Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Journey or Destination

Posts

Journey or Destination

#1

Journey or Destination

David Cockey

>Several times during panel discussions at WIA, John Economaki made a comment that what was really important was the results of woodworking efforts, not how the object was made. He said once the maker is gone no one will care about whether the dovetails were cut tails first or pins first, what plane was used to smooth the top, etc. The bottom line to John seemed to be what sort of legacy is left behind by the results.

Robin Lee countered that his view that what is important is what gives the woodworker pleasure. If it's the finished object fine, if it's the "doing" that creates only a pile of shavings that's equally good.

Seems to me that this is a variation of the classic philosophical debate of what matters, the voyage or the destination.

Currently for me it's learning new skills. Sometime soon I'll use them once again to create objects.

Re: Journey or Destination

#2

Jim in Burlington Ont.

And then some

Jim in Burlington On

>It's also about the tools. Making, owning and using. Seaching them out and tuning them up. Buying lumber and hornding lumber. Creating great designs. There are so many skills to using different kinds of tools. The spectrum is so big that you have to be carefully how many doors you open.

Re: Journey or Destination

#3

Funny how we need these dichotomies

Bill Houghton, sunny in Sebastopol, CA

>No reason that it can't be the journey AND the destination.

A perfect journey that winds up in [insert here the name of the city/place you like least in the world*] is seriously anticlimactic, while suffering great pain/anguish/boredom/discomfort - say, flying on almost any modern airline** - to get to the greatest place in the world leaves you worn out before the fun begins.

But this is a matter of personal mileage on the journey, too. I know a lot of the power side would find my willingness to take a little longer to accomplish something in order to do it without sawdust infuriatingly slow and often enjoy watching the tool remove wood as if by magic, while I often find the power tool experience, if not uncomfortable, certainly not fun (but I understand the attraction: I enjoy our sprightly little Volvo, but I do confess that, when I drive our gas-hogging Chevy pickup, I do occasionally put the pedal to the wood just to get the V8 rush).

To get specific: taking great pleasure in the process of building a grossly ugly piece of furniture is ultimately unsatisfying; suffering greatly to build a beautiful piece will leave you reminded forever of how little fun you had.

Of course, most of the time, it's not a matter of the extremes (see, there, I fell into a variant of the dichotomies in the process of arguing against them), but a matter of relatively more or less fun/relatively more or less good final product. But I think my argument stands.

I suspect, for the non-production maker, that, however s/he chooses to enjoy a good journey, the destination contains the journey - memories of the building infuse the final piece, and, in the process, may create a special meaning for the piece's owner too, especially if the owner is part of the same family as the maker.

Funny that John Economaki, who makes his living selling tools that justify their price primarily on the basis of the non-essential aesthetic value would make such an argument. Seems like if he really felt that way, his tools would be made of matte-finished steel.

*I didn't name my choice of place because someone might think it's the dead center of the Universe - and it is, for him/her.

**No disrespect meant to anyone who works in the airline industry, but the airlines have not improved the air travel experience of late.

Re: Journey or Destination

#4

Re: Journey or Destination

Christopher Fitch @ Memphis

>It's funny you mention that because Frank Klausz had his own take that he repeated a few times. He commented on the (paraphrasing) "toolmakers with their accuracy down to 1000 of an inch. They measure the thickness of their shavings...who cares about the shavings. I want to see what you make not the shavings."

Just his interesting and somewhat refreshing viewpoint.

Re: Journey or Destination

#5

Reasons to Woodwork

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>I think that "destination" verses "journey" is an oversimplification, but it is one we understand. Another oversimplification is to divide woodworkers into those that do it for money (professionals) and those who do not (hobbiests). The truth is that there are just so many ways in which to gain pleasure, and so many different reasons to use tools:

Some take pride in using ingenuity to create objects.

Some will consider that developing handskills is the ultimate objective of woodworking.

Some consider that a completed piece of furniture is the ultimate objective of woodworking.

Some just want more power.

For some it is just a hobby and for others it is a living.

Some treat the workshop as a sanctuary rather than a place of work.

Some treat the workshop as a place of work and cannot conceive of it as a sanctuary.

Some think of woodworking as fun and enjoy spending money on tools, in the same way that a golfer buys clubs and knickknacks.

Some think of woodworking as a business and consider any expenditure on non-basic tools as frivolous and wasteful.

The bottom line is that we come together with a common love of woodwork - whatever that means to each of us - and the forum is where we share (not reject) these various interests and experiences.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Journey or Destination

#6

Re: Journey or Destination

Charlie

>When the primacy of actually building stuff is characterized as a 'refreshing viewpoint' then that pretty much says it all as far as I'm concerned.

Before I had a shop fire, I hadn't bought a tool in probably six years. Assuming no more fires or theft, I'll wrap up my career with what's in the shop now. I'm 47.

It IS possible, and frankly liberating, to not be in a perpetual state of shopping.

Re: Journey or Destination

#7

Great question....

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>It's one of those questions that has no answer or it has countless answers.

I often ponder why we do what we do. I have joked...."why do it if you can't gloat". To that extent, we might do what we so we can share with others. But, why do we want to share with others? Is it, "mine is bigger than yours" type thing? I remember when my son took his very first dump in the big toilet. He was so proud, he left it there until he could get everybody into the bathroom and gloat. He was 22 years old at the time, but hey, still a great accomplishment. He might have been younger, my old memory plays tricks on me at times. *smirk*

I think the answer lies within each one of us. There is no one general answer for all of us. I try to think of a common thread that ties us all together. Perhaps it's just wood. The smell of different woods, the feel, the texture. Could a common thread merely be the artist in us? I see it in so many beautiful things that people make.

Why and what we do seems to reflect other aspects of our life. How and where we grew up as one example. For each one of us, it's different. Most of us don't just work with wood, we do lots of other things too. I say most because I'm sure there are a few of you out there who have a bathroom in the corner of your shop and an army cot next to it. I know a guy who built his shop in his house. So what's his answer? Funny thing though, he had to knock out a few walls. One day a friend asked him if he knew what a supporting wall was, have you looked at your roof?

At this point I'd like to conclude this but I'm afraid I have no conclusion. It's a story with no ending. It's a subject we could discuss until we die of old age.

Marv

Re: Journey or Destination

#8

Steven Antonucci

Both

steve antonucci

>Great question. As a turner, I feel like I can answer a hand tools question, since I hold a tool im my hand to make my objects. :-)

From the maker's perspective, I cannot see how you get away from the journey. In my experience, the journey is almost inseparable from the destination. It speaks to our experiences and influences and allows us to put ourselves into our work- which is the only way that we can produce work of any lasting aesthetic.

The destination is important simply because your name goes on your work-either intentionally or by association. We all want our work to be well executed and appreciated by the viewer. Sometimes, it is our intent to "show the past"-the journey-our sweat and toil to become masters at our craft. Other times, we hide that journey and leave it to the viewer to figure our what went into the piece. Either way, the journey becomes part of the destination.

Steve

Re: Journey or Destination

#9

Behavior Science

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Meyers- Briggs divided the population into "process people" and "results oriented" people (as well as other subgroups). Once it becomes understood and accepted that these tendencies become established in adults, and may be inherited, it follows that some people find reward making shavings while others aren't rewarded until they can make a product. It is a skilled marketing person that successfully sells to both by keeping both happy.

The differences between the typical engineer and the typical poet are understood and accepted. When these types take up woodworking the same personality traits that led them to become poets and engineers will lead them to find different rewards in the hobby.

It soon becomes clear that these two personality populations inhabit this Forum. What generates discussion is when these tendencies are not understood by someone of the opposite type. One side considers the other strange instead of different.

Re: Journey or Destination

#10

Another aspect

Al Goldstein

>To take a different approach - many of us are attracted to woodworking to fulfill a basic human need to feel connected to our efforts and to have a sense of control over what we are doing.

We have day jobs that do not fulfill this need such as pushing papers, administering others or being a small part of a large effort, to name a few. The one piece of advice I gave my kids was to find a job where they had some control over their work situation.

In my workshop I have total control. Some days I plan the next project and look over catalogs for my next tool. Some days I work at the wood to produce this project. Along the way I make mistakes and correct them. Sometimes I use power tools and other times I try to expand my competence with hand tools. The woodworking experience is very different with power or hand tools. I enjoy both.

Sharing knowledge with others is another joy of woodworking. Competition dominates my day job and I'm probably not alone in being in such a situation. Woodworking clubs and this web site provide a social network where we all help each other and all grow in the process. Thank you Ellis.

Some of us make our living at woodworking. To get paid for doing what you enjoy is a goal that few of us attain in this modern world. Maybe that is the key. In this modern world we are not as connected to the products of our work as were the crafts people of old. So we retreat to our workshops to take control and connect with our tools and the wood we work.

Hope I didn't ramble too much, but I felt that there were practical, very human reasons why we all enjoy being woodworkers.

Re: Journey or Destination

#11

Re: Another aspect

Jim Crammond in Monroe, Mi

>Hi Al,

No, you didn't ramble too much, it all made a lot of sense and your thoughts are shared by many of us.

Glad to see you posting here, how have you been?

I guess I'm a journey sort of woodworker, I really enjoy solving all of the little problems that make up the successful completion of the project. Deciding on the design, what types of joints would work best, learning how to make the joints, performing the different processes then seeing how they come together as a finished product. Once the project is completed, I loose interest in it pretty quickly. Although I have to say that it is fun to see a project that I completed 5-10 years ago and had long forgotten then compare to my current skills.

Jim

Re: Journey or Destination

#12

Journey

David Miller from Iowa

>I agree with those who say Journey. I do this for therapy - if I wanted just the end result I would use power tools. I usually give away everything I make because my house is full of furniture.

Re: Journey or Destination

#13

Re: Journey or Destination

Charlie

>"Robin Lee countered that his view that what is important is what gives the woodworker pleasure. If it's the finished object fine, if it's the "doing" that creates only a pile of shavings that's equally good."

That's not a terribly shocking POV coming from a guy who sells tools for a living.

I've decided to start collecting antique dental instruments. Anybody need a tooth pulled?

Re: Journey or Destination

#14

Re: Behavior Science

Christopher Fitch @ Memphis

>I would have to say that I fit in both camps. I like the process (or journey) aspect as well as the end results. I'm not sure what that says about me but that's my position on it.

Re: Journey or Destination

#15

Re: Funny how we need these dichotomies

ThomD

>"Funny that John Economaki, who makes his living selling tools that justify their price primarily on the basis of the non-essential aesthetic value would make such an argument. Seems like if he really felt that way, his tools would be made of matte-finished steel."

His tools, in theory, have quality of result. He cares how they are made to the degree that they are made well, but he doesn't see any difference in that result whether hand milled or CNC, for instance. The person interested in process, might prefer programing or spinning a knob. Sounds consistant to me.

Another dicotemy would be between those who should go to woodworking panel discusions and those who shouldn't. For process people it sounds like a potential waste of time since it's a bit like a review that gives away the ending. For those who are outcome oriented it allows them to skip to the ending. So possibly John's point was more apt, since he was at least speaking to the people who were likely to be in the room. Or maybe it's Robin's since while his crowd shouldn't be there, they might be the only ones focused enough on the process to spend time discusing it, even if that mainly benefits the people who skip to the end of the book. Sounds like they need another conference to sort this all out.

Re: Journey or Destination

#16

Re: Funny how we need these dichotomies

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>"taking great pleasure in the process of building a grossly ugly piece of furniture is ultimately unsatisfying..."

I've occasionally given in to requests from others and have made "grossly ugly" stuff to satisfy those requests. The difference was that I made them in the way I wanted, using techniques that satisfied me and thus turned what would normally have been something that was a total waste of my time into at least a satisfying process.

I'm re-reading Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance for the umpteenth time, and it seems that this is precisely what Pirsig is talking about. If you haven't read it, take the time to slog through it (it's not easy reading, at least for me). It should be required for all of us.

Bruce

Re: Journey or Destination

#17

:)

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Journey or Destination

#18

Another example of pseudo subspeciation.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Journey or Destination

#19

Re: Behavior Science

Charlie

>I guess I'm stupid. I think woodworking is fun all the way up to and including completing the project.

All of this other stuff is a contortion to accommodate those whose biggest thrill in the craft is finding a UPS delivery at their door when they get home from work.

Re: Journey or Destination

#20

Collecting & Woodworking - Different

David Cockey

>Collecting tools is a distinct activity from woodworking. Someone can engage in both or either. Sounds like you are a woodworker but not a collector. One of the planes on Ron Brese's bench at Berea wouldn't be used after the show. It was headed to a non-woodworker who just liked the looks of Ron's planes.

Collecting can also be a journey and/or a destination for those who are into it. The journey part is the search and aquisition of the tools. The destination part is the collection itself.

Re: Journey or Destination

#21

Both for both

David Cockey

>Both points of view were expressed by guys who make and sell tools for a living, although very differently. And both can apply to those who enjoy buying new tools, and those who plan to never buy another tool.

Re: Journey or Destination

#22

John Economaki also says

wilbur

>"...[D]uring panel discussions at WIA, John Economaki made a comment that what was really important was the results of woodworking efforts, not how the object was made. He said once the maker is gone no one will care about whether the dovetails were cut tails first or pins first, what plane was used to smooth the top, etc. The bottom line to John seemed to be what sort of legacy is left behind by the results."

FWIW, John also said that although that the first purpose of a tool is to work wood in the manner that it was designed for, tools also serve a secondary purpose in our shop, and that is to inspire us to do better work by looking nice while resting on the shelf, waiting to be used. By being aesthetically pleasing, our tools can also serve as a source for inspiration for our projects.

So go ahead and get that infill plane! Even if you find that it doesn't leave a surface that is any better than a tuned up Bailey eBay special, if it will make you feel good having it, that's all the justification you need.

Of course, one might also get the same inspiration from a set of blue handled Marples that was picked up at the Borg. The point is that there is value to a tool beyond simple function, although without function, that tool is going to be useless regardless of how good it looks.

Re: Journey or Destination

#23

Re: Collecting & Woodworking - Different

Charlie

>Here's John Brown, the recently deceased chairmaker, on the subject:

"Travishers are very hard to come by. I suspect this is because most of them are hanging neatly on the walls of the High Wycomb chair museum, or, because of their scarcity, are in collections. I abhor this situation; tools are for use. On the three visits I have made to the chair museum at Wycomb, I have been the only visitor, and I stand with mouth watering looking at literally dozens and dozens of travishers..."

Re: Journey or Destination

#24

Steven Antonucci

Sorry Charlie- Shopping is fun!

steve antonucci

>I think that men enjoy shopping even more than women do- because we buy cooler things!

I am 42 and short of having some tragedy befall my shop, I never NEED to buy another tool as long as I live. But I will.

And I will savor every second of it- from the research into what, who and which - down to wiping off oil/cosmo/whatever and making that first cut/shaving/whatever. I will step back with a huge SEG on my face and think "Happy day, this is MINE!!!"

He who dies with the most tools has the best widow garage sale. Ever.

Steve

Re: Journey or Destination

#25

Steven Antonucci

I think there's a pill for that now?

steve antonucci

>