Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

Posts

Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

#1

Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

charlie belden

>I don't recall if it was this message board that raised the question of handsaw handle angles

- so if this was posted here before, my apologies.

Being one of those folks trained as an engineer, I tend to wonder about things others probably don't. So when I wanted to make a saw handle I went looking for info about the handle angle to the top of the saw blade. Lo and behold, someone did a couple of web pages with photos of a bunch of open handled as well as closed handled hand saws.

So, a little playing in PhotoShop and a little playing in a primitive CAD program and I had a BUNCH of angles. Popped those in a spread sheet and found that closed handled hand saw use a different range of angles than open handled handsaw. Sort of made sense since a dovetail saw for example, is used differently than say a tenon saw. But the AVERAGE of the angles for each one is where most of the data clustered. (I know - way to much time on my hands.)

The open handled saw handle angle average was 45.5 degrees while the closed handled saw handle angles average was 65 degrees - 20 degrees difference.

Got any idea why the difference - or why 45 and 65 degrees?


img

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

#2

Handsaw Handle Angles - Closed Handled

charlie belden

>Why 65 degrees for these and only 45 degrees for the open handled handles?


img

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

#3

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

Bob Demers

>Humm you are definitively an engineer :-)

Jokes asides these differences in handle's angle determine how the saw 'hang' in your hands. That is the angle your hand make in relation to the saw tooth line. I will then surmise that different saws usage would benefit from different hang angle, in order to saw more effortlessly.

If you read old trade catalogs and such in Disston, Simonds, Atkins etc, they all vaunt how better their saws are hang. I'll look up a pic in my collection to illustrate my point

Bob

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

#4

There's been some discussion of this before

Bill Houghton, sorta sunny in Sebastopol, CA

>Some of the early-20th-century texts in my library indicate that a saw handle's angle is determined by striking a line at 90 degrees to the grip of the handle and running that line through the midpoint of the saw's blade at the tooth line. This often does apply even to longer backsaws.

Shorter saws (10" and shorter) seem consistently to run that line just in front of the heel of the saw. I've got several short saws with closed handles that do this too, so it's not limited to open handles.

I haven't studied saw use enough to understand why the difference.

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

#5

Hang according to Simonds

Bob Demers

>Ok took me a while to manipulate the pics but here we go

the first one is from Simonds 1923 catalog.

Scan follow, but here is the text:

Simonds 1923 catalog

Test the hang of the saw by holding it down on a line with the arm from the shoulder, pointing the saw to the ground in front of the body.

Feel how the weight comes where the most cutting takes place

Next is from Atkins

Bob


img

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

#6

Hang according to Atkins part 1

Bob Demers

>This is from Atkins Saw sense brochuire abiut the same vintage, mid 20s. Everyone seems to have 'discovered' that the hang made a difference in that time frame. Funny about that..

Bob


img

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

#7

Atkins part 2

Bob Demers

>Grumble grumble more picture manipulations to get it up there..

Anyhoo, like I said earlier if you look up saw's litterature froms the mids 20s to early 30s, everyone seems to have gotten the 'hang' of it (pun intended)

If you have various saws, try them and see how they hang in your hands, feel how your wrist/hand/arm are in line with the saw plate when sawing. You will notice a more confortable posture on some saws, beside the comfort level, the hang is one contributor to that feeling, it will also change how much effort you spend cutting.

Now how much degrees does it take to make a difference? I have no idea. All I know is that some saw feel better in my hands than some other. And the hang is different between these.

Atkins part 2

Bob


img

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

#8

Hang measurement is not right

Bob Demers

>One small last point.

To measure the saw hang angle, uses the saw plate (at the cutting line) not at the top. Reason is not all saws have parallel saw plate.

Certainly not handsaws, and not all back saws, some have a tapered saw line from toe to heel.

Small point, but it will skew some of your angle calculations.

By how much I have no idea, but I though I mention it

Bob

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

#9

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

MikeW

>"Got any idea why the difference - or why 45 and 65 degrees?"

Hi Charlie,

The hang, in conjunction with tooth ppi and filing aggressiveness, affects the amount of "natural" force at the toothline.

In general, all open handled saws from the "modern era" have higher hangs and geater ppi than a larger closed handled back saw. If you had as high a hang on a 10 ppi 14" long sash saw as an 8" 18 ppi open handled saw, it would supply too much force behind the midpoint at the tooth line. The net effect is that it would be incredibly more difficult to start and maintain effecient cutting. It would be "out of balance," wanting to tip up at the toe.

There's more issues if you think about the above. Saw makers historically chose different hangs within a given range for each type of saw, length and ppi. Bob Brode's charts demonstrate this range very well.

Take care, Mike

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

#10

Whatever Happened to Bob Brode?

Ray Gardiner

>Does anyone know if Bob Brode is still around?

Regarding hang angles, it can get very complex, the actual sawing action plays a part, I can recall being very impressed a while back when someone was complaining on a forum that his newly made dovetail saw was "sticking" part way through the cut, MikeW suggested changing the hang angle. Problem fixed. As the arm swings through an arc it is possible to get a sort of "over-center" locking effect. Might make a good study for someone.

Like most things stick with what works and feels right.

Regards

Ray

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

#11

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

charlie belden

>Hmmmm. I was thinking in terms of dovetail saws, tenon saws and maybe carcase saws - all backsaws - not longer "unbacked" rip, cross cut and utlity saws (compromise between rip and cross cut).

With the longer, "unbacked" saws, it seems it's about efficiently applying power to the cut - to a line.

With the "backsaws" it's more about fine control - and stopping at a scribe line - rather than power. With dovetails and tenon saws, having the top of the "back" parallel to the line of the teeth helps stopping at the scribe line. With the longer rip and cross cut saws following the line is the requirement - stopping at a specific line usually isn't.

With a long rip or cross cut saw, the surface of the cut face isn't critical - the edge will be joined usually - with a hand plane or a power joiner. With dovetail saws and tenon saws, the goal is to use the cut face/edge without any additional tool or machine work.

Since table saws and sliding compound miter saws are doing long rip and wide cross cuts that used to be done with hand saws, can we focus on shorter back saws - dovetail and tenon saws?

Folks making these things for daily use, often for hours at a time, must have thought about handle angles.

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

#12

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>IIRC, someone here (Todd Hughes?) said that a good starting point is to have the line of the angle point to the midpoint of the length of the saw blade.

Pam

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

#13

can we focus on shorter back saws ?

Bob Demers

>Sure, since thats what you measured and you are still wondering about that 20 degrees difference you noticed.

But I do not think that handsaws (panel, rip, Xcut etc) are that much different animals than back saws. In the sense that the quality of the cut is affected more by the tooth geometry etc and not the hang of the handle.

I think its also more than efficiency, I think that its also about making the tool comfortable to use for its given task. That task being different for smaller dovetail saw and taller saw plate tenon saw, would then require a different hang angle to work efficiently.

Efficiently as in putting the right amount of power behind the tooth so that they dont hang up or stick, but work correctly as their makers intended.

That comment from Ray about the dovetail saw that was sticking halfway in use and fixed by Mike suggestion that he change the hang illustrate this point very well in my mind.

See also Joel blog for an explanation of their choice of different hang for their dovetail and tenon saw.

Nonetheless the 20 degrees difference in open and closed tote remain intriguing. Your hand hold the saw in the same manner, three fingers in the hole or handle, fourth finger extended along the way, should not make that much difference, one would think?

In the end, handsaws are very personal tools, much like chisels, they must fit the user's hands properly and be comfortable. A big variable right there.

Bob, running out for a medical test this AM, im fasting and want coffee badly..

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

#14

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>What is needed is an adjustable tote that allows it to have it's angle changed to fit the user.

Here ya go sawmakers, another feature to sell your product. I'll have my people talk to your people and we'll work something out.

Andrew????

Marv

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

#15

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

MikeW

>I was only discussing backed saws. Ones with open handles and ones with closed handles.

Whether it is an 8" 18 ppi open handled saw used for DTs or a 16" 10 ppi closed handled saw used for ripping tenon cheeks, it is all about how the force of the arm/hand translates into the cutting action at the toothline.

The hang of the handle, combined with other factors, transmits that force to the toothline. Too high a hang in relation to the toothline creates a difficult sawing action by transmitting that force to a place at the toothline too close to the rear (heel) of the blade. Consider it "unbalanced" force.

There are ergonomic issues--how does one stand cutting DT joinery versus tenons and how is the stock held with either? How high is the stock held in a vise cutting DTs versus tenons?

A long tenon saw has the lower hang handle because the stock is generally placed high in the vise. If it were a higher hang, your arm would be in an unnatural position. The higher hang of the DT saw expects/requires the stuff being cut to be held lower in the vise, the body position different than when sawing tenons.

The different hangs, in conjunction with the ppi and toothing, expects and requires different work holding and body posture.

"With dovetails and tenon saws, having the top of the "back" parallel to the line of the teeth helps stopping at the scribe line."

As for tapered height back saws (what Joel calls canted back saws) where the toe of a back saw has less usable depth than the heel, versus parallel height saws (what I quote above), I'll leave it to personal preference. I personally believe a tapered back saw is easier to stop on lines on the far side.

Take care, Mike

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

#16

I don't know, but I wish he was still around.

Don in Northern Arizona

>I have 3 saws that I purchased from him, and they are the sharpest, best cutting older saws that I own. Two are a matched set of rip/crosscut pre-1896 10" Disston 4s that are pitted but cut like a dream.

Don

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

#17

delightful reading

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I am appreciative that some people have (or) take "time on their hands" for these kinds of investigations.

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

#18

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles (sorry so long)

Adam Cherubini

>Charlie,

This is the exact issue that initally got me interested in making my own hand saws. I started looking onto this 1999-2000. Here's what I think:

For long saws who's purpose is to cut quickly, a hang angle that places most or all of one's effort behind the teeth is the most efficient. Mind you there are 2 issues: The angle and the position of the handle. Japanese saws do this and Western saws used to do this. The disadvantage of this approach is that when the saw becomes dull, you need to push down on the teeth to get them to engage. And this is very difficult to do with a low hang angle saw.

18th c saws relied on rectangularly shaped saw plates to produce the required downforce. I think makers like Disston made saws more triangular in shape to save steel and changed the hang angle to compensate for the loss. I think the triangular shape was also advantageous for Disston's customers who couldn't or didn't sharpen their own saws.

Honestly, after building my saws in 2003 and having worked with them ever since, I think the effect is subtle. I couldn't swear to you that my Kenyon saw is appreciably faster cutting than a good Disston. So much of the performance of a saw is related to the sharpenss and exact geometry of the teeth. I think it's a bit like comparing a LN and LV smoothing plane. Chances are you'l pick the plane with the sharper iron.

That said, I have very fine Disstons and I prefer my saws. I find the Kenyon hang angle (and handle) more comofortable. And even though my saws aren't taper ground (which may well be the reason they don't seem to be appreciably faster) I prefer them.

Regarding the hang angle of the back saws, I think the issue is similar with one twist: Back saws are genrally used in conjuction with a vise. So your body position is more upright, the work is higher. Long back saws benefit from the low hang angles. But when you have to saw a near corner out with a tenon saw, even a few extra degrees of hang angle can make the difference between stooping a bit and kneeling on the floor (not uncommon in my shop).

Because I routinely "saw the corners out", I'm experimenting with greater hang angles but lower handle postions to compensate with my new 1750 style saws. So far, I like them, but I'm continuing to tweak the design. Small design changes with saws have fairly dramatic repercussions.

For DT saws, I think their really high hang angles suggests the "saw teh corners out" technique. I think they were designed to operate toe up for 80% of their cutting. I've never thought starting a cut with the teeth flat on the end grain was a good idea. I wish those who are good at this technique well, but I think it's a more difficult method to learn and has very limited usefulness beyind this one type of cut.

Fine 18th c cabinetmakers did an awful lot of half blind dts. It's fairly rare to see an exposed thru dt on an 18th c carcass. And all half blind pins have to be sawn toe up if the stock is held vertically. So I think this is why dt's have that 45 degree toe presentation. That's the way they were supposed to be used.

Saws for the bench hook you want low hang angles. I think teh worst saws are those Disston Tenons with the handle up at teh top corner with a dt like hang angle. Those saws (is it the #12 series back saws?) are what convinces me that either Disston or their customers didn't know what they were doing. It was a world gone mad!!! People sawing incorrectly!! tweet! tweet! Here come the saw police!

Sorry. I'm okay know.

Adam

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

#19

Re: Backsaws for miter boxes

Dave Mount

>Might be my imagination, but some of the closed handle saws with more vertical handles (measured as larger angles as Charlie has marked them) look like pretty beefy saws that might have been used in miter boxes, particularly larger ones. I can see how the likely height of the work in a miter box (i.e., sitting on top of a bench) and a long stroke (as in mitering wide stock) would argue for a more vertical handle. Pam's rule of thumb would also argue for this for large miter boxes with long bladed saws.

I also may be selectively sampling, but it looks to me like among the closed-handled saws, those that look like smaller saws tend to have less vertical (as in lower angles as Charlie measured them) handles, which might also fit with use on dovetails and with Pam's rule.

I suspect the sampling of saws is complicated by some having angles deliberately selected for their intended use, and some being arbitrary (i.e., selected for some reason other than deliberately linking angle to use).

Interesting discussion.

Dave

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

#20

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles (sorry so long)

ThomD

>"Fine 18th c cabinetmakers did an awful lot of half blind dts. It's fairly rare to see an exposed thru dt on an 18th c carcass. And all half blind pins have to be sawn toe up if the stock is held vertically. So I think this is why dt's have that 45 degree toe presentation. That's the way they were supposed to be used."

My feeling also. I come from english cab. stock, and the diagonal type start is what they seem to do. I dismissed it early on because my earlier saws were too agressive, and wouldn't start on a corner. Your point about the amount of HB DTs they did is a good one, plays into the same line of thinking.

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

#21

Re: Backsaws for miter boxes

charlie belden

>OK - so we've got a mix of handle angles arbitrarily selected by a mass produced saws manufacturer and purpose specific angles which are optimized for a specific type of cut.

Either way, the user can adapt to what they're using and make it work - perhaps not ideally - but workable - cuts wood and well enough to get a job done. I suspect that word of mouth determined which saw manufacturer's saws worked best for specific tasks. I doubt however that user feedback got to the manufacturers - who probably weren't users - and if it did and required even moderate increases in production cost, were ignored.

And if Stanley hand planes is typical of woodworking tool manufacturers, I'm betting they put stock on hand from a previous model on the early runs of new versions. So even when you find a specific model of a tool, you may be getting a Mix and Match tool - which can make for a bit of confusion on the user's end. And manufacturers often use the "If YOU can't make our tool work it's because YOU are doing something wrong". And conveniently, they typically didn't include a set of instructions for the "right way" of using the tool - the old Common Knowledge thing.

Graham Blackburn notes that western saw handles encourage grabbing the handle with a grip suitable for use firing a 357 magnum - which is what you DON'T want to do since it tends to get you applying more downward force at the teeth. Rather than letting the teeth do their job, this forces them to try and bite off more wood than intended, resulting in a lack of control and more tearing and splitting of the wood instead of shearing it.

It's only the heel of the palm that should be applying cutting force on the push stroke, the fingers and thumb merely preventing unwanted rotation around the long axis of the saw. Theoretically fingers don't need to wrap around the handle at all - pinching the handle between the thumb and index finger should provide enough grip for the pull stroke at least for shorter back saws. So why a pistol grip, open or closed?

Japanese pull stroke cutting saws discourage applying unneccary forces. Trying to muscle through a cut with a straight handle is uncomforable as hell - so you don't try that but once. But I'll leave the pull vs push to cut debate for another thread.

Re: tooth geometry - again, technology may make some of the Tried And True Rules no longer applicable with modern steels and heat treatment methods. Of course that may preclude the user from being able to resharpen their saws. But with some saws, you can get replacement blades which are easy to swap out - and, if you're tool cabinet tends towards crowding, storing just a replacement "blade" rather than two complete saws - with those damn bulky handles - takes up a lot less space.

There sure is a lot of subtle factors in a tool which seems so simple and straightforeward - which is why woodworking is so interesting.

I'm learning a lot about handsaws from this thread - well beyond my initial question.

Thanks!

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

#22

hack style

paul womack

>And even though my saws aren't taper ground

Since you say you want "weight in your plate", taper grinding (indeed, any grinding) would be a disadvantage, at least in this regard.

BugBear

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

#23

Re: I don't know, but I wish he was still around.

Bob Brode

>[A friend alerted me to this forum/thread.]

Gee, nice to be remembered.

I've been dormant for a few years on old tools trading. Hope to get back into it when time allows. (My weirdo local web hoster quietly pulled the plug on the server that had my tools website a while back, not that I'd changed it in eons. Someday I'll put up a reformed version elsewhere.)

Anyway, it's good to see the thoughtful discussions of handsaw usage and configuration here.

Bob

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

#24

Re: Backsaws for miter boxes

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Seems to me that most of the manufacturers and/or resellers who hang around here are very solicitous of the user's experience. Most of these experiences can be anticipated by a quality maker, but there's nothing like reports from the shops. Or reviews for that matter. In this tiny world, it matters, for sales if nothing else.

Pam

Re: Handsaw Handle Angles - Open Handled

#25

Re: I don't know, but I wish he was still around.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Me, too, used to love looking at your Japanese saws. If you remember the url, you can perhaps recover most of your site via the wayback machine.

Pam