Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Addicted to sharpening...

Posts

Addicted to sharpening...

#1

Addicted to sharpening...

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Ok, so I finally figured out how to sharpen something without use of my wet grinding wheel. Now I can't quit. I'm finding it relaxing, lapping chisels and irons, switching grits, finishing on a stone. My wife doesn't understand. I show her how polished the bevel is, and she just nods impatiently.

Case in point: I bought this Berg 1/4" socket chisel a couple years ago. End was all chipped, handle's loose. Thought about it today, and started in with some 120 grit paper. About twenty minutes later, I gots this:



Sharpest thing I own right now. For now. Gimme another twenty minutes... ;-)

Now I need to dig out the lathe and make a new handle. Hmm - I have some curly claro walnut somewhere...

Scott

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#2

"Now I can't quit..."

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Well in that case, I'll be sending a few things to you for sharpening...

8^)

Guess they'll be behind your dull as Oprah lathe tools eh?

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#3

Dull as Oprah...

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>I know I've used that phrase, but nothing is as dull as Oprah!

I've already started in on the skews. The gouges will take a little more time, but I'm getting them done. Woot!

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#4

Dull as Oprah?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Geesh, here I am responding to another of your posts, but this time it's to complain rather than explain (how bad making raised panels with power tools can be). You've insulted blacks, women, and voiced an incredible jealousy of Oprah Winfrey. Good job, must be a record. And it would have been so easy to find a white man to dis.

Pam

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#5

You owe him an apology, Pam...

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>If you're gonna piss at someone, piss at me. He was quoting me and comments I've made about my lathe tools being dull as Oprah, a statement I stand behind. You've never seen my lathe tools...

FWIW, and I'm sure that's not much, I have an aversion to the woman. Not because she's black, female, or fat. Because she's an angel-talking idiot. If you have a problem with that, and want to slight me because I'm offending some psuedo-feminist proclivity you flaunt when convenient, well, have at me.

But you owe Mr. Burr an apology. I'm sure he's waiting.

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#6

To all

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Folks,

This is a good thread--sharpening is always great stuff. I'm going to let the sharp remarks above stand, because we don't want to suppress or derail a very positive subject.

Please return to the subject, with no further sharp words. All of us love that feeling when we have made a breakthrough in sharpening. That is all the original poster was saying.

Any arguments, write me off line.

Thanks,

Wiley Horne

Moderator, Hand Tools

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#7

Personally I'm shocked!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>A a bit , pissed off.

I've never dissed anyone but you Pammie, and that's for good reason. Please show me a link or a post in which I have, and I'll eat a piece of oak with a shoe in my mouth.

As to talking down the white man I could start with our current prez or any hand full of current elected gov's.

I'm not going there because I do have respect for this place and know not to tread there.

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#8

Everybody needs a Hobby

Todd Hughes

>Well guess that is great if your goal is spending alot of time sharpening things till they are perfect but I think most craftsmen would be more concerned with putting them to use then spending this much time and effort to get them to be like this. Do you think the old time wood workers spent 20 plus min. to put an edge on thier chisels and were worried how polished it looked under a loop ?

Is good that you are learning to sharpen but remember the reason you are sharpening the thing which is probably to use it, eh? Will all this time and effort spent really produce that much measurable better results to make it worth while? Yes you need sharp tools ,but you need to know also how to sharpen them efficiently and when they are "good enough"....unless your hobby is just sharpening up things.

Looks like a pretty good berg handle still with a decal, why replace it?.....Todd

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#9

Re: Everybody needs a Hobby

wilbur

>"Well guess that is great if your goal is spending alot of time sharpening things till they are perfect but I think most craftsmen would be more concerned with putting them to use then spending this much time and effort to get them to be like this. Do you think the old time wood workers spent 20 plus min. to put an edge on thier chisels and were worried how polished it looked under a loop ?"

My guess is that no, the old time woodworkers didn't spend 20 minutes sharpening a chisel. But they probably would have spent 20 minutes taking a dull tool and making it sharp, which is a one time task. And as you know, maintaining that sharpness, once the chisel is sharp, is a relatively trivial task, and takes considerably less time than 20 minutes for a rehoning.

"Looks like a pretty good berg handle still with a decal, why replace it?.....Todd"

Scott said the handle of the chisel is loose. Do you think the old time woodworkers would have chosen to work with a chisel with a loose handle because they were concerned with maintaining the decal, instead of replacing it with a well fitting handle instead?

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#10

now I understand

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I used to be puzzled that some spouses were not supportive of their husband's "woodworking" activities. Of the possible hobbies one might have it seemed to be most practical in that the return of useful products vs the investment in stuff could be positive, and strongly so. An "in house" cabinet maker seemed more useful than an in house gardener or plumber, and way more so than an in house golfer, for example. It was a while before I encountered "woodworkers" that didn't make stuff, and then I came to understand.

To whatever degree it is important , a sure way to get support is to make something useful to those from whom support(praise, admiration, funds,etc) might come. That could obviously be a spouse, but it could also be children, relatives, friends and neighbors, or even fellow woodworkers who also make stuff. I have come to know better than to seek admiration for a well cut mortise, but I get plenty for the table it becomes.

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#11

Re: Everybody needs a Hobby

John Aniano, in NJ...

>Wilbur, Todd and Scott,

Might I suggest that Scott try to please both of you and fix the loose handle on the chisel? I agree with you both - you can't work with a loose handle AND the Berg handle looks like it still has a lot of life. Just fix it so it isn't loose any more. Epoxy anyone?..

My $0.02...

John

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#12

AMEN and AMEN

roninkokomo

>Marc Adams tells a story about wanting to apprentice for a while with Tage Frid to learn how to sharpen/hone his tools.

Frid used belt sander and a buffing wheel.. When Marc expressed considerable surprise, Frid said "Do you want to work wood or spend all your time sharpening.

Understand, Frid's tool were very very sharp... he just got there in a way that made more sense to him.

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#13

Gobsmacked...

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Ya know, I post a simple thread, thinking I should be happy after a dozen plus years woodworking, having (finally) learned an essential skill. Who knew it'd leave so many people put-off? Sorry if my exuberance was misguided; I'll strive for abject curmudgeondom from here out...

As far as putting the tools to use, I guess the Shaker footstool, tall clock, and spokeshave I finished within a couple months don't count for much, do they? I really need to start putting tools to work, full-time student and work status aside.

Please, someone kill this thread. It's depressing and disappointing at once.

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#14

Re: Everybody needs a Hobby

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>True, but we all get addicted to stuff now and then, just like Rush.

Pam

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#15

Very sensible thought, but

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>it doesn't apply to Scott. He makes stuff.

Wiley

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#16

It's a good thread, Scott, and a good subject

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>I know the feeling you're describing. It's like when you get to where you can pick up the stone with the tool. And sure enough, you do go around sharpening everything all over again. It's a great moment!

One of the better tips on sharpening I ever heard was to finish up with a light touch (Harrelson Stanley, who can sharpen).

Wiley

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#17

Similar anecdote

John in NM

>Was related in Hank Gilpin's eulogy article when Tage Frid died. I would imagine that many of his students were struck by the practicality of his tool use.

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#18

Re: now I understand

ThomD

>Good point, and there are lots more ways to make co-habitants miserable, than to not make stuff: Not finish stuff; distribute dust, noise, fumes, and the occasional fire evenly around the house; spend lots of money on stuff that takes up tons of space; disappear online for hours on end; frequent trips to the emergency; frequent trips to the woods to cut wood up that displaces the car. And I am just getting started...

Overall, golfers probably are more social, make more money, are better looking, and invade the house with a lot less stuff.

It is all about ballance from what I have observed at a distance.

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#19

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

charlie belden

>When you make things out of wood - in order to dull cutting edges enough to be the excuse for sharpening - ya'll are in BIG trouble.

Oddly, it's the narrow chisels that are the trickiest to sharpen freehand on a stone, india, arkansas or japanese.

Worn your finger tips off on one of your hands yet? If not, you will ; ).

There is definitely a Zen Thing with hand sharpening on stones. Three minutes into it and your mind zones out to another place - where time ain't important at all. Hell, if you set up to sharpen a set of chisels - even the need to eat can get overlooked - 'til you keel over. And sometimes while your body is doing the sharpening ritual, your mind will identify and/or solve impending/current problems.

Don't mistake shiny for sharp. You can polish a piece of steel to 100 percent reflectivity - and not have a sharp edge. And just because an edge will shave hairs off your arm - doesn't mean that it's REALLY sharp.

Oh - and train yourself NOT to try and catch a sharp chisel as it rolls off the table top and heads for the cement floor. It's easier to resharpen a damaged chisel than it is working with a sliced finger or hand.

Enjoy!

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#20

Re: Gobsmacked...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Scott,

One thing I learned long ago, no one appreciates someone elses accomplishments as much as the person doing the accomplishing.

Before I learned to not solicit compliments I experienced disappointment with most everything I was proud of that I made. I just didn't understand why everyone didn't notice every little detail of my fine work, of my wonderful creation, of my best accomplishment of all time.

Now days I just brag and gloat until the person I don't really expect to impress rolls their eyes back in their head. I love it when they attempt to escape as they slowly make their way toward a nearby door, while making excuses why they need to be some place else. Of course I follow them out the door as they leave and sometimes even follow them out to their car. Then the next time I see them, I'll ask them what they thought about whatever it was I was bragging and gloating about.

Now days when I try it with my wife, she'll just tell me that she just doesn't give a rat's ass about any of that boring crap.

Bottom line....I just enjoy what I do and to hell with what other people think. I don't need their approval or disapproval, unless of course they are paying me for something I've done for them. I'll still get some bragging and gloating in though. *grin*

Marv

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#21

Re: Gobsmacked...

John L. Blue

>Keep it up, your thread was inspiring to me!

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#22

Godsmack!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>ROCK ON DUDE!

Oh wait a minute...

Man o man. Looking at the shaker stool they grow up awfully fast.

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#23

I think people misread your intent, Scott

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I think people thought you were turning into one of those people who just plays with the tools - which it's clear you're not.

It is a rush finally getting the rhythm on a hand skill, isn't it? You're doing the right thing, having gotten the rhythm, to repeat it frequently and often, to drive it into your body memory, before it gets lost.

As in, "How do I get to Carnegie Hall?"

Congrats - I have yet to be fully confident that I can sharpen. Maybe I need to take a vacation back to PA again and have you show me.

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#24

Re: Gobsmacked...

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>Scott,

Congratulations on your newfound appreciation/recognition and skill of creating a sharp edge. Speaking for myself, it was an event of great personal satisfaction when I finally realized a true �scary sharp�� edge. It was not that many years ago that I don�t remember the joy of the experience!

It truly is eye opening. For the next month or so you will be sharpening everything in site. It�s amazing what a �new� �really sharp� edge on an old familiar tool can do.

Pick a sharpening method, practice till you are comfortable with it, (shave an arm hair or two) and enjoy. Acquisition of this skill and knowledge is essential to our woodworking futures.

My appologies to those here who were born with a fully developed sharpening gene, but some of us had to learn this the hard way, and it truly is AMAZING!

Bob in NJ

Re: Addicted to sharpening...

#25

Pay no attention to the naysayers, scott...

James Watriss

>There are some craftsmen... and some operations... that don't demand a lot of time and effort to get a tool that sharp. But I think there's a point where it's a lot like many other things we do. The first dovetailed drawer for some people can take half a day. After a while, it takes a lot less time.

If you can take a chisel to that level of polish, good for you, I say. There are a lot of people who couldn't if they tried. Maybe you don't need to take everything to that level... but it's good to know that you can if you need to.