Re: starting off with no bench
ThomD
>"Yeah, frustrating. You almost need a bench to build a bench."
+1
This is true, and in the majority of cases a bench would have been available to the person with that need. When I faced this problem years ago, I bought an Inca jointer planer, and bought some raw wood to convert. It is tough to do the starting from zilch thing in a Gilligan's island setting. Typically a maker in the past would have had:
- A shop to work in as an apprentice etc...
- A sawmill or sawyer to source wood in pieces appropriate to the task so less lamination
- Help to do the grunt work, unless he was the grunt work
- An environment with a lot more how-to info for this kind of task because back then this was how things were done, not squeezed out of scarce hobby income.
- Probably access to the means to move really heavy timbers.
To try to use hand tools to make stuff like the Klausz bench that is clearly designed around machine tools just doubles the work. I have built a bench from a tree, and while it is a lot of work it does seem more sensible as a starting point than lots of little sticks glued together. In fact most benches can be made 100% with power tools, unlike other furniture that demands hand work. I think this says a little about the kind of bench design we have today
If you want to build a serious bench all by hand I would recommend building a simple one first, and to that end breaking it down to it's essential parts.
A classic bench consists of a beam, two vises, a base and a tool well (or more beams). The simplest version of this is in the original Landis Workbench Book, the Imai bench. The trestles are 3 2x2s with one nailed across the top, and a piece or wider wood nailed across the uprights front to back, ply would do. Think of the trestles as two mini stud walls. There are two scissor like braces on the sides that join the trestles end to end. Total construction time 5-10 minutes solid as a rock. Because it is so light though, it makes sense to space the trestles almost the full length of the top, otherwise they tend to allow the top to tip.
You attach the beam to the front of this base. The simplest beam, and one that is actually hard to beat, is made of plywood. Go to HD and get a sheet of plywood cut up into a box beam kit. There is some info on this in the current Xmas tools and shop supplement by FWW. Though I think most of that stuff is too heavy for what is needed. I built mine about 5-6 inches thick and 8 or 9 inches wide. Get them to rip say two 9 inch full length strips. Then you get them to rip the rest into your spacer width (or a lot of it anyway). So that might be 4" stock. You make the side out of that, and use a piece every foot for bulkheads, glue and screw or clamp it together (try to minimize stuff fasteners or pull them later), and it will be straight and perfect and never move. It is an asset to use several bulkhead pieces in an area you can mortise over so it is really solid, but you would be surprised at how solid a beam made of 3/4" ply is. I used paint grade maple for my beam, and it was about 35 dollars for the one piece I needed, with some left over.
Of course you can use a real beam, but many of us do not have access to free or cheap beam wood, and it is hard to beat the ply box beam for a city dwellers bench. I built mine while I was searching for a real beam at a decent price. I never switched to the real beam because I use this easy to set up Imai deal out of doors and it is far easier to move around the ply beam. I also use it when I need really accurate planing because it never shifts it's zero appreciably.
The main thing about the well area behind the beam is that while some people love it and others leave it, it demonstrates that the front of the bench, the beam, is the main action area. This varies depending on your use, but I can confidently state that for making a bench the area behind the beam is pretty secondary. A ply box like a well, or a piece of lighter table top material is all you need.
The front vise is used in conjunction with the beam, but it can also be mounted to any good solid object I mostly use mine almost as a second work station and think it would almost be better if it was mounted remotely which I just mention since you might have such a spot already.
The tail vise is very useful, but is also fairly easy to live without. Of all the parts it doesn't really need to be on a temporary structure.
I think it is better to make a trestle and beam bench because it has uses down the road, from a jobsite type bench, to a scaffold, even when you own the perfect bench. If you make a more complicated 75% bench it will not be as much of a learning experience in the simple style of woodworking, and it will take a while, and cost more money. Save the complex end of the task for your ultimate bench. If you prefer.