Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

starting off with no bench

Posts

starting off with no bench

#1

starting off with no bench

Brian

>This almost seems silly. I've made a few very small things, but nothing large.

I have no real work bench. I have a bench that's quite tall for me and not suitable for handplaning. Wobbly and tall. I might be able to cut it, brace it and replace the top. I'm not sure if it's worth the effort though.

I lust after Norm Vandal's shaker bench or Frank Klausz' bench and many others for that matter.

My main interest is in using hand tools, though I do have an old table saw, band saw and router. I have Stanley #4, #7. Record 60 1/2. I do have a Record 9" vise that can be used for an interim bench.

With all that said, how does one build a workable bench from that kind of tool assortment? I have no way to hold the wood well, especially to joint long boards, and no power planer and jointer to cheat with.

I don't mind the idea of building a bench or a few benches before getting to my ideal bench. So maybe I could use the Record 9" on the front of an intermediate bench.

Any thoughts on the best way to start this to minimize frustration and avoid wasting money?

Thanks

Re: starting off with no bench

#2

Re: starting off with no bench

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>That's about all I have now in tools. I built my first bench using three things you don't have. Two sawhorses and a Workmate. The sawhorses were the plastic kind you buy at the borg and I used them to set my top on while I planed it and finished it. They both broke before I finished. Making some out of wood is a good idea. The Workmate was, and is, invaluable. I was able to do everything with it that needed to be done. I laminated a top out of 4/4 hard maple that I bought dressed on three sides. I ripped the boards out with my table saw. I'll never do that again. I glued up in fours and then everything together. A lot of planning was still necessary. There are many ways to skin a cat. Look around and find your acceptable alternate. But the sawhorses and the Workmate are probably the best first things to make and acquire. You'll continue to use them long after the bench is done.

Re: starting off with no bench

#3

My first one

roninkokomo

>Was all from Lowes. The legs were built up 4 x 4s and lap jointed together and bolted with carriage bolts. The top was laminated using yellow pine 2 x 4s on edge glued and held together by threaded rod at the ends . Several of us could have danced on it.

really only took one Saturday to make.

Re: starting off with no bench

#4

Re: starting off with no bench

Bob Easton

>Yeah, frustrating. You almost need a bench to build a bench.

Yet, you DO have enough tools to get the job done. I'm assuming you have a few clamps. A jointer plane is a good thing to have for jointing boards you will be edge gluing, but it is NOT essential. You can do that with your #7. For any two boards that are going to be glued edge to edge, clamp them together face to face and then plane both edges together. Any unevenness from not having a very long plane will be mirrored in each edge and they'll fit together just fine.

I found Chris Scwarz's Workbench book invaluable. It's strength is a chapter that details almost any activity you might use a bench for and the several ways of accomplishing that activity. It really helps in deciding which characteristics of a bench are important to the kind of work you intend.

myself, I'm a boat builder and Chris's book helped me decide on how to build a really long bench that's great for handling edges of long boards. See more at: http://www.bob-easton.com/blog/?cat=11

Re: starting off with no bench

#5

Re: starting off with no bench

Tom MacGregor

>I laminated the frame members for my bench out of three layers of 5/4 x 4 pine right out of the lumberyard. By having the middle piece protrude or leaving a space I easily made tight, square, heavy duty through mortice & tenon joints. The side rails (left a small gap in the middle layer) have 1/2" threaded rod through them to bolt on the two ends. It was fast, easy, not too expensive & is solid as a rock. If I ever want to change the top the original frame should be strong enough to support any choice of material.

Re: starting off with no bench

#6

Re: starting off with no bench

ThomD

>"Yeah, frustrating. You almost need a bench to build a bench."

+1

This is true, and in the majority of cases a bench would have been available to the person with that need. When I faced this problem years ago, I bought an Inca jointer planer, and bought some raw wood to convert. It is tough to do the starting from zilch thing in a Gilligan's island setting. Typically a maker in the past would have had:

- A shop to work in as an apprentice etc...

- A sawmill or sawyer to source wood in pieces appropriate to the task so less lamination

- Help to do the grunt work, unless he was the grunt work

- An environment with a lot more how-to info for this kind of task because back then this was how things were done, not squeezed out of scarce hobby income.

- Probably access to the means to move really heavy timbers.

To try to use hand tools to make stuff like the Klausz bench that is clearly designed around machine tools just doubles the work. I have built a bench from a tree, and while it is a lot of work it does seem more sensible as a starting point than lots of little sticks glued together. In fact most benches can be made 100% with power tools, unlike other furniture that demands hand work. I think this says a little about the kind of bench design we have today

If you want to build a serious bench all by hand I would recommend building a simple one first, and to that end breaking it down to it's essential parts.

A classic bench consists of a beam, two vises, a base and a tool well (or more beams). The simplest version of this is in the original Landis Workbench Book, the Imai bench. The trestles are 3 2x2s with one nailed across the top, and a piece or wider wood nailed across the uprights front to back, ply would do. Think of the trestles as two mini stud walls. There are two scissor like braces on the sides that join the trestles end to end. Total construction time 5-10 minutes solid as a rock. Because it is so light though, it makes sense to space the trestles almost the full length of the top, otherwise they tend to allow the top to tip.

You attach the beam to the front of this base. The simplest beam, and one that is actually hard to beat, is made of plywood. Go to HD and get a sheet of plywood cut up into a box beam kit. There is some info on this in the current Xmas tools and shop supplement by FWW. Though I think most of that stuff is too heavy for what is needed. I built mine about 5-6 inches thick and 8 or 9 inches wide. Get them to rip say two 9 inch full length strips. Then you get them to rip the rest into your spacer width (or a lot of it anyway). So that might be 4" stock. You make the side out of that, and use a piece every foot for bulkheads, glue and screw or clamp it together (try to minimize stuff fasteners or pull them later), and it will be straight and perfect and never move. It is an asset to use several bulkhead pieces in an area you can mortise over so it is really solid, but you would be surprised at how solid a beam made of 3/4" ply is. I used paint grade maple for my beam, and it was about 35 dollars for the one piece I needed, with some left over.

Of course you can use a real beam, but many of us do not have access to free or cheap beam wood, and it is hard to beat the ply box beam for a city dwellers bench. I built mine while I was searching for a real beam at a decent price. I never switched to the real beam because I use this easy to set up Imai deal out of doors and it is far easier to move around the ply beam. I also use it when I need really accurate planing because it never shifts it's zero appreciably.

The main thing about the well area behind the beam is that while some people love it and others leave it, it demonstrates that the front of the bench, the beam, is the main action area. This varies depending on your use, but I can confidently state that for making a bench the area behind the beam is pretty secondary. A ply box like a well, or a piece of lighter table top material is all you need.

The front vise is used in conjunction with the beam, but it can also be mounted to any good solid object I mostly use mine almost as a second work station and think it would almost be better if it was mounted remotely which I just mention since you might have such a spot already.

The tail vise is very useful, but is also fairly easy to live without. Of all the parts it doesn't really need to be on a temporary structure.

I think it is better to make a trestle and beam bench because it has uses down the road, from a jobsite type bench, to a scaffold, even when you own the perfect bench. If you make a more complicated 75% bench it will not be as much of a learning experience in the simple style of woodworking, and it will take a while, and cost more money. Save the complex end of the task for your ultimate bench. If you prefer.

Re: starting off with no bench

#7

Re: starting off with no bench

James Watriss

>Hi Brian.

Where are you? A lame curiosity question to be sure, but someone in here may be local enough to help you out.

My first bench was an old wooden-topped cabinet in a basement under an apartment building. Landlords didn't mind, and it was pretty ok. The basement was dark, though, and the brick wall made for very poor reflected lighting. And the cabinet wasn't stable, away from the wall.

The next one was built on a surface of a pair of sawhorses, and 2, 2x2x10 boards. It worked. A couple of clamps held everything down, while I was cutting 4x4s into legs and stretchers. The ends were like Kirby's bench, with mortises and tenons holding them together. The stretchers were lag bolted into place. I had a pair of 4x4 scraps that were about 10-12" long. I glued one onto each stretcher, on the right hand side, (facing that side of the bench, so there would end up being one support at each end of the bench) to add width. One stretcher alone would not be a balanced racking support. But with both stretchers in place, there was one support at each end of the bench, and it worked. One lag bolt into the smaller end of the stretcher, and one into the other end of the stretcher, and one into the end of the support, for a total of 3 lag bolts per stretcher. That bench held up pretty well. I mortised in a pop-up plane stop, made from a scrap of purpleheart I found, and I was really proud of the one piece of "fancy" wood. All of the work for this bench was doable on the 2x12s.

Basically, the 2x12 and sawhorse setup is a variation on the trestle and beam arrangement. But there's a minimum of fussing over the beam. In the building where I had my last shop, I knew a lot of guys who kept 3 or 4 sets of trestles, and a pair of stout beams for working on. When they were doing built in or cabinet work, they could use low trestles for assembling huge sets of cabinets together, to check alignments on things, before breaking down, and shipping to the jobsite. Taller trestles, with beams, and a scrap of plywood, makes for a pretty good table for doing smaller stuff that doesn't require the stoutness of a full blown bench... like drill and screw operations, or assemblies.

I won't say that the trestle and beam is my ideal bench. It's not. But it's versatile, and the clamping strategies you'll figure out while using it will be relevant when you move on to a regular bench and you need to clamp things down. AND, you can break it all down and put it aside when you need the space more than you need the trestles.

Personal ramblings aside, I have to say that you sound like you have your head on straight. I still remember some poor guy who came in here years ago with a C-shaped bench design that was to have had 2 tail vises, a shoulder vise, a pattern-maker's vise... and he was still a beginner. So to hear that you understand that you might go through a few benches along the way, is a good sign.

The students at North Bennet Street use simple benches with a front vise only. No tail vise, they may or may not have drawers, and they're not much bigger than 5 or 6 feet. Most of them are old and abused, the vises don't always work well, and the work that comes out of that bench room is world class. You don't need a fancy, tricked out bench to do great work. Head on your shoulders and a willingness to improvise as necessary is 90% of the game, because there's no "perfect" bench, or way to work that is perfectly fitted for everything. But there are a lot of them that are good enough, if you're able to figure out how to work on them.

Re: starting off with no bench

#8

scott grandstaff

starting off with no bench

scott grandstaff

>Yo Brian

Sounds like you want to get into the game.

While many will give you copious advise on how to spend large amounts of money..........ahem

You don't really know what you want in a bench yet anyway. Don't worry, keep working, it'll come.

If its cheap and effective you need..............

In the meantime, shore up what you already have.

Make a top layer for whatever top you have on it now and glue them together. Clear studs are buck-apiece cheap if you search through a whole unit of them at the lumber yard. 1 1/2 more inches will make a world of difference. You have to cut or plane off the 1/8" roundover at each edge before you glue up. Life's a bitch.

If you have no long clamps use a piece of stout rope and a stick to twist some clamping pressure. It worked for Stradaveri. Hunt down a couple luthier websites for examples.

Its mass you want in your benchtop most. Prettiest look is for later.

Lop off the legs if they are too tall and sister up another 2x4 or whatever size you have now, on each leg.

Diagonal braces aren't as decorative as long mortise and tenon joints, but they built the Eifel tower and will serve you too.

Figure 20 bucks, a long days labor, you can be in the game for real.

And you'll have a bench to build your bench with.

I bet you get decades out of it too, maybe forever.

Remember, you can pretty it up with moldings and finish and such next weekend.

Its why they were invented, after all.

No need to live with ugly!

yours Scott

Re: starting off with no bench

#9

Re: starting off with no bench *LINK*

Al

>Quit worrying about jointing and dimensioning the wood, it's not necessary for your first bench. Just go to Home depot or lowes and pick through the 2x 4's and take the straightest ones that you can find. You'll need about 16 of them to make a top that's 24 inches wide which is plenty wide enough. I frequently work boards that are 12 or 16 inches wide, and the 24 inch wide bench leaves some room for tools on top besides the board. Any wider than 24 inches and you can't get a 36 inch clamp across the top or easily reach across the bench to grab a tool hanging on the wall.

I made my bench about 7.5 ft long cause that's what I had room for. if you can go the whole 8 feet, then you won't have to trim the 2x4's. Besides, the longer you make it the more storage you'll have below it.

Glue up the 2x4's two at a time and then glue those pieces together two at a time and continue until you have a solid top. If you want dog holes, cut them out before you glue up the 2x4's and keep them close to the front edge of the bench, cause that's where they'll be most useful. Actually, IF I had it to do over, I think I'd just drill the dog holes into the bench top when it was finished. My square dog holes all came out slightly different sizes and so my dogs don't work as smoothly as they should and they're not really perfectly lined up either - whatever, they still work as intended. Round dogs are easy to make, Round dog holes are easy for a beginner to make too - just a better quicker way to skin that cat.

For the legs I laminated 2x4's together to make 4x4's. For the braces, I laminated a couple of 2x 6's together. Laminated construction for the legs let me cut out the mortices before laminating the legs together so I didn't have to chop mortices and they came out really sloppy so I stuffed the gaps with shavings and glue - drawbored and pegged them and they've held for 4 years now and hundreds of board feet of stock dimensioning with hand planes. No biggee, I wasn't going for a design award here, it's just a bench. It just has to be heavy, solid and hold the work.

Once the base is built, and the top is laminated together, throw the top on the base and plane it's underside flat so that it'll mate up properly to the base. Then flip it, attach it to the base and flatten the top.

I bought a single screw from lee valley for $35 and used it as the basis for a front leg vise.

I stuck a record vise on the tail endthat I purchased at a flea market, and I rarely use it. When I do, it's usually not for wood working.

Based on my experience, having a proper bench dramatically improved my skills. Building it helped me spot where mistakes can be made and how to better plan to avoid those mistakes. Don't set your sights too high on one of those fancy benches that we all drool over in the magazines and books, just throw yourself into the project without thinking about it too much. Figure out how tall you want it and how long and how wide and then just dive in. Analysis paralysis is terrible and it can prevent you from actually accomplishing anything.

Check out my bench below, don't mind the UPC tags still left on the ends of the 2x4's. They remind me of where I started.

I also included a link to the plans I used to build my bench. Thank you Bob KEY!

Good Luck.

Al


img

http://www.oldtoolsshop.com/z_pdf/shopImprov/BobAndDavesGoodFastAndCheapBench-ne.pdf

Re: starting off with no bench

#10

Re: starting off with no bench

Parisian, VL

>Do you know anyone in the building trades? ask around if you don't. What you might like is one used solid core commercial office door (36'x96"x2" or thereabouts IIRC)made of MDF with smooth laminate fake wood finish. These can be had by doing some dumpster diving or a nice one for a six pack or maybe $25.00. Ripe it to the desired width on a table saw. (I recommend that you use an old carbide tipped blade that you don't particularly like because MDF can hold some junk in it that could tear up a good blade.) Place your cut down door over a pair of sturdy saw horses and you are good to go. I've got one at the shop with a quarter inch thick steel plate bolted to it and a 6" mechanics vise mounted on one corner that must be 20-25 years old. This beast was a quick temporary work bench when put together, and it still gets abused on a regular almost daily basis.

Victor - Houston TX

Victor

Re: starting off with no bench

#11

bootstrapping a bench

paul womack

>Any thoughts on the best way to start this to minimize frustration and avoid wasting money?

If you can find a nearby fellow forum member, loaning some time a bench would seem a splendid strategy, and sociable fun too!

BugBear

Re: starting off with no bench

#12

Don't stress here too much Brian...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I don't have a real bench yet. I get plenty done on a old steel computer assembly bench with a piece of 1-1/2 flooring plywood for a top and a face vice.

Your first bench will not be your last. Throw together something cheap but sturdy. Don't worry about it being too smooth, just get it flat and your good to go.

Re: starting off with no bench

#13

Re: starting off with no bench

Brian

>Thank you all for your diverse suggestions. I'll have to pick a strategy and implement it. I'll let you know how it comes out.

I did actually have a bench before. It wasn't great. It had been left at my old house by the previous owner. I added the record vice I mentioned and had a workbench. I should have built a real bench then. The novel thing about it was that it had a lot of compartments in it that were paint can sized. A big heavy painting bench I guess. The previous owner had left paint cans all over it, front and back. That added enough weight that it didn't move when I planed with it.

I moved from that house to California and now back to St. Louis again and just hadn't picked up my tools in 7 years, maybe. Ugghh.

Anyway, you all are right. I need to scrounge up a solution and get something going quickly again and go from there.

Thanks again for all your help. This is a great site. I can tell I'm going to spend a lot of time here.

Brian

Re: starting off with no bench

#14

Wilbur's solution

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>A while ago Wilbur had no bench, so he put a beam of some sort on saw horses and braced the beam and/or the horses with a 2X4 attached to the wall. Maybe he has some photos or can find the original post (I sure couldn't).

Pam

Re: starting off with no bench

#15

bench designs

paul womack

>A cheap bench can be mondo rigid - just use either diagonal bracing or sheet goods facing to make the frame rack proof.

BugBear

Re: starting off with no bench

#16

Here it is *LINK*

wilbur

>Here's the post I made on my "temporary" workbench. I say "temporary" because it's now been almost six months since I set it up, and it's worked so well for what I have needed to do that the only progress I've made on my "real" workbench was to move the lumber for it from my garage to my basement.

My little self pat on the back is that I got a chance to talk to Chris Schwarz at WIA, and he mentioned that this post was his go-to answer for the "How do I build a bench without a bench?" question.


A scrap piece of 1x4 is as good as a 400 lb bench!