We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>"...[D]uring panel discussions at WIA, John Economaki made a comment that what was really important was the results of woodworking efforts, not how the object was made. He said once the maker is gone no one will care about whether the dovetails were cut tails first or pins first, what plane was used to smooth the top, etc. The bottom line to John seemed to be what sort of legacy is left behind by the results."
I would have to disagree with this. on an extreme level if a customer buys something that is made by slave labor under horrible conditions is that a object you want to own?
On the other side if the object is personally made by an individual working at a reasonable wage and costs more - is it worth the premium.
On a more relevant cast the individualism and customization that is possible with some tools is impossible with others for example machine carving doesn't look nice as hand carving, and the joinery possible by hand vastly exceeds what can be done by machine. This latter point means little to some people but for some people - like myself - the perfectly proportioned joint, or the elegant flourish is what makes a good piece of furniture a great piece.
>I bought a few new carving tools in March. Before that I had gone 14 years without buying anything but sawblades. And sharpening stones to replace those I wore down to nothing. For a guy working at full stride, new tools are a nuisance. The cost of the tool is trivial compared to the time spent getting it going and the time it takes to adapt to the new tool and regain speed, surety, finesse.
>At what, specifically, was John Economacki directing his comments? The project, or the woodworking "experience," lack of a better term. To me woodworking has been a series of destinations, all of which have been milestones in a greater journey. Each project, beginning with my first school project as a grammar schooler, has been a learning experience and opened new doors and excited new interests. I focus on each project and sometimes take pride in its completion (sometines not). That seems to be the "destination" part Econamacki was talking about. But upon the completion of each project, I set my sights on something new and more challenging to expand my knowledge and skill. That's the journey part. I don't know that I have an overall "destination" in mind for my woodworking, and I'd hate to think I would ever reach such a destination. It would mean "The End" and I'd have to go look for something else to challenge my mind and my hands. For me woodworking is all about the journey - a journey that I hope never ends.
>I heard him make this comment during two separate panel discussions on tool making and precision. He basically was saying that you won't be remembered by how you made something (pins vs tails, dovetail saw vs his new bench saw) or how precise the tools you made it with are. Rather you will be remembered by the results. Also during one of the panel discussions he talked briefly about being motivated by wanting to leave a legacy of good tools.
In some respects he was saying we should talk more about the furniture, etc we make and less about the tools we make it with.
>The cost of the tool is trivial compared to the time spent getting it going and the time it takes to adapt to the new tool and regain speed, surety, finesse.
Hi Warren
What you say is very understandable, but to put in a context it refers to the experiences of a professional woodworker. It is an experience that may not be understood or accepted by other woodworkers, particularly hobbiests.
I have the same antipathy about buying new tools for my professional practice (in psych). Tools? ... such as neuropsychological tests (that I require as part of an diagnostic evaluation). There is always a new "ubeaut" (best, unsurpassed) test to replace the old. Every few years new tests emerge with reputedly more sensitive diagnostic probes and with new norms.... I could go on and on. It probably leaves me as cold about this area as new woodworking tools make you feel. We all know that, by-and-large, the skill does not lie with the tool but with the person behind the tool. Still, good tools do make the task easier.
Of course, when I started out in my private practice 25 years ago I had every psych tool under the sun. Most just collect dust on the shelf or have been binned.
Does one actually need most of the tools in the average hobbiests workshop? Congering up visions of a workshop like my own ... :) ... then definitely not. But then I am not a professional woodworker, and if I were I'd probably spend only what I need to spend to get the job done.
I am sure that others will report similar feelings and experiences from different areas of work.
>I guess one's point of view is determined by one's motivation. It sounds like Economacki is motivated by the thought of leaving a legacy of fine furniture. I'm not. My motivation is the doing of it. It's purely for my own enjoyment. Perhaps that's selfish, but it's my hobby, not my vocation. I hope I leave behind a legacy of well argued cases, well handled legal matters amd satisfied clients (I'm a lawyer by profession); but when I leave my office, woodworking is my respite from the wrangling and fighting that is my business. If I leave behind some nice creations for posterity, that would be nice, but it's not my primary motivation.
>When I was a young man I was more focused on the destination. Do what had to be done to get through the journey as quickly as possible.
As I grew older I learned that the destination was much more enjoyable and lasting if I paid more attention to the journey. I slowed down and even enjoyed the journey.
Now, it's mostly about the journey. I even try to make it last longer so I can notice every aspect of it. The destination is a bonus, that is, if I get there.
>I really appreciate Charlie's point of view here, but I have fallen prey to the acquisition bug a time or two myself.
I think there are a lot of people who feel like they're collecting, but I think there's a really critical line that has to be drawn somewhere.
Whenever I read about tool collections, the tools that are on display are not what I read about in here. There's a vast array of tools that are each unique in one fashion or another.
Old tools that are hard to find, and are worth preserving because they are so rare... and it's worth having them around to provide a touchstone for future tool makers. It's worth being able to look into the Seaton chest, for example, to see how tools were made, and see if there are details that have been previously overlooked for one reason or another, that hint at something about historical woodworking or manufacturing techniques. These are tools that can teach us something, and they're worth collecting... but not hoarding.
Other unique tools will fall into the category of examples of genius, or artistic talent. Some tools are so specialized... but so amazingly well executed, that they really wouldn't serve a function for most other craftsmen for the work that they do. Other tools are hand made by foundry guys, or pattern makers, or others, and they're individually special for various reasons that are appreciable in some particular way.
On the other hand, the guys who "collect," every known production piece by a manufacturer who is still in business... that's just an acquisition bug. They see what other people have, and they want one, too. That doesn't make them collectible, that just means they're very good bait. Like a spinning lure, they're nice and shiny... and they're pretty good at hooking whatever the manufacturer is fishing for. That's neither collecting, nor woodworking. And they're a good example of the people who haven't thought about journey or destination. They're buying tools for something they may or may not be proficient in. Buying more tools won't make them more proficient. But it also doesn't make them a collector either, since they're not really as discriminating as a serious collector. Lacking purpose or direction, they flounder about, bleeding money.
Some folks will take offense at this, I'm sure. I'm not claiming complete innocence on this count, either. But I can say with certainty that my motivation in these cases boiled mainly down to "oooh! SHINY!" and had nothing to do with collecting.
>Sorry to disagree with you. Warren is absoutly right IMO. Better to use what you have than try or know to thep up i.e. improve/learn a new tool or technique. I'll show you some pics soon that will so you what I'm talking about.
I fear that you did not understand my message. Perhaps I was unclear. I was, in fact, agreeing with Warren. I was simply pointing out that a professional will use what they have got and make it work.
Unless the tool can pay its way, a professional (woodworker or other) is less likely to invest in it. Watching the overhead expenses is important. It is the hobbiests who are more likely to purchase a variety of equipment when they see it as pleasure not profit.