Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

Posts

Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

#1

Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

Hank Knight

>I needed to put a small bead on the edge of a curved skirt for the hunt board I'm building. Because of the curve, my side bead plane wouldn't work, so I decided to make up a little scratch stock for the job. Several people have posted questions about scratch stocks recently, so I took the opportunity to turn yeaterday's project into a photo essay for those who haven't used scratch stocks before. As you'll see, they're simple, easy to make and very effective tools.

All you need is a block of wood, a bolt of some sort and a blade. I started with a piece of 8/4 hard maple, a 5/16" machine screw with a knurled head and an old card scraper.

Sratch Stock

Cut the block to a convenient size and chamfer the edges for comfort. Then drill a hole for the bolt. The bolt engages the cutter and keeps it locked in place, so where you drill the hole depends on the size of your stock and the placement of the cutter.

Scratch Stock

Then saw a kerf in the block to house the cutter:

Scratch Stock

Tap the hole for the machine screw:

Scratch Stock

Next, prepare the cutter. I made mine from an old card scraper, scoring it with a Dremel tool and snapping it off. Clean up the edges with a file and cut the profile. You can cut just about any reasonable profile you need for your work and you can put more thatn one profile on the same cutter; just turn the cutter in the stock to expose a different profile. Mine is a simple quirk and bead - a little over 1/8". I used a 1/8" chainsaw file:

Sratch Stock

Hone the edges of the profile dead flat and sharp. I took mine through the Arkansas grits up to surgical black. I don't have a stone small enough to hone the inside edges of the bead. I tried wrapping a piece of fine wet-or-dry sandpaper around a screwdriver shank, but it dubbed over the edge and ruined it. I recut the profile and just honed the flats. It worked fine:

Scratch Stock

I found that my saw kerf was too wide for the cutter. I was afraid I'd get chatter, so I made a shim out of brass shim stock. The non-business end of my cutter extends past the edge of the block so I bent the shim around the edge of the cutter to protect my hand. Note this cutter has two profiles; one bead is a little larger than the other:

Scratch Stock

Here's the assembled scratch stock:

Scratch Stock

To use, set the cutter so the profile extends beyond the edge of the block and lock it down with the screw. Reference the cut by keeping the edge of the block in contact with the workpiece and pull or push the stock along the edge:

Sratch Stock

Start with light pressure and adjust the angle of the stock to get a clean cut. A well sharpened cuter will actually give you shavings instead of sawdust:

Scratch Stock

Keep repeating until you cut the full profile. Be aware of the grain direction. If the cutter begins to tear out or chatter, change the angle and/or the direction of the cut. After you get the cut started, you can increase the pressure on the stock, but you really don't need to muscle it. Just keep a nice steady pressure and repeat the cut until you get there:

Sratch Stock - A nice quirk and bead

Easy peasy. You'll be surprised at how easy this is and the quality of the cut you can get with a well prepared cutter. Mine required almost no sanding.

Hope you found this useful.

Hank

Scratching away.

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

#2

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Great post Hank!

And a beautiful bead, also. This would make a good article, actually. I believe this style of beader is used by Garrett Hack, in his classes. Really solid, with no play. I have a similar beader to Hank's, and use it with a 1/16" stringing cutter.

Wiley

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

#3

thank you for an excellent lesson

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

#4

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

Hank Knight

>Thanks, Wiley. I learned this from Hack. I should have given him credit in the tutorial, although I doubt he originated it.

Hank

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

#5

Thanks, Bill, and you're welcome.

Hank Knight

>

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

#6

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

Kevin French, Antrim, NH------WebKitFormBoundary3x

>I thought that's where i saw that tool. Thanks Hank for posting it.

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

#7

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

Greg B�tit, Crown Point, NY.

>On behalf of us who mostly lurk here, thank you for taking the time to share that with us.

I was just reading a book on Shaker furniture and studying the section on a small hanging cupboard that had a bead around the frame of the door. The author states that the Shakers probably used a scratch stock, but in his reproduction of the piece he uses a side bead plane.

I was thinking that using a scratch stock would make the stopped bead on the vertical parts of the cupboard front a lot easier than with the plane. Intuitively it would be easier to see where you are cutting and control the start and stop with a scratch bead.

Making a tool like this for a particular application at one time seemed daunting to me, but your taking the time to show how simple making a scratch bead is has helped overcome my hesitancy.

Thanks again,

greg

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

#8

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

Hank Knight

>Thanks for the comment, Greg. This is such an easy project, you can do it as a one-off for any piece you're building. The nice thing is that once you make the stock, it easy to make new cutters. You're right, this is much easier for stopped beads. You can see exactly where you're cutting. Not so with a side bead.

Hank

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

#9

Very timely post. Many thanks.

Parisian, VL

>

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

#10

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

Alan Schwabacher

>Thank you, that description with photos made it very clear. I've been intending to try this sooner or later, and your post undoubtedly made it sooner. One question I have is whether the bolt has ever let the cutter shift, which might ruin the workpiece. I guess there's not a lot of sideways force on the blade, but I was wondering how solidly it's held this way.

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

#11

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

Hank Knight

>Alan,

I've made several of these and I've never had one slip. That doesn't mean it can't happen.

Hank

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

#12

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Hank

Very nice tutorial. Indeed, this is one design I also learned from Garrett Hack, although I have not made an adjustable one like yours. It is nice and it has been on my To-Do list for a long time.

GH:



There is one point that I must critique you on. I consider that you have placed the blade on the less desirable axis. I would always use as long a fence as possible (see above). This provides a great deal more stability, with less likelihood of wandering off line. Plus it is just more comfortable to hold.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

#13

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

Hank Knight

>Hi Derek,

I agree that the longer axis would ordinarily be preferable, especially on straight work. In this case I was beading a curve so I didn't need the longer registration. The longer axis would probably be better from a durability standpoint, too. The way my stock is oriented, the screw is pushing the grain apart. It will split someday if I put too much force on the screw. I was worried, however, about tapping end grain if I oriented the stock the other way. It probably would have been fine. If I recall correctly, Garrett Hack's is oriented the way you suggest, with the screw running into the end grain.

Hank

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

#14

I thought I was the slowest woodworker...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Around these parts. Hank you got me beat I believe;^)

Very nice bead and beader for that matter. Thanks for sharing.

So how's the progression? A pic perhaps?

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

#15

hack style

paul womack

>Those scratch stock work well for small cuts, near the edge. This includes beads, of course, which makes this a good solution for a common scenario.

My page shows a more general, but harder to build, variation, which has better performance for large cuts, or cuts further from the edge.

http://www.geocities.com/plybench/scratch.html

For more complex "real" mouldings, the traditional 'L' shape is actually hard to beat.

BugBear

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

#16

Re: I thought I was the slowest woodworker...

Hank Knight

>Scott,

I think I take the Slow Woodworker Prize. I average getting to work in my shop maybe one weekend out of four, maybe less. I do manage to inch along, though. I've been working on the hunt board since March. Here's a recent photo:

Photobucket

Hank

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

#17

Thoughts and questions regarding registration

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi All,

This dialogue is interesting. I find Hank's reason for a shorter registration--the need for a handy tool that will work a curve--to be convincing.

Nevertheless, Derek's and Paul's emphasis on registration length has a lot of intuitive appeal. And of course the thought is reinforced by the example of moulding planes, which typically have a 9-1/2" registration, at least in those moulders which have a fence section.

However, let me offer an observation about fence length and registration in beading tools. First, one can search high and low and never find a commercial beader with a long registration. Some examples include the entire range of Preston beaders and routers, the LN (and Stanley 66), the Windsor Beaders No. 5 and No. 7. All have stubby fences.

Why is it that those making beading tools for the trade used short fences? Well, as Hank said in his tutorial, working inside or outside curves is a very good reason for a short fence, or even a point fence as found on the Windsor Beader No. 5.

There is one other case that i have experienced where a short fence is good. This is where you are having to work a bead or a stringing channel up against a stop. In my case, the stop was a therm foot, where a long registration would have left me far short of my end point, had the stringing tool had a long registration. Well, this is a rare example, but perhaps there are other cases where a shorter fence is better.

As a third thought, I haven't found a short fence to be an issue in scratching mouldings. If you 'roll' into the cut--and take your time--each pass serves to establish and deepen the cut so that it is continuously self-defining and self-steering. I don't find that there is a tendency of the cutters to veer and try to find a path outside the one you're easing them into.

My question: Why do you suppose it is that there are no vintage beading tools which feature longish fences? Why are they all short? Is it just the ability to work curves, or is something else involved?

Wiley

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

#18

didn't you answer your question...

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>A long fence isn't necessary

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

#19

Scratch stock for Chester Co. chest

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Bill,

I'm trying to recall the stock on your scratch for the Chester Co. chest of drawers. That was beautiful work. How did you hold the cutter?

Wiley

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

#20

Re: Scratch stock for Chester Co. chest

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>On a traditional scratchstock there is an arm which goes out from the fence and over the work. Holding the end of the arm with one hand and the fence portion with the other gives one more control over perpendicularity than a tool with no arm. So the stock can be used for curved work as well as straight runs. The arm also provides a depth stop to make the molding more uniform.

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

#21

Thanks! Question, and a word on Bugbear's site

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Warren,

Thank you for the reply. You make a great point about the arm acting as a depth fence. Do you have an opinion as to the length of fence--long, short, or single point of contact--and need for registration against the side of the work? I realize that the answer to this is probably 'it all depends', but am fishing for your insights.

I went back and re-read Paul Womack's treatise on scratch stocks. It has been a while, and I had forgotten what a thorough job he did on the subject. If I'm reading correctly, Paul liked both the long fence and the point fence over the stubbier fence found on every commercial beader and router I have seen (course, I ain't seen them all) . Paul's scratch stock page:

http://www.geocities.com/plybench/scratch.html

Wiley

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

#22

Re: Thanks! Question, and a word on Bugbear's site

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I have used an scratch stock that is about 1/2 inch thick- that is a flat 1/2 inch against the work. I have seen some that were rounded so as to fit better inside a curve, but I never felt the need for this. The scratch stock really doesn't work well on anything more than a gentle curve. I think the leverage of the arm diminishes the need for a long registration. And making moldings like this is tiring enough with two hands so I would not want a tool that uses just one hand.

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

#23

Well done Hank!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>It looks exactly like the last pic you posted! Well done;^)

Just kidding, things are coming along. Slow but sure, the best way to approach something IMHO.

Looking good Hank thanks for the update!

Scott who's G&G sideboard is (slowly) somewhat progressing also.

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

#24

O.K. Scott, Your Turn

Hank Knight

>"Scott who's G&G sideboard is (slowly) somewhat progressing also."

Pics, we want Pics!

Re: Scratch Stock Tutorial - Revisited

#25

Re: Scratch stock for Chester Co. chest

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I roughed it out by other means and smoothed and refined it with the scraper blade, hand held. In this case the pattern was already established so the scraper settled into the coarse pattern.