Re: Handsaw Handle Angles (sorry so long)
Adam Cherubini
>Charlie,
This is the exact issue that initally got me interested in making my own hand saws. I started looking onto this 1999-2000. Here's what I think:
For long saws who's purpose is to cut quickly, a hang angle that places most or all of one's effort behind the teeth is the most efficient. Mind you there are 2 issues: The angle and the position of the handle. Japanese saws do this and Western saws used to do this. The disadvantage of this approach is that when the saw becomes dull, you need to push down on the teeth to get them to engage. And this is very difficult to do with a low hang angle saw.
18th c saws relied on rectangularly shaped saw plates to produce the required downforce. I think makers like Disston made saws more triangular in shape to save steel and changed the hang angle to compensate for the loss. I think the triangular shape was also advantageous for Disston's customers who couldn't or didn't sharpen their own saws.
Honestly, after building my saws in 2003 and having worked with them ever since, I think the effect is subtle. I couldn't swear to you that my Kenyon saw is appreciably faster cutting than a good Disston. So much of the performance of a saw is related to the sharpenss and exact geometry of the teeth. I think it's a bit like comparing a LN and LV smoothing plane. Chances are you'l pick the plane with the sharper iron.
That said, I have very fine Disstons and I prefer my saws. I find the Kenyon hang angle (and handle) more comofortable. And even though my saws aren't taper ground (which may well be the reason they don't seem to be appreciably faster) I prefer them.
Regarding the hang angle of the back saws, I think the issue is similar with one twist: Back saws are genrally used in conjuction with a vise. So your body position is more upright, the work is higher. Long back saws benefit from the low hang angles. But when you have to saw a near corner out with a tenon saw, even a few extra degrees of hang angle can make the difference between stooping a bit and kneeling on the floor (not uncommon in my shop).
Because I routinely "saw the corners out", I'm experimenting with greater hang angles but lower handle postions to compensate with my new 1750 style saws. So far, I like them, but I'm continuing to tweak the design. Small design changes with saws have fairly dramatic repercussions.
For DT saws, I think their really high hang angles suggests the "saw teh corners out" technique. I think they were designed to operate toe up for 80% of their cutting. I've never thought starting a cut with the teeth flat on the end grain was a good idea. I wish those who are good at this technique well, but I think it's a more difficult method to learn and has very limited usefulness beyind this one type of cut.
Fine 18th c cabinetmakers did an awful lot of half blind dts. It's fairly rare to see an exposed thru dt on an 18th c carcass. And all half blind pins have to be sawn toe up if the stock is held vertically. So I think this is why dt's have that 45 degree toe presentation. That's the way they were supposed to be used.
Saws for the bench hook you want low hang angles. I think teh worst saws are those Disston Tenons with the handle up at teh top corner with a dt like hang angle. Those saws (is it the #12 series back saws?) are what convinces me that either Disston or their customers didn't know what they were doing. It was a world gone mad!!! People sawing incorrectly!! tweet! tweet! Here come the saw police!
Sorry. I'm okay know.
Adam