Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Wanna see a nice backsaw? *LINK*

Posts

Re: Wanna see a nice backsaw? *LINK*

#26

Re: Congratulations to Andrew Lunn

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Mike,

You said....

Absolutely NOT. Neither the Japanese nor western saws have altered sawing dynamics due to the top edge of the blade shape. What matters is the tooth shape.

-------------------------------------

Now there's a statement that makes some sense. Good logic dictates that canting the blade to enhance the function of a saw is a myth.

A saw's function is based on three basic aspects, first, size of teeth and the angles of the teeth. Second, the angle of the tote in relation to the tooth edge. And third, the height of the workpiece in relation to the users height and posture.

Of course there are a number of other aspects that are important but those things need not be mentioned when discussing the pros and cons of a canted blade.

Maybe wheat carving the tote would make a difference? *smirk*

Marv

Re: Wanna see a nice backsaw? *LINK*

#27

Re: Congratulations to Andrew Lunn

MikeW

>Wheat carving enhances a positive grip, which in turn lessens slippage. Therefore, more of the user's energy is tranfered directly to the cutting edge for greater sawing efficiency. Duh!

Take care Marv!

Nice seeing you around a bit more. And thanks for starting this thread. Andrew's a great guy doing really neat things.

Mike

Re: Wanna see a nice backsaw? *LINK*

#28

Re: Congratulations to Andrew Lunn

MikeW

>OK, a more serious response. Something I seem to be unable to do except for short bursts. I hate being house-bound...

"A saw's function is based on three basic aspects...Second, the angle of the tote in relation to the tooth edge."

Sort of true. Maybe more so than not. The hang angle affects the amount of inherent force applied to the cutting edge. Combined with something like rake, the relation is more or less apparent depending on how agressive or weak the rake angle is.

So on something like the subject saw that has relaxed rakes at the toe and the heel, it changes the effect of the downward force in those areas by making the cutting force less effective. Which to the user makes it an easier start and softer end of stroke.

Ok. That's all I can muster right now...Mike

Re: Wanna see a nice backsaw? *LINK*

#29

Just wonderin'

Dan Donaldson

>I would assume that when the blade is sharpened, it is placed in the saw vise and everything is done relative to the edge of the blade. (i.e. perpendicular to it) I wonder if the cant in the saw would affect the angle that you hold it for sawing and hence the angle that the teeth enter the wood. A canted back would affect the view that you have of the saw and maybe the way you hold the cut. Just a thought.

Re: Wanna see a nice backsaw? *LINK*

#30

Re: Just wonderin'

MikeW

>Hi Dan,

"I would assume that when the blade is sharpened, it is placed in the saw vise and everything is done relative to the edge of the blade. (i.e. perpendicular to it)"

Yes. Relative being the key word.

"I wonder if the cant in the saw would affect the angle that you hold it for sawing and hence the angle that the teeth enter the wood. A canted back would affect the view that you have of the saw and maybe the way you hold the cut."

Yes, I believe one holds a canted saw differently. By the time the second or third tooth engages, however, the teeth are cutting exactly the saw whether a saw has a canted back or not. The exact same thing happens when holding a saw so that the toothline is not squarely resting on a board. That is, it is only starting on a corner. Hoever, as the saw begins to establish the kerf, the relationship of the kerf floor and the teeth remain as constant as one can push the saw in a straight line.

Really, all that matters is that kerf floor and the angle of the teeth engaged in it as far as the cutting dynamics of the teeth are concerned.

The other issues that affect cutting with a western back saw (like the hang angle, length of blade, etc) affct the force at the cutting edge at a given spot along the toothline.

But nothing about the shape of the top edge of the blade affects that force nor rake angle in relation to the kerf floor.

Take care, Mike

Re: Wanna see a nice backsaw? *LINK*

#31

Re: Just wonderin'

Dan Donaldson

>I was wondering more about the perception of the person holding the saw.

Re: Wanna see a nice backsaw? *LINK*

#32

Re: Congratulations to Andrew Lunn

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Mike,

You said,

Wheat carving enhances a positive grip, which in turn lessens slippage. Therefore, more of the user's energy is tranfered directly to the cutting edge for greater sawing efficiency. Duh!

----------------------------------------------------

I will assume your tongue was in your cheek, the one next to your mouth? right? LOL

90% of the grip is accomplished with the three or four fingers. Wheat carving is only partially used by the thumb, that is if it has any advantage at all, for righties, that is.

If the wheat carving does in fact improve the grip and reduce slippage, the location of the carving is on the wrong side of the tote for right handed folks. Perhaps wheat carving should be on both sides like it is with pistol grips.

Actually, gripping a tote should be fairly light and somewhat relaxed, especially when using a regular handsaw. A backsaw is a bit different in this sense due to the required control for accuracy.

As with a nib, wheat carving is merely meant as embellishment but only if it is done with that in mind. So much of the wheat carving we see on the old totes seems to me to be an after-thought with no artistic effort what so ever, hence, detracting, instead of improving. Even the Disston #12 that is thought of as their top of the line saw were messy and random. Some will say it adds character to an old saw. In my mind, it's just plain messy and was carelessly done. Yes, the workers were trying to meet production quotas, but that is no excuse for sloppy workmanship. I should say "sloppy work" not workmanship.

When I wheat carve a tote, I smooth out the sharp edges so the wheats somewhat blend with the surface of the grip, purposely making the carving so it effects the grip at a minimum.

Marv

Re: Wanna see a nice backsaw? *LINK*

#33

Sawing Perception with a canted blade

MikeW

>Sorry Dan,

"I wonder if the cant in the saw would affect the angle that you hold it for sawing and hence the angle that the teeth enter the wood. A canted back would affect the view that you have of the saw and maybe the way you hold the cut."

There were basically two parts. I only really responded to the first half.

My response to the second sentance was mentioned or alluded to in an above post. I do believe the average user tends to hold the saw differently. Perhaps not consistently. I know sometimes I am holding a canted back saw with the toothline level to the desired cut's baselines and other times the back is "levelish" and the toothline angled up.

For myself, it is more difficult to overcut the baslines on joinery with a canted saw by accident. This is simply due to the toothline angled up and so when the baseline is reached on the front, it is not quite to the line on the far side.

fwiw, when using a Japanese saw with a wider end opposite the handle, if the saw becomes level along the top edge, chances are good one will blow a baseline.

Take care, Mike

Re: Wanna see a nice backsaw? *LINK*

#34

Re: Congratulations to Andrew Lunn

MikeW

>Hi Marv, yes the tongue was firmly pressed.

Take care, Mike

Re: Wanna see a nice backsaw? *LINK*

#35

Maybe it's just me, but....

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>If I'm looking at the top edge of the saw while I'm starting a cut or finishing the cut or anything in between, my focus is on the wrong thing.

Do we look at the top edge of a regular handsaw when using one? I guess some people do. Maybe thats why they can't saw a straight line and then blame the saw.

I'm sometimes boggled at some of the over anal-izing of something that is so insignificant as the angle of the top edge of a saw, any saw.

Just a thought....*smile*...*grin* :))

Marv

Re: Wanna see a nice backsaw? *LINK*

#36

Re: Maybe it's just me, but....

MikeW

>I would agree one's focus should not be centralized on the top edge of the saw. There is a visual, a periphery, component however.

Analyzing what happens or how it happens--or the affect of carved embellishments--is part and parcel of making tools better or more attractive (or artistically enjoyable).

Take care, Mike

Re: Wanna see a nice backsaw? *LINK*

#37

Out of curiosity Andrew...

James Watriss

>Have you ever messed with progressive pitch on your saws? I read that you alter the tooth angle at each end, so I was curious if you'd played around with tooth size as well. I've used others (eastern and western) so it's just what I'm used to now... hence the question.

Re: Wanna see a nice backsaw? *LINK*

#38

Re: Out of curiosity Andrew...

Andrew Lunn

>Hi James,

I like progressive rake better because it gives me finer control when adjusting the teeth. You could of course adjust the rake on a progressively pitched saw, but if you are going to do that, then why bother with the progressive pitch to begin with. It seems unnecessary. And to choose one or the other, adjusting the rake seems more exact. Hope this answers your question. Take it easy.

Andrew