicted to sharpening...

Posts

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#26

Re: Sharpening gene

James Watriss

>Wish I'd had one of those. I started with sharpening pocket and sheath knives when I was in the army at 18, and it took me until I was out of college 11 years later that I finally started to "get it." And even then, it took 2 years of regular sharpening at woodworking school after that for it to really "sink in."

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#27

It's happened to all of us

roninkokomo

>Seemed to be a little touchy there

This is a very diverse group of folks, with an astounding variety of skill and interest levels.

WE have folks like Chico Sakman who build incredible pieces ( There are others of course but he comes to mind)

There are folks who have never built a breadbox, but who love tools

and in a way, for them, the shop is a project.

We have all gradations between those extremes. That's OK, even though it does make the conversation awkward at times because you don't know which of those extremes you may be talking to, and despite the fact that this is America, "land of the free" and all that, Chico's opinion on building furniture is probably more valuable than the guy who has never build a breadbox.

The different kinds of users of this forum will not all see eye to eye because they have different agendas.

I think it is marvelous that you are developing sharpening honing skills to a high level in the traditional manner. It gives you the freedom to make choices, in a way that you did not have before.

In some ways that is what is behind some of the good natured bickering about the Dark side and the screaming whirling digit eating beasties that inhabit that world. There are many guys with shops full of those critters who, for whatever reason have chosen the quiet side of the pond. They DO know how to use the beasties, but some choose not to.

I think we need to honor the other guys choices. We might be curious about how he got there, but until he asks us he probably doesn't need us to convert him to our way.

I really do believe that this is the best, and most friendly forum of its kind on the net and want to thank Ellis again for the chance to be a part of it

ron

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#28

Nice work

Todd Hughes

>Looks like you were doing pretty nice work befor you learned to take 20 plus min. to sharpen a small chisel

My point is I simply think sharpening should be thought of somthing that is done so that the main work can be made...and not somthing that should have more thought or time put into it then you need too.

I am a slow head and I can't imagine me taking more then 5 min. to put an edge on any chisel ...even if I had to regrind out chips using my belt sander [ or even my tredle grindstone] I am NOT saying this to make me out as some super skilled craftsman...Im NOT and I refuse to believe that it really takes much skill to do this, whether I am doing it or sombody else. Would my chisel be as sharp as one done by a guy that spends all this time and then looks at the edge under a loupe?...Probably not but for practical purposes it will probably perform the same. I sharpen edges so they are hair shaving sharp and say thats good enough.

Maybe I should post how it takes me 1/2 hour to put a wood screw in a piece of wood .......Todd