Re: Congratulations to Andrew Lunn
Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.
>Hi Mike,
You said,
Wheat carving enhances a positive grip, which in turn lessens slippage. Therefore, more of the user's energy is tranfered directly to the cutting edge for greater sawing efficiency. Duh!
----------------------------------------------------
I will assume your tongue was in your cheek, the one next to your mouth? right? LOL
90% of the grip is accomplished with the three or four fingers. Wheat carving is only partially used by the thumb, that is if it has any advantage at all, for righties, that is.
If the wheat carving does in fact improve the grip and reduce slippage, the location of the carving is on the wrong side of the tote for right handed folks. Perhaps wheat carving should be on both sides like it is with pistol grips.
Actually, gripping a tote should be fairly light and somewhat relaxed, especially when using a regular handsaw. A backsaw is a bit different in this sense due to the required control for accuracy.
As with a nib, wheat carving is merely meant as embellishment but only if it is done with that in mind. So much of the wheat carving we see on the old totes seems to me to be an after-thought with no artistic effort what so ever, hence, detracting, instead of improving. Even the Disston #12 that is thought of as their top of the line saw were messy and random. Some will say it adds character to an old saw. In my mind, it's just plain messy and was carelessly done. Yes, the workers were trying to meet production quotas, but that is no excuse for sloppy workmanship. I should say "sloppy work" not workmanship.
When I wheat carve a tote, I smooth out the sharp edges so the wheats somewhat blend with the surface of the grip, purposely making the carving so it effects the grip at a minimum.
Marv