Funny how we need these dichotomies
Bill Houghton, sunny in Sebastopol, CA
>No reason that it can't be the journey AND the destination.
A perfect journey that winds up in [insert here the name of the city/place you like least in the world*] is seriously anticlimactic, while suffering great pain/anguish/boredom/discomfort - say, flying on almost any modern airline** - to get to the greatest place in the world leaves you worn out before the fun begins.
But this is a matter of personal mileage on the journey, too. I know a lot of the power side would find my willingness to take a little longer to accomplish something in order to do it without sawdust infuriatingly slow and often enjoy watching the tool remove wood as if by magic, while I often find the power tool experience, if not uncomfortable, certainly not fun (but I understand the attraction: I enjoy our sprightly little Volvo, but I do confess that, when I drive our gas-hogging Chevy pickup, I do occasionally put the pedal to the wood just to get the V8 rush).
To get specific: taking great pleasure in the process of building a grossly ugly piece of furniture is ultimately unsatisfying; suffering greatly to build a beautiful piece will leave you reminded forever of how little fun you had.
Of course, most of the time, it's not a matter of the extremes (see, there, I fell into a variant of the dichotomies in the process of arguing against them), but a matter of relatively more or less fun/relatively more or less good final product. But I think my argument stands.
I suspect, for the non-production maker, that, however s/he chooses to enjoy a good journey, the destination contains the journey - memories of the building infuse the final piece, and, in the process, may create a special meaning for the piece's owner too, especially if the owner is part of the same family as the maker.
Funny that John Economaki, who makes his living selling tools that justify their price primarily on the basis of the non-essential aesthetic value would make such an argument. Seems like if he really felt that way, his tools would be made of matte-finished steel.
*I didn't name my choice of place because someone might think it's the dead center of the Universe - and it is, for him/her.
**No disrespect meant to anyone who works in the airline industry, but the airlines have not improved the air travel experience of late.