Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Trouble with iron shifting in plane

Posts

Trouble with iron shifting in plane

#1

Trouble with iron shifting in plane

Joe Shelton

>I'm unable, so far, to keep the iron set in a new hollow. This is not a high end plane; it's a rosewood (?) bodied plane from China, and the iron tapers distinctly from the edge to the tail, so it never abuts the sides of the plane until it shifts under pressure.

I'm leery of hammering the wedge in much tighter.

Any advice on approaches to make this iron work in this body?

JS

Re: Trouble with iron shifting in plane

#2

Re: Trouble with iron shifting in plane

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I haven't seen this type of plane, but here are some ideas. I would wonder if the wedge is tight to the iron at lowest point, near the edge. If it is not tight here, pressure at the edge of the iron can get more leverage to move it sideways. You might try putting a thin shaving between the iron and the bed or between the iron and the wedge right at the tip to test this out before making alterations to the bed or the wedge. On old molding planes the tangs are often so soft and malleable that you can put in a slight curve to them to limit sideways motion (and sometimes you have to bend a tang that is too crooked). And I think beech has a much better wedging action than rosewood.

Re: Trouble with iron shifting in plane

#3

Re: Trouble with iron shifting in plane

Tom MacGregor

>Check the iron, where it beds and the wedge to see if they're all flat enough for good contact. If any of the surfaces don't match well the blade will pivot on the high points under load.

Re: Trouble with iron shifting in plane

#4

Re: Trouble with iron shifting in plane

Patrick Lund

>I asked Don MacConnell of Clark & Williams the same question during WIA. He said if there is a high spot as Tom said it would seat right. Don told me to take a marker us on eraser boards and coat the back of the iron. Then gently seat it in the plane and insert the wedge. Remove the iron and check the bed of the plane. The marker should have rubbed off on the plane bed at the mouth and then up towrad the back. Those are the most critcal areas. Remove the high spots until you get the marker to rub off on the wood at those to critcal areas.

Re: Trouble with iron shifting in plane

#5

Re: Trouble with iron shifting in plane

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yes, but any graphite will do, such as a pencil.

Joe, eastern planes seem to ship as kits rather than fully tuned instruments. This is SOP. Don't be afraid to hit it a bit harder than what you're comfortable with; but then follow Patrick's process. You may need a very small chisel.

A pretty good starting guide is at http://mt1.woodworkforums.com/showthread.php?t=45709

Also, Harrelson Stanley at Japanese Tools has published an excellent dvd covering dai tuning. He also has a yearly dai making seminar with Inomoto-san, master dai maker. I took this class to learn how to tune better; but it was probably not necessary.

Also, reading and studying "Japanese Tools" by Toshio Odate is highly recommended. And know that the sole on a Japanese smoothing plane is not level over its length. Don't know about Chinese planes, aside from that monstrous Chinese rebate plane made of pecan I got on ebay.

Pam

Re: Trouble with iron shifting in plane

#6

Great advice here, all. Thanks

Joe Shelton

>I used the dry erase marker approach, found a high spot and reduced it.

Also ground the mating surface of the blade a little bit, and lightly sanded the top of the wedge.

The plane now stays set, at a rather light cut, and even works nicely in end grain.

Thank you all for helping me fix this.

JS